ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Insurance Sales Manager Jobs in Rochester, NY (NOW HIRING)

ASSA ABLOY

Regional Sales Manager

East Rochester, NY

$90K/yr

Successful Area Sales Managers combine new business development, strategic account management, and consultative selling to drive sustainable growth. You will be responsible for generating new ...

ASSA ABLOY

Regional Sales Manager

East Rochester, NY

$90K/yr

Successful Area Sales Managers combine new business development, strategic account management, and consultative selling to drive sustainable growth. You will be responsible for generating new ...

ASSA ABLOY

Regional Sales Manager

Rochester, NY

$90K/yr

Successful Area Sales Managers combine new business development, strategic account management, and consultative selling to drive sustainable growth. You will be responsible for generating new ...

ASSA ABLOY

Regional Sales Manager

Rochester, NY

$90K/yr

Successful Area Sales Managers combine new business development, strategic account management, and consultative selling to drive sustainable growth. You will be responsible for generating new ...

smcnorthamerica

Manager Sales

Rochester, NY · Remote

The Sales Manager will be responsible for managing and directing all sales activities within their designated responsibilities. Additional responsibility is to lead, guide, coach, mentor, and manage ...

SMC Corporation of America

Manager Sales

Rochester, NY · On-site

The Sales Manager will be responsible for managing and directing all sales activities within their designated responsibilities. Additional responsibility is to lead, guide, coach, mentor, and manage ...

smcnorthamerica

Manager Sales

Rochester, NY · Remote

The Sales Manager will be responsible for managing and directing all sales activities within their designated responsibilities. Additional responsibility is to lead, guide, coach, mentor, and manage ...

previous page

Showing results 41-60

All JobsInsurance Sales JobsInsurance Sales Manager JobsInsurance Sales Manager Jobs in Rochester, NY

Insurance Sales Manager information

See Rochester, NY salary details

$34K

$74.3K

$127.3K

How much do insurance sales manager jobs pay per year?

As of Sep 9, 2026, the average yearly pay for insurance sales manager in Rochester, NY is $74,252.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $50,300.00 and $89,800.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What does an insurance sales manager do?

An Insurance Sales Manager oversees a team of insurance sales agents, setting sales targets, developing training programs, and ensuring compliance with industry regulations. They are responsible for recruiting, mentoring, and motivating their team to meet or exceed sales goals. Additionally, they analyze market trends, identify new business opportunities, and work closely with clients to ensure their insurance needs are met. Their role is crucial in driving the growth and success of insurance agencies or companies.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an insurance sales manager?

To thrive as an Insurance Sales Manager, you need strong sales expertise, leadership abilities, and a solid understanding of insurance products, usually supported by a bachelor’s degree and relevant experience. Familiarity with CRM software, sales analytics tools, and often state-specific insurance licensing are typically required. Excellent communication, motivational leadership, and strategic problem-solving are vital soft skills for inspiring teams and building client relationships. These skills ensure effective team performance, regulatory compliance, and the achievement of ambitious sales targets.

What are some common challenges faced by insurance sales managers, and how can they effectively address them?

Insurance Sales Managers often encounter challenges such as meeting ambitious sales targets, motivating a diverse team, and adapting to changing regulations or market trends. To address these, successful managers focus on transparent communication, ongoing training, and fostering a collaborative environment where team members can share best practices. Additionally, leveraging customer relationship management (CRM) tools and regularly reviewing performance metrics helps managers identify areas for improvement and maintain a high-performing team.

What is the difference between Insurance Sales Manager vs Insurance Agent?

AspectInsurance Sales ManagerInsurance Agent
CredentialsLicenses, management experienceLicenses, sales certifications
Work EnvironmentOversees teams, develops sales strategiesDirectly sells insurance policies to clients
Employer & Industry UsageInsurance companies, agenciesInsurance agencies, brokerages
Search & Comparison IntentManagement roles, leadership in salesSales positions, individual insurance sales

The main difference between an Insurance Sales Manager and an Insurance Agent lies in their roles. The Insurance Sales Manager focuses on leading sales teams, developing strategies, and overseeing operations, often requiring management experience and licenses. In contrast, the Insurance Agent directly sells policies to clients, focusing on individual sales and customer service. Both roles are essential in the insurance industry but serve different functions within the sales process.

Is it hard to make money in insurance sales?

Insurance sales managers often earn commissions based on policy sales and renewals, so income can vary widely depending on sales performance, experience, and client base. Success typically requires strong sales skills, persistence, and the ability to build relationships, with income potential increasing as these skills develop. Many in this role also pursue industry certifications to improve earning opportunities.

What are the most commonly searched types of Insurance Sales jobs in Rochester, NY?

The most popular types of Insurance Sales jobs in Rochester, NY are:

What cities near Rochester, NY are hiring for Insurance Sales Manager jobs?

Cities near Rochester, NY with the most Insurance Sales Manager job openings:

Insurance Sales Manager jobs near you
Infographic showing various Insurance Sales Manager job openings in Rochester, NY as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 73% Full Time, 22% Part Time, and 4% Contract. Highlights an 90% Physical, 1% Hybrid, and 9% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $74,252 per year, or $35.7 per hour.

Inside Sales Representative - Insurance

Rochester, NY • On-site

Paychex
Human Resources Consulting Services • 10K+ employees
Learn more about Paychexexternal

$45K - $90K/yr

Full-time

Medical, Retirement, PTO

Re-posted 21 days ago

Key responsibilities

  • Manage the entire sales cycle from prospecting to closing insurance sales through virtual interactions.

  • Identify client needs and present Paychex insurance solutions to key stakeholders and decision-makers.

  • Conduct outbound prospecting via cold calls, emails, and follow-up on marketing leads to generate sales opportunities.

Paychex rating

7.3

Company rating: 7.3 out of 10

Based on 176 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

238th of 501 rated business services

Job description

Paychex is reimagining how businesses manage their workforce by bringing payroll, HR, benefits, and advisory services together into a single connected HCM platform. As Paychex and Paycor come together, we're combining innovative technology, data-driven insights, AI, and human expertise to help organizations work smarter, support their people, and achieve better business outcomes. This is an exciting time to join our team as we continue to invest in innovation, simplify client experiences, and shape the future of work. At Paychex, you'll have the opportunity to grow your career, make a meaningful impact, and be part of something bigger as One Paychex.
Overview
Insurance Inside Sales Representatives are responsible for prospecting clients remotely and managing the entire sales cycle from within our Insurance Inside Sales Hub. They engage with customers via phone, email, or other virtual channels to effectively close deals and meet sales targets. This role exclusively sells for the Paychex Insurance Agency Organization.
Responsibilities
  • Accountable for the end-to-end sales cycle from prospecting, qualifying, demonstrating and closing business to achieve quota.
  • Identify client needs and present Paychex solutions to key stakeholders and decision-makers through virtual interactions.
  • Scheduling appointments with referral sources to secure referrals to end users.
  • Conduct outbound prospecting via cold calls, emails, and social engagements, and follow up on marketing leads, to qualify opportunities and generate pipeline.
  • Performs insurance needs analysis for clients to provide solutions to insurance and benefit needs.
  • Use technology tools to accurately track activities and forecasts.
  • Collect data to support underwriting process, close sales.
  • Projecting a positive image in representing the company to clients and the community.
  • Writes and processes sales contracts in a professional manner and by HRS operation guidelines.
  • Continually develop technical, competitive, and sales skills knowledge to effectively represent an Insurance sales organization.
  • May be required to travel for purposes of attending Conference, training sessions, and/or area regional or national meetings
  • **Must be available to work in office in Rochester, NY**

Qualifications
  • H.S. Diploma in Business or related discipline - Required
  • Bachelor's Degree in Business or related discipline - Preferred
  • 2 years of experience in Relevant sales/sales management experience or the equivalent combination of education and experience.
  • This role requires you to be eligible for applicable insurance licensing in all 50 states, which may involve an enhanced background check. If you are not currently licensed, you will be required to obtain the necessary insurance license(s) within 90 calendar days of your official start date. Failure to obtain the required license(s) within 90 days of your start date and to maintain eligibility throughout the duration of your employment may result in corrective action, up to and including termination of employment. Paychex Insurance Agency, Inc. (PIA) will cover the cost of up to two (2) attempts to pass a state insurance licensing exam including exam materials and testing fee. The cost of any additional attempts will be at the expense of the individual employee. If an individual is hired by PIA with an active and current license(s), that employee will be responsible for the timely updating and/or verifying of any changes that may have occurred with their state license(s) prior to their start date at PIA. This includes any state of residence changes, e-mail changes, mailing address changes or name changes. - Required

Compensation
In the spirit of pay transparency, we are excited to share that the compensation range for this position is typically $45,000- $90,000. This range includes BOTH base pay plus commissions but does not consider other components that make up the total rewards package for the position. If you are hired at Paychex, your overall compensation will be determined based on factors such as geographic location, skills, education, and/or experience which may result in total compensation outside of this range.
Live the Paychex Values
  • Act with uncompromising integrity.
  • Provide outstanding service and build trusted relationships.
  • Drive innovation in our products and services and continually improve our processes.
  • Work in partnership and support each other.
  • Be personally accountable and deliver on commitments.
  • Treat each other with respect and dignity.

    • What's in it for you?
    • We value your well-being: We provide over 21 comprehensive rewards, including medical coverage, virtual wellness classes, tuition reimbursement, 401(k) + employer match, adoption assistance, financial assistance, and much more.
    • We value your time: From paid time off to company holidays, culture days, and comprehensive work-life balance programs, we will ensure you have the flexibility you need to be your best.
    • We value your development: Our award-winning training and development programs empower our employees with ongoing learning opportunities to give you the building blocks to grow your career.
    • We value your perspective: Our company culture reflects the diversity of our employees. We want you to be you and your voice to be heard.
    • We value our communities: We offer paid time off for volunteerism and promote many company-wide and local initiatives that benefit organizations you care about.

      • Note: The benefits described apply to full-time employees. Benefits for part-time, contract, and intern roles may vary.
      Not sure if you meet every requirement?
      At Paychex, we know that great talent comes in many forms. If you're passionate about the role but don't check every box, we still encourage you to apply. You might be the right fit - either for this position or another opportunity with us.
      Paychex is an equal opportunity employer. We are committed to fostering a respectful and inclusive workplace where all individuals are treated fairly and evaluated based on their qualifications, experience, and merit. We comply with all applicable federal, state, and local laws prohibiting discrimination in employment.

    What Paychex employees say

    Pay

    Benefits

    Hours and flexibility

    Workplace

    Get the full story on Breakroom

    Paychex logo

    About Paychex

    Sourced by ZipRecruiter

    Consult with America's businesses, leveraging Paychex key referral channels and partnerships to educate stakeholders on our services, and provide consultative solutions to increase market share and drive revenue.

    Industry

    Human resources consulting services

    Company size

    10,000+ Employees

    Headquarters location

    Rochester, NY, US

    Year founded

    1971

    Social media

    FacebookTwitter

    View All Paychex Jobs

    Apply