Payroll Specialist
$28 - $32/hr
Join a Growing Team as a Payroll Specialist Are you a detail-oriented payroll professional looking for an opportunity to make an impact? Our client, a well-established Manufacturing company in the ...
New
Quick apply
Payroll Specialist
$28 - $32/hr
Join a Growing Team as a Payroll Specialist Are you a detail-oriented payroll professional looking for an opportunity to make an impact? Our client, a well-established Manufacturing company in the ...
New
Payroll Specialist
Castleton, IN · On-site
$28 - $32/hr
Join a Growing Team as a Payroll Specialist Are you a detail-oriented payroll professional looking for an opportunity to make an impact? Our client, a well-established Manufacturing company in the ...
Posted today
Payroll Specialist
Castleton, IN · On-site
$28 - $32/hr
Join a Growing Team as a Payroll Specialist Are you a detail-oriented payroll professional looking for an opportunity to make an impact? Our client, a well-established Manufacturing company in the ...
Posted today
Payroll Specialist
Rocky Ripple, IN · On-site
$28 - $32/hr
Join a Growing Team as a Payroll Specialist Are you a detail-oriented payroll professional looking for an opportunity to make an impact? Our client, a well-established Manufacturing company in the ...
Posted today
Payroll Specialist
Rocky Ripple, IN · On-site
$28 - $32/hr
Join a Growing Team as a Payroll Specialist Are you a detail-oriented payroll professional looking for an opportunity to make an impact? Our client, a well-established Manufacturing company in the ...
Posted today
Payroll Specialist
Meridian Hills, IN · On-site
$28 - $32/hr
Join a Growing Team as a Payroll Specialist Are you a detail-oriented payroll professional looking for an opportunity to make an impact? Our client, a well-established Manufacturing company in the ...
Posted today
Payroll Specialist
Meridian Hills, IN · On-site
$28 - $32/hr
Join a Growing Team as a Payroll Specialist Are you a detail-oriented payroll professional looking for an opportunity to make an impact? Our client, a well-established Manufacturing company in the ...
Posted today
Payroll Specialist
Noblesville, IN · On-site
$22 - $30/hr
Payroll Administrator Department: Accounting This is an in-person position at our headquarters in Noblesville, IN. Hours are 8am-5pm (or 7am-4pm) We are growing and looking to add an additional ...
Payroll Specialist
Noblesville, IN · On-site
$22 - $30/hr
Payroll Administrator Department: Accounting This is an in-person position at our headquarters in Noblesville, IN. Hours are 8am-5pm (or 7am-4pm) We are growing and looking to add an additional ...
Payroll Specialist
Noblesville, IN · On-site
$22 - $30/hr
Payroll Administrator Department: Accounting This is an in-person position at our headquarters in Noblesville, IN. Hours are 8am-5pm (or 7am-4pm) We are growing and looking to add an additional ...
Payroll Specialist
Noblesville, IN · On-site
$22 - $30/hr
Payroll Administrator Department: Accounting This is an in-person position at our headquarters in Noblesville, IN. Hours are 8am-5pm (or 7am-4pm) We are growing and looking to add an additional ...
Payroll Specialist
$28 - $32/hr
Join a Growing Team as a Payroll Specialist Are you a detail-oriented payroll professional looking for an opportunity to make an impact? Our client, a well-established Manufacturing company in the ...
New
Quick apply
Payroll Specialist
$28 - $32/hr
Join a Growing Team as a Payroll Specialist Are you a detail-oriented payroll professional looking for an opportunity to make an impact? Our client, a well-established Manufacturing company in the ...
New
As Payroll Accountant, you will serve as the expert ensuring our payroll practices remain accurate, compliant, and aligned across all state we operate in. This is an opportunity for someone who ...
As Payroll Accountant, you will serve as the expert ensuring our payroll practices remain accurate, compliant, and aligned across all state we operate in. This is an opportunity for someone who ...
Payroll Accountant
Evansville, IN · On-site
NOW HIRING - Payroll Accountant! Join a role where payroll is more than processing checks. As Payroll Accountant, you will serve as the expert ensuring our payroll practices remain accurate ...
Payroll Accountant
Evansville, IN · On-site
NOW HIRING - Payroll Accountant! Join a role where payroll is more than processing checks. As Payroll Accountant, you will serve as the expert ensuring our payroll practices remain accurate ...
Payroll Accountant
Evansville, IN · On-site
NOW HIRING - Payroll Accountant! Join a role where payroll is more than processing checks. As Payroll Accountant, you will serve as the expert ensuring our payroll practices remain accurate ...
Payroll Accountant
Evansville, IN · On-site
NOW HIRING - Payroll Accountant! Join a role where payroll is more than processing checks. As Payroll Accountant, you will serve as the expert ensuring our payroll practices remain accurate ...
Payroll Specialist
$65K - $75K/yr
Payroll Specialist (HRIS Experience Required) Location: Indianapolis, IN Salary: $65,000 - $75,000 + Benefits Looking for a role where you can combine your payroll expertise and HRIS knowledge to ...
Payroll Specialist
$65K - $75K/yr
Payroll Specialist (HRIS Experience Required) Location: Indianapolis, IN Salary: $65,000 - $75,000 + Benefits Looking for a role where you can combine your payroll expertise and HRIS knowledge to ...
Payroll Processor
Greenfield, IN · On-site
Payroll Specialist Location: Greenfield, IN (east side of Indianapolis) Company: Bookkeeping Plus, Inc. Now Hiring! Are you a payroll pro who thrives on variety and precision? Join one of the area ...
Quick apply
Payroll Processor
Greenfield, IN · On-site
Payroll Specialist Location: Greenfield, IN (east side of Indianapolis) Company: Bookkeeping Plus, Inc. Now Hiring! Are you a payroll pro who thrives on variety and precision? Join one of the area ...
Payroll Specialist
Indianapolis, IN · On-site
$22.50 - $30.50/hr
Under the general supervision of the Senior Payroll Manager, and according to established policies and procedures, the Payroll Specialist performs the processing of payroll and all related duties.
Payroll Specialist
Indianapolis, IN · On-site
$22.50 - $30.50/hr
Under the general supervision of the Senior Payroll Manager, and according to established policies and procedures, the Payroll Specialist performs the processing of payroll and all related duties.
Payroll Specialist
Indianapolis, IN · On-site
$22.25 - $30.25/hr
Process biweekly payroll & supplemental payrolls for more than 1,000 employees * Process all payroll reporting after each transmittal * Send out biweekly and supplemental payroll reports for various ...
Payroll Specialist
Indianapolis, IN · On-site
$22.25 - $30.25/hr
Process biweekly payroll & supplemental payrolls for more than 1,000 employees * Process all payroll reporting after each transmittal * Send out biweekly and supplemental payroll reports for various ...
Payroll Specialist
$28 - $30/hr
Payroll Specialist - $28-$30/hr DOE! This position is a direct hire opportunity! Integrity Trade Services is hiring a Payroll Specialist for our retail (home improvement) client to start immediately ...
Quick apply
Payroll Specialist
$28 - $30/hr
Payroll Specialist - $28-$30/hr DOE! This position is a direct hire opportunity! Integrity Trade Services is hiring a Payroll Specialist for our retail (home improvement) client to start immediately ...
Payroll Specialist
Merrillville, IN · On-site
$23 - $31.50/hr
Description UNDERSTANDING The Payroll and Benefits Specialist is responsible for ensuring employees are paid accurately and on time while maintaining the administration of company benefits deductions ...
Payroll Specialist
Merrillville, IN · On-site
$23 - $31.50/hr
Description UNDERSTANDING The Payroll and Benefits Specialist is responsible for ensuring employees are paid accurately and on time while maintaining the administration of company benefits deductions ...
Payroll Specialist
Indianapolis, IN · On-site
$22.25 - $30.25/hr
Process biweekly payroll & supplemental payrolls for more than 1,000 employees * Process all payroll reporting after each transmittal * Send out biweekly and supplemental payroll reports for various ...
Payroll Specialist
Indianapolis, IN · On-site
$22.25 - $30.25/hr
Process biweekly payroll & supplemental payrolls for more than 1,000 employees * Process all payroll reporting after each transmittal * Send out biweekly and supplemental payroll reports for various ...
Payroll Specialist
$22.50 - $30.50/hr
Process biweekly payroll & supplemental payrolls for more than 1,000 employees * Process all payroll reporting after each transmittal * Send out biweekly and supplemental payroll reports for various ...
Payroll Specialist
$22.50 - $30.50/hr
Process biweekly payroll & supplemental payrolls for more than 1,000 employees * Process all payroll reporting after each transmittal * Send out biweekly and supplemental payroll reports for various ...
Payroll Specialist
Merrillville, IN · On-site
$23 - $31.50/hr
UNDERSTANDING The Payroll and Benefits Specialist is responsible for ensuring employees are paid accurately and on time while maintaining the administration of company benefits deductions and other ...
Payroll Specialist
Merrillville, IN · On-site
$23 - $31.50/hr
UNDERSTANDING The Payroll and Benefits Specialist is responsible for ensuring employees are paid accurately and on time while maintaining the administration of company benefits deductions and other ...
Payroll Specialist
Indianapolis, IN · On-site
$22.50 - $30.50/hr
Process biweekly payroll & supplemental payrolls for more than 1,000 employees * Process all payroll reporting after each transmittal * Send out biweekly and supplemental payroll reports for various ...
Payroll Specialist
Indianapolis, IN · On-site
$22.50 - $30.50/hr
Process biweekly payroll & supplemental payrolls for more than 1,000 employees * Process all payroll reporting after each transmittal * Send out biweekly and supplemental payroll reports for various ...
Payroll Supervisor information
See Indiana salary details
$40K - $47.8K
3% of jobs
$47.8K - $55.7K
4% of jobs
$55.7K - $63.6K
11% of jobs
$67.5K is the 25th percentile. Wages below this are outliers.
$63.6K - $71.5K
14% of jobs
$71.5K - $79.3K
16% of jobs
The median wage is $80.4K / yr.
$79.3K - $87.2K
16% of jobs
$87.2K - $95.1K
11% of jobs
$95.6K is the 75th percentile. Wages above this are outliers.
$95.1K - $102.9K
9% of jobs
$102.9K - $110.8K
7% of jobs
$110.8K - $118.7K
6% of jobs
$118.7K - $126.6K
3% of jobs
$40K
$85.1K
$126.6K
How much do payroll supervisor jobs pay per year?
As of Aug 17, 2026, the average yearly pay for payroll supervisor in Indiana is $85,066.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $67,600.00 and $99,000.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.
What is a payroll supervisor?
Payroll Supervisors are professionals responsible for overseeing the payroll department within an organization. They ensure that employees are paid accurately and on time, manage payroll staff, and maintain compliance with tax laws and company policies. Their duties often include reviewing payroll reports, resolving discrepancies, and implementing payroll procedures. Payroll Supervisors also coordinate with HR and finance departments to handle benefits, deductions, and other compensation-related matters.
What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a payroll supervisor, and why are they important?
To thrive as a Payroll Supervisor, you need strong knowledge of payroll regulations, accounting principles, and experience with payroll processing, typically supported by a degree in accounting or finance. Familiarity with payroll software such as ADP, SAP, or Paychex, and possibly certification like the Certified Payroll Professional (CPP), is highly valuable. Excellent attention to detail, leadership, and effective communication skills set top performers apart in this role. These skills are crucial to ensure accurate payroll processing, compliance with legal requirements, and efficient team management.
What are some common challenges faced by payroll supervisors, and how can they be managed effectively?
Payroll Supervisors often face challenges such as keeping up with frequent changes in tax laws, ensuring payroll compliance, and handling discrepancies or errors under tight deadlines. Managing a team and coordinating with HR and finance departments to resolve issues promptly is essential. Staying organized, leveraging robust payroll software, and maintaining clear communication within the team and with other departments can help manage these challenges effectively.
What is the difference between Payroll Supervisor vs Payroll Specialist?
| Aspect | Payroll Supervisor | Payroll Specialist |
|---|---|---|
| Credentials | Typically requires a high school diploma or associate degree; certifications like CPP or FPC are common | Similar credentials; often holds CPP or FPC certifications |
| Work Environment | Supervises payroll team, oversees payroll processes, and ensures compliance | Executes payroll processing, audits, and data entry tasks |
| Employer & Industry Usage | Used across industries; found in HR or finance departments | Commonly employed in payroll or HR departments within various industries |
| Search & Comparison Intent | People comparing payroll management roles or seeking supervisory positions | Individuals looking for hands-on payroll processing roles |
The Payroll Supervisor oversees payroll operations and manages payroll staff, ensuring accuracy and compliance. The Payroll Specialist focuses on processing payroll data, maintaining records, and executing payroll tasks. While both roles require similar certifications and work in payroll departments, the supervisor has a leadership role, whereas the specialist handles the detailed payroll processing.
Is payroll a stressful job?
Payroll supervisors are responsible for ensuring accurate and timely processing of employee payments, which can involve tight deadlines and attention to detail. The job can be stressful during peak periods such as payroll processing deadlines or audits, but effective organization and familiarity with payroll software can help manage workload and reduce stress.
What are the top 3 skills for a payroll supervisor?
A payroll supervisor needs strong attention to detail to ensure accurate processing of employee payments, excellent organizational skills to manage payroll schedules and compliance, and proficiency with payroll software and systems. Good communication skills are also essential for coordinating with HR, finance, and employees. Certifications like payroll certification can enhance credibility and efficiency in the role.
More about Payroll Supervisor jobs
What are popular job titles related to Payroll Supervisor jobs in Indiana?
For Payroll Supervisor jobs in Indiana, the most frequently searched job titles are:
What job categories do people searching Payroll Supervisor jobs in Indiana look for?
The top searched job categories for Payroll Supervisor jobs in Indiana are:
What are popular job titles related to Payroll Supervisor jobs in IN?
For Payroll Supervisor jobs in IN, the most frequently searched job titles are:
$28 - $32/hr
Full-time
Medical, Dental, Vision, Life, Retirement, PTO
Posted yesterday
New
Job description
Join a Growing Team as a Payroll Specialist
Are you a detail-oriented payroll professional looking for an opportunity to make an impact? Our client, a well-established Manufacturing company in the Indianapolis area, is seeking a Payroll Specialist to join their accounting and finance team. This role offers the opportunity to work in a collaborative environment where accuracy, customer service, and process improvement are valued. If you enjoy managing payroll operations, ensuring compliance, and supporting employees, we'd love to hear from you.
Responsibilities
Search managed by: Coleman Harris
Benefit offerings available for our associates include medical, dental, vision, life insurance, short-term disability, additional voluntary benefits, EAP program, commuter benefits and a 401K plan. Our benefit offerings provide employees the flexibility to choose the type of coverage that meets their individual needs. In addition, our associates may be eligible for paid leave including Paid Sick Leave or any other paid leave required by Federal, State, or local law, as well as Holiday pay where applicable.
Equal Opportunity Employer/Veterans/Disabled
Military connected talent encouraged to apply
To read our Candidate Privacy Information Statement, which explains how we will use your information, please navigate to https://www.lhh.com/us/en/candidate-privacy
The Company will consider qualified applicants with arrest and conviction records in accordance with federal, state, and local laws and/or security clearance requirements, including, as applicable:
Are you a detail-oriented payroll professional looking for an opportunity to make an impact? Our client, a well-established Manufacturing company in the Indianapolis area, is seeking a Payroll Specialist to join their accounting and finance team. This role offers the opportunity to work in a collaborative environment where accuracy, customer service, and process improvement are valued. If you enjoy managing payroll operations, ensuring compliance, and supporting employees, we'd love to hear from you.
Responsibilities
- Process multi-state payroll accurately and on schedule
- Maintain payroll records and employee compensation information
- Review and audit payroll data including wages, deductions, taxes, and benefits
- Ensure compliance with federal, state, and local payroll regulations
- Prepare and distribute W-2s, payroll reports, and other required documentation
- Process garnishments, benefit deductions, and payroll adjustments
- Reconcile payroll accounts and assist with month-end reporting
- Respond to employee payroll inquiries in a timely and professional manner
- Partner with Human Resources regarding new hires, terminations, and employee changes
- Assist with payroll audits and support continuous process improvements
- 3+ years of payroll processing experience
- Knowledge of payroll tax regulations and compliance requirements
- Experience processing payroll for multiple employees and pay groups
- Proficiency with payroll software such as ADP, Paychex, UKG, Workday, or similar systems
- Strong Microsoft Excel skills
- Excellent attention to detail and organizational abilities
- Ability to handle confidential information with professionalism
- Strong communication and problem-solving skills
- Certified Payroll Professional (CPP) designation
- Multi-state payroll experience
- Experience with HRIS and ERP systems
Search managed by: Coleman Harris
Benefit offerings available for our associates include medical, dental, vision, life insurance, short-term disability, additional voluntary benefits, EAP program, commuter benefits and a 401K plan. Our benefit offerings provide employees the flexibility to choose the type of coverage that meets their individual needs. In addition, our associates may be eligible for paid leave including Paid Sick Leave or any other paid leave required by Federal, State, or local law, as well as Holiday pay where applicable.
Equal Opportunity Employer/Veterans/Disabled
Military connected talent encouraged to apply
To read our Candidate Privacy Information Statement, which explains how we will use your information, please navigate to https://www.lhh.com/us/en/candidate-privacy
The Company will consider qualified applicants with arrest and conviction records in accordance with federal, state, and local laws and/or security clearance requirements, including, as applicable:
- The California Fair Chance Act
- Los Angeles City Fair Chance Ordinance
- Los Angeles County Fair Chance Ordinance for Employers
- San Francisco Fair Chance Ordinance