ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Manager Insurance Recruiter Jobs (NOW HIRING)

Novella

Lead Insurance Recruiter

New York, NY · On-site

The Role We're seeking an Insurance Recruiter to help us build the best wholesale teams in the ... Strong organizational skills and ability to manage multiple searches simultaneously. * Someone ...

West Monroe

Manager, Insurance

Chicago, IL

Support recruiting, onboarding, and talent development efforts within the Insurance practice ... Experience managing project teams, workstreams, budgets, and client relationships * Ability to ...

West Monroe

Manager, Insurance

Chicago, IL · On-site

As a Manager, you will lead client engagements, mentor consulting teams, contribute to business ... Support recruiting, onboarding, and talent development efforts within the Insurance practice ...

Invenergy

Manager, Insurance (Captive)

Chicago, IL

The Manager, Insurance will be responsible for overseeing the captive insurance program. This ... Your recruiter can share more about bonus eligibility for this position during the hiring process.

RSM

Assurance Manager - Insurance

Dallas, TX

RSM is looking for a Audit Manager to join our Insurance team. Our Insurance group is a rapidly ... the recruitment process and/or employment/partnership.RSM is committed to providing equal ...

RSM

Assurance Manager - Insurance

Chicago, IL

RSM is looking for a Audit Manager to join our Insurance team. Our Insurance group is a rapidly ... the recruitment process and/or employment/partnership.RSM is committed to providing equal ...

RSM

Assurance Manager - Insurance

Orlando, FL

RSM is looking for a Audit Manager to join our Insurance team. Our Insurance group is a rapidly ... the recruitment process and/or employment/partnership.RSM is committed to providing equal ...

RSM

Assurance Manager - Insurance

Los Angeles, CA

RSM is looking for a Audit Manager to join our Insurance team. Our Insurance group is a rapidly ... the recruitment process and/or employment/partnership.RSM is committed to providing equal ...

RSM

Assurance Manager - Insurance

Indianapolis, IN

RSM is looking for a Audit Manager to join our Insurance team. Our Insurance group is a rapidly ... the recruitment process and/or employment/partnership.RSM is committed to providing equal ...

RSM

Assurance Manager - Insurance

Milwaukee, WI

RSM is looking for a Audit Manager to join our Insurance team. Our Insurance group is a rapidly ... the recruitment process and/or employment/partnership.RSM is committed to providing equal ...

Wipfli Advisory LLC

Tax Manager - Insurance

$106K - $160K/yr

Supervise and mentor insurance tax team members, supporting their professional and technical ... Amanda Feltner, from our recruiting team, will be guiding you through this process. Visit her ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsInsurance Recruiter JobsManager Insurance Recruiter Jobs

Manager Insurance Recruiter information

See salary details

$33K

$52.3K

$79K

How much do manager insurance recruiter jobs pay per year?

As of Jul 21, 2026, the average yearly pay for manager insurance recruiter in the United States is $52,286.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $41,000.00 and $57,500.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is the difference between Manager Insurance Recruiter vs Insurance Recruiter?

AspectManager Insurance RecruiterInsurance Recruiter
CredentialsTypically requires experience in recruiting and leadership skillsFocuses on recruiting skills, often with less emphasis on management
Work EnvironmentLeads recruiting teams, manages hiring strategiesExecutes recruiting tasks, sources candidates
Employer & Industry UsageUsed in larger insurance firms or agencies with HR departmentsCommon across insurance companies, staffing agencies
Search & Comparison IntentLooking for leadership roles in insurance recruitingSeeking entry to mid-level recruiting positions

The main difference is that a Manager Insurance Recruiter oversees recruiting teams and strategies, while an Insurance Recruiter focuses on sourcing and hiring candidates. The manager role involves leadership and strategic planning, whereas the recruiter role is more execution-focused.

What cities are hiring for Manager Insurance Recruiter jobs? Cities with the most Manager Insurance Recruiter job openings:
What are the most commonly searched types of Insurance Recruiter jobs? The most popular types of Insurance Recruiter jobs are:
What states have the most Manager Insurance Recruiter jobs? States with the most job openings for Manager Insurance Recruiter jobs include:
Manager Insurance Recruiter jobs near you
Lead Insurance Recruiter

Lead Insurance Recruiter

Novella

New York, NY • On-site

Full-time

Re-posted 11 days ago

Job description

Novella is building AI to protect the largest, most complicated assets in the world. Whether it's a rocket going to space or a skyscraper on the coast, Novella is building the first AI powered specialty insurance brokerage.
The Role
We're seeking an Insurance Recruiter to help us build the best wholesale teams in the country. You'll be in charge of finding and recruiting the best E&S brokers and underwriters across the country.
This isn't typical recruiting. You'll need to deeply understand the E&S wholesale market, know what makes a great producer tick, and be able to sell top talent on the promise of technology. You'll own the full recruiting lifecycle - from sourcing and outreach to closing and onboarding - while building the systems and processes that will scale our recruiting function.
The ideal candidate has recruited in insurance before. They have a network and the drive to find and attract the best talent in insurance.
The Day to Day
  • Own the full-cycle recruiting process for wholesale producer roles: sourcing, screening, interviewing, closing, and onboarding.
  • Build and maintain a pipeline of high-quality wholesale producer candidates through direct outreach, networking, referrals, and creative sourcing strategies.
  • Partner with leadership to define ideal candidate profiles, compensation structures, and hiring plans.
  • Develop relationships within the E&S insurance community to build Novella's employer brand and reputation.
  • Build a pipeline of underwriting talent to support our programs group.
  • Create and refine recruiting processes, interview frameworks, and onboarding programs that scale.

What We're Looking For
  • 3+ years of recruiting experience, with meaningful time spent hiring in insurance, financial services, or a related industry.
  • Deep understanding of the wholesale insurance market and what makes a successful producer and underwriter.
  • Proven ability to source and close candidates in competitive markets.
  • Excellent relationship-building skills. You can earn trust with senior candidates and keep them engaged throughout long hiring processes.
  • Strong organizational skills and ability to manage multiple searches simultaneously.
  • Someone flexible who understands every day at an early stage startup is like a decade in the corporate world. We move quickly and do whatever needs to get done no matter your title.

Apply