1

Insurance Program Manager Jobs in Cincinnati, OH

The Program Manager ensures the successful delivery of high-quality services by providing ... Auto Insurance * Successfully complete the following as a condition of hire: * Background Screening

The Program Manager ensures the successful delivery of high-quality services by providing ... Auto Insurance * Successfully complete the following as a condition of hire: * Background Screening

The Program Manager ensures the successful delivery of high-quality services by providing ... Auto Insurance * Successfully complete the following as a condition of hire: * Background Screening

Senior Program Manager, Operations

Cincinnati, OH · On-site

$111K - $111K/yr

Senior Program Manager, Operations - Blue Ash, OH This Senior Program Manager, Operations will lead ... Life Insurance - Term life coverage with the option to purchase supplemental coverage

next page

Showing results 1-20

Insurance Program Manager information

See Cincinnati, OH salary details

$36.9K

$103.1K

$150.6K

How much do insurance program manager jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 24, 2026, the average yearly pay for insurance program manager in Cincinnati, OH is $103,106.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $76,300.00 and $127,100.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What does an insurance program manager do?

An Insurance Program Manager is responsible for overseeing and coordinating insurance programs within an organization. They develop, implement, and monitor policies and procedures to ensure that insurance coverage meets the company's needs and complies with regulations. Their duties often include managing relationships with insurance carriers, analyzing risk, handling claims, and ensuring cost-effective coverage. They also provide guidance and education to staff about insurance plans and policies.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an insurance program manager?

To thrive as an Insurance Program Manager, you need expertise in insurance products, risk assessment, and program management, typically supported by a bachelor's degree in business, finance, or a related field. Familiarity with insurance management software, regulatory compliance systems, and project management tools is often required, and certifications like CPCU or ARM are advantageous. Exceptional leadership, analytical thinking, and strong communication skills set top performers apart in this role. These skills and qualifications are crucial to effectively oversee insurance programs, ensure compliance, minimize risk, and deliver value to clients and stakeholders.

What are some common challenges faced by insurance program managers, and how can they be addressed?

Insurance Program Managers often encounter challenges such as balancing regulatory compliance with client needs, coordinating between multiple stakeholders, and adapting to changes in industry regulations. To address these, it is important to stay current with regulatory updates, foster strong communication channels among internal teams and external partners, and develop robust project management practices. Building relationships with underwriters, brokers, and clients can also help streamline processes and resolve issues efficiently.

What is the difference between Insurance Program Manager vs Insurance Underwriter?

AspectInsurance Program ManagerInsurance Underwriter
CredentialsTypically requires a bachelor’s degree in business, finance, or related field; professional certifications like CPCU or ARM are commonRequires a bachelor’s degree in finance, economics, or related field; certifications like CPCU or AINS are often preferred
Work EnvironmentManages insurance programs, collaborates with teams, and oversees policy developmentEvaluates risks, reviews applications, and determines policy terms and pricing
Employer & Industry UsageUsed in insurance companies, brokers, and agencies for program oversightFound in insurance companies, underwriting firms, and brokers for risk assessment

The Insurance Program Manager focuses on managing and coordinating insurance programs, ensuring they meet business goals. In contrast, the Insurance Underwriter evaluates individual risks to determine policy terms. Both roles require similar credentials and are integral to the insurance industry, but they differ in daily responsibilities and focus areas.

What are popular job titles related to Insurance Program Manager jobs in Cincinnati, OH?

For Insurance Program Manager jobs in Cincinnati, OH, the most frequently searched job titles are:

What job categories do people searching Insurance Program Manager jobs in Cincinnati, OH look for?

The top searched job categories for Insurance Program Manager jobs in Cincinnati, OH are:

What cities near Cincinnati, OH are hiring for Insurance Program Manager jobs?

Cities near Cincinnati, OH with the most Insurance Program Manager job openings:

Infographic showing various Insurance Program Manager job openings in Cincinnati, OH as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 74% Full Time, 20% Part Time, and 5% Contract. Highlights an 87% Physical, 1% Hybrid, and 12% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $103,106 per year, or $49.6 per hour.

Program Manager

Cincinnati, OH • On-site

Full-time

Re-posted 23 days ago


Job description

WHAT WE DO
Since its foundation in Best Behavioral Health has pioneered bold and effective approaches to assist people experiencing behavioral health concerns. We operate services throughout Southern Ohio, connecting our clients to a comprehensive continuum of homelessness prevention, street outreach, behavioral health counseling, employment preparation and placement assistance, individualized case management, supportive services etc.

Our programs provide person-centered, culturally competent supportive services to clients who have a history of chronic mental health, and/or co-occurring conditions.

WHAT IS A PROGRAM MANAGER?
The Program Manager ensures the successful delivery of high-quality services by providing administrative oversight and supervisory leadership to the program staff through a hands-on, lead by example approach. Responsibilities of the Program Manager include:


Supportive Services

  • Carrying a small caseload of more challenging and complex clients
  • Providing field-based case management and service coordination services designed to assist clients


Service Supervision

  • Overseeing day-to-day service delivery by providing direct supervision to program staff, facilitating case consultation, guiding delivery, and providing support with complex or challenging issues
  • Ensuring the development and implementation of a team-based approach to service delivery that incorporates evidence-based practices, leverages the strengths of individuals and the group as a whole, and fosters professional growth
  • Monitoring and verifying services provided to each client to determine quality and effectiveness of services
  • Acting as the primary point of contact to address client-level and structural problems as they arise
  • Conducting supervisory meetings and providing regular feedback, guidance and training to case management staff
  • Recruiting, hiring and training new staff as needed
  • Fundraising
  • Office management
  • Additional duties as assigned


Program Development & Implementation

  • Implement policies, procedures and practices that ensure the delivery of quality services that are in compliance with contractual obligations and agency standards.
  • Coordinating services with partner agencies including the creation of written documentation that accurately reflects partnerships


Program Administration & Compliance

  • Ensuring that all documentation standards set forth by the program contract and polices are maintained through monitoring and regular audits
  • Reviewing client service plans to ensure that services are appropriate, documentation is accurate and complete, and that all standards have been adhered to
  • Generating regular reporting, assessing outcomes, and analyzing and communicating observed trends or needs that may impact services


WHAT YOU BRING
We're looking for candidates that:

  • Display excellent leadership skills with a hands-on, lead-by-example approach
  • Have experience in case management, mental health and community resources
  • Demonstrate knowledge and understanding of evidence-based practices in service delivery such as intensive case management, motivational interviewing, harm reduction, critical time intervention and housing first
  • Demonstrate strong interpersonal skills and the ability work in a variety of settings with a diverse range of individuals in a culturally sensitive and appropriate manner
  • Maintain and execute confidential information according to HIPAA standards
  • Possess a high level of tolerance and understanding for individuals with urgent and multiple case management and health needs
  • Work just as well independently as they do on a team
  • Exercise mature judgement, and are highly motivated, self-starting and proactive
  • Are excellent at communicating, whether in writing or verbally
  • Have a strong sense of prioritization and can coordinate multiple demands in a high-pressure environment
  • LPCC/LPC/LISW or LSW strongly preferred


MANDATORY REQUIREMENTS
For this role the Program Manager must:

  • Have at least 2 years of experience in a leadership role in social services or related field
  • Be able and willing to work flexible hours which may include evenings or weekends
  • Have or be able and willing to obtain CPR/First Aid training
  • Have reliable transportation and:
  • A valid driver's license
  • Auto Insurance
  • Successfully complete the following as a condition of hire:
  • Background Screening
  • Education verification