1

Arbitration Jobs in Wisconsin (NOW HIRING)

Arbitrator I (Manheim)

Caledonia, WI · On-site

$18.22 - $27.36/hr

Reviews customer claims to verify that they meet Manheim's National Arbitration policies and any account-specific guidelines. * Investigates basic, less complex cases (e.g., late title claims, basic ...

$80 - $100/hr

Arbitration * Restorative Practices * Conflict coaching * Organizational consulting * Employee relations * Higher education administration * Organizational development Preferred Qualifications ...

By clicking Apply Now, I agree Privacy Policy and Terms of Use including arbitration, waivers and limitations of liability. Message and data charges may apply. You may revoke consent at any time. See ...

By clicking Apply Now, I agree Privacy Policy and Terms of Use including arbitration, waivers and limitations of liability. Message and data charges may apply. You may revoke consent at any time. See ...

By clicking Apply Now, I agree Privacy Policy and Terms of Use including arbitration, waivers and limitations of liability. Message and data charges may apply. You may revoke consent at any time. See ...

By clicking Apply Now, I agree Privacy Policy and Terms of Use including arbitration, waivers and limitations of liability. Message and data charges may apply. You may revoke consent at any time. See ...

By clicking Apply Now, I agree Privacy Policy and Terms of Use including arbitration, waivers and limitations of liability. Message and data charges may apply. You may revoke consent at any time. See ...

By clicking Apply Now, I agree Privacy Policy and Terms of Use including arbitration, waivers and limitations of liability. Message and data charges may apply. You may revoke consent at any time. See ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

Arbitration information

See Wisconsin salary details

$10

$24

$43

How much do arbitration jobs pay per hour?

As of Aug 9, 2026, the average hourly pay for arbitration in Wisconsin is $24.48, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $16.01 and $30.10 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is the difference between Arbitration vs Mediator?

AspectArbitrationMediator
RoleDecides disputes by rendering a binding or non-binding decisionFacilitates negotiation between parties to reach a mutual agreement
CredentialsOften requires legal or specialized training, certifications vary by jurisdictionTypically trained in conflict resolution or mediation techniques, certification preferred
Work EnvironmentPrivate, often in legal or corporate settingsNeutral setting, may be in offices or online
UsageUsed in legal disputes, contractual disagreements, industry-specific conflictsUsed to resolve disputes informally, encourage communication

While arbitration involves a neutral arbitrator making a binding or non-binding decision to resolve disputes, mediators facilitate discussions to help parties reach a voluntary agreement. Both roles require specialized skills and are used in different dispute resolution contexts within legal and corporate environments.

What are some common challenges faced by professionals working in arbitration, and how can they be effectively managed?

Professionals in arbitration often encounter challenges such as managing complex multi-party disputes, strict confidentiality requirements, and tight procedural timelines. Navigating differing legal systems and ensuring impartiality can also be demanding, especially in international cases. Effective management involves strong organizational skills, clear communication with all parties, and staying updated on evolving arbitration rules and best practices. Collaborating closely with legal teams and maintaining transparency helps ensure a fair and efficient process.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an arbitrator?

To thrive as an Arbitrator, you need a solid understanding of dispute resolution, legal principles, and often a background in law or a relevant industry. Familiarity with arbitration rules (such as those of the AAA or ICC), case management systems, and sometimes professional certifications like those from the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (CIArb) are commonly required. Strong analytical thinking, impartiality, and excellent communication are essential soft skills for effectively managing proceedings and building trust between parties. These skills are crucial to ensure fair, efficient, and respected resolutions in complex legal or commercial disputes.

Do arbitrators make a lot of money?

Arbitrators' salaries vary based on experience, industry, and the complexity of cases they handle. Typically, they earn between $50,000 and $150,000 annually, with experienced professionals or those working in specialized fields earning higher incomes. Many arbitrators work as independent contractors or consultants, which can influence their earnings.

Is being an arbitrator a good career?

Being an arbitrator is a specialized legal role that involves resolving disputes outside of court through arbitration processes. It requires strong communication, negotiation skills, and often certification or training in arbitration procedures. The career can be stable and well-paying, especially with experience and expertise in specific industries or legal areas.

What is arbitration?

Arbitration is a form of alternative dispute resolution where a neutral third party, known as an arbitrator, hears both sides of a dispute and makes a binding or non-binding decision. It is often used as an alternative to court litigation because it can be faster, more private, and less formal. Arbitration is commonly used in commercial, labor, and consumer disputes, and the process is governed by the rules agreed upon by the parties or set by an arbitration institution. The arbitrator’s decision, called an award, is usually final and enforceable by law. This method is especially valued for its confidentiality and efficiency.
What are the most commonly searched types of Arbitration jobs in Wisconsin? The most popular types of Arbitration jobs in Wisconsin are:
What are popular job titles related to Arbitration jobs in Wisconsin? For Arbitration jobs in Wisconsin, the most frequently searched job titles are:
Infographic showing various Arbitration job openings in Wisconsin as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 100% Full Time. Highlights an 67% In-person, and 33% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $50,927 per year, or $24.5 per hour.

$18.22 - $27.36/hr

Full-time

Medical, Dental, Vision, Retirement, PTO

Re-posted 21 days ago


Cox Communications rating

8.3

Company rating: 8.3 out of 10

Based on 127 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

18th of 97 rated telecommunications companies


Job description

Company

Cox Automotive - USA

Job Family Group

Vehicle Operations

Job Profile

Arbitrator I

Management Level

Individual Contributor

Flexible Work Option 

Hybrid - Ability to work remotely part of the week

Travel %

No

Work Shift

Day

Compensation

Hourly base pay rate is $18.22 - $27.36/hour. The hourly base rate may vary within the anticipated range based on factors such as the ultimate location of the position and the selected candidate's knowledge, skills, and abilities. Position may be eligible for additional compensation that may include commission (annual, monthly, etc.) and/or an incentive program.

Job Description

Hybrid Role: Ideal candidates will reside within 15 miles of Manheim Chicago, IL or Caledonia, WI.

At Manheim (a Cox Automotive company), we strive to make sure every customer is completely satisfied when they do business with us. On the off chance we fall short, we do our best to make things right, pronto.

That's where you come in.

We're looking for an Auto Claims Specialist I to learn the ropes of resolving customer complaints and ensuring we don't make the same mistake again. Do you have the skills we're looking for? Keep reading for more details!

Benefits:

  • We all have lives and responsibilities outside of work. We have an exceptional work/life balance at Cox, with flexible time-off policies.

  • We show our appreciation for our talent with a competitive salary package and top-notch bonus & incentive plans.

  • How does a great healthcare benefits package from day one sound? Multiple options are available for individuals and families. One employee-only plan could be FREE, if you participate in our health screening program.

  • 10 days of free child or senior care through your complimentary Care.com membership.

  • Generous 401(k) retirement plans with up to 6% company match.

  • Employee discounts on hundreds of items, from cars to computers to continuing education.

  • Looking to grow your family? You'll have access to our inclusive parental leave policies, plus comprehensive fertility coverage and adoption assistance.

  • Want to volunteer in your community? We encourage that and even offer paid hours for you to do so.

  • We all love our pets-whether they walk, crawl, fly, swim or slither-and we're happy to supply insurance for them as well.

At Cox, we believe in being transparent - please click on this link (Cox Benefits Overview) to learn more about our amazing benefits.

What You'll Do:

From your very first day on the job, you'll receive guidance and coaching so you can learn the ropes. You'll work with everyone from buyers to sellers to dealers in coordinating and validating customer returns and claims. With Guidance, responsibilities include:

  • Reviews customer claims to verify that they meet Manheim's National Arbitration policies and any account-specific guidelines.

  • Investigates basic, less complex cases (e.g., late title claims, basic condition report claims, vehicle availability, post-sale inspection fails, mechanical/structural/undisclosed vehicle damage, etc.) or those requiring more prescriptive decision-making.

  • Interfaces with all departments involved in the complaint (i.e., reconditioning, front office, dealer services, vehicle entry, etc.), including during the fact finding and investigative phases.

  • Uses appropriate resources to investigate and facilitate relevant inspection, documentation, and communication to ensure appropriate actions are completed to move cases forward or to resolution.

  • Uses appropriate levels/limits of financial approval authority to resolve cases.

  • Evaluate claims by obtaining, comparing, evaluating, and validating various forms of information.

  • Prepares and facilitates communication for resolution via telephone, email, and in-person discussion.

  • Mediates disputes and negotiates repair and/or pricing of disputed vehicles to arrive at a mutually acceptable solution and to keep vehicles sold.

  • Monitors and maintains accurate files for each arbitration case, verifying the accuracy of all required documentation, including invoices and settlement agreements.

  • Engages with supervisor/manager to determine if escalation is required.

  • Performs other duties as assigned.

Who You Are:

  • You've got a knack for negotiation. You're ethical, dependable, and trustworthy. You're eager to learn. You also have the following qualifications:

Minimum:

  • High School Diploma/GED

  • Generally, less than 2 years of experience.

  • Accuracy and attention to detail.

  • Organizational and time management skills.

  • The ability to adapt in a fluid and changing environment.

Preferred:

  • 1+ years of automotive or body shop experience.

  • Claims adjuster experience.

Cox is a great place to be, wouldn't you agree? Apply today!

Drug Testing

To be employed in this role, you'll need to clear a pre-employment drug test. Cox Automotive does not currently administer a pre-employment drug test for marijuana for this position. However, we are a drug-free workplace, so the possession, use or being under the influence of drugs illegal under federal or state law during work hours, on company property and/or in company vehicles is prohibited.

Benefits

Employees are eligible to receive a minimum of sixteen hours of paid time off every month and seven paid holidays throughout the calendar year. Employees are also eligible for additional paid time off in the form of bereavement leave, time off to vote, jury duty leave, volunteer time off, military leave, and parental leave.

About Us

Through groundbreaking technology and a commitment to stellar experiences for drivers and dealers alike, Cox Automotive employees are transforming the way the world buys, owns, sells - or simply uses - cars. Cox Automotive employees get to work on iconic consumer brands like Autotrader and Kelley Blue Book and industry-leading dealer-facing companies like vAuto and Manheim, all while enjoying the people-centered atmosphere that is central to our life at Cox. Benefits of working at Cox may include health care insurance (medical, dental, vision), retirement planning (401(k)), and paid days off (sick leave, parental leave, flexible vacation/wellness days, and/or PTO). For more details on what benefits you may be offered, visit our benefits page. Cox is an Equal Employment Opportunity employer - All qualified applicants/employees will receive consideration for employment without regard to that individual's age, race, color, religion or creed, national origin or ancestry, sex (including pregnancy), sexual orientation, gender, gender identity, physical or mental disability, veteran status, genetic information, ethnicity, citizenship, or any other characteristic protected by law. Cox provides reasonable accommodations when requested by a qualified applicant or employee with disability, unless such accommodations would cause an undue hardship.EOE, including disability/vetsApplicants must currently be authorized to work in the United States for any employer without current or future sponsorship. No OPT, CPT, STEM/OPT or visa sponsorship now or in future.




What Cox Communications employees say

Pay

Benefits

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom


Cox Communications logo

About Cox Communications

Sourced by ZipRecruiter

Cox Communications is the largest private telecom company in America, serving six million homes and businesses. That's a lot, but we also proudly serve our employees. Our benefits and our award-winning culture are just two of the things that make Cox a coveted place to work. If you're interested in bringing people closer through broadband, smart home tech and more, join Cox Communications today! Cox empowers employees to build a better future and has been doing so for over 120 years. With exciting investments and innovations across transportation, communications, cleantech and healthcare, our family of businesses - which includes Cox Automotive and Cox Communications - is forging a better future for us all. Ready to make your mark?

Industry

Media and telecom

Company size

10,000+ Employees

Headquarters location

Atlanta, GA, US