1

Insurance Recruiter Jobs in Indiana (NOW HIRING)

Tom Wood Inc is seeking a motivated and detail-oriented Recruiter to join our team in Indianapolis ... Comprehensive health, dental, and vision insurance options. * 401(k) plan with company match.

Tom Wood Inc is seeking a motivated and detail-oriented Recruiter to join our team in Indianapolis ... Comprehensive health, dental, and vision insurance options. * 401(k) plan with company match.

Recruiter

Alexandria, IN ยท On-site

$30 - $35/hr

The full-cycle Recruiter will support hiring efforts across our entire organization which operates ... Life insurance, Short and Long Term Disability * Professional development opportunities * A ...

Recruiter

Indianapolis, IN ยท On-site

$50K - $60K/yr

Tom Wood Inc is seeking a motivated and detail-oriented Recruiter to join our team in Indianapolis ... Comprehensive health, dental, and vision insurance options. * 401(k) plan with company match.

Tom Wood Inc is seeking a motivated and detail-oriented Recruiter to join our team in Indianapolis ... Comprehensive health, dental, and vision insurance options. * 401(k) plan with company match.

The Corporate Recruiter is responsible for managing full-cycle recruiting efforts to attract ... Medical, Dental and Vision Insurance * PTO from Day 1 * 7 Paid Holidays (plus 6 additional half ...

Corporate Recruiter

Indianapolis, IN ยท On-site

$40K - $60K/yr

The Recruiting Coordinator plays a key role in supporting the recruiting and hiring process across ... Full Insurance Benefits * PTO * 401K plan with 2% employer contribution * Company outings & yearly ...

Executive Recruiter

Evansville, IN ยท On-site

$81K - $165K/yr

... insurance. 401K, continuing education opportunities and an employee assistance program are also ... The Executive Recruiter builds and maintains robust talent pipelines, strengthens Old National ...

The Recruiting Coordinator plays a key role in supporting the recruiting and hiring process across ... Full Insurance Benefits * PTO * 401K plan with 2% employer contribution * Company outings & yearly ...

... insurance. 401K, continuing education opportunities and an employee assistance program are also ... The Executive Recruiter is responsible for identifying, engaging, and attracting highly qualified ...

Recruiter - Contract

Evansville, IN ยท Remote

$25 - $27/hr

As a Contract Recruiter, you will be responsible for full-cycle recruitment and will source ... Life Insurance coverage for you and options for your family. * Save on expenses with Flexible ...

Recruiter - Contract

Indianapolis, IN ยท Remote

$25 - $27/hr

As a Contract Recruiter, you will be responsible for full-cycle recruitment and will source ... Life Insurance coverage for you and options for your family. * Save on expenses with Flexible ...

Recruiter - Contract

Lafayette, IN ยท Remote

$25 - $27/hr

As a Contract Recruiter, you will be responsible for full-cycle recruitment and will source ... Life Insurance coverage for you and options for your family. * Save on expenses with Flexible ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

Insurance Recruiter information

See Indiana salary details

$11

$25

$42

How much do insurance recruiter jobs pay per hour?

As of Jul 28, 2026, the average hourly pay for insurance recruiter in Indiana is $25.91, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $19.23 and $30.43 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What are the main day-to-day responsibilities of an Insurance Recruiter?

Insurance Recruiters are responsible for sourcing, screening, and interviewing candidates for various insurance-related positions such as agents, underwriters, and claims specialists. On a typical day, you might post job openings, review resumes, conduct phone screens, collaborate with hiring managers to understand role requirements, and negotiate job offers. You'll also build and maintain a network of qualified professionals in the insurance field to fill both immediate and future vacancies. The role often involves balancing multiple open positions and deadlines, requiring excellent organizational and communication skills to ensure a smooth hiring process.

What does an Insurance Recruiter do?

An Insurance Recruiter is responsible for identifying, attracting, and hiring qualified candidates for roles within the insurance industry. They work closely with hiring managers to understand job requirements, source candidates through various channels, and conduct interviews. Additionally, they may screen resumes, negotiate job offers, and ensure a smooth onboarding process. Their goal is to find top talent that aligns with a company's needs while maintaining a strong candidate experience.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive in the Insurance Recruiter position, and why are they important?

To thrive as an Insurance Recruiter, you need a strong background in recruitment, talent sourcing, and knowledge of insurance industry roles and compliance standards, often supported by a degree in human resources or a related field. Familiarity with applicant tracking systems (ATS), professional networking platforms like LinkedIn, and CRM software is typically required. Outstanding interpersonal skills, persuasive communication, and resilience help you excel in building relationships with candidates and clients. These abilities are vital for effectively identifying top talent, meeting agency or company staffing goals, and maintaining a competitive edge in the insurance sector.

What are the most commonly searched types of Insurance Recruiter jobs in Indiana? The most popular types of Insurance Recruiter jobs in Indiana are:
What are popular job titles related to Insurance Recruiter jobs in Indiana? For Insurance Recruiter jobs in Indiana, the most frequently searched job titles are:
What cities in Indiana are hiring for Insurance Recruiter jobs? Cities in Indiana with the most Insurance Recruiter job openings:
Infographic showing various Insurance Recruiter job openings in Indiana as of July 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 71% Full Time, 22% Part Time, and 6% Contract. Highlights an 96% Physical, 1% Hybrid, and 3% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $53,898 per year, or $25.9 per hour.

Associate Recruiter - Farmers Insurance

Sparrow Agency LLC

Noblesville, IN โ€ข On-site

$36K - $450K/yr

Full-time

Medical, Life, PTO

Posted 11 days ago


Job description

The Associate Recruiter will support the Recruiting Director and Agency Recruiter in building the future of Farmers Insurance across Indiana. This role will focus on sourcing, pre-screening, and onboarding prospective agency owners and team members to help expand our agency footprint and support growth across the state.


Farmers Insurance has an ambitious vision to triple market share in Indiana and is seeking a motivated, relationship-driven individual who can help build an elite recruiting pipeline. This is an opportunity to grow within a fast-paced organization with career advancement opportunities in recruiting, sales, leadership, and future agency ownership.



Benefits

Annual Base Salary + Bonus Opportunities

Flexible Schedule

Hands on Training

Career Growth Opportunities

Licensing Support and Guidance

Access to Farmers proven systems, branding, and District support

Paid Time Off (PTO)

Mon-Fri Schedule


Responsibilities

Source and connect with potential insurance agent candidates

Conduct candidate outreach and initial qualification interviews

Assist with licensing, onboarding, and new agent launch processes

Maintain recruiting activity tracking and follow-up systems

Partner with the recruiting team to build a strong pipeline of future agents


Requirements

1+ years of experience in recruiting, sales, customer service, or leadership preferred

Proven track record of success in a sales or recruiting

Self-motivated, goal-oriented, and passionate about helping others succeed

Active or willing to obtain P&C and/or Life & Health insurance licenses


**Due to the volume of candidates, we will only be reviewing those who have fully completed their Personality Assessment and short answers, so please ensure you complete the assessment when prompted. :)