ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Evening Supervisor Jobs in Rochester, NY (NOW HIRING)

Wegmans Food Markets

Cook Supervisor

Fairport, NY

$21.75 - $22.50/hr

Morning, Afternoon, Evening (Includes Weekends). Age Requirement: Must be 18 years or older Location: Fairport, NY Address: 6600 Pitts-Palmyra Rd Pay: $21.75 - $22.50 / hour Job Posting: 08/03/2026 ...

The Arc Wayne

Residence Supervisor - Lyons, NY

Newark, NY · On-site

$24.13 - $25.55/hr

Provides periodic observation of staff during evening and overnight shifts. Completes any necessary ... Supervises record maintenance, documentation of service provision (i.e. - residential habilitation ...

The Arc Wayne

Residence Supervisor - Lyons, NY

Newark, NY · On-site

$24.13 - $25.55/hr

Provides periodic observation of staff during evening and overnight shifts. Completes any necessary ... Supervises record maintenance, documentation of service provision (i.e. - residential habilitation ...

previous page

Showing results 41-60

All JobsEvening Supervisor JobsEvening Supervisor Jobs in Rochester, NY

Evening Supervisor information

See Rochester, NY salary details

$10

$15

$25

How much do evening supervisor jobs pay per hour?

As of Aug 11, 2026, the average hourly pay for evening supervisor in Rochester, NY is $15.74, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $13.48 and $15.95 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What are some common challenges faced by evening supervisors and how can they be addressed?

Evening Supervisors often encounter challenges such as managing reduced staffing levels, ensuring consistent communication between day and night shifts, and handling unexpected issues that arise after regular business hours. To address these, strong organizational skills and proactive planning are essential, along with clear documentation and effective handover procedures. Building strong relationships with your team and maintaining open lines of communication with other supervisors can also help ensure smooth operations during evening hours.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an evening supervisor?

To thrive as an Evening Supervisor, you need strong leadership, organizational, and problem-solving skills, often supported by prior supervisory experience or relevant industry knowledge. Familiarity with workforce management systems, scheduling software, and standard reporting tools is typically required. Outstanding communication, adaptability, and conflict resolution abilities help foster a productive team environment during off-peak hours. These skills ensure smooth operations, effective staff management, and customer satisfaction during evening shifts.

What is an evening supervisor?

Evening Supervisors are professionals responsible for overseeing operations and staff during the evening shift in various organizations, such as hotels, hospitals, retail stores, or warehouses. They ensure that activities run smoothly, address any issues that arise, and provide support to employees working during this time. Their duties often include managing schedules, handling customer concerns, enforcing company policies, and maintaining safety standards. Evening Supervisors play a key role in ensuring continuity between day and night operations and often report to higher management about shift performance and incidents.

What is the difference between Evening Supervisor vs Customer Service Representative?

AspectEvening SupervisorCustomer Service Representative
Required CredentialsHigh school diploma; some roles may prefer supervisory or leadership experienceHigh school diploma or equivalent; customer service skills
Work EnvironmentSupervises staff during evening shifts, often in retail, hospitality, or warehousesInteracts directly with customers, typically in retail, call centers, or service centers
Employer & Industry UsageCommon in retail stores, restaurants, warehouses, and hospitality sectorsFound across retail, telecom, banking, and service industries

The main difference is that an Evening Supervisor oversees staff and operations during evening hours, ensuring tasks are completed, while a Customer Service Representative primarily handles customer interactions and support. Both roles may require similar credentials, but their responsibilities and work environments differ significantly.

What are the most commonly searched types of Supervisor jobs in Rochester, NY? The most popular types of Supervisor jobs in Rochester, NY are:
What cities near Rochester, NY are hiring for Evening Supervisor jobs? Cities near Rochester, NY with the most Evening Supervisor job openings:
Evening Supervisor jobs near you

Cook Supervisor

Wegmans Food Markets

Fairport, NY

$21.75 - $22.50/hr

Full-time

Medical, Life, Retirement, PTO

Posted 22 days ago

Wegmans Food Markets rating

7.9

Company rating: 7.9 out of 10

Based on 836 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

4th of 122 rated grocery stores

Job description

Schedule: Full time
Availability: Morning, Afternoon, Evening (Includes Weekends).
Age Requirement: Must be 18 years or older
Location: Fairport, NY
Address: 6600 Pitts-Palmyra Rd
Pay: $21.75 - $22.50 / hour
Job Posting: 08/03/2026
Job Posting End: 09/02/2026
Job ID:R0289868

EARN A BONUS UP TO $1,500!

Step into a leadership role where your culinary skill and passion for food set the tone for the entire kitchen! In our people-first kitchen, you'll lead and develop a team of cooks to fine tune their skills and grow their career. Your leadership, culinary expertise, and attention to detail will drive profitability and a smooth kitchen environment.

What You'll Do

  • Assist the sous chefs in running the kitchen and overseeing the team
  • Follow recipes, use proper knife skills, and apply cooking techniques to ensure consistency
  • Share your knowledge and passion for food with customers by suggesting meal ideas using products from departments around the store
  • Manage employee performance, including training, feedback and development opportunities

Requirements

  • 2+ years of prep or line cook experience
  • Experience leading a team
  • Food safety and quality assurance knowledge

At Wegmans, we’ve always believed we can achieve our goals only if we first fulfill the needs of our people. Putting our people first and offering competitive compensation, comprehensive benefits and a wide range of meaningful perks is just the beginning of what defines a rewarding career at Wegmans.

Comprehensive benefits*

  1. Paid time off (PTO) to help you balance your personal and work life
  2. Higher premium pay rates for working overtime, on Sundays, or on a recognized holiday
  3. Health care benefits that provide a high level of coverage at a low cost to you
  4. Retirement plan with a 401(k) match
  5. A generous scholarship program to help employees meet their educational goals
  6. LiveWell Employee & Family program to support your emotional, work-life and financial wellness

Our employees have put us high on Fortune 100 Best Companies to Work For® list every year since it was first produced in 1998. Discover what it means to work for a mission-driven, values-based company where YOU make the difference.

*Certain eligibility requirements must be satisfied, and offerings may differ based upon area or the company and/or position.

+

At Wegmans, we’ve always believed we can achieve our goals only if we first fulfill the needs of our people. Putting our people first and offering competitive compensation, comprehensive benefits and a wide range of meaningful perks is just the beginning of what defines a rewarding career at Wegmans.

Comprehensive benefits*
  1. Paid time off (PTO) to help you balance your personal and work life
  2. Higher premium pay rates for working overtime, on Sundays, or on a recognized holiday
  3. Health care benefits that provide a high level of coverage at a low cost to you
  4. Retirement plan with a 401(k) match
  5. A generous scholarship program to help employees meet their educational goals
  6. LiveWell Employee & Family program to support your emotional, work-life and financial wellness

Our employees have put us high on Fortune 100 Best Companies to Work For® list every year since it was first produced in 1998. Discover what it means to work for a mission-driven, values-based company where YOU make the difference.

*Certain eligibility requirements must be satisfied, and offerings may differ based upon area or the company and/or position.

What Wegmans Food Markets employees say

Pay

Benefits

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom

Wegmans Food Markets logo

About Wegmans Food Markets

Sourced by ZipRecruiter

Wegmans Food Markets, situated in Rochester, NY, US, is a widely recognized name in the retail grocery industry. The company was founded in 1916 by Walter Wegman as Rochester Fruit and Vegetable Company and has since been providing a diverse series of high-quality grocery products. It is built on the mission of “helping families live healthier, better lives through food.” Core values of caring, high standards, making a difference, respect, and empowerment drive the firm to uphold its quality, bringing every meal an opportunity for happiness. Wegmans has been celebrated with multiple accolades and was named the best grocery chain in the U.S. by Food & Wine in 2020.

Industry

Food and beverage stores

Company size

10,000+ Employees

Headquarters location

Rochester, NY, US

Year founded

1916

View All Wegmans Food Markets Jobs

Apply