1

Nonprofit Development Director Jobs in Indiana (NOW HIRING)

GoodLeap is also proud to support our award-winning nonprofit, GivePower, which is building and ... Work in collaboration with Business Development Directors to ensure partner success. Provide best ...

Foundation Director

Noblesville, IN · On-site

$62.73 - $85.31/hr

Working closely with the Library Director/CEO, the Foundation Board, and the Library Board of ... Five or more years of nonprofit fundraising, development, or related leadership experience. * Two ...

New

Clinical Director

Anderson, IN · On-site

$70K - $82K/yr

Monitoring therapeutic progress and directing the development and implementation of clinical ... The Villages is Indiana's largest private non-profit provider of Child and Family services ...

Clinical Director

Anderson, IN · On-site

$70K - $82K/yr

Monitoring therapeutic progress and directing the development and implementation of clinical ... The Villages is Indiana's largest private non-profit provider of Child and Family services ...

Clinical Director

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$70K - $82K/yr

Monitoring therapeutic progress and directing the development and implementation of clinical ... The Villages is Indianas largest private non-profit provider of Child and Family services ...

Clinical Director

Anderson, IN · On-site

$90 - $120/hr

Monitoring therapeutic progress and directing the development and implementation of clinical ... non-profit provider of Child and Family services, including Foster Care. The Villages champions ...

Showing results 41-60

Nonprofit Development Director information

See Indiana salary details

$15.2K

$91.1K

$169.4K

How much do nonprofit development director jobs pay per year?

As of Sep 4, 2026, the average yearly pay for nonprofit development director in Indiana is $91,073.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $70,400.00 and $109,000.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What does a nonprofit development director do?

A Nonprofit Development Director is responsible for planning and implementing strategies to raise funds and resources for a nonprofit organization. This role involves overseeing fundraising campaigns, building relationships with donors, managing grant applications, and coordinating events. They also work closely with the executive team to set fundraising goals and ensure the organization has the financial support needed to fulfill its mission.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a nonprofit development director?

To thrive as a Nonprofit Development Director, you need expertise in fundraising strategy, donor relations, grant writing, and a strong understanding of nonprofit management, often supported by a relevant degree and experience in development roles. Familiarity with donor management software (such as Raiser's Edge or Salesforce), CRM systems, and fundraising analytics tools is typically required. Outstanding communication, relationship-building, and leadership skills set top performers apart in this position. These skills are crucial to building sustainable funding streams and fostering mission-aligned partnerships that ensure organizational impact and growth.

What are some common challenges a nonprofit development director faces when building donor relationships?

One common challenge for Nonprofit Development Directors is establishing trust and long-term relationships with donors in a competitive fundraising environment. Balancing personalized attention with a large portfolio of prospects can be demanding, as can aligning donor interests with organizational needs. Additionally, Development Directors often need to collaborate closely with program staff and leadership to ensure that fundraising messages are accurate and compelling. Successfully navigating these challenges requires strong communication skills, strategic planning, and adaptability.

What is the difference between Nonprofit Development Director vs Nonprofit Fundraising Manager?

AspectNonprofit Development DirectorNonprofit Fundraising Manager
Primary FocusStrategic development, long-term growth, and overall fundraising goalsExecuting specific fundraising campaigns and events
ResponsibilitiesBuilding donor relationships, creating development plans, overseeing fundraising staffManaging fundraising activities, coordinating campaigns, donor outreach
CredentialsTypically requires a bachelor’s degree, experience in fundraising, and strong communication skillsSimilar credentials, often with experience in event planning and donor relations
Work EnvironmentOffice-based, strategic planning meetings, donor visitsEvent sites, community outreach, campaign coordination

The Nonprofit Development Director focuses on strategic planning and long-term growth of fundraising efforts, while the Nonprofit Fundraising Manager handles the day-to-day execution of fundraising activities. Both roles require similar credentials and work in related environments, but their scope and responsibilities differ significantly.

What are the most commonly searched types of Nonprofit Development jobs in Indiana?

The most popular types of Nonprofit Development jobs in Indiana are:

What are popular job titles related to Nonprofit Development Director jobs in Indiana?

For Nonprofit Development Director jobs in Indiana, the most frequently searched job titles are:

What cities in Indiana are hiring for Nonprofit Development Director jobs?

Cities in Indiana with the most Nonprofit Development Director job openings:

Infographic showing various Nonprofit Development Director job openings in Indiana as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 80% Full Time, 16% Part Time, and 3% Contract. Highlights an 90% Physical, 4% Hybrid, and 6% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $91,073 per year, or $43.8 per hour.

Assistant Athletic Director, Development

Butler University

Indianapolis, IN • On-site

Full-time

Medical, Dental, Vision, Life, Retirement, PTO

Posted 2 days ago

New


Key responsibilities

  • Manage a portfolio of approximately 100 donors and prospects, including activities such as visits, qualification/disqualifications, solicitations, and tracking total dollars raised.

  • Identify, cultivate, and solicit current and new gift prospects, primarily in the $10,000-$250,000 range, and assist with fundraising initiatives and events.

  • Attend and support fundraising events, collaborate on event planning, and cultivate relationships with donors and prospects during gamedays and other related activities.


Butler University rating

6.8

Company rating: 6.8 out of 10

Based on 8 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

482nd of 628 rated colleges and universities


Job description

Position Overview

The Assistant Athletic Director/Development position will serve as a gift officer on behalf of the Athletic Department. This position will develop and manage a portfolio consisting of mid-major donors, major gift donors, and prospects. The primary focus will be on identifying new prospects, cultivating current/prospective donors, soliciting major gifts, and stewarding existing/new donors. This position will manage the Athletics Endowment Program and assist with management of the Butler Way Society.

Responsibilities

Fundraising

  • Manage a portfolio of approximately 100 donors and prospects and work towards individual metric goals including visits, qualification/disqualifications, solicitations, and total dollars raised.
  • Identify, prioritize, cultivate and solicit current and new gift prospects primarily in, but not limited to, the $10,000-$250,000 range.
  • Partner with the Office of University Advancement to ensure compliance with all relevant University and University Advancement fundraising policies and procedures.
  • Manage Athletics Endowment Program with expectations of donor participation and endowment growth.
  • Assist Senior Associate Athletic Director/Development with all fundraising initiatives
     

Events

  • Attend and have a presence at Athletics Department and Bulldog Club fundraising events including, but not limited to, Butler Basketball Tip-Off Party, Butler Way Society events, Corporate Golf Outing, Butler Golf Classic, Hall of Fame events, and Athletic Director's Reception.
  • Collaborate with Director of Development and Advancement events team for planning and administration of Athletics Department and Bulldog Club fundraising event.
     

Priority Points

  • Bulldog Club lead for the Priority Points System
  • Maintain full knowledge and history of the points system and provide answers and suggestions to any inquiries from current/prospective donors and season ticket holders.
  • Work directly with Advancement Services on coordinating all priority point information and data.
  • Serve as lead for Advancement staff when they receive questions about priority points, serving as a resource for all front-line fundraisers so they have a working knowledge of the priority points system to better assist University donors/prospects.
  • Assist the Athletics Ticket Office in annual Select-A-Seat event
     

Hospitality

  • On gamedays, spend time in various hospitality areas (i.e. Wildman Room, Efroymson Family Gym, Tony's on 49th, Sellick Room, and Terrace Tent) effectively using this time to cultivate relationships with those donors/prospects in attendance.
     

Donor Relations

  • Cultivation and stewardship; attend away games and associated events (when applicable) to further relationships with assigned donors and prospects.
  • Full understanding of the university's alumni, donor, and prospective donor database with the ability look-up data on specific donors, run lists of gifts and data, as well as input contact reports.
     

Required Qualifications

  • Bachelor's degree
  • 3-5 years successful fundraising related (sales) experience
  • Knowledge and understanding of philanthropy and fundraising principles
  • Organizational skills; ability to multi-task/manage several projects simultaneously and meet deadlines
  • Demonstrated flexibility, creativity, strategic-thinking skills; willingness to take initiative and learn
  • Experience working in intercollegiate, higher education, or non-profit fundraising
  • Ability to communicate with donors and internal constituents both written and verbal
  • Positive attitude with strong interpersonal skills along with strong customer service skills
  • Proven ability to work autonomously, collaboratively and within a team structure
  • Ability to execute face-to-face solicitations in support of organization's mission
  • Travel related to donor visits and events as needed
  • Proficiency in software systems such as: MS Word, Office, Teams, Excel, PowerPoint, Outlook, and fundraising CRM systems
     

Preferred Qualifications

  • Master's degree preferred
  • Experience in an intercollegiate athletic department preferred
     

BU Benefits and Perks

Please check out Butler's Total Rewards website to learn more about our benefit offerings, which include:

Paid Time Off and Holidays:

  • 20 days of paid time off (vacation and PTO days) per Fiscal year
  • 8 Paid Holidays
  • In addition, a paid Winter Break between Christmas Eve and New Year's Day
  • Paid Parental Leave (after 1 year of full-time employment)

Health:

  • Comprehensive medical, dental, and vision plans including disability and life insurance programs

Retirement:

  • 10% employer contribution after 1 year of full-time employment

Tuition Assistance:

  • Remission of tuition for classes taken at Butler for employees, spouses, and dependent children.
  • Eligibility after 9 months of full-time employment
  • Employees & spouses- undergraduate/graduate degrees
  • Dependents (under age 26)- undergraduate degree
  • Covers tuition only
  • Tuition Exchange Program for Dependents at participating institutions

Butler Facilities Access, Discounts and Perks:

  • Access to Butler's on-site fitness facility and libraries for full-time staff and faculty
  • LinkedIn Learning Courses
  • Free premium subscription to the Calm App
  • Free subscription to the WSJ, The Economist, and NYT
  • Discount at the College Bookstore
  • Discount on select Athletic and Arts/Events Center Performances
Butler University is a private, nationally recognized comprehensive university encompassing seven colleges: Arts, Business, Communication, Education, Liberal Arts & Sciences, Pharmacy & Health Sciences and Founder's College. Approximately 4,500 undergraduate and 1,000 graduate and doctoral students are enrolled at Butler, representing 46 states and 24 countries.

Join us at the crossroads of tradition & transformation. A career at Butler University offers more than just a job-it's an opportunity to join a dedicated, innovative, and supportive community grounded in equity, academic excellence, and meaningful impact. Aligned with Boldly Butler, our strategic plan, faculty and staff play a vital role in delivering transformational learning experiences, enriching our campus and community, and ensuring a thriving Butler for generations to come.

Butler University is an equal opportunity employer. We welcome applications from all individuals, regardless of age, sex, race, religion, color, disability, protected veteran status, national origin, or any other legally protected category.

What Butler University employees say

Pay

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom