1

Short Term Disability Case Manager Jobs in Indiana

Case Manager

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$17.50 - $22.50/hr

Now Hiring a Case Manager for our newest Detox and Residential treatment facility, located in ... Voluntary Short-Term Disability * Voluntary Long -Term Disability * Employer-Paid Life and AD&D

Case Manager

Indianapolis, IN

$17.50 - $22.50/hr

Now Hiring a Case Manager for our newest Detox and Residential treatment facility, located in ... Voluntary Short-Term Disability * Voluntary Long -Term Disability * Employer-Paid Life and AD&D

Case Manager

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$19 - $24.50/hr

Now Hiring a Case Manager for our newest Detox and Residential treatment facility, located in ... Voluntary Short-Term Disability * Voluntary Long -Term Disability * Employer-Paid Life and AD&D

Case Manager

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$17.50 - $22.50/hr

Now Hiring a Case Manager for our newest Detox and Residential treatment facility, located in ... Voluntary Short-Term Disability * Voluntary Long -Term Disability * Employer-Paid Life and AD&D

Case Manager

Fort Wayne, IN

$18.50 - $23.75/hr

... Short-Term Disability Voluntary Long -Term Disability Employer-Paid Life and AD&D LifeTime Benefit Term Insurance with Long Term Care Legal Coverage Pet Insurance Identity Theft Protection Employer ...

Case Manager

Fort Wayne, IN · On-site

$18.50 - $23.75/hr

... Short-Term Disability Voluntary Long -Term Disability Employer-Paid Life and AD&D LifeTime Benefit Term Insurance with Long Term Care Legal Coverage Pet Insurance Identity Theft Protection Employer ...

Case Manager

Fort Wayne, IN · On-site

$18.25 - $23.50/hr

Initiate case management for each client upon intake, addressing any pressing needs * Oversee ... Short-Term Disability • Voluntary Long -Term Disability • Employer-Paid Life and AD&D • ...

Case Manager

Fort Wayne, IN · On-site

$18.50 - $23.75/hr

Initiate case management for each client upon intake, addressing any pressing needs * Oversee ... Short-Term Disability • Voluntary Long -Term Disability • Employer-Paid Life and AD&D • ...

Case Manager

Fort Wayne, IN · On-site

$18.50 - $23.75/hr

Initiate case management for each client upon intake, addressing any pressing needs * Oversee ... Short-Term Disability • Voluntary Long -Term Disability • Employer-Paid Life and AD&D • ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

Short Term Disability Case Manager information

See Indiana salary details

$13

$23

$40

How much do short term disability case manager jobs pay per hour?

As of May 28, 2026, the average hourly pay for short term disability case manager in Indiana is $23.56, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $18.32 and $25.62 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a Short Term Disability Case Manager, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Short Term Disability Case Manager, you need knowledge of disability claims processes, medical terminology, and a relevant degree or experience in insurance, healthcare, or case management. Familiarity with claims management systems, Microsoft Office Suite, and sometimes certification such as Certified Case Manager (CCM) is valuable. Exceptional organizational skills, empathy, and effective communication help build trust with clients and coordinate with healthcare providers. These skills ensure accurate claim evaluation, regulatory compliance, and positive client outcomes during challenging times.

What are some common challenges faced by Short Term Disability Case Managers, and how can they be managed effectively?

Short Term Disability Case Managers often face challenges such as balancing a high caseload, ensuring timely communication with both claimants and healthcare providers, and navigating complex medical and legal documentation requirements. Effective organization, clear communication, and a strong understanding of disability policies are crucial for success in this role. Many employers provide ongoing training and utilize case management software to streamline processes, which can help Case Managers stay on top of deadlines and deliver quality support to claimants.

What does a Short Term Disability Case Manager do?

A Short Term Disability Case Manager is responsible for overseeing and coordinating the claims process for employees who are temporarily unable to work due to illness or injury. They review medical documentation, communicate with claimants, healthcare providers, and employers, and ensure that claims are processed efficiently and in compliance with regulations. Their goal is to support claimants through their recovery while managing the employer’s short term disability policies and ensuring fair decisions are made about benefits eligibility.

What is the difference between Short Term Disability Case Manager vs Long Term Disability Case Manager?

AspectShort Term Disability Case ManagerLong Term Disability Case Manager
CredentialsTypically requires a bachelor's degree in healthcare, social work, or related field; certifications like CRC or CDMS are commonSimilar credentials as short term, often requiring experience in disability or insurance claims
Work EnvironmentOffice-based, handling claims for short-term disability benefits, often with regular hoursSimilar environment, managing long-term claims, sometimes with more complex case management
Employer & IndustryInsurance companies, third-party administrators, healthcare providersInsurance companies, disability management firms, healthcare organizations

While both roles involve managing disability claims, Short Term Disability Case Managers focus on temporary, short-duration claims, whereas Long Term Disability Case Managers handle more complex, long-term cases. The skills, credentials, and work environments are quite similar, but the scope and duration of cases differ.

What cities in Indiana are hiring for Short Term Disability Case Manager jobs? Cities in Indiana with the most Short Term Disability Case Manager job openings:

Short-Term Disability Claims Examiner

OneAmerica

Indianapolis, IN • Hybrid

Full-time

Posted 12 days ago


Job description

At OneAmerica, we deliver on promises when customers need us most.  We believe the best way to serve our customers is to know that every individual, employee, family and business we work with has unique personal and financial goals.  We keep our promises, so we can help them achieve their goals and realize their definition of financial success.

Job Summary

The STD Claims Examiner is responsible for contributing to the overall success of OneAmerica objectives by providing timely and accurate support to our client companies and the Claims department. This individual will be responsible for managing appropriate adjudication of short-term disability claims in accordance with policy provisions. The STD Claims Examiner will initiate and facilitate case management as well as other ancillary services to assure optimum outcomes.

We are currently seeking Level I & II Representative experience.

KEY RESPONSIBILITIES:

  • Promote a positive customer service image through prompt, accurate and courteous responses to customer information needs
  • Consistently adhere to the documented workflow guidelines and established procedures.
  • Maintain required levels of confidentiality
  • Demonstrate competency in all modules of training program. Remain abreast of industry standards via internal/external continuing education
  • Promptly and thoroughly investigate and evaluate claims within departmental and regulatory guidelines
  • Interpret and administer contract provisions including, but not limited to, eligibility, covered weekly earnings, definition of Total Disability, verification of applicable offsets and pre-existing investigations
  • Calculate benefit and identify other income replacement benefits. Processes financial activities, including, but not limited to, payment adjustments, stop payments, voids and check reissues, other income adjustments, reimbursement checks, and final benefits. Processes overpayments in accordance with established procedures
  • Assist in the subrogation process to recover money from third parties
  • Work in coordination with an LTD Examiner to ensure an appropriate transition from the STD claim to LTD
  • Document claim file actions and telephone conversations appropriately
  • Refer claim activity outside authority level to Supervisor/Manager for review
  • Proactively communicate with claimants, policyholders and physicians to resolve investigations issues
  • Establish, communicate and manage claimant and policyholder expectations
  • Utilize most efficient means to obtain claim information
  • Fully investigates all relevant claim issues, provides payment or denials promptly and in full compliance with departmental procedures and Unfair Claims Practice regulations
  • Respond to customer service issues within required timeframes
  • Involve technical resources (Social Security Specialist, medical resources and vocational resources) at appropriate claim junctures
  • Support relationships with technical resources to achieve appropriate outcomes
  • Meet or exceed departmental service, quality and production objectives
  • Collaborate with team members and management in identifying and implementing improvement opportunities. Informs Supervisor of any trends noted within specific client companies
  • All other duties as assigned

REQUIREMENTS:

  • BA/BS or equivalent combination of education and experience
  • 0-2+ years of experience in managing Short Term Disability claims with first pay authority
  • Ability to fluently speak and write Spanish a plus
  • Excellent customer service skills
  • Excellent math and calculation skills
  • Good decision-making skills
  • Ability to analyze complex claim information
  • Working knowledge of Microsoft Excel and Word
  • High School Diploma required, or any combination of education and experience which would provide an equivalent background.

Salary Band: 3C

#LI-SC1

This selected candidate will be expected to work hybrid in Portland, ME or Indianapolis, IN. The candidate will also be expected to physically return to the office in CA, IN or ME as business needs dictate or for team-building and collaboration.

If you are offered and accept this position, please be advised that OneAmerica Financial does not have any offices located in the State of New York and OneAmerica Financial associates are not permitted to work remotely in the State of New York. 

Disclaimer:  OneAmerica Financial is an equal opportunity employer and strictly prohibits unlawful discrimination based upon an individual’s race, color, religion, gender, sexual orientation, gender identity/expression, national origin/ancestry, age, mental/physical disability, medical condition, marital status, veteran status, or any other characteristic protected by law.

For all positions:

Because this position is regulated by the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act, if an offer is made, applicants must undergo mandated background checks as a condition of employment. Such background checks include criminal history. A conviction is not necessarily an absolute bar to employment. Consistent with applicable regulatory guidelines and law, factors such as the age of the offense, evidence of rehabilitation, seriousness of violation, and job relatedness are considered.

To learn more about our products, services, and the companies of OneAmerica Financial, visit oneamerica.com/companies.