ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Evening Supervisor Jobs (NOW HIRING)

Grand St Settlement Inc.

Evening Supervisor

Brooklyn, NY · On-site

$22/hr

Evening Supervisor/Weekend Supervisor DEPARTMENT: Youth Services LOCATION(S): Gowanus Community Center; 420 Baltic Ave., Brooklyn, NY REPORTS TO: Program Director/Assistant Director SALARY RANGE: $22 ...

Grand St Settlement Inc.

Evening Supervisor

Brooklyn, NY · On-site

$23 - $25/hr

Evening Supervisor/Weekend Supervisor DEPARTMENT: Youth Services LOCATION(S): Roosevelt Community Center REPORTS TO: Program Director/Assistant Director SALARY RANGE: $23-25/hour up to 35hrs/week ...

Festival Foods

Produce Evening Supervisor

Eau Claire, WI · On-site

$18.75 - $23.50/hr

Produce Evening Supervisor Reports To: Produce Department Manager Seeking 12pm-8pm help! Are you a leader with a passion for fresh produce and a dedication to outstanding guest service? As an Evening ...

Oswego Health

Laboratory Evening Supervisor

Oswego, NY · On-site

$41 - $48/hr

Job Title: Laboratory Evening Supervisor Department: Laboratory Reports to: Laboratory Administrative Director Revision Date: 6/30/2026 Status: Non-Exempt Job Summary: The Laboratory Evening ...

Festival Foods

Produce Evening Supervisor

Eau Claire, WI · On-site

$18.75 - $23.50/hr

Produce Evening Supervisor Reports To: Produce Department Manager Seeking 12pm-8pm help! Are you a leader with a passion for fresh produce and a dedication to outstanding guest service? As an Evening ...

Opportunity Matters Inc

Evening Supervisor

Sartell, MN · On-site

$25/hr

The Evening Supervisor utilizes a company van to visit homes and provide supervision presence in the evenings and early night hours. This position is responsible to ensure staff are present at the ...

Festival Foods

Bakery Evening Supervisor

Janesville, WI · On-site

$16 - $21.75/hr

Bakery Evening Supervisor Reports To: Bakery Manager Are you passionate about bakery food-service operations and excited to lead a retail pastry team in the evening hours? Join us as a Bakery Evening ...

Grand St Settlement Inc.

Evening Supervisor

Brooklyn, NY · On-site

$40K/yr

Evening Supervisor DEPARTMENT: Youth Services Department LOCATION: Unity Plaza Community Center, 576 Blake Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11207 REPORTS TO: Program Director and/or Assistant Program Director ...

Festival Foods

Bakery Evening Supervisor

Janesville, WI · On-site

$16 - $21.75/hr

Bakery Evening Supervisor Reports To: Bakery Manager Are you passionate about bakery food-service operations and excited to lead a retail pastry team in the evening hours? Join us as a Bakery Evening ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsEvening Supervisor Jobs

Evening Supervisor information

See salary details

$11

$16

$26

How much do evening supervisor jobs pay per hour?

As of Jul 17, 2026, the average hourly pay for evening supervisor in the United States is $16.84, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $14.42 and $17.07 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is the highest salary of a supervisor?

The highest salary for an evening supervisor can vary depending on the industry, location, and level of experience, but it typically ranges up to $70,000 to $80,000 annually for senior or specialized roles. Factors such as certifications, management responsibilities, and the size of the organization can influence compensation levels.

What are some common challenges faced by Evening Supervisors and how can they be addressed?

Evening Supervisors often encounter challenges such as managing reduced staffing levels, ensuring consistent communication between day and night shifts, and handling unexpected issues that arise after regular business hours. To address these, strong organizational skills and proactive planning are essential, along with clear documentation and effective handover procedures. Building strong relationships with your team and maintaining open lines of communication with other supervisors can also help ensure smooth operations during evening hours.

Who gets paid more, a manager or a supervisor?

In most organizations, managers typically earn higher salaries than supervisors due to greater responsibilities, decision-making authority, and experience requirements. Supervisors often oversee daily operations and team members, while managers handle strategic planning and broader organizational tasks. Salary differences can vary based on industry, company size, and location.

Can I be a supervisor with no experience?

While some companies may consider candidates for an evening supervisor position with little or no prior experience, most supervisory roles require basic leadership skills, such as communication and problem-solving, and often prefer candidates with relevant work experience. Training is typically provided on the job to develop necessary supervisory skills. Having related experience or certifications can improve your chances of being hired as a supervisor without prior supervisory experience.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an Evening Supervisor, and why are they important?

To thrive as an Evening Supervisor, you need strong leadership, organizational, and problem-solving skills, often supported by prior supervisory experience or relevant industry knowledge. Familiarity with workforce management systems, scheduling software, and standard reporting tools is typically required. Outstanding communication, adaptability, and conflict resolution abilities help foster a productive team environment during off-peak hours. These skills ensure smooth operations, effective staff management, and customer satisfaction during evening shifts.

What are Evening Supervisors?

Evening Supervisors are professionals responsible for overseeing operations and staff during the evening shift in various organizations, such as hotels, hospitals, retail stores, or warehouses. They ensure that activities run smoothly, address any issues that arise, and provide support to employees working during this time. Their duties often include managing schedules, handling customer concerns, enforcing company policies, and maintaining safety standards. Evening Supervisors play a key role in ensuring continuity between day and night operations and often report to higher management about shift performance and incidents.

What does a night supervisor do?

A night supervisor oversees operations during evening or overnight shifts, ensuring safety, security, and smooth workflow. They monitor staff, handle emergencies, enforce policies, and may use security or management tools to maintain a secure environment.

What is the difference between Evening Supervisor vs Customer Service Representative?

AspectEvening SupervisorCustomer Service Representative
Required CredentialsHigh school diploma; some roles may prefer supervisory or leadership experienceHigh school diploma or equivalent; customer service skills
Work EnvironmentSupervises staff during evening shifts, often in retail, hospitality, or warehousesInteracts directly with customers, typically in retail, call centers, or service centers
Employer & Industry UsageCommon in retail stores, restaurants, warehouses, and hospitality sectorsFound across retail, telecom, banking, and service industries

The main difference is that an Evening Supervisor oversees staff and operations during evening hours, ensuring tasks are completed, while a Customer Service Representative primarily handles customer interactions and support. Both roles may require similar credentials, but their responsibilities and work environments differ significantly.

More about Evening Supervisor jobs
What cities are hiring for Evening Supervisor jobs? Cities with the most Evening Supervisor job openings:
What are the most commonly searched types of Supervisor jobs? The most popular types of Supervisor jobs are:
What states have the most Evening Supervisor jobs? States with the most job openings for Evening Supervisor jobs include:
Evening Supervisor jobs near you
Infographic showing various Evening Supervisor job openings in the United States as of July 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 54% Full Time, 43% Part Time, 1% Temporary, and 1% Contract. Highlights an 98% Physical, 1% Hybrid, and 1% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $35,026 per year, or $16.8 per hour.

Evening Supervisor

Grand St Settlement Inc.

Brooklyn, NY • On-site

$22/hr

Full-time

Posted 18 days ago

Job description

POSITION TITLE: Evening Supervisor/Weekend Supervisor

DEPARTMENT: Youth Services

LOCATION(S): Gowanus Community Center; 420 Baltic Ave., Brooklyn, NY

REPORTS TO: Program Director/Assistant Director

SALARY RANGE: $22 hourly

DATE: School year September 2025 – June 2026

SCHEDULE: School Year Program Hours: Monday-Friday, 6pm - 10pm, Saturday 10am - 5pm. Candidates are expected to work a 4-8-hr shift within program hours, with exact working schedules varying based on program needs.

JOB SUMMARY: Evening Supervisor/Weekend Supervisor manages and oversees the evening and weekend teen/adult programs at Cornerstone facilities. The Evening Supervisor ensures the smooth operation of program activities, supervises staff and maintains a safe and engaging environment for guests, participants and staff.

EDUCATION, EXPERIENCE, AND REQUIREMENTS:

  • High School Diploma or GED required, some college or college degree preferred
  • At least 1 year of experience working with middle school and high school youths in a supervisory role.
  • Valid CPR/AED and First Aid certification through recognized accrediting body preferred
  • Familiarity with DYCD Connect is preferred

PRE-EMPLOYMENT REQUIREMENTS:

  • Candidate must successfully complete the following: NYSDOH Fingerprinting Screening, NYS Clearance Review Background Check, SEL, 3 Reference Checks, Physical w/updated TB test

ESSENTIAL DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES:

  • Oversee the center’s operation and ensure a safe and positive environment for teens. This includes enforcing rules/policies, managing and de-escalate conflicts and responding to emergencies.
  • Assist in planning and development of activities, events and programs for teens by considering their interests and needs.
  • Facilitate professional developments for staff and conduct onboarding processes with new hires.
  • Supervise staff, interns and volunteers and ensure that they are trained, engaged and perform their assigned duties effectively.
  • Effectively communicate with teens, families and other stakeholders, building positive relationships and addressing concerns.
  • Maintain accurate records of attendance, activities and incidents.
  • Input data onto DYCD Connect and communicate with DYCD program managers and deputies.
  • Participate in training and professional development opportunities to enhance skills and knowledge.
  • Coordinate and manage events, including planning, logistics and execution.
  • Build and maintain relationships with community partners to expand opportunities for program participants and families.
  • Clean, organize and maintain workspace and shared spaces throughout the facility.
  • Coordinate community relations efforts and participate in outreach activities.
  • Assist in the planning, organization and execution of community events.
  • Other assignments as required by the program director.

HOW TO APPLY:

Please submit a resume and thoughtful cover letter, outlining how your skills and experience meet the qualifications of the position you are applying for. If selected, we ask that you also provide us with three (3) professional references that we can contact (at least one (1) professional reference should be from a former supervisor). Please click on the link provided below, or use the link in a search bar, and apply online through our career center.

https://workforcenow.adp.com/jobs/apply/posting.html?client=grandst&ccId=19000101_000001&type=MP&lang=en_US

No phone calls, please!

Please be advised that job offers can only be made once your clearances come through!

Equal Opportunity Employer