What are the top 10 cities with the highest pay for Insurance Case Manager?

We've identified 10 cities in Indiana where Insurance Case Manager jobs typically pay above the area average. Topping the list is Carmel (4.9% above average), followed by Merrillville and South Bend. City Annual Salary Monthly Pay Weekly Pay Hourly Wage Carmel $50,762 $4,230 $976 $24.40 Merrillville $49,998 $4,166 $961 $24.04 South Bend $49,828 $4,152 $958 $23.96 Crawfordsville $49,462 $4,121 $951 $23.78 Danville $49,270 $4,105 $947 $23.69 Zionsville $49,230 $4,102 $946 $23.67 Batesville $49,000 $4,083 $942 $23.56 Hammond $48,948 $4,079 $941 $23.53 Lafayette $48,916 $4,076 $940 $23.52 Avon $48,759 $4,063 $937 $23.44

Insurance Case Manager

Insurance Case Manager Salary in Indiana

Q: How much does an Insurance Case Manager make in Indiana?

The average annual pay for an insurance case manager in Indiana is $48,379 a year — that works out to approximately $23.26 an hour. That is 4.8% below the national average of $50,841. The middle 80% of Insurance Case Managers earn between $34,256 (10th percentile) and $62,327 (90th percentile) per year, depending on experience and employer.

Q: What are Top 5 Best Paying Related Insurance Case Manager Jobs in Indiana?

We found several jobs related to Insurance Case Manager in Indiana that pay more on average. Topping the list is Outreach Manager at $33,167 (68.6%) above Insurance Case Manager. Job Title Annual Salary Monthly Pay Weekly Pay Hourly Wage Outreach Manager $81,546 $6,795 $1,568 $39.20 Medicaid Eligibility $52,659 $4,388 $1,012 $25.32 Regional Case Manager $49,977 $4,164 $961 $24.03 Hospital Case Manager $49,000 $4,083 $942 $23.56 Case Management Associate $39,100 $3,258 $751 $18.80

$30.9K

$48.1K

$69.9K

$48,379

/year

$23.26

/hour

Insurance Case Manager Salary Comparison by Location

Nationwide

United States

$50,841

Indiana

$48,379

Do you get a good deal as an Insurance Case Manager?

Take The Breakroom Quiz to find out if your job offers fair pay and conditions. The 3-minute quiz lets you compare your pay, hours, benefits, and more.

Take The Breakroom Quiz

How much does an Insurance Case Manager make in Indiana?

As of Aug 19, 2026, the average annual pay for an Insurance Case Manager in Indiana is $48,379 a year.

Just in case you need a simple salary calculator, that works out to be approximately $23.26 an hour. This is the equivalent of $930/week or $4,031/month.

While ZipRecruiter is seeing salaries as high as $69,939 and as low as $30,926, the majority of Insurance Case Manager salaries currently range between $37,100 (25th percentile) to $56,100 (75th percentile) with top earners (90th percentile) making $62,327 annually in Indiana. The average pay range for an Insurance Case Manager varies greatly (by as much as 19000), which suggests there may be many opportunities for advancement and increased pay based on skill level, location and years of experience.

Indiana ranks number 50 out of 50 states nationwide for Insurance Case Manager salaries.

To estimate the most accurate annual salary range for Insurance Case Manager jobs, ZipRecruiter continuously scans its database of millions of active jobs published locally throughout America.

Find your next high paying job as an Insurance Case Manager on ZipRecruiter today.

What are Top 10 Highest Paying Cities for Insurance Case Manager Jobs in Indiana

We've identified 10 cities where the typical salary for an Insurance Case Manager job is above the average in Indiana in Indiana. Topping the list is Carmel, , with Merrillville, and South Bend, close behind in the second and third positions. South Bend, beats the average in Indiana by $1,449 (3.0%), and Carmel, furthers that trend with another $2,383 (4.9%) above the $48,379 average.

With these 10 cities paying on average above the average for Indiana, the opportunities for economic advancement by changing locations as an Insurance Case Manager appears to be exceedingly fruitful.

Finally, another factor to consider is the average salary for these top 10 cities varies very little at 4% between Carmel, and Avon, , reinforcing the limited potential for much wage advancement. The possibility of a lower cost of living may be the best factor to use when considering location and salary for an Insurance Case Manager role.

City	Annual Salary	Monthly Pay	Weekly Pay	Hourly Wage
Carmel	$50,762	$4,230	$976	$24.40
Merrillville	$49,998	$4,166	$961	$24.04
South Bend	$49,828	$4,152	$958	$23.96
Crawfordsville	$49,462	$4,121	$951	$23.78
Danville	$49,270	$4,105	$947	$23.69
Zionsville	$49,230	$4,102	$946	$23.67
Batesville	$49,000	$4,083	$942	$23.56
Hammond	$48,948	$4,079	$941	$23.53
Lafayette	$48,916	$4,076	$940	$23.52
Avon	$48,759	$4,063	$937	$23.44

What are Top 5 Best Paying Related Insurance Case Manager Jobs in Indiana

Analyzing similar jobs related to the Insurance Case Manager job category in Indiana, we found 5 that were relevant. However, none pay more than the $48379 state average for Insurance Case Manager jobs.

Job Title	Annual Salary	Monthly Pay	Weekly Pay	Hourly Wage
Outreach Manager	$81,546	$6,795	$1,568	$39.20
Medicaid Eligibility	$52,659	$4,388	$1,012	$25.32
Regional Case Manager	$49,977	$4,164	$961	$24.03
Hospital Case Manager	$49,000	$4,083	$942	$23.56
Case Management Associate	$39,100	$3,258	$751	$18.80

About Our Data

ZipRecruiter salary estimates, histograms, trends and comparisons are derived from both employer job postings and third party data sources.

Infographic detailing Insurance Case Manager salary in Indiana as of August 2026. Shows a bar chart with salary percentiles ranging from $37,100 to $62,327 annually, with the Indiana average at $48,379 per year or $23.26 per hour. Includes a list of the top 10 highest paying cities in Indiana for Insurance Case Manager jobs, with Carmel leading at $50,762 annually.

All Salaries Insurance Case Manager Salary Insurance Case Manager Salary in Indiana