ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Evening Insurance Jobs (NOW HIRING)

Pumpkin

Licensed Insurance Agent- Evening Shift

We have insured over 230,000 pets and paid more than $176 million in claims since launch. Pumpkin also offers PumpkinNow, the only urgent pay service that can pay pet parents for eligible claims ...

Homma Talent

Evening Manager

Saint Helena, CA · On-site

$74K/yr

As the Evening Manager, you will lead the effort to manage any "glitches" that need to be ... Health insurance, Vision insurance, Dental insurance * 401(k) matching * Employee discounts

Insurance Way Agency

Be Seen First

Medicare Insurance Agent

Boca Raton, FL · On-site

$52K - $250K/yr

Schedule Monday - Friday: 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM Additional evening hours and weekends are required ... Qualifications Active Health & Life Insurance License (required). AHIP certification (or ability to ...

Posted today

Insurance Way Agency

Be Seen First

Medicare Insurance Agent

Boca Raton, FL · On-site

$52K - $250K/yr

Schedule Monday - Friday: 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM Additional evening hours and weekends are required ... Qualifications Active Health & Life Insurance License (required). AHIP certification (or ability to ...

Posted today

next page

Showing results 1-20

All Jobsevening JobsFinance and Insurance JobsEvening Insurance Jobs

Evening Insurance information

See salary details

$31K

$58.2K

$86.5K

How much do evening insurance jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 28, 2026, the average yearly pay for evening insurance in the United States is $58,198.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $48,000.00 and $66,500.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is the difference between Evening Insurance vs Evening Claims Adjuster?

AspectEvening InsuranceEvening Claims Adjuster
Required CredentialsInsurance license, relevant certificationsInsurance license, claims handling certifications
Work EnvironmentOffice or remote, primarily during business hours, with evening shiftsField or office-based, handling claims during evening hours
Employer & Industry UsageInsurance companies, brokers, agenciesInsurance companies, third-party claims firms
Common Search & ComparisonInsurance roles with evening shiftsClaims adjustment roles in the evening

Both roles involve working within the insurance industry, often requiring similar licenses and certifications. The main difference is that Evening Insurance typically refers to roles in insurance sales or customer service during evening hours, while Evening Claims Adjuster focuses on evaluating and settling claims during evening shifts. Understanding these distinctions helps job seekers find the right position based on their skills and career goals.

What cities are hiring for Evening Insurance jobs?

Cities with the most Evening Insurance job openings:

What are the most commonly searched types of Insurance jobs?

The most popular types of Insurance jobs are:

What states have the most Evening Insurance jobs?

States with the most job openings for Evening Insurance jobs include:

Evening Insurance jobs near you

Licensed Insurance Agent- Evening Shift

Independence Pet Group

Remote

Full-time

Medical, Dental, Vision, Life, Retirement, PTO

Posted 8 days ago

Job description

Established in 2021, Independence Pet Holdings is a corporate holding company that manages a diverse and broad portfolio of modern pet health brands and services, including insurance, pet education, lost recovery services, and more throughout North America.
We believe pet insurance is more than a financial product and build solutions to simplify the pet parenting journey and help improve the well-being of pets. As a leading authority in the pet category, we operate with a full stack of resources, capital, and services to support pet parents. Our multi-brand and omni-channel approach include our own insurance carrier, insurance brands and partner brands.
Job Summary:
Pumpkin is seeking an Insurance Agent who will report to the Supervisor, Customer Care. This friendly and motivated individual will be responsible for researching and responding to insurance and non-insurance customer service inquiries over phone, email, text, chat, and social media. The Insurance Agent will also play a key role in processing new customer enrollments, claims and fulfillment tasks. The ideal candidate is friendly, motivated, and always looking for new ways to provide an exceptional experience. The shift for this role will be 12:00-8:30pm EST.
Job Location: Remote - United States
Main Responsibilities:
  • Provide exceptional customer care to customers across multiple communication channels like phone, email, text, chat and social, in a timely and efficient manner

  • Uses problem-solving skills to solve customer issues, rectify poor experiences, and maintain positive relationships with customers

  • Understand company policies to ensure all claims and policies are compliant and/or know when to make an exception

  • Answer customer questions and provide insurance and non-insurance related information

  • Educate customers on our full product offerings and take the initiative to help them buy additional coverage

  • Process new customer enrollments, incoming claims, and ongoing fulfillment tasks in accordance with company policies

  • Use ticketing software, back office software, and other digital tools to manage and track performance

  • Data entry for the above tasks

  • Other duties as assigned

Basic Qualifications:
  • Prior experience in customer service role involving a high degree of customer interface

  • Experience with ticketing software (Zendesk, Kustomer, Gladly, etc.)

  • Roll-up-your-sleeves mentality - does what it takes to get the job done

  • Excellent verbal and written skills

  • Administrative and computer skills

  • Great attention to detail with every task

  • Entrepreneurial interest and a passion for pets

  • Existing Property & Casualty Insurance License

All of our jobs come with great benefits including healthcare, parental leave and opportunities for career advancements. Some offerings are dependent upon the location of where you work and can include the following:
  • Comprehensive full medical, dental and vision Insurance
  • Basic Life Insurance at no cost to the employee
  • Company paid short-term and long-term disability
  • 12 weeks of 100% paid Parental Leave
  • Health Savings Account (HSA)
  • Flexible Spending Accounts (FSA)
  • Retirement savings plan
  • Personal Paid Time Off
  • Paid holidays and company-wide Wellness Day off
  • Paid time off to volunteer at nonprofit organizations
  • Pet friendly office environment
  • Commuter Benefits
  • Group Pet Insurance
  • On the job training and skills development
  • Employee Assistance Program (EAP)

Interview Technology Notice:
Please note that phone and video interviews or screenings may be recorded and transcribed using interview technology to support our recruitment process.
By continuing with the interview, you consent to this use.
Text Messaging Notice:
If you provide a mobile phone number, you may receive job-related communications via text message. Message and data rates may apply.
You may opt out of text communications at any time by replying "STOP."

Apply