1

Compensation Manager Jobs in Indiana (NOW HIRING)

Managing in that processing environment can feel robotic. Strategic Comp is a growing workers' compensation insurer with dedication to and pride in outstanding claims outcomes. Our profitability ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

Compensation Manager information

See Indiana salary details

$33.8K

$109.2K

$161.3K

How much do compensation manager jobs pay per year?

As of Jul 6, 2026, the average yearly pay for compensation manager in Indiana is $109,173.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $91,400.00 and $126,100.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What Is a Compensation Manager?

A compensation manager is part of a corporate HR team which researches and develops the pay policies in a company. They use research to help determine fair pay scales for all the company employees. Duties include helping the business with recruiting and integrating new employees. At a small company, they might be responsible for all aspects of the pay system, while at a larger company they may have specific responsibilities, such as doing market research or surveying workers.

What does a compensation manager do?

A compensation manager develops and manages salary structures, incentive programs, and benefits to ensure competitive and equitable pay practices within an organization. They analyze market data, ensure compliance with regulations, and collaborate with HR and finance teams to align compensation strategies with company goals. Strong analytical skills and knowledge of compensation software are essential for this role.

What is the difference between Compensation Manager vs Compensation Analyst?

AspectCompensation ManagerCompensation Analyst
CredentialsBachelor's degree, often HR or Business; certifications like CCP or CBPBachelor's degree in HR, Business, or related; certifications like CCP beneficial
Work EnvironmentOversees compensation strategies, manages teams, collaborates with HR leadershipAnalyzes salary data, prepares reports, supports compensation programs
Employer & Industry UsageUsed in large organizations across various industriesCommon in HR departments, especially in finance, healthcare, and tech sectors

The Compensation Manager focuses on developing and managing overall compensation strategies, policies, and team leadership. In contrast, the Compensation Analyst primarily conducts data analysis, prepares reports, and supports compensation program implementation. Both roles require similar credentials but differ in scope and responsibilities within the compensation function.

What jobs pay $500,000 a year in the US?

In the US, Compensation Managers typically do not earn $500,000 annually; such high salaries are more common in executive roles like CEOs, investment bankers, or specialized surgeons. High-paying positions often require extensive experience, advanced degrees, and leadership responsibilities. Compensation Managers earning this level are rare and usually hold senior executive or consulting roles with bonuses and stock options included.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a Compensation Manager, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Compensation Manager, you need expertise in compensation analysis, benefits administration, and compliance, often supported by a degree in human resources or business and relevant certifications such as CCP (Certified Compensation Professional). Familiarity with HRIS systems, data analytics tools, and compensation benchmarking software is typically required. Strong analytical thinking, attention to detail, and effective communication skills help you design competitive pay structures and collaborate with stakeholders. These skills ensure fair, data-driven compensation practices that support employee satisfaction and organizational goals.

What degree do you need to be a compensation manager?

A compensation manager typically needs a bachelor's degree in human resources, business administration, finance, or a related field. Many employers prefer candidates with a master's degree or professional certifications such as the Certified Compensation Professional (CCP). Relevant experience and knowledge of compensation strategies and HR software are also important.

What are some common challenges Compensation Managers face when designing competitive pay structures?

Compensation Managers often navigate the challenge of balancing internal equity, market competitiveness, and budget constraints when designing pay structures. They must ensure that compensation packages attract and retain top talent while staying compliant with regulations and maintaining fairness across the organization. Additionally, Compensation Managers regularly analyze market data, manage employee expectations, and collaborate with HR and leadership to support organizational goals. These complexities require strong analytical skills, communication, and the ability to adapt to changing market trends.
What are the most commonly searched types of Compensation jobs in Indiana? The most popular types of Compensation jobs in Indiana are:
What are popular job titles related to Compensation Manager jobs in Indiana? For Compensation Manager jobs in Indiana, the most frequently searched job titles are:
What cities in Indiana are hiring for Compensation Manager jobs? Cities in Indiana with the most Compensation Manager job openings:
Infographic showing various Compensation Manager job openings in Indiana as of June 2026, with employment types broken down into 80% Full Time, 17% Part Time, and 3% Contract. Highlights an 88% Physical, 3% Hybrid, and 9% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $109,173 per year, or $52.5 per hour.

Total Rewards (Compensation & Benefits) Analyst

Innovative Hematology, Inc.

Indianapolis, IN • Hybrid

$66K - $83K/yr

Full-time

Posted 7 days ago


Job description

About IHI

At the Innovative Hematology (IHI), we offer a future where people with rare blood disorders flourish. Our experts provide the highest quality comprehensive services and holistic care to patients with bleeding, clotting and other hematologic disorders, and to their families.

What You Will Do

The Total Rewards Analyst is responsible for the operational administration, analysis, and continuous improvement of compensation and benefits programs. This role owns day-to-day Total Rewards analytics, reporting, and program execution, while supporting strategic program development led by the Total Rewards Program Manager.

The Opportunity

  • Compensation (Operational Execution)
    • Conducts market pricing and benchmarking; evaluate roles for grade and salary placement
    • Maintains pay structures, job architecture, and compensation documentation
    • Analyzes internal equity, market competitiveness, and pay relationships
    • Produces recurring compensation reports and dashboards
    • Tracks key metrics (compa-ratio, range penetration, market index, pay equity indicators)
    • Supports merit, bonus, and incentive cycles (modeling, tracking, reporting)
    • Identifies compression, inversion, and retention risks
    • Participates in salary surveys and analyze results
  • Benefits (Administration & Reporting)
    • Administers benefit programs including enrollments, life event changes, and employee inquiries
    • Supports open enrollment execution (system configuration, communications, vendor coordination)
    • Monitors participation, utilization, and vendor reporting
    • Maintains accurate benefit records and documentation
    • Develops and maintain IHI's employee benefits site and employee benefits education
  • HR Analytics & Reporting
    • Develops and maintain standardized and self-service HR/Total Rewards reports (e.g., ADP)
    • Reduces reliance on manual report pulls by enabling HR team access and usability
    • Ensures data integrity across compensation and benefits systems
    • Delivers analytics to support operational and leadership decision-making
    • Provides analytical and administrative support for disability and leave management programs, including tracking leave utilization, coordinating with third-party administrators, monitoring case status, and supporting employee and manger inquiries
  • Program Administration & Process Ownership
    • Serves as day-to-day liaison with vendors, brokers, and third-party administrators
    • Develops, document, and maintain SOPs for recurring Total Rewards processes
    • Executes administrative processes aligned with defined SOPs
    • Supports year-end activities including open enrollment and compensation cycles
  • Collaboration & Support
    • Partners with HR Generalist on job evaluation, leveling, and organizational design
    • Provides guidance to HR Generalists on compensation and benefits processes
    • Partners with HR Generalist and managers to administer disability, leave of absence, and accommodation programs, ensuring compliance with company policies and applicable federal and state regulations
    • Supports Total Rewards Program Manager with data, analysis, and presentation materials
    • Participates in team workflows with clear accountability boundaries
  • Compliance & Governance Support (Defined Boundary)
    • Ensures accurate data and documentation to support audits and compliance reviews
    • Executes operational controls (data validation, reconciliations, reporting)
    • Escalates compliance risks or discrepancies to HR Compliance leadership
    • Supports the administration of FMLA, ADA, Short-Term Disability (STD), Long-Term Disability (LTD), and other leave programs by partnering with HR Generalists to ensure timely processing, regulatory compliance, and accurate recordkepping.
  • (Note: This role supports compliance processes but does not own compliance governance or regulatory reporting.)

This position is designed to be a hybrid role, splitting time between the IHI office in Indianapolis, IN and home. Only candidates residing in the Indianapolis metropolitan and surrounding area will be considered.

Requirements

  • Minimum Bachelor's degree in human resources or related field, or 5 years of experience in Human Resources, required.
  • Minimum 1-3 years of benefits, compensation, HR analytics, finance, or related experience; healthcare experience, preferred.
  • Knowledge of employee benefits and applicable laws and regulations.
  • Proficiency in Word and Microsoft Office, including Microsoft Excel and PowerPoint.
  • Knowledge of appropriate analysis and application of competitive salary surveys.
  • Strong Excel proficiency skills.
  • Skills with preparing presentations leveraging data analytics.

Benefits

IHI is a not-for-profit program based in Indianapolis and offers a competitive salary and benefit package.

IHI is the only federally designated comprehensive hemophilia program in Indiana, and serves the entire state through services available in Indianapolis and at outreach clinics.

IHI is a leader in hemophilia care, education and clinical research and has a dedicated on-site multidisciplinary staff to ensure availability of a wide range of required services.

IHI participates in national and international clinical research, including new infusion products and therapies, investigation of long-term outcomes, and the impact of associated conditions. The IHI research program provides patients access to new therapies, and an opportunity to improve care. Our center has more than 50 clinical research projects involving bleeding disorders, sickle cell disease, thrombosis and more.

Innovative Hematology, Inc. is an Equal Opportunity Employer.