ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Commission Insurance Controller Jobs (NOW HIRING)

Elite Insurance Partners

Controller

Tampa, FL

Controller Elite Insurance Partners Tampa, FL | Full-time | On-site Salary: $135,000 - $165,000 per ... Experience in financial services, insurance, brokerage, or professional services. * Commission ...

Elite Insurance Partners

Controller

Tampa, FL · On-site

$135K - $165K/yr

Controller Elite Insurance Partners Tampa, FL | Full-time | On-site Salary: $135,000 - $165,000 per ... Experience in financial services, insurance, brokerage, or professional services. * Commission ...

Elite Insurance Partners

Controller

Tampa, FL · On-site

$135K - $165K/yr

Controller Elite Insurance Partners Tampa, FL | Full-time | On-site Salary: $135,000 - $165,000 per ... Experience in financial services, insurance, brokerage, or professional services. * Commission ...

Elite Insurance Partners

Controller

Tampa, FL · On-site

$135K - $165K/yr

Description Controller Elite Insurance Partners Tampa, FL Full-time On-site Salary: $135,000 - $165 ... Experience in financial services, insurance, brokerage, or professional services. * Commission ...

Sovereign Insurance Group

Controller

Berwyn, PA · On-site

Oversee all aspects of commission accounting, including: * Direct bill and agency bill commission ... Health insurance, vision, dental, life insurance, and more. This includes an employer-sponsored HSA ...

Sovereign Insurance Group

Controller

Berwyn, PA · On-site

Oversee all aspects of commission accounting, including: * Direct bill and agency bill commission ... Health insurance, vision, dental, life insurance, and more. This includes an employer-sponsored HSA ...

Northwestern Mutual - Denver

Controller

Denver, CO · On-site

$135K - $155K/yr

Oversee bi-monthly commission processing * Accounts payable oversite and approval * Manage and ... Medical, dental, and vision coverage * Long-term and short-term disability insurance * Matching ...

Scott Cars, Inc.

Automotive Controller

Allentown, PA · On-site

Review and manage payroll processing, commissions, manager bonuses, and payroll accruals. * Oversee ... Coordinate annual audits, tax filings, insurance renewals, and regulatory compliance. * Administer ...

Scott Cars, Inc.

Automotive Controller

Allentown, PA · On-site

Review and manage payroll processing, commissions, manager bonuses, and payroll accruals. * Oversee ... Coordinate annual audits, tax filings, insurance renewals, and regulatory compliance. * Administer ...

Scott Cars, Inc.

Automotive Controller

Allentown, PA · On-site

Review and manage payroll processing, commissions, manager bonuses, and payroll accruals. * Oversee ... Coordinate annual audits, tax filings, insurance renewals, and regulatory compliance. * Administer ...

Insurors of Texas

Controller / Accountant

Waco, TX · On-site

... commission reconciliation, payroll, and key financial reporting functions. This role works closely ... Benefits Paid Time Off (PTO) Health Insurance Dental Insurance Vision Insurance Life Insurance Mon ...

Scott Cars, Inc.

Automotive Controller

Allentown, PA

Review and manage payroll processing, commissions, manager bonuses, and payroll accruals. * Oversee ... Coordinate annual audits, tax filings, insurance renewals, and regulatory compliance. * Administer ...

Robert Half

Controller

Parsippany, NJ · On-site

$180K - $200K/yr

... stage insurance entity. Position is mostly remote with a few days a month in midtown NYC office ... commissions tracking, and reconciliations. · 6-10+ years of progressive accounting and finance ...

Pine View Buildings

Controller

Statesville, NC · On-site

... commission processing Assist with financing activities, including loans and credit lines You're a ... Life Insurance Paid Time Off & Holidays Health Savings Account Additional coverage options:

Luther Seminary

Controller

Saint Paul, MN · On-site

$130K - $140K/yr

Luther is accredited by the Higher Learning Commission and the Association of Theological Schools ... Manage insurance and risk programs in collaboration with the CFO, including primary responsibility ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsInsurance Controller JobsCommission Insurance Controller Jobs

Commission Insurance Controller information

See salary details

$55K

$119.5K

$175.5K

How much do commission insurance controller jobs pay per year?

As of Jul 13, 2026, the average yearly pay for commission insurance controller in the United States is $119,497.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $97,000.00 and $138,500.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is the difference between Commission Insurance Controller vs Insurance Underwriter?

AspectCommission Insurance ControllerInsurance Underwriter
CredentialsTypically requires a bachelor's degree in finance, accounting, or related field; certifications like CPCU or ARM are commonUsually holds a bachelor's degree in finance, economics, or related field; professional designations like CPCU or AIC are beneficial
Work EnvironmentWorks within insurance companies managing commissions, financial reporting, and complianceWorks in underwriting departments assessing risk and determining policy terms
Employer & Industry UsageCommonly employed by insurance carriers and brokersEmployed by insurance companies, agencies, and brokers

The Commission Insurance Controller focuses on managing commissions, financial controls, and compliance within insurance firms, while Insurance Underwriters evaluate risks and set policy terms. Both roles require similar credentials and often work within the same industry environment, but their core responsibilities differ significantly.

What type of insurance pays the highest commissions?

In the insurance industry, life insurance and annuities typically offer the highest commissions for agents and controllers. These products often have larger premiums and longer-term policies, resulting in higher commission rates compared to other insurance types like health or property insurance.

Do insurance brokers make money on commission?

Insurance brokers typically earn money through commissions paid by insurance companies for each policy they sell. The commission rate varies depending on the type of insurance and the agreement with the insurer, and brokers often receive ongoing commissions for policy renewals. This commission-based structure is a common way for brokers to generate income in the industry.

What is the average commission for an insurance agent?

The average commission for an insurance agent typically ranges from 10% to 20% of the premium for each policy sold, depending on the type of insurance and the company. Commission structures can vary based on experience, sales volume, and whether the agent is independent or tied to a specific insurer.

How do life insurance brokers get paid with 80% commission?

A Commission Insurance Controller overseeing broker payments would understand that life insurance brokers typically earn commissions based on a percentage of the policy premium, with 80% being unusually high and often representing the initial commission rate. Such high commissions are usually paid upfront and may be shared between the broker and the agency, depending on the compensation structure and contractual agreements. Brokers often receive commissions through insurance carriers or agencies, and these payments are tracked using specialized software or systems to ensure accuracy and compliance.
What cities are hiring for Commission Insurance Controller jobs? Cities with the most Commission Insurance Controller job openings:
What are the most commonly searched types of Insurance Controller jobs? The most popular types of Insurance Controller jobs are:
What states have the most Commission Insurance Controller jobs? States with the most job openings for Commission Insurance Controller jobs include:
Commission Insurance Controller jobs near you
Controller

Controller

Elite Insurance Partners

Tampa, FL

Full-time

Medical, Dental, Vision, Life, Retirement, PTO

Re-posted 15 days ago

Job description

Controller
Elite Insurance Partners
Tampa, FL | Full-time | On-site
Salary: $135,000 - $165,000 per year, based on experience and qualifications
About Elite Insurance Partners
Elite Insurance Partners (EIP) is a growing, technology-driven organization in the insurance and financial services space. We are focused on helping consumers navigate important insurance decisions while continuing to build scalable systems, strong operations, and a high-accountability workplace.
 
As we continue to grow, we are strengthening our internal finance and accounting operations. This is an opportunity for an experienced accounting leader to step into a visible, hands-on role where their work will directly support better reporting, stronger controls, cleaner processes, and smarter business decisions.
About the Role
EIP is hiring a Controller to lead and improve accounting operations while partnering with leadership on financial strategy, cash flow visibility, revenue analysis, reporting, and process improvement.
 
This is a hands-on leadership role for someone who can own the details, strengthen controls, improve workflows, provide accurate reporting, and drive meaningful process improvements. The ideal candidate takes initiative, follows through, and looks for ways to improve the accounting function rather than simply maintaining existing processes.
What You Will Do
  • Own daily accounting operations, including general ledger activity, journal entries, reconciliations, accounts payable, accounts receivable, vendor payments, and supporting documentation.
  • Lead the month-end close process and ensure accurate, timely financial reporting for leadership.
  • Prepare accrual-basis and cash-basis financial reports, including balance sheet, income statement, cash flow, and supporting schedules.
  • Identify and implement process improvements that reduce manual work, improve accuracy, strengthen internal controls, and increase efficiency across the accounting function.
  • Maintain depreciation, amortization, prepaid expense, accrual, and other recurring accounting schedules.
  • Oversee commission and revenue reconciliation across multiple revenue streams and product lines.
  • Research and resolve commission discrepancies, underpayments, overpayments, and timing issues.
  • Develop financial insights and analytics to support strategic decision-making, including cash flow forecasting, KPI tracking, and readiness for future reporting needs.
  • Support budgeting, forecasting, and financial analysis for leadership decision-making.
  • Partner with leadership and cross-functional teams to improve reporting accuracy, automation, and operational efficiency.
  • Validate the accuracy and completeness of financial information before it is shared with external parties such as lenders, investors, auditors, or tax partners.
  • Prepare documentation and schedules for external accountants, tax preparers, audits, reviews, and year-end financial needs.
Required Qualifications
  • Bachelor's degree in Accounting, Finance, or a related field.
  • 7+ years of progressive accounting experience with demonstrated ownership of accounting processes.
  • Prior experience as a Controller, Assistant Controller, or Accounting Manager with full month-end close ownership.
  • Strong understanding of GAAP, accrual accounting, financial statements, reconciliations, and internal controls.
  • Advanced experience with QuickBooks Online or similar cloud-based accounting software.
  • Advanced Microsoft Excel skills, including pivot tables, formulas, reconciliations, and financial modeling.
  • Experience owning or heavily supporting accounts payable, accounts receivable, general ledger management, and financial reporting.
  • Proven ability to take initiative, identify problems, and drive improvements beyond assigned tasks.
  • Strong attention to detail, organization, accuracy, and follow-through.
  • Ability to communicate financial information clearly to both finance and non-finance leaders.
  • Ability to work full-time on-site in Tampa, FL.
Preferred Qualifications
  • CPA or CMA certification.
  • Experience in financial services, insurance, brokerage, or professional services.
  • Commission accounting or revenue reconciliation experience across multiple carriers, revenue streams, or product lines.
  • Complex revenue recognition experience.
  • Financial Planning & Analysis (FP&A) or financial modeling experience.
  • Demonstrated success improving accounting processes, internal controls, close procedures, or accounts payable workflows.
  • Experience working with external accounting firms or outsourced finance partners.
  • Ability to lead cross-functional initiatives and support adoption of new processes or systems.
  • Business intelligence, dashboard reporting, automation, or finance technology experience.
Work Location and Schedule
  • Full-time, on-site position in Tampa, FL.
  • Standard business hours, with flexibility as needed during close cycles, reporting deadlines, and business-critical projects.
Compensation and Benefits
  • $135,000 - $165,000 annual salary, based on experience and qualifications.
  • Medical, dental, and vision insurance.
  • Life and disability insurance.
  • 401(k) with company match.
  • Paid time off and paid holidays.
  • Professional development opportunities.
  • On-site amenities including a gym, Starbucks, cafeteria with cooks, massage chair room, and covered walking trail.