ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Subrogation Adjuster Jobs in Indiana (NOW HIRING)

CSAA

$44K - $58K/yr

Addresses subrogation and total loss responsibilities. * Ensures the insurance program agreements ... Must hold an Adjuster licensed for all applicable states or obtain license(s) within 90 days of ...

Erie Insurance

Property Adjuster II

Lafayette, IN · On-site +1

$63K - $100K/yr

Recognizes subrogation situations and initiates appropriate action. * Services assigned territory ... Assists in training of new claims adjusters. * Participates on Catastrophe Team when required. The ...

Erie Insurance

Property Adjuster II

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$63K - $100K/yr

Recognizes subrogation situations and initiates appropriate action. * Services assigned territory ... Assists in training of new claims adjusters. * Participates on Catastrophe Team when required. The ...

Erie Insurance

Property Adjuster II

Indianapolis, IN · On-site +1

$63K - $100K/yr

Recognizes subrogation situations and initiates appropriate action. * Services assigned territory ... Assists in training of new claims adjusters. * Participates on Catastrophe Team when required. The ...

Erie Insurance

Property Adjuster II

Terre Haute, IN · On-site +1

$63K - $100K/yr

Recognizes subrogation situations and initiates appropriate action. * Services assigned territory ... Assists in training of new claims adjusters. * Participates on Catastrophe Team when required. The ...

Erie Insurance

Property Adjuster II

Terre Haute, IN · On-site

$63K - $100K/yr

Recognizes subrogation situations and initiates appropriate action. * Services assigned territory ... Assists in training of new claims adjusters. * Participates on Catastrophe Team when required. The ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsSubrogation Adjuster JobsSubrogation Adjuster Jobs in Indiana

Subrogation Adjuster information

See Indiana salary details

$30K

$61.8K

$93.3K

How much do subrogation adjuster jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 8, 2026, the average yearly pay for subrogation adjuster in Indiana is $61,797.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $47,600.00 and $71,400.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What are the typical daily responsibilities of a subrogation adjuster?

Subrogation Adjusters spend their days reviewing claim files, investigating the circumstances surrounding losses, and determining liability for potential recovery opportunities. They frequently communicate with other insurers, claimants, witnesses, and sometimes legal professionals to gather information or negotiate settlements. Daily work also includes documenting findings, drafting demand letters, and managing a caseload using specialized claims software. This role requires strong attention to detail and effective multitasking, as managing multiple cases and deadlines is common.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive in the subrogation adjuster position, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Subrogation Adjuster, you need strong analytical skills, knowledge of insurance claims processes, and a background in legal or insurance fields, often supported by relevant certifications. Familiarity with claims management software, subrogation systems, and document management tools is highly valuable. Excellent negotiation, problem-solving, and communication skills help you effectively recover funds and collaborate with internal and external parties. These abilities are essential to ensure efficient resolution of subrogation claims and maximize recoveries for employers or clients.

How to become a subrogation adjuster?

To become a subrogation adjuster, typically one needs a high school diploma or equivalent, along with experience in insurance claims or claims adjusting. Many employers prefer candidates with a relevant license or certification, such as the Certified Subrogation Professional (CSP) or state-specific adjuster licenses. Developing strong negotiation, investigation, and analytical skills is also important for success in this role.

What is a subrogation adjuster?

A Subrogation Adjuster investigates and recovers money from third parties who are responsible for insurance claims. They review claims, gather evidence, negotiate settlements, and work with legal teams if necessary. Their goal is to minimize financial losses for the insurance company by ensuring responsible parties reimburse covered claims. Strong analytical, negotiation, and communication skills are essential in this role.

What are the most commonly searched types of Subrogation Adjuster jobs in Indiana? The most popular types of Subrogation Adjuster jobs in Indiana are:
What are popular job titles related to Subrogation Adjuster jobs in Indiana? For Subrogation Adjuster jobs in Indiana, the most frequently searched job titles are:
What job categories do people searching Subrogation Adjuster jobs in Indiana look for? The top searched job categories for Subrogation Adjuster jobs in Indiana are:
Subrogation Adjuster jobs near you
Infographic showing various Subrogation Adjuster job openings in Indiana as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 93% Full Time, 4% Part Time, 1% Temporary, and 2% Contract. Highlights an 73% Physical, 9% Hybrid, and 18% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $61,797 per year, or $29.7 per hour.

Claims Adjuster II - Casualty

Brotherhood Mutual

Fort Wayne, IN • On-site

Full-time

Re-posted 26 days ago

Brotherhood Mutual rating

7.3

Company rating: 7.3 out of 10

Based on 6 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

235th of 303 rated insurance

Job description

Job Title: Claims Adjuster II - Casualty
FLSA Status: Exempt
Job Family: Claims
Department: Casualty Claims
Location: Corporate Office (Fort Wayne, IN)
JOB SUMMARY
Responsible for effectively analyzing and resolving assigned claims consistent with Claims Department
standards and company objectives.
POSITION ESSENTIAL FUNCTIONS AND RESPONSIBILITIES
To perform this job successfully, an individual must be able to perform each essential duty satisfactorily.
Reasonable accommodations may be made to enable individuals with disabilities to perform the essential
functions.
  • Resolve all assigned claims (including the occasional serious/complex claim, which could include
    but not be limited to unusual damage or coverage issues, or that need the involvement of expert
    analysis or require early recognition of policyholder concerns) within established settlement
    authority in a prompt, fair and equitable manner. Identify and investigate coverage, damage, and
    reserve adequacy on assigned claims.
  • Apply statutes, common law, and other applicable legal and regulatory concepts for the effective,
    efficient and equitable resolution of assigned claims.
  • Achieve established claim file audit objectives.
  • Communicate with policyholders, agents, claimants, attorneys, medical providers and other
    persons as needed and direct independent adjusters, appraisers and other support service
    providers to ensure effective, efficient, and equitable claims resolution.
  • Acquire, record and maintain all essential file documentation in accordance with established
    guidelines.
  • Provide timely status reports regarding assigned claims to claims department management and
    others.
  • Identify and pursue appropriate cost containment, loss mitigation and subrogation recovery
    opportunities.
  • Participate and provide input in departmental meetings or interdepartmental meetings, projects or
    processes that relate to the claims function.
  • Travel as needed to attend training programs, conferences, mediation/other legal proceedings,
    and to conduct investigation relating to claims resolution.
  • Further the attainment of overall department objectives by assisting other claims personnel as
    needed.
  • Participate as needed in the orientation or training of new department personnel.
  • Complete other projects as assigned.

POSITION RESPONSIBILITES (supplement to the Position Description)
  • Handle assigned auto claims involving 1st and 3rd party property damage, represented bodily injury, UM/UIM, and PIP.
  • Investigate, evaluate, and resolve auto claims by reviewing coverage, liability, damages, and reserves and by obtaining and documenting relevant facts, statements, reports, estimates, photos, and other supporting information.
  • Apply policy language and legal requirements in the handling and resolution of auto claims.
  • Communicate with insureds, claimants, agents, attorneys, appraisers, repair facilities, and other service providers to support timely and effective claim resolution.
  • Handle litigated auto claims by retaining and managing legal counsel as needed and coordinating claim activity through resolution.
  • Identify opportunities for cost containment, loss mitigation, subrogation, SIU escalation, and other appropriate next steps in accordance with departmental guidelines.
  • Maintain accurate claim file documentation, data entry, and communication in accordance with departmental, policy, legal, and regulatory requirements.

ADDITIONAL SKILLS (supplement to the Position Description)
  • Ability to communicate effectively, orally and in writing, regarding coverage, liability, damages, and reserving on auto claims.
  • Ability to apply working knowledge of applicable laws, regulations, and claim handling requirements.
  • Ability to handle difficult or confrontational situations professionally and use sound judgment in claim resolution.
  • Ability to identify subrogation opportunities, SIU referrals, and other issues requiring escalation.

KNOWLEDGE, SKILLS, AND ABILITIES
The requirements listed below are representative of the knowledge, skills, and/or abilities required to perform
each essential duty satisfactorily. Reasonable accommodations may be made to enable individuals with
disabilities to perform the essential functions.
  • Must be able to effectively communicate with others (both oral and written). Must demonstrate the
    ability to present a reasoned position in both an oral and written format.
  • Must be able to make independent decisions.
  • Must have good interpersonal skills. Must have the ability to handle confrontational situations in a
    productive manner. Must demonstrate the ability to employ sound negotiation techniques in the
    resolution of assigned claims.
  • Must have good organizational skills.
  • Must have a good understanding of basic issues related to claims. Must have a good
    understanding of coverage issues.
  • Must be able to access, input and retrieve information from a computer.
  • Must have a good understanding of all automated claims department processing systems and
    workflows.
  • Should be able to sit for prolonged periods of time.
  • Possess the ability to inspect losses by walking, lifting, climbing or bending.
  • Effectively interface with external contacts, Brotherhood employees, managers, and department
    staff members.

EDUCATION AND/OR EXPERIENCE
List Degree Requirement, Years' Experience, and Certifications
  • Bachelor's degree or completed AIC or completed 3 parts of CPCU, is required.
  • Must be able to take and pass mandatory adjuster licensing requirements.
  • Must have 3 years or more of claim technical experience.
  • AIC/CPCU or other insurance-related course work is desired.
  • 5 years or more of Brotherhood Mutual claims technical experience is desired.

Terms and Conditions
This description is intended to describe the general content of and requirements for the performance of this position. It is not to be construed as an exhaustive statement of duties, responsibilities, or requirements.
Because the company's niche is the church and related ministries market, and because effective service requires a thorough understanding of this market, persons in this position must be familiar with church operations and must conduct themselves in a manner that will neither alienate nor offend persons within this target niche.
Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company reserves the right to modify, interpret, or apply this position description in any way the company desires. This job description in no way implies that these are the only duties, including essential duties, to be performed by the employee occupying this position. This position description is not an employment contract, implied or otherwise. The
employment relationship remains "at-will".
Equal Opportunity Employer
This employer is required to notify all applicants of their rights pursuant to federal employment laws.
For further information, please review the Know Your Rights notice from the Department of Labor.

What Brotherhood Mutual employees say

Pay

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom

Apply