ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Teller Supervisor Jobs in Indiana (NOW HIRING)

First Financial Bank NA

Teller Supervisor

Terre Haute, IN · On-site

$20.50 - $27.75/hr

Teller Supervisor Location: Terre Haute-Main IN (On-Site) Status: Full-Time, Hourly Non-Exempt Why Join First Financial Bank? If you are a dependable, customer-focused leader with strong cash ...

New

Security Federal Savings Bank

Teller

Logansport, IN · On-site

$14.75 - $18.50/hr

Teller Duties * Responsible for maintaining teller cash drawer following bank's procedures ... Performs other duties as directed by supervisor Requirements * High school diploma or equivalent

Security Federal Savings Bank

Teller

Logansport, IN

$14.75 - $18.50/hr

Teller Duties * Responsible for maintaining teller cash drawer following bank's procedures ... Performs other duties as directed by supervisor Requirements * High school diploma or equivalent

F&M Bank

Teller

Berne, IN · On-site

$13.75 - $17.25/hr

At F&M, our bank tellers do more than handle money; they establish and nurture lasting ... supervisor about anticipated time off or modifications to break times.

Home Bank SB

Teller

Greenwood, IN · On-site

$15.25 - $19/hr

Regulates automated teller machines and night depository * Balances cash drawer at the end of the ... SUPERVISORY RESPONSIBILITIES This position does not require supervisory responsibilities. WORK ...

Home Bank SB

Teller

Plainfield, IN · On-site

$15.75 - $19.50/hr

Regulates automated teller machines and night depository * Balances cash drawer at the end of the ... SUPERVISORY RESPONSIBILITIES This position does not require supervisory responsibilities. WORK ...

Security Federal Savings Bank

Teller (Float)

Delphi, IN · On-site

$15.50 - $19.50/hr

Teller Duties * Responsible for maintaining teller cash drawer following bank's procedures ... Performs other duties as directed by supervisor Requirements * High school diploma or equivalent

Home Bank SB

Teller

Martinsville, IN · On-site

$14.50 - $18.25/hr

Regulates automated teller machines and night depository * Balances cash drawer at the end of the ... SUPERVISORY RESPONSIBILITIES This position does not require supervisory responsibilities. WORK ...

Security Federal Savings Bank

Teller (Float)

Delphi, IN

$15.50 - $19.50/hr

Teller Duties * Responsible for maintaining teller cash drawer following bank's procedures ... Performs other duties as directed by supervisor Requirements * High school diploma or equivalent

Home Bank SB

Teller

Greenwood, IN · On-site

$15.25 - $19/hr

Regulates automated teller machines and night depository * Balances cash drawer at the end of the ... SUPERVISORY RESPONSIBILITIES This position does not require supervisory responsibilities. WORK ...

Home Bank SB

Teller

Plainfield, IN · On-site

$15.75 - $19.50/hr

Regulates automated teller machines and night depository * Balances cash drawer at the end of the ... SUPERVISORY RESPONSIBILITIES This position does not require supervisory responsibilities. WORK ...

Home Bank SB

Teller

Martinsville, IN · On-site

$14.50 - $18.25/hr

Regulates automated teller machines and night depository * Balances cash drawer at the end of the ... SUPERVISORY RESPONSIBILITIES This position does not require supervisory responsibilities. WORK ...

Home Bank SB

Part-Time Teller

Martinsville, IN · On-site

$14.50 - $18.25/hr

Regulates automated teller machines and night depository * Balances cash drawer at the end of the ... SUPERVISORY RESPONSIBILITIES This position does not require supervisory responsibilities. WORK ...

Home Bank SB

Part-Time Teller

Martinsville, IN · On-site

$14.50 - $18.25/hr

Regulates automated teller machines and night depository * Balances cash drawer at the end of the ... SUPERVISORY RESPONSIBILITIES This position does not require supervisory responsibilities. WORK ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsTeller Supervisor JobsTeller Supervisor Jobs in Indiana

Teller Supervisor information

See Indiana salary details

$14

$23

$30

How much do teller supervisor jobs pay per hour?

As of Sep 7, 2026, the average hourly pay for teller supervisor in Indiana is $23.06, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $19.66 and $26.78 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is a teller supervisor?

Teller Supervisors are banking professionals who oversee the daily operations of a bank’s teller line. They are responsible for supervising teller staff, ensuring customer service standards are met, and maintaining compliance with banking regulations. Teller Supervisors also handle complex transactions, resolve customer issues, and assist with training new tellers. Their role is crucial for maintaining efficient and accurate financial services within a branch.

What skills and qualifications are needed to be a teller supervisor?

To thrive as a Teller Supervisor, you need strong cash handling abilities, leadership experience, and a background in finance or banking, often supported by a high school diploma or associate degree. Familiarity with banking software, transaction processing systems, and compliance procedures is typically required. Excellent customer service skills, attention to detail, and the ability to motivate and train team members set outstanding supervisors apart. These skills and qualities are vital for ensuring efficient branch operations, regulatory compliance, and a positive customer experience.

What challenges do teller supervisors face when managing a team, and how can they be addressed?

Teller Supervisors often encounter challenges such as balancing customer service expectations with operational accuracy, ensuring team members adhere to compliance standards, and addressing performance inconsistencies among staff. Effective communication and ongoing training are key to overcoming these issues. By fostering a supportive environment, setting clear expectations, and providing regular feedback, Teller Supervisors can help their teams perform efficiently while minimizing errors and maintaining high service standards.

What is the difference between Teller Supervisor vs Teller?

AspectTeller SupervisorTeller
CredentialsHigh school diploma; some roles may prefer experience in banking or cash handlingHigh school diploma or equivalent; entry-level position
Work EnvironmentBank branch, overseeing tellers and customer transactionsBank branch, handling customer transactions directly
ResponsibilitiesSupervises tellers, ensures compliance, handles escalationsProcesses deposits, withdrawals, and customer inquiries

The main difference between a Teller Supervisor and a Teller is the level of responsibility. The Teller Supervisor oversees tellers' daily operations and ensures customer service quality, while the Teller focuses on processing transactions. Both roles require similar credentials and work in the same environment, but the supervisor has additional leadership duties.

What are the most commonly searched types of Teller Supervisor jobs in Indiana?

The most popular types of Teller Supervisor jobs in Indiana are:

What are popular job titles related to Teller Supervisor jobs in Indiana?

For Teller Supervisor jobs in Indiana, the most frequently searched job titles are:

What job categories do people searching Teller Supervisor jobs in Indiana look for?

The top searched job categories for Teller Supervisor jobs in Indiana are:

What are popular job titles related to Teller Supervisor jobs in IN?

For Teller Supervisor jobs in IN, the most frequently searched job titles are:

Teller Supervisor jobs near you
Infographic showing various Teller Supervisor job openings in Indiana as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 76% Full Time, 19% Part Time, 1% Temporary, 2% Contract, and 1% Nights. Highlights an 97% Physical, 1% Hybrid, and 2% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $47,958 per year, or $23.1 per hour.

Assistant Teller Supervisor

Indiana Members Credit Union

Westfield, IN • On-site

$19 - $20/hr

Full-time

Posted 4 days ago

Indiana Members Credit Union rating

5.3

Company rating: 5.3 out of 10

Based on 6 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

Job description


Summary/objective 

Assist Teller Supervisor in all functions of the branch including answering teller questions.  Ensure the branch is in balance daily and train staff on all policies and procedures (new or changed).  Ascertain the branch is secure when leaving for the day.


RESPONSIBILITIES AND DUTIES

  • Assist with supervising tellers, informing and training staff on new products, procedures and policies
  • Ensure all tellers, branch and vault are in balance daily
  • Assist employees with problem solving and questions
  • Supply cash for tellers (order and detail Brinks)
  • Process various member transactions 
  • Access and update safe deposit box records when applicable
  • Handle and maintain security of large amounts of cash, including balancing and supplying ATM & cash dispensers
  • Communicate with branch manager, supervisor, branch staff and all back-office departments for assistance and member requests
  • Open and close various types of accounts, certificates, etc.
  • Process and create/order ATM/Debit cards for members 
  • Process stop payments, print statements and histories for members.
  • Remote capture of checks
  • Scan documents
  • Balance and sell gift cards
  • Order branch supplies
  • Assist with night deposits, ATM deposits, wire transfers, large currency reports, deceased members, and irate members
  • Assist with open/close of branch
  • Assist with pool teller evaluations, log of bait money, reports from imaging system
  • Make sure lobby is stocked and counters and machines are kept clean
  • Attend credit union meetings and training as scheduled

EDUCATION AND EXPERIENCE

  • High school diploma, GED or equivalent
  • 6 - 12-months of supervisor and/or financial institution experience
  • Completion of internal Teller Supervisor and other required training programs 



What Indiana Members Credit Union employees say

Pay

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom