ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Property Claims Supervisor Jobs (NOW HIRING)

The Hankey Group

Claims Supervisor

Los Angeles, CA

$75K - $98K/yr

As a Claims Supervisor at Knight Insurance Group, you will manage and lead a team of Personal Auto ... Minimum of 5 years of experience in claims handling of bodily injury and property damage claims ...

Hankey Group External

Claims Supervisor

Los Angeles, CA · On-site

$75K - $98K/yr

As a Claims Supervisor at Knight Insurance Group, you will manage and lead a team of Personal Auto ... Minimum of 5 years of experience in claims handling of bodily injury and property damage claims ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsProperty Claims Supervisor Jobs

Property Claims Supervisor information

See salary details

$35K

$87.9K

$139K

How much do property claims supervisor jobs pay per year?

As of Jun 13, 2026, the average yearly pay for property claims supervisor in the United States is $87,861.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $68,000.00 and $105,000.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is a Property Claims Supervisor job?

A Property Claims Supervisor oversees the claims process for property-related insurance claims, ensuring accurate assessments and timely resolutions. They manage a team of adjusters, provide guidance on complex claims, and ensure compliance with company policies and industry regulations. Their role involves reviewing claims, negotiating settlements, and improving efficiency in the claims-handling process. Additionally, they may interact with policyholders, contractors, and legal professionals to facilitate fair and effective claim resolutions.

What are the typical challenges faced by Property Claims Supervisors, and how does the role address them?

Property Claims Supervisors frequently navigate challenges such as managing high claim volumes, ensuring timely resolutions, and balancing the needs of both customers and the organization. They must monitor claim quality, support adjusters with complex cases, and handle escalated issues, often under tight deadlines. Successful supervisors use strong leadership and analytical skills to prioritize workloads, coach team members, and foster an environment focused on customer service excellence. By efficiently addressing these challenges, supervisors play a key role in mitigating risk, enhancing team performance, and maintaining organizational reputation.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive in the Property Claims Supervisor position, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Property Claims Supervisor, a strong background in property insurance claims, leadership experience, and knowledge of industry regulations are essential, often supported by a bachelor's degree or relevant certifications. Familiarity with claims management software, estimating tools such as Xactimate, and compliance systems is typically required. Outstanding organizational, problem-solving, and communication skills help supervisors effectively manage teams and support policyholders. These capabilities are important to ensure timely, accurate claim resolutions and maintain high customer satisfaction in a complex and fast-paced environment.

More about Property Claims Supervisor jobs
What cities are hiring for Property Claims Supervisor jobs? Cities with the most Property Claims Supervisor job openings:
What are the most commonly searched types of Property Claims Supervisor jobs? The most popular types of Property Claims Supervisor jobs are:
What states have the most Property Claims Supervisor jobs? States with the most job openings for Property Claims Supervisor jobs include:
What job categories do people searching Property Claims Supervisor jobs look for? The top searched job categories for Property Claims Supervisor jobs are:
Property Claims Supervisor jobs near you
Claims Manager - Property

Claims Manager - Property

COLUMBIA INSURANCE GROUP

Columbia, MO • On-site, Remote

Other

Medical, Dental, Vision, Retirement, PTO

Posted 21 days ago

Job description

Pay Philosophy
The typical starting salary for this position is determined by a number of factors, including, but not limited to, acquired skills, experience, education, and certifications/designations. This position may be eligible for annual merit increases and participation in our bonus program.
What are we looking for?
Join our team as a Claims Manager - Property. In this position you will be providing direct oversight of property claims supervisors and large loss adjusters and is accountable for claim outcomes, financial results, operational effectiveness, and service quality.
Who we are and what we do?
At Columbia Insurance, we believe our people are the heart of our success and our greatest strength. With robust benefits, a fun, family-like atmosphere, and a culture that thrives on real connections, Columbia truly is the place to be. Our vision is to lead the industry in people-first partnerships. The best way to achieve that is by bringing together a team of skilled, passionate, and talented individuals.
Why us?
  • Medical, Dental, and Vision coverage
  • 401(k) and company match
  • Generous paid time off (PTO), paid company holidays, paid maternity/paternity leave, and supplemental sick leave
  • Family-like culture
  • Year-round wellness initiatives
  • Company sponsored events
  • Opportunities for professional development with conferences, events, and continued education

Company History
Our legacy has roots back to 1889 when we first became part of the mutual insurance movement in the Midwest. Today, our extensive heritage resonates nationwide, as we proudly serve customers in 14 states across the country.
BASIC FUNCTION AND RESPONSIBILITY
The Property Claims Manager is responsible for the overall leadership, performance, and results of the commercial property claims line of business.
ESSENTIAL FUNCTIONS
  • Provide leadership, coaching, and direction to property claims supervisors and large loss adjusters.
  • Set clear performance expectations and ensure consistent, high-quality claims handling practices.
  • Foster a collaborative, accountable, and service-focused claims culture aligned with the company's values.
  • Oversee the handling of all commercial property claims, including complex and large loss claims.
  • Ensure claims are handled in compliance with company guidelines, regulatory requirements, and best practices.
  • Monitor and manage property claim severity, frequency, cycle times, and overall financial performance.
  • Analyze claim outcomes and implement strategies to improve results and policyholder experience
  • Recommend settlement authority and set reserves within authority and escalate issues appropriately to claims leadership
  • Identify potential high severity losses and report them in a timely manner to management.
  • Participate in claim roundtables and provide mentorship or guidance to less experienced adjusters as needed.
  • Contribute to internal audits and complete file reviews.
  • Collaborate with underwriting and risk management teams on legal trends, claim developments, and lessons learned.
  • Develop, implement, and maintain a comprehensive catastrophe response program.
  • Lead catastrophe planning, readiness, vendor management, and post-event response.
  • Coordinate internal and external resources during CAT events to ensure timely, effective claims handling.
  • Conduct post-CAT reviews and implement improvements based on lessons learned.
  • Monitor trends in the insurance industry related to property claims, catastrophe management, construction costs, and regulatory changes.
  • Recommend and implement changes, enhancements, or new approaches to improve claim outcomes and operational effectiveness.
  • Serve as a subject matter expert for property claims within the organization.
  • Identify, evaluate, and recommend innovative technologies, tools, and vendors to streamline property claims processes.
  • Partner with leadership and internal teams to implement solutions that drive efficiency, accuracy, and improved results.
  • Lead or support initiatives focused on automation, data utilization, and workflow optimization.
  • Oversee property claims reporting to reinsurers, ensuring accuracy, timeliness, and compliance with treaty requirements.
  • Serve as a key liaison with reinsurance partners regarding property losses and catastrophe events.
  • Support audits, reviews, and data requests related to reinsurance.
  • Enforce company policies and procedures.
  • Other duties as assigned.

REQUIRED QUALIFICATIONS
  • 10+ years of experience handling commercial property claims, with a strong background in large loss management and catastrophe claims.
  • 5+ years of prior leadership experience in property claims.
  • Operational experience with Xactimate and XactAnalysis.
  • Proven ability to manage competing priorities in a fast-paced environment.
  • Proven leadership experience managing supervisors and/or senior claims professionals.
  • Strong understanding of property claims operations, coverage analysis, and financial impacts.
  • Experience with catastrophe response planning and execution.
  • Excellent analytical, organizational, and communication skills.
  • Demonstrates experience or ability to deal with significant/complex coverage matters.
  • Deep knowledge of property claims, especially negotiation and resolution techniques.
  • Proven ability to manage high severity claims and exercise independent judgment with limited supervision.
  • Strong written and verbal communication skills, with the ability to present complex information clearly and persuasively.
  • Experience working with outside counsel, experts, and insureds.
  • Has sound critical thinking, and problem-solving capabilities.
  • Outstanding customer service, attention to detail, and multi-tasking skills.
  • Strong computer skills, including a strong knowledge of Microsoft applications (Outlook, Word, Excel)
  • Must have a valid adjuster license in designated home state (or willing to obtain one within 60 days after hire) with the ability to obtain additional non-residential adjuster licenses.
  • Ability to travel, as necessary.

EDUCATION QUALIFICATIONS
  • Bachelor's degree strongly preferred

PREFERRED QUALIFICATIONS
  • Professional designations such as CPCU, AIC, SCLA, or similar.
  • Experience implementing process improvement initiatives and/or new claims technology.
  • Familiarity with reinsurance structures and reporting requirements.
  • Experience working in Guidewire Claim Center.

EOE
Columbia Insurance prohibits discrimination and harassment of any type and affords equal employment opportunities to employees and applicants without regard to race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, pregnancy, age, national origin, disability status, genetic information, protected veteran status, or any other characteristic protected by law.
If you are unable to complete the electronic application for any reason, please contact Mandi Giboney: mgiboney@columbiainsurance.com 573-777-4087

Apply