1

Pizza Restaurant Manager Jobs in Indiana (NOW HIRING)

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop ...

Showing results 21-40

Pizza Restaurant Manager information

See Indiana salary details

$25.2K

$52.3K

$72.8K

How much do pizza restaurant manager jobs pay per year?

As of Sep 7, 2026, the average yearly pay for pizza restaurant manager in Indiana is $52,300.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $42,800.00 and $60,400.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What does a pizza restaurant manager do?

A Pizza Restaurant Manager oversees the daily operations of a pizza restaurant, ensuring excellent customer service, food quality, and staff performance. Their responsibilities include hiring and training employees, managing inventory and supplies, handling customer complaints, and maintaining health and safety standards. Additionally, they may be involved in marketing, budgeting, and implementing strategies to increase sales and profitability. Effective managers balance administrative duties with hands-on leadership to create a successful and enjoyable dining experience.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a pizza restaurant manager, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Pizza Restaurant Manager, you need strong leadership, operational management, and food safety knowledge, often supported by experience in food service or hospitality management. Familiarity with POS systems, inventory management software, and health and safety certifications is typically required. Excellent customer service, team motivation, and problem-solving abilities set outstanding managers apart. These skills ensure smooth restaurant operations, satisfied customers, and a productive, compliant work environment.

What are some common challenges faced by a pizza restaurant manager, and how can they be effectively addressed?

Pizza Restaurant Managers often encounter challenges such as maintaining consistent food quality, managing high staff turnover, and handling busy peak hours. Effective solutions include implementing thorough staff training programs, fostering a positive work culture to boost retention, and using efficient scheduling and workflow systems during rush periods. Additionally, clear communication with both kitchen and front-of-house teams helps ensure smooth operations and excellent customer service.

What is the difference between Pizza Restaurant Manager vs Pizza Shift Supervisor?

AspectPizza Restaurant ManagerPizza Shift Supervisor
ResponsibilitiesOversees entire restaurant operations, manages staff, handles customer service, and ensures quality standards.Supervises staff during a shift, manages daily operations, and ensures smooth service flow.
Required CredentialsExperience in restaurant management, possibly a food safety certification, and leadership skills.Experience in restaurant service, basic leadership skills, and sometimes a food handler's permit.
Work EnvironmentOffice-like environment with managerial duties, meetings, and staff oversight.Fast-paced restaurant setting focused on daily shift operations.

The Pizza Restaurant Manager typically has broader responsibilities, overseeing the entire restaurant, while the Pizza Shift Supervisor focuses on managing staff and operations during a specific shift. Both roles require relevant experience and certifications, but the manager's role is more strategic and comprehensive.

How to become a pizza restaurant manager?

To become a pizza restaurant manager, candidates typically need previous experience in restaurant or food service roles, strong leadership and communication skills, and knowledge of restaurant operations. Many employers prefer candidates with a high school diploma or equivalent, and some may require food safety certifications or management training. Progression often involves starting as a server or cook and advancing to supervisory roles before applying for management positions.

What are popular job titles related to Pizza Restaurant Manager jobs in Indiana?

For Pizza Restaurant Manager jobs in Indiana, the most frequently searched job titles are:

What cities in Indiana are hiring for Pizza Restaurant Manager jobs?

Cities in Indiana with the most Pizza Restaurant Manager job openings:

Infographic showing various Pizza Restaurant Manager job openings in Indiana as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 80% Full Time, and 20% Part Time. Highlights an 100% In-person job distribution, with an average salary of $52,300 per year, or $25.1 per hour.

Restaurant Manager

Donatos Pizza

Indianapolis, IN • On-site

Full-time

Re-posted 19 hours ago


Donatos Pizza rating

4.8

Company rating: 4.8 out of 10

Based on 80 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

81st of 89 rated restaurants


Job description

The Restaurant Manager (RM) is responsible for Employee Development, Operations Excellence, Sales Growth, Profit Growth, and our customer's experience (Hospitality). The role of the RM is to develop people and build prosperity. The RM is the leader in the restaurant, acting as a coach and providing a restaurant environment that is focused on integrity,

honesty, and pride. The Restaurant Manager provides resources, training, and development, and utilizes a systematic and principle-centered management approach to maximize restaurant-operating results, to fulfill the Mission & Promise.

Minimum Requirements:

Restaurant Managers must have a flexible schedule that includes the ability to work variety of opening, mid and closing shifts, along with working weekends and holidays.

Education

High School diploma or equivalent.

ServSafe certification

Internal Candidates must complete required training and development activities

Previous Experience

External - 1 year in similar role preferred, successful completion of Donatos MIT program required

Internal - 6 months Donatos experience preferred, management experience required

Can execute all items on the RM readiness checklist

Physical Requirements

Must be able to perform the essential functions of this position safely while meeting productivity standards

Able to stand and/or walk entire shift

Able to lift up to 50 pounds occasionally

Occasional bending and twisting

Duties & Responsibilities:

  • Ensures each new associate receives the proper on-boarding and training and understands their role in fulfilling the Mission & Promise.
  • Models performance standards (primary responsibility is to direct and coach, secondary responsibility is to assist).
  • Ensures staffing levels are optimal during all volume periods; acts in a timely and decisive manner to adjust staffing for business volume changes.
  • Effectively controls cash and assets and ensures adherence to cash handling policies.
  • Empowers and allows restaurant associates to make decisions and resolve customer concerns in a way that fully satisfies our customer.
  • Anticipates the needs of the customers at all access points and removes existing or potential service barriers.
  • Displays caring and empathy for customers and follows correct steps when resolving complaints.
  • Executes plans to improve customer satisfaction through regular utilization & communication of customer feedback program (SMG website), customer callbacks, and refining results to create improvement plans.
  • Engages the local community; builds strong relationships that result in partnerships within the community, win-win opportunities, and sales growth.
  • Controls food cost components of waste, prep, weights, portioning, on hand amounts (food orders/build to/inventory management) and theft during shifts.
  • Demonstrates, trains, and enforces operating norms, including but not limited to uniform policy, attendance, safety procedures, and cleanliness.
  • Opens and/or closes the restaurant with proper administrative procedures and completes assigned paperwork.
  • Ensures product quality meets Donatos standards and guest expectations.
  • Properly executes, enforces, and manages food safety and sanitation requirements.
  • Ensures Associates understand and follow the food safety & personal hygiene standards required by Donatos and the local Health Department.
  • Seeks out and eliminates potential food safety violations and unsafe practices or conditions.
  • Coaches and counsels the team to achieve restaurant and personal development goals.
  • Assists all management in developing and ensures the Readiness Checklist process is utilized by all management team members.
  • Communicates performance standards and expectations to all team members and provides ongoing feedback on progress toward objectives and results.
  • Assumes accountability for P & L results.
  • Delegates responsibility among team members for achieving financial results.
  • Identifies areas of opportunity and implements action plans to achieve cost reductions.
  • Monitors sales volumes and adjusts projections accurately.
  • Conducts meetings such as product rollouts, manager meetings, monthly safety meetings, operating systems, etc.

Donatos is an Equal Opportunity/ Affirmative Action Employer:

We provide equal employment opportunities to all qualified employees and applicants for employment without regard to race, religion, sex, age, marital status, national origin, sexual orientation, citizenship status, veteran status, disability or any other legally protected status. We prohibit discrimination in decisions concerning recruitment, hiring, compensation, benefits, training, termination, promotions, or any other condition of employment or career development.

Donatos is just as dedicated to our Associates as we are to our guests. After all, delivering the best food and service starts with attracting (and keeping) the very best team members.
Whether you're looking for your first job or want to advance your career, you'll love being part of a work environment that's not just rewarding and fun, but supportive too. We're committed to hiring associates who we feel will be a great fit with the Donatos family - and then empowering them to become leaders who bring out the full potential of everyone around them.

Education:no requirementsEmployment Type: FULL_TIME

What Donatos Pizza employees say

Pay

Benefits

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom


Donatos Pizza logo

About Donatos Pizza

Sourced by ZipRecruiter

Donatos Pizza, operating in the food and restaurant industry, is a popular pizza delivery company based in Columbus, OH, US. Established in 1963 by Jim Grote, the company has since expanded its operations across multiple states within the country. Donatos is known for its Edge-to-Edge pizza, which is identified by covering every square inch of pizza with toppings. Their regular menu includes various specialty pizzas, subs, salads, and desserts, all adhering to the business' high-quality food standards.

Industry

Retail

Company size

10,000+ Employees

Headquarters location

Columbus, OH, US

Year founded

1963