1

Payroll Supervisor Jobs in Wisconsin (NOW HIRING)

Specialist, Payroll - Vantagen

Janesville, WI · On-site

$23 - $31.50/hr

Under the supervision of the Payroll Supervisor, this role is expected to be independently managing their client relationships, however, when needed, escalating issues or challenges for prompt ...

Specialist, Payroll - Vantagen

Milwaukee, WI · On-site

$23.25 - $31.50/hr

Under the supervision of the Payroll Supervisor, this role is expected to be independently managing their client relationships, however, when needed, escalating issues or challenges for prompt ...

Specialist, Payroll - Vantagen

Madison, WI · On-site

$23.75 - $32.25/hr

Under the supervision of the Payroll Supervisor, this role is expected to be independently managing their client relationships, however, when needed, escalating issues or challenges for prompt ...

Specialist, Payroll - Vantagen

Eau Claire, WI · On-site

$23.25 - $31.75/hr

Under the supervision of the Payroll Supervisor, this role is expected to be independently managing their client relationships, however, when needed, escalating issues or challenges for prompt ...

Specialist, Payroll - Vantagen

Milwaukee, WI · On-site

$23.25 - $31.50/hr

Under the supervision of the Payroll Supervisor, this role is expected to be independently managing their client relationships, however, when needed, escalating issues or challenges for prompt ...

Specialist, Payroll - Vantagen

Appleton, WI · On-site

$23 - $31.25/hr

Under the supervision of the Payroll Supervisor, this role is expected to be independently managing their client relationships, however, when needed, escalating issues or challenges for prompt ...

Specialist, Payroll - Vantagen

Appleton, WI

$23 - $31.25/hr

Under the supervision of the Payroll Supervisor, this role is expected to be independently managing their client relationships, however, when needed, escalating issues or challenges for prompt ...

Specialist, Payroll - Vantagen

Madison, WI · On-site

$23.75 - $32.25/hr

Under the supervision of the Payroll Supervisor, this role is expected to be independently managing their client relationships, however, when needed, escalating issues or challenges for prompt ...

Under the supervision of the Payroll Supervisor, this role is expected to be independently managing their client relationships, however, when needed, escalating issues or challenges for prompt ...

Specialist, Payroll - Vantagen

Eau Claire, WI · On-site

$23.25 - $31.75/hr

Under the supervision of the Payroll Supervisor, this role is expected to be independently managing their client relationships, however, when needed, escalating issues or challenges for prompt ...

Assistant Finance Director

Janesville, WI · On-site

$51.52 - $56.11/hr

Works with the Payroll Supervisor, HR, and IT to implement process changes or enhancements. * Assist the Public Works Accounting Supervisor in oversight of the DPW Accounting Division. Act as backup ...

Assistant Finance Director

Janesville, WI · On-site

$51.52 - $56.11/hr

Works with the Payroll Supervisor, HR, and IT to implement process changes or enhancements. Assist the Public Works Accounting Supervisor in oversight of the DPW Accounting Division. Act as backup to ...

Accounting Clerk

Mukwonago, WI · On-site

$18.25 - $23.50/hr

Accounting Clerk is responsible for keeping the company's expenses and payables accurate, as well as processing the company's payroll. Supervisor: Accounting/Finance Manager Required Qualifications:

Payroll Specialist

Sparta, WI · On-site

$21.75 - $29.50/hr

The Payroll Specialist will process weekly hourly payrolls for all Ashley Companies and prepare ... Answer questions from supervisors and employees regarding pay. What Do You Need? * Associate Degree ...

Payroll Manager

Milwaukee, WI · On-site

$120K - $130K/yr

Prior leadership experience with responsibility for supervising payroll personnel or functions. * Hands-on experience managing bi-monthly payroll schedules with a high degree of accuracy. * Bachelors ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

Payroll Supervisor information

See Wisconsin salary details

$42.4K

$90.2K

$134.2K

How much do payroll supervisor jobs pay per year?

As of Sep 5, 2026, the average yearly pay for payroll supervisor in Wisconsin is $90,232.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $71,700.00 and $105,000.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is a payroll supervisor?

Payroll Supervisors are professionals responsible for overseeing the payroll department within an organization. They ensure that employees are paid accurately and on time, manage payroll staff, and maintain compliance with tax laws and company policies. Their duties often include reviewing payroll reports, resolving discrepancies, and implementing payroll procedures. Payroll Supervisors also coordinate with HR and finance departments to handle benefits, deductions, and other compensation-related matters.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a payroll supervisor, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Payroll Supervisor, you need strong knowledge of payroll regulations, accounting principles, and experience with payroll processing, typically supported by a degree in accounting or finance. Familiarity with payroll software such as ADP, SAP, or Paychex, and possibly certification like the Certified Payroll Professional (CPP), is highly valuable. Excellent attention to detail, leadership, and effective communication skills set top performers apart in this role. These skills are crucial to ensure accurate payroll processing, compliance with legal requirements, and efficient team management.

What are some common challenges faced by payroll supervisors, and how can they be managed effectively?

Payroll Supervisors often face challenges such as keeping up with frequent changes in tax laws, ensuring payroll compliance, and handling discrepancies or errors under tight deadlines. Managing a team and coordinating with HR and finance departments to resolve issues promptly is essential. Staying organized, leveraging robust payroll software, and maintaining clear communication within the team and with other departments can help manage these challenges effectively.

What is the difference between Payroll Supervisor vs Payroll Specialist?

AspectPayroll SupervisorPayroll Specialist
CredentialsTypically requires a high school diploma or associate degree; certifications like CPP or FPC are commonSimilar credentials; often holds CPP or FPC certifications
Work EnvironmentSupervises payroll team, oversees payroll processes, and ensures complianceExecutes payroll processing, audits, and data entry tasks
Employer & Industry UsageUsed across industries; found in HR or finance departmentsCommonly employed in payroll or HR departments within various industries
Search & Comparison IntentPeople comparing payroll management roles or seeking supervisory positionsIndividuals looking for hands-on payroll processing roles

The Payroll Supervisor oversees payroll operations and manages payroll staff, ensuring accuracy and compliance. The Payroll Specialist focuses on processing payroll data, maintaining records, and executing payroll tasks. While both roles require similar certifications and work in payroll departments, the supervisor has a leadership role, whereas the specialist handles the detailed payroll processing.

How much do payroll supervisors make in the US?

Payroll supervisors in the US typically earn an average salary of around $70,000 to $85,000 per year, depending on experience, location, and company size. They often oversee payroll processing, ensure compliance, and may use payroll software like ADP or Paychex.
More about Payroll Supervisor jobs

What are the most commonly searched types of Payroll Supervisor jobs in Wisconsin?

The most popular types of Payroll Supervisor jobs in Wisconsin are:

What are popular job titles related to Payroll Supervisor jobs in Wisconsin?

For Payroll Supervisor jobs in Wisconsin, the most frequently searched job titles are:

What job categories do people searching Payroll Supervisor jobs in Wisconsin look for?

The top searched job categories for Payroll Supervisor jobs in Wisconsin are:

What cities in Wisconsin are hiring for Payroll Supervisor jobs?

Cities in Wisconsin with the most Payroll Supervisor job openings:

What are popular job titles related to Payroll Supervisor jobs in WI?

For Payroll Supervisor jobs in WI, the most frequently searched job titles are:

Infographic showing various Payroll Supervisor job openings in Wisconsin as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 75% Full Time, 20% Part Time, 1% Temporary, 2% Contract, and 1% Nights. Highlights an 97% Physical, 1% Hybrid, and 2% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $90,232 per year, or $43.4 per hour.

Specialist, Payroll - Vantagen

Bakertilly

Janesville, WI • On-site

$23 - $31.50/hr

Full-time

Re-posted 2 days ago


Baker Tilly rating

8.8

Company rating: 8.8 out of 10

Based on 34 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

5th of 23 rated bookkeepers and accountants


Job description

Overview

Baker Tilly is a leading advisory, tax and assurance firm, providing clients with a genuine coast-to-coast and global advantage in major regions of the U.S. and in many of the world's leading financial centers - New York, London, San Francisco, Los Angeles, Chicago and Boston. Baker Tilly Advisory Group, LP and Baker Tilly US, LLP (Baker Tilly) provide professional services through an alternative practice structure in accordance with the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct and applicable laws, regulations and professional standards. Baker Tilly US, LLP is a licensed independent CPA firm that provides attest services to its clients. Baker Tilly Advisory Group, LP and its subsidiary entities provide tax and business advisory services to their clients. Baker Tilly Advisory Group, LP and its subsidiary entities are not licensed CPA firms.

Baker Tilly Advisory Group, LP and Baker Tilly US, LLP, trading as Baker Tilly, are independent members of Baker Tilly International, a worldwide network of independent accounting and business advisory firms in 141 territories, with 43,000 professionals and a combined worldwide revenue of $5.2 billion. Visitbakertilly.comor join the conversation onLinkedIn,FacebookandInstagram.

Please discuss the work location status with your Baker Tilly talent acquisition professional to understand the requirements for an opportunity you are exploring.

Baker Tilly is an equal opportunity/affirmative action employer. All qualified applicants will receive consideration for employment without regard to race, color, religion, sex, national origin, disability or protected veteran status, gender identity, sexual orientation, or any other legally protected basis, in accordance with applicable federal, state or local law.

Any unsolicited resumes submitted through our website or to Baker Tilly Advisory Group, LP, employee e-mail accounts are considered property of Baker Tilly Advisory Group, LP, and are not subject to payment of agency fees. In order to be an authorized recruitment agency ("search firm") for Baker Tilly Advisory Group, LP, there must be a formal written agreement in place and the agency must be invited, by Baker Tilly's Talent Attraction team, to submit candidates for review via our applicant tracking system.

Job Description:

The main responsibilities of this role is to provide direct support and consulting to our payroll clients. This role is expected to understand payroll in depth and to maintain knowledge of payroll practices and laws so as to provide better service and information to our clients. Under the supervision of the Payroll Supervisor, this role is expected to be independently managing their client relationships, however, when needed, escalating issues or challenges for prompt resolution.
Client Service & Deliverables

  • Ensure client payroll information is accurate within their specific payroll system and resolve any discrepancies

  • Review and/or process payrolls in a timely manner to meet client deadlines to include updating employee records, calculating/paying bonuses or severance, reviewing accuracy of federal and state income related tax calculations, and reconciling payroll deposits, tax withholdings, wage garnishments, etc.

  • Prepare reports of employee earnings, taxes, deductions, and employer's contribution for social security and unemployment


Client Service

  • Establish strong and trusted client relationships by effectively consulting with clients on all payroll related matters

  • Maintain confidence of employee data by keeping all information confidential

  • Accurately convey detailed information in both written and verbal format

  • Provide technical software support to clients

  • Identify and accurately capture out of scope work

  • Identify new opportunities to expand services to clients


Implementation & Technology

  • Be an additional resource to the implementation team when needed

  • Interviews clients to gain understanding of payroll needs

  • Manage new client implementation projects, ensuring timely completion and client satisfaction

  • Train clients on payroll processes as necessary

Individual and Team Development

  • Be a resource to new hires and/or less experienced staff as it relates to clients, software, payroll, and/or processes

  • Provide honest feedback to new hires/less experienced staff in a timely manner

  • Help build team capabilities and knowledge by sharing insights and lessons learned

  • Research and maintain product knowledge on ADP software platforms

  • Maintain current knowledge of local, state, and federal practices and laws


Qualifications:
  • 2-year degree preferred or 2 years experience in lieu of degree

  • Associate degree preferred

  • Experience with ADP software platforms desirable

  • Working knowledge of Outlook and Microsoft Office Suite (Word, Excel, PowerPoint)

  • Highly detail oriented and focused on accuracy

  • Strong organization and time management skills

  • Strong adaptability and multi-tasking skills

  • Ability to effectively work in a deadline driven environment serving multiple clients

  • Ability to provide exceptional client service

  • Strong written and verbal communication skills; appropriately and professionally communicates with all levels

  • Ability to learn new technology and processes quickly

  • Ability to learn from experiences and integrate new knowledge and skills into daily work and share with colleagues as appropriate

The compensation range for this role is $15.97 to $41.00. Actual compensation is influenced by a variety of factors including but not limited to skills, experience, qualifications, and geographic location.


What Baker Tilly employees say

Pay

Benefits

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom