ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Night Shift Supervisor Jobs in Indiana (NOW HIRING)

Palmer-Donavin

Night Shift Operations Supervisor

Bluffton, IN · On-site

$11.50 - $15.50/hr

The Night Shift Supervisor is responsible for leading the warehouse night shift operation and ensuring all outbound material is pulled, packaged, and loaded safely, accurately, and on schedule for ...

NewDay

Night Shift Residential Shift

Bloomfield, IN

$12.75 - $17/hr

Overview: Night shift personal are entrusted to spearhead our efforts in bringing hope, healing ... Meet with incoming supervisor at end of shift to review all nightshift documentation, duties, and ...

Harlan Bakeries LLC

Production Shift Supervisor

Avon, IN · On-site

Production Shift Supervisor ID: 1150 Location: Avon, IN Department: Operations More about this job ... Ability to work 10-12 hours as needed and work at night. Apply Now Refer to a Friend Alternatively ...

OmniSource

Shift Supervisor

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$14.25 - $18.25/hr

Leads all production activities on the night shift in an ASR processing operation. The supervisor is responsible for safe execution of the production plan, staffing, throughput, housekeeping, quality ...

OmniSource

Shift Supervisor

Indianapolis, IN

$14.25 - $18.25/hr

Leads all production activities on the night shift in an ASR processing operation. The supervisor is responsible for safe execution of the production plan, staffing, throughput, housekeeping, quality ...

OmniSource

Shift Supervisor

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$14.25 - $18.25/hr

Leads all production activities on the night shift in an ASR processing operation. The supervisor is responsible for safe execution of the production plan, staffing, throughput, housekeeping, quality ...

Steak 'n Shake

NIght Shift Manager

Fort Wayne, IN · On-site

$16/hr

Night Shift Manager - Steak 'n Shake - Paying up to $16 per hour! At Steak 'n Shake, we don't just ... Prior experience in a supervisory, shift lead, or restaurant management role preferred * US work ...

Renolit

Night Shift Production Supervisor

La Porte, IN

$49K - $67K/yr

Proven Supervisory skills in a manufacturing environment * Strong initiative to produce quality products. * Must have excellent attendance and safety record * Ability to work a 12-hour shift * Good ...

Kentucky Fried Chicken

Shift Supervisor

Jeffersonville, IN

$14.50 - $18.25/hr

Immediate Opening for a Highly Skilled Shift Supervisor Are you looking for a fun, dynamic work ... Flexible schedule options including Monday to Friday, weekends, day and night shifts * Paid time ...

Subway - 13088-0

Night Shift Manager

Edinburgh, IN

$13 - $15/hr

As part of the Subway ® Team, you as a Shift Manager will focus on six main things: * Providing an ... Scheduling and supervising staff * Being a team player In addition to the role of a typical ...

Kentucky Fried Chicken

Shift Supervisor

Sellersburg, IN

$14 - $17.75/hr

Immediate Opening for a Highly Skilled Shift Supervisor Are you looking for a fun, dynamic work ... Flexible schedule options including Monday to Friday, weekends, day and night shifts * Paid time ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsSupervisor JobsNight Shift Supervisor JobsNight Shift Supervisor Jobs in Indiana

Night Shift Supervisor information

See Indiana salary details

$10

$21

$32

How much do night shift supervisor jobs pay per hour?

As of Aug 30, 2026, the average hourly pay for night shift supervisor in Indiana is $21.29, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $15.10 and $27.21 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is a night shift supervisor?

Night Shift Supervisors are professionals responsible for overseeing operations and staff during the night hours in various industries, such as manufacturing, healthcare, or logistics. Their duties typically include managing workflow, addressing issues that arise, ensuring safety protocols are followed, and serving as the primary point of contact for their team. They also handle shift scheduling, performance evaluations, and may be required to report on productivity and incidents that occur during their shift. The role demands strong leadership, problem-solving skills, and the ability to work independently at hours when senior management may not be present.

What are some common challenges faced by a night shift supervisor, and how can they be effectively managed?

Night Shift Supervisors often encounter challenges such as lower staffing levels, limited access to management support, and the need to ensure safety and productivity during off-hours. Effective time management, proactive communication, and the ability to quickly resolve issues independently are critical. Building a strong rapport with the night shift team and staying organized can help address these challenges, while regular handovers with day shift supervisors ensure continuity and support.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a night shift supervisor, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Night Shift Supervisor, you need strong leadership, problem-solving abilities, and experience in supervising staff, often supported by a background in operations or logistics. Familiarity with shift scheduling software, incident reporting systems, and health and safety protocols is typically required. Excellent communication, adaptability, and conflict resolution skills help you effectively manage teams and resolve issues during off-hours. These skills ensure smooth operations, high productivity, and a safe work environment during night shifts.

What is the difference between Night Shift Supervisor vs Warehouse Supervisor?

AspectNight Shift SupervisorWarehouse Supervisor
CredentialsHigh school diploma; some roles prefer certifications in safety or logisticsHigh school diploma; certifications in inventory management or safety are common
Work EnvironmentOvernight shift in manufacturing, logistics, or retail warehousesDay or evening shifts in warehouse settings, overseeing daily operations
Employer & Industry UsageManufacturing, retail, logistics companiesWarehousing, distribution centers, logistics firms

While both roles involve supervising warehouse operations, the Night Shift Supervisor specifically manages overnight teams and operations, ensuring safety and productivity during night hours. The Warehouse Supervisor typically oversees daily warehouse activities during regular hours. The roles share similar credentials and work environments but differ mainly in shift timing and specific operational focus.

Do night shift supervisors pay well?

Night shift supervisors typically earn higher wages than their daytime counterparts due to shift differentials, with average salaries varying by industry and location. They often receive additional compensation for working overnight hours and may need leadership skills and experience in their field. Overall, the pay for night shift supervisors is generally competitive within supervisory roles.

What are the most commonly searched types of Shift Supervisor jobs in Indiana?

The most popular types of Shift Supervisor jobs in Indiana are:

What are popular job titles related to Night Shift Supervisor jobs in Indiana?

For Night Shift Supervisor jobs in Indiana, the most frequently searched job titles are:

What job categories do people searching Night Shift Supervisor jobs in Indiana look for?

The top searched job categories for Night Shift Supervisor jobs in Indiana are:

What cities in Indiana are hiring for Night Shift Supervisor jobs?

Cities in Indiana with the most Night Shift Supervisor job openings:

What are popular job titles related to Night Shift Supervisor jobs in IN?

For Night Shift Supervisor jobs in IN, the most frequently searched job titles are:

Night Shift Supervisor jobs near you
Infographic showing various Night Shift Supervisor job openings in Indiana as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 75% Full Time, 19% Part Time, 3% Contract, and 2% Nights. Highlights an 98% Physical, 1% Hybrid, and 1% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $44,274 per year, or $21.3 per hour.

Night Shift Operations Supervisor

Palmer-Donavin

Bluffton, IN • On-site

$11.50 - $15.50/hr

Full-time

Medical, Dental, Vision, Life, Retirement, PTO

Posted 10 days ago

Job description

Position Overview:

Palmer-Donavin is a leading distributor of building materials serving customers throughout the Midwest and Southeast. Our night shift operation plays a critical role in delivering on our promise of outstanding service to our customers.

The Night Shift Supervisor is responsible for leading the warehouse night shift operation and ensuring all outbound material is pulled, packaged, and loaded safely, accurately, and on schedule for delivery to customers.

This role oversees nightly workflow, assigns tasks, and manages the performance and development of the night shift team. The supervisor works closely with operations leadership and other departments to resolve issues, maintain safety standards, and ensure warehouse operations run efficiently.

This position is a hands-on working supervisor role, supporting the team on the warehouse floor while directing workflow, maintaining operational standards, and driving accountability for results.

The night shift plays a critical role in delivering Palmer-Donavin’s commitment to outstanding customer service by ensuring materials are prepared and loaded correctly for next-day delivery.

Shift: Sunday - Thursday 7:30pm - 4:00am (overtime as business requires).

Key Responsibilities:

  • Lead nightly outbound warehouse operations to ensure orders are pulled, packaged, and loaded safely, accurately, and on schedule for delivery
  • Assign and prioritize work across the shift based on nightly workload and operational needs
  • Lead daily startup meetings to review safety topics, previous day errors, KPI performance, and the nightly workload
  • Assist employees with pulling, packaging, and loading outbound material as needed to meet operational deadlines
  • Conduct quality control inspections of outbound trucks to ensure materials are loaded correctly and secured for safe transport
  • Monitor workflow and adjust work distribution or staffing to maintain efficiency and productivity
  • Troubleshoot operational issues and coordinate with sales, purchasing, and operations teams to resolve problems quickly
  • Monitor team performance and coach employees to meet productivity, quality, and attendance expectations
  • Supervise, train, and develop warehouse employees to build a reliable and high-performing team
  • Support hiring and onboarding efforts, including interviewing candidates and assisting with new employee training
  • Enforce company safety policies, conduct daily safety discussions, and investigate accidents or safety incidents
  • Maintain communication with operations leadership and participate in meetings to support operational performance and continuous improvement

Qualifications:

  • High School Graduate or General Education Degree (GED)
  • 1+ years of experience in management

Requirements:

  • Satisfactory criminal history check
  • Satisfactory result on a pre-employment drug screening

Benefits:

Employee owners enjoy a comprehensive benefits package including:

  • Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP)
  • Company performance bonuses
  • 401(k) with company matching
  • Medical, dental, and vision coverage
  • Life and disability insurance
  • Paid time off beginning in the first year
  • Parental leave
  • Wellness program
  • Employee discounts on building materials
  • Ongoing training and development opportunities

Apply