ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Insurance Manager Jobs in Milwaukee, WI (NOW HIRING)

Lake Auto Group

Be Seen First

Finance & Insurance (F&I) Manager

Milwaukee, WI · On-site

$150K - $199K/yr

Finance & Insurance (F&I) Manager Lake Auto Group | Where People Matter Most Drive Success. Build Relationships. Make an Impact. Huge earning potential - $200,000 + Lake Auto Group is searching for a ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsInsurance JobsInsurance Manager JobsInsurance Manager Jobs in Milwaukee, WI

Insurance Manager information

See Milwaukee, WI salary details

$36.9K

$81.6K

$120.7K

How much do insurance manager jobs pay per year?

As of Sep 3, 2026, the average yearly pay for insurance manager in Milwaukee, WI is $81,576.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $65,500.00 and $97,500.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is an insurance manager?

An insurance manager oversees the performance of all the employees who work for an insurance branch and verifies that all corporate policies are followed, including the filing of client records. Specifically, as an insurance manager, you supervise a sales agent or broker to help them drive sales and make sure they sell enough policies. Then, you ensure each of your sales agents receives a commission for excelling in their duties. To maximize profits, you set premiums by using actuary data and information from appraisers to determine the likelihood of clients filing claims, as well as the value of their assets. In this role, you are typically involved in many actions that the branch takes, such as the approval, denial, or investigation of claims.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an insurance manager?

To thrive as an Insurance Manager, you need expertise in risk assessment, policy analysis, and regulatory compliance, often supported by a bachelor's degree in finance, business, or a related field. Familiarity with insurance management software, claims processing systems, and industry certifications like CPCU or ARM is highly valuable. Strong leadership, negotiation, and interpersonal skills help build effective teams and maintain client relationships. These abilities are crucial for ensuring seamless operations, regulatory adherence, and delivering excellent service in a competitive insurance environment.

What are some common challenges faced by insurance managers and how can they be addressed?

Insurance Managers often face challenges such as keeping up with changing regulations, managing diverse client portfolios, and balancing risk assessment with customer service. Staying updated with industry regulations and investing in continuous professional development can help address compliance issues. Effective communication and strong organizational skills are essential for managing multiple clients and teams. Additionally, leveraging modern insurance software can streamline operations and enhance accuracy in policy management.

What is the difference between Insurance Manager vs Insurance Underwriter?

AspectInsurance ManagerInsurance Underwriter
CredentialsOften requires insurance-related certifications and management experienceTypically holds actuarial, underwriting, or insurance licenses
Work EnvironmentManages teams, oversees policies, and develops strategies within insurance companiesEvaluates risks, assesses applications, and determines policy terms
Employer & Industry UsageCommonly employed in insurance firms, brokers, and agenciesPrimarily found in insurance companies and underwriting firms
Search & Comparison IntentPeople compare roles involving insurance policy oversight and managementIndividuals interested in risk assessment and policy issuance

The main difference between an Insurance Manager and an Insurance Underwriter lies in their responsibilities. Insurance Managers oversee teams, develop policies, and manage overall operations, while Insurance Underwriters focus on evaluating individual risks and determining policy terms. Both roles require insurance-related credentials and are integral to the insurance industry, but they serve different functions within the insurance process.

More about Insurance Manager jobs

What are the most commonly searched types of Insurance jobs in Milwaukee, WI?

The most popular types of Insurance jobs in Milwaukee, WI are:

What job categories do people searching Insurance Manager jobs in Milwaukee, WI look for?

The top searched job categories for Insurance Manager jobs in Milwaukee, WI are:

What cities near Milwaukee, WI are hiring for Insurance Manager jobs?

Cities near Milwaukee, WI with the most Insurance Manager job openings:

Insurance Manager jobs near you
Infographic showing various Insurance Manager job openings in Milwaukee, WI as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 73% Full Time, 21% Part Time, and 5% Contract. Highlights an 92% Physical, 1% Hybrid, and 7% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $81,576 per year, or $39.2 per hour.

Finance and Insurance Manager

Milwaukee Division

Waukesha, WI

Full-time

Medical, Dental, Vision, Retirement, PTO

Re-posted 9 days ago

Job description

Job Summary

The Finance and Insurance (F&I) Manager is responsible for helping customers finance their vehicle purchase by working with lending agencies. They also must have a deep understanding of aftermarket options and warranties that can be purchased with the vehicle being sold.

Rare opportunity to join our premier Porsche & Mercedes-Benz dealership in Waukesha, WI. 

Store Hours: Monday-Thursday 9am-8pm, Friday 9am-6pm, Saturday 9am-5pm.

Benefits

  • Competitive Pay

  • Medical, Vision, Dental

  • 401(k) Retirement Plan 

  • Paid Vacation

  • Paid Training

  • Closed Sundays (2 days off per week)

Responsibilities

  • Develop a comprehensive menu selling process to maximize the finance department’s overall profitability and product penetration

  • Track portfolio with lenders

  • Review and inspect the flow of the department’s paperwork daily to ensure timely turnaround on all deals

  • Ensure all deals are fully compliant with local, state, and federal guidelines

  • Demonstrate commitment to supporting the sales department in achieving its goals

  • Be an example of professional morals, ethics, and excellent customer service

  • Work closely with sales team on enforcement of proper selling methods

  • Set and maintain finance department work schedule 

Qualifications

  • Prior automotive F&I experience required

  • Minimum of high school diploma or GED equivalent required 

  • Excellent communication and customer service skills

  • Professional appearance and strong work ethic

  • Knowledge of regulatory and compliance requirements

  • Ability to work within a fast-paced environment

  • Valid driver’s license 

About Us

The International Autos Group is a family owned and operated group of dealerships serving customers in the Milwaukee, Sheboygan, Chicago, Northwest Indiana markets and Minnesota. The owner of the organization is Ralph Mauro, the son of Frank Mauro, who purchased his original dealership in 1968. Frank Mauro left behind quite a legacy and one that included instilling strong work ethics in Ralph. In turn, Ralph instilled those hard work ethics in his son, Francis, who became the third-generation of the Mauro family to join the auto industry. The International Autos Group will do all they can to promote their employees' growth in the company.

We are an equal opportunity employer. All applicants will be considered for employment without attention to race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, veteran or disability status. We are committed to providing a safe, drug-free work environment. Applicants must be willing to submit to a pre-employment background check. Interested candidates must possess a valid driver's license and have a satisfactory driving record.

Apply