ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Property Insurance Agent Jobs in Indiana (NOW HIRING)

AAA Hoosier Motor Club

Insurance Agent

Muncie, IN

$45K - $110K/yr

... Agent to grow our team. This role is ideal for someone who thrives on building connections ... Licenses: • ACTIVE Property amp; Casualty (P amp;C) Insurance License (or willingness to obtain ...

AAA Hoosier Motor Club

Insurance Agent

Terre Haute, IN · On-site

$45K - $110K/yr

... Agent to grow our team. This role is ideal for someone who thrives on building connections ... Microsoft Office and Insurance Specific Software Certificates & Licenses: • ACTIVE Property ...

AAA Hoosier Motor Club

Insurance Agent

Indianapolis, IN

$45K - $110K/yr

... Agent to grow our team. This role is ideal for someone who thrives on building connections ... Licenses: • ACTIVE Property amp; Casualty (P amp;C) Insurance License (or willingness to obtain ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsProperty Insurance Agent JobsProperty Insurance Agent Jobs in Indiana

Property Insurance Agent information

See Indiana salary details

$13

$34

$65

How much do property insurance agent jobs pay per hour?

As of Jun 9, 2026, the average hourly pay for property insurance agent in Indiana is $34.61, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $24.47 and $41.63 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a Property Insurance Agent, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Property Insurance Agent, you need a solid understanding of insurance products, risk assessment, and sales techniques, typically supported by a relevant state insurance license. Familiarity with customer relationship management (CRM) software, policy management systems, and quoting tools is essential. Strong interpersonal skills, active listening, and problem-solving abilities help agents build trust and effectively address client needs. These skills ensure agents can accurately match coverage to client risks, foster long-term relationships, and succeed in a competitive market.

What is the difference between Property Insurance Agent vs Insurance Broker?

AspectProperty Insurance AgentInsurance Broker
CredentialsLicensing required, varies by stateLicensing required, often similar to agents
Work EnvironmentWorks for insurance companies, selling their policiesWorks independently or for agencies, representing multiple insurers
Employer & Industry UsageEmployed by insurance companies or agenciesIndependent or affiliated with brokerage firms
Comparison Search IntentFocuses on policies from specific insurersProvides options across multiple insurers

In summary, Property Insurance Agents typically work for specific insurance companies, selling their policies, while Insurance Brokers act independently or for brokerages, offering clients a variety of policies from multiple insurers. Both roles require licensing and serve the insurance industry, but their employer relationships and scope of options differ.

What are some common challenges Property Insurance Agents face when helping clients choose the right coverage?

Property Insurance Agents often encounter the challenge of balancing clients’ budget constraints with the need to ensure comprehensive coverage. Many clients may not fully understand policy details, exclusions, or the risks specific to their property, requiring agents to educate and guide them through complex options. Additionally, agents must stay updated on changing regulations and market offerings to provide the best advice. Building trust and maintaining long-term relationships with clients is essential, as is efficiently handling claims and renewals.

What does a Property Insurance Agent do?

A Property Insurance Agent helps clients find, understand, and purchase insurance policies that protect their properties, such as homes, businesses, or other valuable assets, against risks like fire, theft, or natural disasters. They assess clients' needs, explain coverage options, and assist with policy applications. Agents may also help clients file claims and update coverage as circumstances change, ensuring that clients have appropriate protection for their assets.
What are popular job titles related to Property Insurance Agent jobs in Indiana? For Property Insurance Agent jobs in Indiana, the most frequently searched job titles are:
What job categories do people searching Property Insurance Agent jobs in Indiana look for? The top searched job categories for Property Insurance Agent jobs in Indiana are:
What are popular job titles related to Property Insurance Agent jobs in IN? For Property Insurance Agent jobs in IN, the most frequently searched job titles are:
Property Insurance Agent jobs near you
Infographic showing various Property Insurance Agent job openings in Indiana as of May 2026, with employment types broken down into 2% Internship, 6% As Needed, 86% Full Time, 4% Part Time, and 2% Contract. Highlights an 89% Physical, 3% Hybrid, and 8% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $71,979 per year, or $34.6 per hour.
Insurance Agent - Indiana

Insurance Agent - Indiana

American Family Insurance

Indianapolis, IN

Other

Posted 13 days ago

American Family Insurance rating

7.6

Company rating: 7.6 out of 10

Based on 131 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

186th of 260 rated insurance

Job description

Community leader. Protector of dreams. That's what makes an American Family Insurance Agent. It's a highly rewarding opportunity that allows you to create financial stability while making a positive impact on our customers' lives. If you're looking for a chance to own your future — we're interested in you! Apply today.

At American Family, we're seeking highly motivated individuals with a demonstrated track record of success and eagerness to accomplish something that takes time, energy, and commitment. Do you possess a strong work ethic and have an inner drive that makes you hungry for success? 

Insurance Agents operate as independent contractors, representing American Family and its products exclusively.  As an insurance agent, you'll be responsible for your agency's overall management, sales, and growth.  You'll also hire your team and work with them to meet the strategic business goals you set.

Reasons why you should become an American Family Insurance Agent:

  • Financially Fit: with nearly $8 billion in policyholder equity, American Family has the financial security to protect the dreams of your policyholders
  • Fortune 500 company that is among the largest Property and Casualty insurance groups
  • Offer American Family Insurance products as well as products and services through our subsidiary partners
  • Training and support from a local team – from marketing, prospecting, business consultation and more
  • Unlimited compensation potential including a New Agent Incentive Program

Requirements

  • Obtain Property and Casualty and Life and Health insurance licenses
  • Ability to pass a motor vehicle, financial/credit and criminal background check

We believe people are an organization’s most valuable asset, and their ideas and experiences matter. From our CEO to our agency force, we’re committed to growing a diverse and inclusive culture that empowers innovation that will inspire, protect, and restore our customers’ dreams in ways never imagined.

#LI-CF1

What American Family Insurance employees say

Pay

Benefits

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom

Apply