ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Evening Insurance Sales Jobs in Rochester, NY (NOW HIRING)

LeafHome

LF Sales Rep

Rochester, NY

$100K/yr

If you are a sales PROFESSIONAL ready to be paid for your talents apply now and come join a team of ... insurance offering Schedule: - Flexibility on a weekly basis - Evening and weekend availability ...

Sysco

Sales Representative

Rochester, NY · On-site

$44K - $73K/yr

This position may require working some non-traditional hours (evening, weekends, and holidays) to ... Current automobile insurance with the following limits of liability: Bodily injury - $100,000 each ...

Von Maur

NY SALES ASSOCIATE

Victor, NY · On-site

$16 - $18/hr

Be available to work day, evening, and weekend shifts WHAT YOU CAN EXPECT: We're committed to ... Comprehensive benefits including health, dental, vision, disability, term life insurance and ...

Von Maur

NY SALES ASSOCIATE - SHOES

Victor, NY · On-site

$16 - $18/hr

Be available to work day, evening, and weekend shifts WHAT YOU CAN EXPECT: We're committed to ... Comprehensive benefits including health, dental, vision, disability, term life insurance and ...

Von Maur

NY SALES ASSOCIATE - COSMETICS

Victor, NY · On-site

$16 - $18/hr

Be available to work day, evening, and weekend shifts WHAT YOU CAN EXPECT: We're committed to ... Comprehensive benefits including health, dental, vision, disability, term life insurance and ...

KOHLS

Part-Time Retail Sales Associate

Victor, NY · On-site

$16 - $23.10/hr

Required Evening (5pm to Close) Availability About the Role In this role, you will deliver ... INSURANCE PROGRAMS (Life Insurance for you, your family or your pet, as well as other protection ...

ZOOM TAN INC

Sales Associate

Rochester, NY · On-site

$16.50/hr

Dental, Vision, and Health insurance for full time employees. * 401K with 5% company match. Pay ... Must be flexible and adaptable required to work evening, weekend, and/or holidays as well as work ...

Five Star Bank

Sales & Service Associate

Le Roy, NY · On-site

$17 - $23/hr

Evening hours may also be required based on branch needs. * May involve occasional travel to nearby ... Company-Paid Life Insurance and Disability Coverage * Voluntary Benefits (Life, Critical Illness ...

Five Star Bank

Sales & Service Associate

Victor, NY · On-site

$17 - $23/hr

Evening hours may also be required based on branch needs. * May involve occasional travel to nearby ... Company-Paid Life Insurance and Disability Coverage * Voluntary Benefits (Life, Critical Illness ...

Five Star Bank

Sales & Service Associate

Rochester, NY · On-site

$17 - $23/hr

Evening hours may also be required based on branch needs. * May involve occasional travel to nearby ... Company-Paid Life Insurance and Disability Coverage * Voluntary Benefits (Life, Critical Illness ...

Kohl's

Part-Time Retail Sales Associate

Victor, NY

$16 - $23.10/hr

Role Specific Information Required Evening (5pm to Close) Availability About the Role In this role ... INSURANCE PROGRAMS (Life Insurance for you, your family or your pet, as well as other protection ...

Old Navy

Retail Sales Associate - Eastview

Victor, NY

$16 - $16.50/hr

Agreeable to work a flexible schedule to meet the needs of the business, including holiday, evening ... Medical, dental, vision and life insurance.* * See more of the benefits we offer. *For eligible ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsEvening Insurance Sales JobsEvening Insurance Sales Jobs in Rochester, NY

Evening Insurance Sales information

See Rochester, NY salary details

$27.6K

$45.1K

$63.6K

How much do evening insurance sales jobs pay per year?

As of Jul 28, 2026, the average yearly pay for evening insurance sales in Rochester, NY is $45,053.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $37,500.00 and $50,800.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What jobs pay 4000 a week without a degree?

An evening insurance sales position can potentially pay $4,000 a week through commissions and bonuses, especially for experienced agents with high sales volume. Success in such roles often depends on strong communication skills, product knowledge, and a flexible schedule, with some agents earning high income without a college degree.

What is the difference between Evening Insurance Sales vs Day Insurance Sales?

AspectEvening Insurance SalesDay Insurance Sales
Work HoursPrimarily evenings and weekendsStandard daytime hours, typically 9am-5pm
Work EnvironmentOffice or remote, with flexible hoursOffice-based, regular business hours
Required CredentialsInsurance license, sales experienceInsurance license, sales experience
Industry UsageCommon in retail and direct sales settings

Both Evening Insurance Sales and Day Insurance Sales require similar credentials and industry knowledge. The main difference lies in work hours and environment, with evening roles offering flexibility for those who prefer or need to work outside traditional hours. Understanding these differences can help job seekers choose the schedule that best fits their lifestyle.

What type of insurance sales pays the most?

In insurance sales, selling high-value policies such as life insurance, commercial insurance, or specialized coverage often yields higher commissions and earnings. Experienced agents with strong client networks and certifications tend to earn more, especially when working on complex or large accounts. Compensation can also be influenced by commission structures, sales skills, and the insurer's payout policies.

Why do most insurance agents quit?

Many insurance agents quit due to the high level of rejection, inconsistent income, and the pressure to meet sales targets. The job often requires strong interpersonal skills, self-motivation, and resilience, which can be challenging over time, leading to high turnover rates in the industry.

What's the hardest insurance to sell?

In insurance sales, selling long-term or complex policies like life insurance can be more challenging due to their higher cost and the need for detailed customer education. Products that require significant trust or have lower perceived immediate value often take more effort to close. Success depends on strong communication skills and understanding client needs.
What are the most commonly searched types of Insurance Sales jobs in Rochester, NY? The most popular types of Insurance Sales jobs in Rochester, NY are:
What are popular job titles related to Evening Insurance Sales jobs in Rochester, NY? For Evening Insurance Sales jobs in Rochester, NY, the most frequently searched job titles are:
What job categories do people searching Evening Insurance Sales jobs in Rochester, NY look for? The top searched job categories for Evening Insurance Sales jobs in Rochester, NY are:
What cities near Rochester, NY are hiring for Evening Insurance Sales jobs? Cities near Rochester, NY with the most Evening Insurance Sales job openings:
Evening Insurance Sales jobs near you

LF Sales Rep

LeafHome

Rochester, NY

$100K/yr

Contractor

Posted 24 days ago

Job description

LeafFilter Gutters and Gutterprotection

No cold calling- no sweepstake giveaway- real people confirming your leads.

Are you tired of cold calling looking for new business? Tired of the constant follow up, pay cuts, or unqualified leads? Tired of 3-5 hour meetings? LeafFilter by Leaf Home is North Americas largest direct to consumer entity and the largest home remodeling company in North America. LeafFilter pays the best rates, for less time in the field and less time in the home. If you are a sales PROFESSIONAL ready to be paid for your talents apply now and come join a team of the highest paid and most valued design consultants in home remodeling sales. We consider all applicants from all backgrounds, do not hesitate to apply. Some of our best consultants come from very different backgrounds, we have the training you need if you believe you have the talent!

Were looking for motivated sales professionals to join our highly successful sales force in the growing,home improvement industry. Our Design Consultants go to pre-scheduled appointments in residential homes and conduct sales presentations. They provide all of the necessary information for homeowners to make a same-day decision on their gutter protection needs.

Primary Responsibilities:

- Travel to and from your residence to company-generated, pre-qualified appointments with homeowners

- Perform product demonstrations and discuss custom quotes during in-home consultations

- Follow a value-based selling process embodying honesty and integrity

- Attend trainings and regular sales meetings

- Other duties as assigned

Qualifications:

- Hold a valid drivers license (required)

- Comfortable traveling up to 2 hours for appointments on a daily basis (required)

- Ability to lift and carry at least 20-60 lbs. of sample materials (required)

- Capable of navigating various applications on an iPad (required)

- Previous outside sales experience is not a requirement

- Willingness to learn a structured and proven sales process

- A strong desire and ability to close the sale

Compensation:

- Uncapped, full commission structure with current consultants earning $80,000-$220,000 plus.

- Performance-based bonus opportunities

- ICBA Contractors insurance offering

Schedule:

- Flexibility on a weekly basis

- Evening and weekend availability (required)

Job Type: Full-time

Compensation package:

  • Bonus opportunities
  • Commission only
  • Commission pay
  • Uncapped commission

Schedule:

  • Day shift
  • Evening shift
  • Monday to Saturday as needed