ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Insurance Supervisor Jobs in New York (NOW HIRING)

BHIRED

Commercial Insurance Supervisor

Passaic, NJ · On-site

$150K - $200K/yr

Extensive commercial insurance experience * Proven leadership and supervisory background * Strong communication and relationship-building skills * Ability to strategize and support account teams ...

BHIRED

Commercial Insurance Supervisor

Manhattan, NY · On-site

$150K - $200K/yr

Extensive commercial insurance experience * Proven leadership and supervisory background * Strong communication and relationship-building skills * Ability to strategize and support account teams ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsInsurance Supervisor JobsInsurance Supervisor Jobs in New York

Insurance Supervisor information

See New York salary details

$41K

$90.6K

$134K

How much do insurance supervisor jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 6, 2026, the average yearly pay for insurance supervisor in New York is $90,584.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $72,800.00 and $108,300.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an insurance supervisor?

To thrive as an Insurance Supervisor, you need expertise in insurance policies, regulatory compliance, team leadership, and a relevant bachelor's degree or industry certification such as CPCU. Familiarity with insurance management software, claims processing systems, and CRM tools is typically required. Strong interpersonal skills, problem-solving ability, and attention to detail help you motivate teams and resolve complex customer issues. These competencies are crucial for ensuring efficient operations, maintaining compliance, and delivering high-quality service in the insurance sector.

What is the difference between Insurance Supervisor vs Insurance Agent?

AspectInsurance SupervisorInsurance Agent
CertificationsTypically requires state licensing and sometimes management certificationsRequires state licensing, often with specific product licenses
Work EnvironmentOversees teams, manages policies, and ensures compliance within insurance companiesWorks directly with clients to sell and service insurance policies
Employer & Industry UsageEmployed by insurance companies, agencies, or brokeragesEmployed by insurance agencies or as independent agents

Insurance Supervisors focus on managing teams and ensuring policy compliance within insurance companies, while Insurance Agents primarily sell and service insurance policies directly to clients. Both roles require licensing, but their responsibilities and work environments differ significantly.

How does an insurance supervisor typically support team development and performance improvement?

An Insurance Supervisor plays a key role in guiding and developing their team by providing regular feedback, conducting performance reviews, and identifying training needs. They often organize coaching sessions, facilitate knowledge sharing, and set clear performance goals to help team members succeed. Additionally, Insurance Supervisors monitor workflow to ensure efficiency and compliance with industry regulations, fostering a supportive environment where employees can learn and grow. This proactive approach not only enhances team performance but also contributes to overall organizational success.

What does an insurance supervisor do?

An Insurance Supervisor oversees the daily operations of an insurance team, ensuring that policies are processed accurately and customer service standards are met. They are responsible for managing staff, training new employees, monitoring compliance with regulations, and resolving complex claims or customer issues. Insurance Supervisors also analyze workflow, implement process improvements, and report performance metrics to management. Their goal is to maintain efficient operations while upholding company policies and industry standards.
What are popular job titles related to Insurance Supervisor jobs in New York? For Insurance Supervisor jobs in New York, the most frequently searched job titles are:
What job categories do people searching Insurance Supervisor jobs in New York look for? The top searched job categories for Insurance Supervisor jobs in New York are:
What are popular job titles related to Insurance Supervisor jobs in NY? For Insurance Supervisor jobs in NY, the most frequently searched job titles are:
Insurance Supervisor jobs near you
Infographic showing various Insurance Supervisor job openings in New York as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 74% Full Time, 20% Part Time, and 5% Contract. Highlights an 91% Physical, 1% Hybrid, and 8% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $90,584 per year, or $43.5 per hour.

Commercial Insurance Supervisor

BHIRED

Passaic, NJ • On-site

$150K - $200K/yr

Other

Re-posted 20 days ago

Job description

Team Lead/Senior Underwriter

An insurance company is seeking a team lead/senior underwriter with strong commercial insurance experience to join their management team. The ideal candidate will oversee team training, provide strategic guidance, and maintain strong underwriting and client relationships.

Responsibilities include:

  • Training and mentoring new employees
  • Strategizing markets and developing growth opportunities
  • Guiding account reps and supporting client management
  • Maintaining and strengthening underwriting relationships

Ideal qualifications:

  • Extensive commercial insurance experience
  • Proven leadership and supervisory background
  • Strong communication and relationship-building skills
  • Ability to strategize and support account teams effectively

This is an excellent opportunity to take on a senior leadership role in a well-established insurance company and make a direct impact on team and business growth.

Salary: $150k - $200k/Year

To apply, please send your resume to Yosef@bhirednyc.com

Apply