60 Insurance case manager jobs in Columbus, OH


10 of the Most Popular Types of Insurance Case Manager Jobs in 2026

See what kind of roles similar to Insurance Case Manager jobs are hiring now

To become an insurance case manager, you need the right educational qualifications as well as career experience in the insurance industry. Because you can work with various types of insurance, like medical or life, the qualifications vary depending on the exact position. Some employers consider applicants who have an associate degree in a subject such as accounting or finance plus a year of experience, while others accept candidates with a high school diploma or G.E.D. certificate combined with several years of insurance experience, either working as insurance brokers or insurance advisors. Other essential qualities include excellent communication, math, problem-solving, and organizational skills.

If you are interested in a job related to Insurance Case Manager, here are some popular related job searches with the most open positions on ZipRecruiter.

Top Types Of Insurance Case Manager Jobs

List of the top 10 highest paying Insurance Case Manager positions in 2026, with salary ranges, according to ZipRecruiter.
  • Targeted Individuals

    Salary range: $69,500 - $80,000

    Targeted Individuals is a more unusual job search query but still may give you interesting job results. Most salaries for Targeted Individuals jobs pay between $69,500 (25th percentile) and $80,000 (75th percentile) annually. Currently, there are not many open positions nationwide for Targeted Individuals job searches hiring now on ZipRecruiter. You can take a look at what is available and find similar job searches in this list.

  • Kaiser Insurance

    Salary range: $40,500 - $77,500

    Kaiser Insurance is a typical job search query Most salaries for Kaiser Insurance jobs pay between $40,500 (25th percentile) and $77,500 (75th percentile) annually. Currently, there are not many open positions nationwide for Kaiser Insurance job searches hiring now on ZipRecruiter. You can take a look at what is available and find similar job searches in this list.

  • Met Life Pet Insurance

    Salary range: $30,000 - $56,000

    Met Life Pet Insurance is a more unusual job search query but still may give you interesting job results. Most salaries for Met Life Pet Insurance jobs pay between $30,000 (25th percentile) and $56,000 (75th percentile) annually. There are plenty of open positions nationwide for Met Life Pet Insurance job searches hiring now on ZipRecruiter.

  • Weekend Case Manager

    Salary range: $40,000 - $56,000

    Weekend Case Manager is a typical job search query Most salaries for Weekend Case Manager jobs pay between $40,000 (25th percentile) and $56,000 (75th percentile) annually. Currently, there are not many open positions nationwide for Weekend Case Manager job searches hiring now on ZipRecruiter. You can take a look at what is available and find similar job searches in this list.

  • Nonprofit Case Manager

    Salary range: $40,000 - $51,500

    Nonprofit Case Manager is a typical job search query Most salaries for Nonprofit Case Manager jobs pay between $40,000 (25th percentile) and $51,500 (75th percentile) annually. Currently, there are not many open positions nationwide for Nonprofit Case Manager job searches hiring now on ZipRecruiter. You can take a look at what is available and find similar job searches in this list.

  • Contract Case Manager

    Salary range: $40,000 - $56,000

    Contract Case Manager is a typical job search query Most salaries for Contract Case Manager jobs pay between $40,000 (25th percentile) and $56,000 (75th percentile) annually. Currently, there are not many open positions nationwide for Contract Case Manager job searches hiring now on ZipRecruiter. You can take a look at what is available and find similar job searches in this list.

  • Syringe Exchange

    Salary range: $154,500 - $197,500

    Syringe Exchange is a more unusual job search query but still may give you interesting job results. Most salaries for Syringe Exchange jobs pay between $154,500 (25th percentile) and $197,500 (75th percentile) annually. Currently, there are not many open positions nationwide for Syringe Exchange job searches hiring now on ZipRecruiter. You can take a look at what is available and find similar job searches in this list.

  • Annuity New Business Case Manager

    Salary range: $53,000 - $97,000

    Annuity New Business Case Manager is a more unusual job search query but still may give you interesting job results. Most salaries for Annuity New Business Case Manager jobs pay between $53,000 (25th percentile) and $97,000 (75th percentile) annually. Currently, there are not many open positions nationwide for Annuity New Business Case Manager job searches hiring now on ZipRecruiter. You can take a look at what is available and find similar job searches in this list.

  • Refugee Resettlement Case Manager

    Salary range: $43,500 - $57,000

    Refugee Resettlement Case Manager is a more unusual job search query but still may give you interesting job results. Most salaries for Refugee Resettlement Case Manager jobs pay between $43,500 (25th percentile) and $57,000 (75th percentile) annually. Currently, there are not many open positions nationwide for Refugee Resettlement Case Manager job searches hiring now on ZipRecruiter. You can take a look at what is available and find similar job searches in this list.

  • Remote Annuity Case Manager

    Salary range: $40,000 - $51,500

    Remote Annuity Case Manager is a more unusual job search query but still may give you interesting job results. Most salaries for Remote Annuity Case Manager jobs pay between $40,000 (25th percentile) and $51,500 (75th percentile) annually. Currently, there are not many open positions nationwide for Remote Annuity Case Manager job searches hiring now on ZipRecruiter. You can take a look at what is available and find similar job searches in this list.