1

Accounts Payable Supervisor Jobs in Indiana (NOW HIRING)

Accounts Payable Supervisor Location: Indianapolis, Indiana Starting Pay: $70-75K per year DOE THE MOST TRUSTED NAME IN CELEBRATING STUDENT MILESTONES - HERFF JONES Herff Jones is the leading ...

Accounts Payable Supervisor Location: Indianapolis, Indiana Starting Pay: $70-75K per year DOE THE MOST TRUSTED NAME IN CELEBRATING STUDENT MILESTONES - HERFF JONES Herff Jones is the leading ...

Accounts Payable Supervisor REPORTING TO: VP, Corporate Controller SUMMARY: Supervises and coordinates the accounts payable function and assists in other accounting duties as needed. DUTIES ...

Corporate Accounts Payable Supervisor

Milford, IN · On-site

$52K - $72K/yr

Accounts Payable Supervisor REPORTING TO: VP, Corporate Controller SUMMARY: Supervises and coordinates the accounts payable function and assists in other accounting duties as needed. DUTIES ...

ACCOUNTS PAYABLE CLERK

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$18.50 - $23.25/hr

Performs accounts payable functions as directed by the Accounts Payable Supervisor. Essential Duties Ensures that all purchase order and direct payment forms are in order and enters the invoices or ...

Accounts Payable Manager

Brownsburg, IN · On-site

$65K - $80K/yr

Accounts Payable Manager Compensation: $65,000-$80,000 Location: Brownsburg, IN (Onsite) Why This ... Experience supervising an AP team in a high‑volume environment. * Strong proficiency with AP ...

Accounts Payable Manager

Brownsburg, IN · On-site

$65K - $80K/yr

Accounts Payable Manager Compensation: $65,000-$80,000 Location: Brownsburg, IN (Onsite) Why This ... Experience supervising an AP team in a high‑volume environment. * Strong proficiency with AP ...

Supervisor, Accounts Payable

Elkhart, IN

$62K - $86K/yr

Supervisesand coordinates activities of the Accounts Payable team toensureaccurate posting of business transactions, invoice processing, financial data verification for use in maintaining accounts ...

Supervisor, Accounts Payable

Elkhart, IN

$62K - $86K/yr

Supervisesand coordinates activities of the Accounts Payable team toensureaccurate posting of business transactions, invoice processing, financial data verification for use in maintaining accounts ...

Accounts Payable

Elkhart, IN

$19 - $24.50/hr

The Accounts Payable Associate is responsible for oversite of accounts paid through the accounting department. Key job responsibilities will include entering invoices and issuing payments, as well as ...

Accounts Payable

Elkhart, IN · On-site

$19 - $24.50/hr

The Accounts Payable Associate is responsible for oversite of accounts paid through the accounting department. Key job responsibilities will include entering invoices and issuing payments, as well as ...

Accounts Payable Specialist

Mishawaka, IN · Hybrid

$19.50 - $25/hr

Accounts Payable Specialist Location: Mishawaka, Indiana Salary: 50,000-65,000 About the Company & Opportunity A well-established employer is seeking a detail-oriented Accounts Payable Specialist to ...

Accounts Payable Specialist

Mishawaka, IN · Hybrid

$19.50 - $25/hr

Accounts Payable Specialist Location: Mishawaka, Indiana Salary: 50,000-65,000 About the Company & Opportunity A well-established employer is seeking a detail-oriented Accounts Payable Specialist to ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

Accounts Payable Supervisor information

See Indiana salary details

$33.8K

$74.9K

$114.2K

How much do accounts payable supervisor jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 3, 2026, the average yearly pay for accounts payable supervisor in Indiana is $74,932.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $62,300.00 and $85,600.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What are some common challenges an Accounts Payable Supervisor may face, and how can they effectively address them?

Accounts Payable Supervisors often face challenges such as managing high volumes of invoices, ensuring timely payments while preventing errors, and maintaining compliance with company policies and regulatory requirements. To address these challenges, supervisors should prioritize implementing robust internal controls, leveraging automation tools for invoice processing, and fostering clear communication within the AP team and with vendors. Regular training and process reviews can also help the team stay updated on best practices and regulatory changes, ensuring both efficiency and accuracy in operations.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an Accounts Payable Supervisor, and why are they important?

To thrive as an Accounts Payable Supervisor, you need strong accounting knowledge, attention to detail, and experience in accounts payable processes, often supported by a degree in accounting or finance. Familiarity with ERP systems such as SAP or Oracle, as well as proficiency in Excel, is typically required, and certification like the Certified Accounts Payable Professional (CAPP) can be beneficial. Leadership, problem-solving, and effective communication are crucial soft skills for managing teams and resolving vendor issues. These skills ensure accurate financial operations, timely payments, and smooth workflow within the finance department.

What are Accounts Payable Supervisors?

Accounts Payable Supervisors are professionals responsible for overseeing an organization's accounts payable department. They manage the processing of invoices, ensure timely payments to vendors, and maintain accurate financial records. Their duties also include supervising accounts payable staff, resolving payment discrepancies, and implementing process improvements to increase efficiency. By ensuring that all outgoing payments are handled correctly, they play a crucial role in maintaining the financial health and credibility of a business.
More about Accounts Payable Supervisor jobs
What are the most commonly searched types of Accounts Payable Supervisor jobs in Indiana? The most popular types of Accounts Payable Supervisor jobs in Indiana are:
What are popular job titles related to Accounts Payable Supervisor jobs in Indiana? For Accounts Payable Supervisor jobs in Indiana, the most frequently searched job titles are:
What are popular job titles related to Accounts Payable Supervisor jobs in IN? For Accounts Payable Supervisor jobs in IN, the most frequently searched job titles are:
Infographic showing various Accounts Payable Supervisor job openings in Indiana as of July 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 82% Full Time, 15% Part Time, and 2% Contract. Highlights an 92% Physical, 2% Hybrid, and 6% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $74,932 per year, or $36 per hour.

Accounts Payable Supervisor

herffjones

Indianapolis, IN

$75K/yr

Other

Re-posted 22 days ago


Job description

Position Title: Accounts Payable Supervisor

Location: Indianapolis, Indiana

Starting Pay: $70-75K per year DOE

THE MOST TRUSTED NAME IN CELEBRATING STUDENT MILESTONES – HERFF JONES

Herff Jones is the leading provider of graduation and educational products and services designed to inspire achievement and create memorable experiences for students. Herff Jones' products include class rings and jewelry, caps and gowns, yearbooks, diplomas, frames, announcements, and Greek accessories as well as motivation and recognition programs.

Since 1920, our team has worked alongside students, faculty, and staff on campuses nationwide to help build a stronger community and celebrate student milestones. Our continued success relies on hiring extraordinary talent, with a passion for making a difference and eagerness to roll up the sleeves, to help us write the story of our next 100 years.

Your Opportunity:

TheHerff Jones Accounting team is looking for an Accounts Payable Supervisor to join our HJ Family. 

 

Position Summary:

The Accounts Payable Supervisor oversees the accounts payable team, directs the processing of invoices and payments, and maintain accurate financial records and controls. You will be working closely with cross-functional business partners to ensure timely and accurate recording and reporting of accounts payable transactions. You will lead the team in driving continuous improvement through use of enhanced technology and performance metrics to help to shape the future of the Shared Services organization.

What we want you to accomplish:

  • Lead the AP function, managing day-to-day operations and owning the monthly AP close process
  • Assist in streamlining and improving Accounts Payable functions
  • Assist with new ERP integration and testing.

Core Activities:

  • Communicate effectively and professionally with outside suppliers to resolve problems
  • Serve on project teams, such as system upgrades or process enhancements by conducting user acceptance testing for processes affecting Accounts Payable
  • Ensure the invoices and payments are processed in accordance with terms, with a high degree of accuracy and timeliness
  • Understand the full invoice to cash cycle to quickly identify the source of bottlenecks, problems, and drive issues to resolution
  • Support the accuracy of Accounts Payable related to general ledger accounts by ensuring that routine activities are being completed in a timely manner.
  • Research, resolve and communicate invoicing issues, discrepancies, or outstanding balances on vendor accounts accordingly
  • Assist in the development and implementation of our continuous improvement strategy within AP.
  • Develop, implement, and maintain standard systems and processes to ensure adherence to company policies
  • Assemble information for external auditors for the annual audit and quarterly reviews
  • Maintain desktop procedures for all responsibilities
  • Reconcile processed work by verifying entries and comparing them to system reports
  • Review mock payment run prior to sending to Controller for approval weekly
  • Reconcile processed payments by verifying to approved payments file weekly
  • Obtain proper approvals for invoices/items for payment
  • Pay vendors by monitoring discount opportunities and scheduling and preparing payments via check or ACH
  • Maintain current and new vendor setups (verify federal/tax ID numbers, method of payment, payment terms, payment and withholding addresses) and provide approvals
  • Maintain route codes and the approval (authority) matrix
  • Review and issue stop payments, void and reissue requests
  • Review and approve/deny Positive Pay exceptions
  • Partner closely with the accounting team to ensure accurate posting of all transactions
  • Perform month end close process, as backup
  • Review month-end close reconciliation
  • Maintain supporting documents and invoices electronically
  • Review aged credits and invoices (90+ days) for accuracy
  • Respond to vendor & internal inquiries as needed; Verify vendor accounts to monthly statements
  • Increase Vendor ACH Enrollment
  • Write and maintain/update procedure documents
  • Run the 1099 process and file return with the IRS
  • Monthly metrics for Accounts Payable (errors, volume processed)
  • Protect confidentiality of all Company financial information
  • Assign duties or additional responsibilities to AP Specialist(s) as needed
  • Special projects may be assigned periodically

Success Indicators:

  • Ability to work independently, exercising discretion and sound judgment.
  • Skilled team player with interpersonal skills and a record of successfully working with cross-functional business stakeholders
  • Demonstrated success managing workload and prioritizing based on current business needs and time constraints
  • Ability to effectively communicate with the Accounting Manager any questionable items prior to processing
  • Possess great attention to detail and excellent organization skills
  • Increase job knowledge by participating in additional educational opportunities

Education / Certifications Required:

  • HS Diploma or equivalent
  • 5-7 years + prior work experience in Accounts Payable
  • Experience with OCR reader technology preferred
  • Associate Degree in Accounting encouraged to apply
  • Proficient in Microsoft Word, Excel & Outlook

JOIN THE BEST TEAM ON THE FIELD IN SPORT, SPIRIT & ACHIEVEMENT 

About Herff Jones:

Indianapolis-based Herff Jones is the leading provider of graduation and educational products and services designed to inspire achievement and create memorable experiences for students. Herff Jones’ products include class rings and jewelry, caps and gowns, diplomas and announcements as well as motivation and recognition programs. Focused on building long-term relationships through a nationwide network of over 1,400 employees and sales partners, the professionals at Herff Jones have been helping elevate the student experience throughout the lifelong journey of education for more than 100 years. For more information about Herff Jones, please visit www.herffjones.com. 

Herff Jones, Inc. and its affiliates are equal opportunity employers and maintain affirmative action plans to recruit, retain, develop, and promote qualified individuals without unlawful consideration of race, gender, gender identity, color, religion, sexual orientation, national origin, age, disability, citizenship status, veteran status, or any other characteristic protected by federal, state or local law. Herff Jones strives to maintain a work environment free from unlawful discrimination and harassment, where associates are treated with respect and dignity. 

Any employment agency, person or entity that submits a résumé into this career site or to a hiring manager does so with the understanding that the applicant's résumé will become the property of Herff Jones. Herff Jones will have the right to hire that applicant at its discretion without any fee owed to the submitting employment agency, person or entity.