ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Insurance Controller Jobs in Wisconsin (NOW HIRING)

Winsert

Controller

Marinette, WI

Medical, dental, and vision insurance * Life and disability * Health savings account with company ... The Controller is responsible for overseeing the day-to-day financial operations of Winsert while ...

Roman Home Services

Controller

West Allis, WI · On-site

$90K - $140K/yr

Controller - Roman Home Services Roman Home Services is seeking an experienced Controller to lead ... insurance requests, external accountant requests, and other compliance-related needs. * Promote a ...

Roman Home Services

Controller

West Allis, WI

$90K - $140K/yr

Controller - Roman Home Services Roman Home Services is seeking an experienced Controller to lead ... insurance requests, external accountant requests, and other compliance-related needs. * Promote a ...

Roman Home Services

Controller

West Allis, WI · On-site

$90K - $140K/yr

Controller - Roman Home Services Roman Home Services is seeking an experienced Controller to lead ... insurance requests, external accountant requests, and other compliance-related needs. * Promote a ...

Roman Home Services

Controller

West Allis, WI

$90K - $140K/yr

Controller - Roman Home Services Roman Home Services is seeking an experienced Controller to lead ... insurance requests, external accountant requests, and other compliance-related needs. * Promote a ...

Humetis Group

Controller

Madison, WI · On-site

Controller Location: Madison, WI Employment Type: Full-Time | Permanent | Hybrid About Us Client is ... Comprehensive health, dental, and vision insurance * Generous Paid Time Off (PTO) and paid holidays ...

Forest County Potawatomi

Controller

WI · On-site

Life insurance * 401k with match Equal Opportunity Employer This employer is required to notify all applicants of their rights pursuant to federal employment laws. For further information, please ...

LDV, Inc.

Controller

Burlington, WI

Support the organization's workers' compensation, employee benefits and other insurance activities ... Work with controller from sister company and Group Level CFO to establish consistent accounting ...

Monona Plumbing and Fire Protection

Controller

Madison, WI · On-site

$100K - $120K/yr

Work closely with insurance companies and agents to handle quotes, renewals, claims, and audits as ... Proven experience as a Controller or similar role in the construction or mechanical contracting ...

Monona Plumbing and Fire Protection

Controller

Madison, WI · On-site

$100K - $120K/yr

Work closely with insurance companies and agents to handle quotes, renewals, claims, and audits as ... Proven experience as a Controller or similar role in the construction or mechanical contracting ...

LDV, Inc.

Controller

Burlington, WI

Support the organization's workers' compensation, employee benefits and other insurance activities ... Work with controller from sister company and Group Level CFO to establish consistent accounting ...

Radius Packaging

Controller

New Berlin, WI · On-site

... Controller to join our team in New Berlin, WI. This role reports directly to the Chief Financial ... vision insurance • Vacation and company-paid holidays • 401(k) with company match • Bonus ...

The Masterson Company, Inc.

Controller

Milwaukee, WI · On-site

... Insurance, Auditor & Tax firm(s), IT consultants, and legal representation. Serve as primary ... controlling cost adjustments and scrap. Advise operational and purchasing teams on trends. 10. ...

Radius Packaging

Controller

New Berlin, WI · On-site

... Controller to join our team in New Berlin, WI. This role reports directly to the Chief Financial ... vision insurance • Vacation and company-paid holidays • 401(k) with company match • Bonus ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsInsurance Controller JobsInsurance Controller Jobs in Wisconsin

Insurance Controller information

See Wisconsin salary details

$55.5K

$120.6K

$177.1K

How much do insurance controller jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 4, 2026, the average yearly pay for insurance controller in Wisconsin is $120,614.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $97,900.00 and $139,800.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What does an insurance controller do?

An Insurance Controller is responsible for overseeing the financial operations of an insurance company, ensuring compliance with regulations, managing financial reporting, and optimizing budget processes. They analyze financial data, prepare reports, and work closely with executives to support strategic decision-making. Additionally, they help maintain internal controls and risk management practices to safeguard the company's financial health.

Is an insurance controller a high level position?

An insurance controller is typically a senior management role responsible for overseeing financial reporting, compliance, and internal controls within an insurance company. It is generally considered a high-level position that requires extensive industry experience, accounting skills, and often a professional certification such as CPA or CFA.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an insurance controller?

To excel as an Insurance Controller, you need strong financial management, analytical, and accounting expertise, typically backed by a bachelor’s degree in accounting or finance and several years of relevant insurance industry experience. Familiarity with insurance-specific accounting software, ERP systems, and certifications such as CPA or CMA are highly valuable in this role. Outstanding attention to detail, leadership abilities, and excellent communication skills distinguish top performers in insurance controlling. These competencies ensure accurate financial reporting, regulatory compliance, and effective collaboration across departments in a complex industry.

What are the most commonly searched types of Insurance Controller jobs in Wisconsin? The most popular types of Insurance Controller jobs in Wisconsin are:
What are popular job titles related to Insurance Controller jobs in Wisconsin? For Insurance Controller jobs in Wisconsin, the most frequently searched job titles are:
What job categories do people searching Insurance Controller jobs in Wisconsin look for? The top searched job categories for Insurance Controller jobs in Wisconsin are:
Insurance Controller jobs near you
Infographic showing various Insurance Controller job openings in Wisconsin as of July 2026, with employment types broken down into 100% Full Time. Highlights an 94% In-person, and 6% Hybrid job distribution, with an average salary of $120,614 per year, or $58 per hour.

Financial Controller

SERVPRO of Pewaukee & Sussex

Pewaukee, WI • On-site

$70K - $90K/yr

Full-time

Medical, Dental, Vision, Retirement, PTO

Re-posted 6 days ago

Job description

Benefits:
  • 401(k) matching
  • Bonus based on performance
  • Company parties
  • Competitive salary
  • Dental insurance
  • Health insurance
  • Paid time off
  • Vision insurance

Controller
Location: Pewaukee, WI (In-Office)
Status: Full-Time, Exempt
Compensation: $70,000–$90,000 based on experience
Reports To: Ownership
Position Summary
RJ Restoration LLC operates five SERVPRO locations across mitigation, contents, and reconstruction, with annual revenue in the eight-figure range. We need one person to own the financials for the entire business.
This is a hands-on, full-charge role. You run QuickBooks, you pay every bill, you collect every dollar, and you keep the books clean and current. You are the single point of accountability for the day-to-day financial management of the company.
You must be excellent at QuickBooks. That is non-negotiable.

QuickBooks Management
  • Own QuickBooks for the entire company.
  • Keep financial records accurate, current, and clean.
  • Categorize all credit card statement activity correctly and on time.
  • Reconcile all bank and credit card accounts monthly.
  • Code expenses and subcontractor costs to the correct job number so each job's costs are accurate.
Accounts Payable
  • Pay all business expenses on time, including: Subcontractors, Vendors, Rent, Utilities, Credit card balances, Auto loans, Equipment financing, Insurance, Other recurring and one-off obligations.
  • Verify subcontractor invoices against approved scopes of work before payment.
  • Manage vendor records, payment schedules, and 1099 reporting.
Accounts Receivable & Collections
  • Own collections across all divisions: Mitigation, Contents, Reconstruction
  • Invoice promptly and follow up persistently with carriers, adjusters, TPAs, and customers until payment is received.
  • Track accounts receivable aging.
  • Keep ownership informed of outstanding balances and collection challenges.
Financial Close & Reporting
  • Run a clean monthly close process and produce monthly: Profit & Loss Statement, Balance Sheet, and Current Cash Position Report.
  • Coordinate with outside accountants on sales tax and income tax filings.
Payroll
  • Run or coordinate payroll across all locations.
  • Ensure payroll is accurate and processed on time.
Required Qualifications
  • Expert-level QuickBooks proficiency with the ability to manage the system independently.
  • 5+ years of full-charge bookkeeping or accounting management experience.
  • Proven experience owning a company's books from start to finish.
  • Strong background in: Accounts Payable, Accounts Receivable, Collections, Bank Reconciliations and Monthly Close Processes
  • Comfortable and persistent in pursuing payments from insurance carriers and adjusters.
  • Highly organized, accurate, reliable, and capable of meeting deadlines without supervision.
Preferred Qualifications
  • Experience in restoration, construction, or trade-service industries.
  • Familiarity with insurance claim billing and job costing.
  • Familiarity with Wisconsin contractor sales and use tax.
Equal Opportunity Employer
RJ Restoration LLC | SERVPRO Franchise Group is an Equal Opportunity Employer.