Our goal as insurance recruiters is to help insurance organizations identify, attract and retain experienced talent that impacts immediate openings and promotes future growth. We offer Direct Hire ...
Quick apply
Our goal as insurance recruiters is to help insurance organizations identify, attract and retain experienced talent that impacts immediate openings and promotes future growth. We offer Direct Hire ...
Recruiter
Columbus, OH · On-site
$54K - $66K/yr
Medical Insurance * Flexible Benefit Options Including Dental, Vision and Wellness Support ... As a Recruiter, you'll play a meaningful role in building sound relationships with field staff ...
New
Quick apply
Recruiter
Columbus, OH · On-site
$54K - $66K/yr
Medical Insurance * Flexible Benefit Options Including Dental, Vision and Wellness Support ... As a Recruiter, you'll play a meaningful role in building sound relationships with field staff ...
New
Recruiter
Columbus, OH · On-site
$54K - $66K/yr
Medical Insurance * Flexible Benefit Options Including Dental, Vision and Wellness Support ... As a Recruiter, you'll play a meaningful role in building sound relationships with field staff ...
New
Quick apply
Recruiter
Columbus, OH · On-site
$54K - $66K/yr
Medical Insurance * Flexible Benefit Options Including Dental, Vision and Wellness Support ... As a Recruiter, you'll play a meaningful role in building sound relationships with field staff ...
New
Recruiter
South Charleston, OH · On-site
Recruiter Job Summary : This position provides support to production by facilitating new hires from ... Vision Insurance * ❤️ Company-Paid Life Insurance for added peace of mind * 401(k) Retirement ...
Recruiter
South Charleston, OH · On-site
Recruiter Job Summary : This position provides support to production by facilitating new hires from ... Vision Insurance * ❤️ Company-Paid Life Insurance for added peace of mind * 401(k) Retirement ...
Recruiter / Senior Recruiter
Columbus, OH · Hybrid
$60K - $95K/yr
This role will partner with Matic leaders and executives to recruit, assess, and hire talent across insurance sales, customer service, and other departments. This is a hybrid role based out of our ...
Recruiter / Senior Recruiter
Columbus, OH · Hybrid
$60K - $95K/yr
This role will partner with Matic leaders and executives to recruit, assess, and hire talent across insurance sales, customer service, and other departments. This is a hybrid role based out of our ...
... insurance, paid vacation, and more. This is your opportunity to make a difference for you and your ... The Recruiter works jointly with hiring managers overseeing the sourcing, screening, interviewing ...
... insurance, paid vacation, and more. This is your opportunity to make a difference for you and your ... The Recruiter works jointly with hiring managers overseeing the sourcing, screening, interviewing ...
Recruiter
Columbus, OH · On-site
... insurance, paid vacation, and more. This is your opportunity to make a difference for you and your ... The Recruiter works jointly with hiring managers overseeing the sourcing, screening, interviewing ...
Recruiter
Columbus, OH · On-site
... insurance, paid vacation, and more. This is your opportunity to make a difference for you and your ... The Recruiter works jointly with hiring managers overseeing the sourcing, screening, interviewing ...
Recruiter
Columbus, OH · On-site
... insurance, paid vacation, and more. This is your opportunity to make a difference for you and your ... The Recruiter works jointly with hiring managers overseeing the sourcing, screening, interviewing ...
Quick apply
Recruiter
Columbus, OH · On-site
... insurance, paid vacation, and more. This is your opportunity to make a difference for you and your ... The Recruiter works jointly with hiring managers overseeing the sourcing, screening, interviewing ...
Frontline Recruiter
Groveport, OH · On-site
Frontline Recruiter Do you have a passion for dynamic recruiting within a fast-paced environment ... We offer competitive wages, excellent affordable insurance benefits (including health, dental ...
Frontline Recruiter
Groveport, OH · On-site
Frontline Recruiter Do you have a passion for dynamic recruiting within a fast-paced environment ... We offer competitive wages, excellent affordable insurance benefits (including health, dental ...
Recruiter - Full -Time
Columbus, OH · Hybrid
JOB TITLE: Recruiter - Full -Time LOCATION: Hybrid Work from Home - 2 Days in Office TRAVEL ... Indemnity Insurance: Extra protection for life's unexpected detours. * Paid Time Off & Holidays:
Recruiter - Full -Time
Columbus, OH · Hybrid
JOB TITLE: Recruiter - Full -Time LOCATION: Hybrid Work from Home - 2 Days in Office TRAVEL ... Indemnity Insurance: Extra protection for life's unexpected detours. * Paid Time Off & Holidays:
Frontline Recruiter
Groveport, OH · On-site
Frontline Recruiter Do you have a passion for dynamic recruiting within a fast-paced environment ... We offer competitive wages, excellent affordable insurance benefits (including health, dental ...
Frontline Recruiter
Groveport, OH · On-site
Frontline Recruiter Do you have a passion for dynamic recruiting within a fast-paced environment ... We offer competitive wages, excellent affordable insurance benefits (including health, dental ...
Recruiter - Full -Time
Columbus, OH · On-site
$50K - $65K/yr
JOB TITLE: Recruiter - Full -Time LOCATION: Hybrid Work from Home - 2 Days in Office TRAVEL ... Indemnity Insurance: Extra protection for life's unexpected detours. * Paid Time Off & Holidays:
Recruiter - Full -Time
Columbus, OH · On-site
$50K - $65K/yr
JOB TITLE: Recruiter - Full -Time LOCATION: Hybrid Work from Home - 2 Days in Office TRAVEL ... Indemnity Insurance: Extra protection for life's unexpected detours. * Paid Time Off & Holidays:
Recruiter - Full -Time
Columbus, OH · Hybrid
JOB TITLE: Recruiter - Full -Time LOCATION: Hybrid Work from Home - 2 Days in Office TRAVEL ... Indemnity Insurance: Extra protection for life's unexpected detours. * Paid Time Off & Holidays:
Recruiter - Full -Time
Columbus, OH · Hybrid
JOB TITLE: Recruiter - Full -Time LOCATION: Hybrid Work from Home - 2 Days in Office TRAVEL ... Indemnity Insurance: Extra protection for life's unexpected detours. * Paid Time Off & Holidays:
Full-Desk Recruiter
Columbus, OH · On-site
Life Insurance * 401K Plan + Employer Match * PTO (Vacation, Personal, & Holiday) Requirements: * Bachelor's degree preferred. * 2+ years of full desk Recruiting experience required * Must have an ...
New
Full-Desk Recruiter
Columbus, OH · On-site
Life Insurance * 401K Plan + Employer Match * PTO (Vacation, Personal, & Holiday) Requirements: * Bachelor's degree preferred. * 2+ years of full desk Recruiting experience required * Must have an ...
New
Driver Recruiter
Westerville, OH · On-site
Our recruiting environment is fast-moving and highly collaborative. Whether engaging candidates ... We offer competitive wages, excellent affordable insurance benefits (including health, dental ...
Driver Recruiter
Westerville, OH · On-site
Our recruiting environment is fast-moving and highly collaborative. Whether engaging candidates ... We offer competitive wages, excellent affordable insurance benefits (including health, dental ...
Driver Recruiter
Westerville, OH · On-site
Our recruiting environment is fast-moving and highly collaborative. Whether engaging candidates ... We offer competitive wages, excellent affordable insurance benefits (including health, dental ...
Driver Recruiter
Westerville, OH · On-site
Our recruiting environment is fast-moving and highly collaborative. Whether engaging candidates ... We offer competitive wages, excellent affordable insurance benefits (including health, dental ...
Our recruiting environment is fast-moving and highly collaborative. Whether engaging candidates ... We offer competitive wages, excellent affordable insurance benefits (including health, dental ...
Our recruiting environment is fast-moving and highly collaborative. Whether engaging candidates ... We offer competitive wages, excellent affordable insurance benefits (including health, dental ...
Executive Recruiter
Columbus, OH · On-site
$55K - $60K/yr
We're looking for a talented Executive Recruiter to join our growing team. If you're a results ... Life Insurance * 401k * Paid Time Off
Executive Recruiter
Columbus, OH · On-site
$55K - $60K/yr
We're looking for a talented Executive Recruiter to join our growing team. If you're a results ... Life Insurance * 401k * Paid Time Off
Internal Recruiter
Lancaster, OH · On-site
We're looking for a Recruiter (Pipeline Builder) who knows how to hunt. This role is about building ... Health, dental, and vision insurance * Paid time off * Professional development * Referral ...
Quick apply
Internal Recruiter
Lancaster, OH · On-site
We're looking for a Recruiter (Pipeline Builder) who knows how to hunt. This role is about building ... Health, dental, and vision insurance * Paid time off * Professional development * Referral ...
Internal Recruiter
Lancaster, OH · On-site
We're looking for a Recruiter (Pipeline Builder) who knows how to hunt. This role is about building ... Health, dental, and vision insurance * Paid time off * Professional development * Referral ...
Internal Recruiter
Lancaster, OH · On-site
We're looking for a Recruiter (Pipeline Builder) who knows how to hunt. This role is about building ... Health, dental, and vision insurance * Paid time off * Professional development * Referral ...
Insurance Recruiter information
See salary details
$12.02 - $15.01
2% of jobs
$15.01 - $18.01
9% of jobs
$20.38 is the 25th percentile. Wages below this are outliers.
$18.01 - $21
18% of jobs
$21 - $23.99
16% of jobs
The median wage is $24.93 / hr.
$23.99 - $26.99
17% of jobs
$26.99 - $29.98
11% of jobs
$30.73 is the 75th percentile. Wages above this are outliers.
$29.98 - $32.98
11% of jobs
$32.98 - $35.97
7% of jobs
$35.97 - $38.96
5% of jobs
$38.96 - $41.96
3% of jobs
$41.96 - $44.95
1% of jobs
$12
$27
$44
How much do insurance recruiter jobs pay per hour?
As of Aug 24, 2026, the average hourly pay for insurance recruiter in the United States is $27.23, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $20.19 and $31.97 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.
What are popular job titles related to Insurance Recruiter jobs?
For Insurance Recruiter jobs, the most frequently searched job titles are:
What job categories do people searching Insurance Recruiter jobs look for?
The top searched job categories for Insurance Recruiter jobs are:
What cities are hiring for Insurance Recruiter jobs?
Cities with the most Insurance Recruiter job openings:
What states have the most Insurance Recruiter jobs?
States with the most job openings for Insurance Recruiter jobs include:
What are the most commonly searched types of Insurance Recruiter jobs?
The most popular types of Insurance Recruiter jobs are:
Full-time
Medical, Dental, Vision, Life, Retirement, PTO
Re-posted 2 days ago
Job description
About the Role
An insurance agency in Columbus, OH wants to hire an experienced insurance professional to manage internal operations. As Agency Service Manager, you will be involved in client service, community outreach, employee mentoring/supervision, processes and procedures, and ensuring the agency is meeting/exceeding agency objectives.
Location: Columbus, OH
Experience: Property and casualty insurance experience with knowledge of service processes and ideally some prior supervisory/team leadership experience
License: Requires an active Ohio insurance license
Company Description
Capstone Search Group is an insurance recruiting firm that offers creative, unique staffing solutions for the insurance industry! Our clients include insurance companies, agencies, brokers and intermediaries. Our goal as insurance recruiters is to help insurance organizations identify, attract and retain experienced talent that impacts immediate openings and promotes future growth. We offer Direct Hire (Contingency Search, Engaged/Retained and Recruitment Process Outsourcing [RPO]) and Contract Solutions (long-term contract, 1099 and temp-to-perm). We work nationally with expertise that spans top executives, middle management and technical level positions. We are committed to providing recruiting services of the highest degree of confidentiality, professionalism and integrity.
About Capstone Search Group
Sourced by ZipRecruiter
Industry
Recruiting and staffing services
Company size
1 - 10 Employees
Headquarters location
Clive, IA, US
Year founded
2002