ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Case Manager Paralegal Jobs in Indiana (NOW HIRING)

Morgan & Morgan, P.A.

Case Manager

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$19 - $24.50/hr

Prior experience as a Personal Injury Case Manager or Prelitigation Paralegal (strongly preferred) * At least 2 years of working in a legal position or insurance adjuster experience (strongly ...

Morgan & Morgan, P.A.

Case Manager

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$19 - $24.50/hr

Prior experience as a Personal Injury Case Manager or Prelitigation Paralegal (strongly preferred) * At least 2 years of working in a legal position or insurance adjuster experience (strongly ...

Crisp Recruit

Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

Case Management: Manage a high-volume personal injury caseload of approximately 70-80 active files ... Experience: 3-5 years of paralegal experience preferred, ideally in personal injury, with the ...

MichieHamlett Attorneys at Law

$57K - $75K/yr

You will be part of a team responsible for case management, investigation, research, and ... Mentoring from experienced paralegals will help you hit the ground running. Responsibilities: · ...

MichieHamlett Attorneys at Law

Paralegal

Atlanta, IN · On-site

$57K - $75K/yr

You will be part of a team responsible for case management, investigation, research, and ... Mentoring from experienced paralegals will help you hit the ground running. Responsibilities: · ...

MichieHamlett Attorneys at Law

Paralegal

Maxwell, IN

$57K - $75K/yr

You will be part of a team responsible for case management, investigation, research, and ... Mentoring from experienced paralegals will help you hit the ground running. Responsibilities: · ...

MichieHamlett Attorneys at Law

Paralegal

Carthage, IN

$57K - $75K/yr

You will be part of a team responsible for case management, investigation, research, and ... Mentoring from experienced paralegals will help you hit the ground running. Responsibilities: · ...

MichieHamlett Attorneys at Law

Paralegal

Waldron, IN · On-site

$57K - $75K/yr

You will be part of a team responsible for case management, investigation, research, and ... Mentoring from experienced paralegals will help you hit the ground running. Responsibilities: · ...

MichieHamlett Attorneys at Law

Paralegal

Castleton, IN · On-site

$57K - $75K/yr

You will be part of a team responsible for case management, investigation, research, and ... Mentoring from experienced paralegals will help you hit the ground running. Responsibilities: · ...

MichieHamlett Attorneys at Law

Paralegal

Saint Paul, IN · On-site

$57K - $75K/yr

You will be part of a team responsible for case management, investigation, research, and ... Mentoring from experienced paralegals will help you hit the ground running. Responsibilities: · ...

MichieHamlett Attorneys at Law

Paralegal

Cumberland, IN · On-site

$57K - $75K/yr

You will be part of a team responsible for case management, investigation, research, and ... Mentoring from experienced paralegals will help you hit the ground running. Responsibilities: · ...

MichieHamlett Attorneys at Law

Paralegal

Shirley, IN · On-site

$57K - $75K/yr

You will be part of a team responsible for case management, investigation, research, and ... Mentoring from experienced paralegals will help you hit the ground running. Responsibilities: · ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsCase Paralegal JobsCase Manager Paralegal JobsCase Manager Paralegal Jobs in Indiana

Case Manager Paralegal information

See Indiana salary details

$31.9K

$67.9K

$103.2K

How much do case manager paralegal jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 12, 2026, the average yearly pay for case manager paralegal in Indiana is $67,919.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $51,900.00 and $85,200.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is the difference between Case Manager Paralegal vs Legal Assistant?

AspectCase Manager ParalegalLegal Assistant
CredentialsParalegal certification often preferredNo specific certification usually required
Work EnvironmentLaw firms, legal departments, courtsLaw firms, legal departments, courts
Job FocusManaging case files, legal research, assisting attorneysPreparing documents, scheduling, administrative support
Common UsageLegal case management, client interactionAdministrative legal support tasks

While both roles support legal teams, Case Manager Paralegals focus on managing cases and legal research, often requiring paralegal certification. Legal Assistants handle administrative tasks like document preparation and scheduling. Understanding these differences helps in choosing the right career path or job search focus.

What is a case manager paralegal?

Case Manager Paralegals are legal professionals who assist attorneys by managing cases, organizing documents, conducting research, and coordinating communication between clients, witnesses, and legal teams. They play a crucial role in ensuring that all aspects of a case are prepared and handled efficiently, from initial client intake to trial or settlement. Case Manager Paralegals must be highly organized, detail-oriented, and possess strong communication skills to keep cases on track and support attorneys throughout the legal process.

How does a case manager paralegal typically collaborate with attorneys and clients throughout a case?

A Case Manager Paralegal plays a central role in coordinating communication and tasks between attorneys, clients, and other parties involved in a case. They assist attorneys by organizing case files, managing deadlines, conducting legal research, and preparing documents for court submissions. Paralegals often serve as the primary point of contact for clients, updating them on case progress and gathering necessary information. This collaborative approach ensures cases move efficiently and that attorneys have the support needed to focus on legal strategy.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a case manager paralegal, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Case Manager Paralegal, a strong understanding of legal procedures, case management, and documentation is essential, typically supported by a paralegal certificate or relevant degree. Familiarity with case management software, electronic filing systems, and legal research databases is commonly required. Excellent organizational skills, attention to detail, and effective communication are crucial soft skills for managing multiple cases and collaborating with attorneys and clients. These abilities ensure efficient case progression, compliance with legal requirements, and smooth coordination within legal teams.
What are popular job titles related to Case Manager Paralegal jobs in Indiana? For Case Manager Paralegal jobs in Indiana, the most frequently searched job titles are:
What job categories do people searching Case Manager Paralegal jobs in Indiana look for? The top searched job categories for Case Manager Paralegal jobs in Indiana are:
What cities in Indiana are hiring for Case Manager Paralegal jobs? Cities in Indiana with the most Case Manager Paralegal job openings:
Case Manager Paralegal jobs near you
Infographic showing various Case Manager Paralegal job openings in Indiana as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 100% Full Time. Highlights an 100% In-person job distribution, with an average salary of $67,919 per year, or $32.7 per hour.

Case Manager

Morgan & Morgan, P.A.

Indianapolis, IN • On-site

$19 - $24.50/hr

Full-time

Posted 19 days ago

Morgan & Morgan rating

6.7

Company rating: 6.7 out of 10

Based on 49 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

30th of 34 rated law firms

Job description

Summary

We are seeking a Case Manager to join our team. As a Case Manager you must be highly organized and able to work on a varied caseload. The Case Manager will assist the attorney in developing settlements, preparing documents and correspondence as needed. The ideal candidate is customer focused and empathetic.

Responsibilities

  • Daily interaction with existing and potential clients, via telephone and in person
  • Order medical records from providers and communicate with clients and providers during the course of treatment
  • Obtain documents necessary to support injury and/or liability positions
  • Interact with insurance carriers and healthcare providers to secure records and account balances
  • Work directly with multiple coworkers involved in the management and support of case files
  • Maintain organized case files
  • Prepare comprehensive demands and assemble support for submission to carriers under the direct supervision of an attorney
  • Interact with attorneys and present case synopsis when required
  • Manage case files from intake to closing under the direction of an attorney
  • Performs other related duties as assigned to meet the needs of the business

Qualifications

  • Bachelor's degree (preferred)
  • Prior experience as a Personal Injury Case Manager or Prelitigation Paralegal (strongly preferred)
  • At least 2 years of working in a legal position or insurance adjuster experience (strongly preferred)
  • Ability to be a team player and follow procedures
  • Proactive interaction with clients, insurance companies and medical providers
  • Must possess the ability to multi-task, prioritize, and manage workload with a positive attitude and minimal supervision
  • Highly organized with the ability to juggle multiple deadlines in a fast-paced environment
  • Strong writing and communication skills along with attention to detail
  • Extensive computer and database expertise, Microsoft Word, Excel, Outlook, and type no less than 35 wpm
  • Remote and/or hybrid not eligible

#LI-KL1

What Morgan & Morgan employees say

Pay

Benefits

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom

Apply