ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Senior Insurance Underwriter Jobs in Indiana (NOW HIRING)

Boutique Recruiting

Senior Underwriter

Fort Wayne, IN · On-site +1

$90K - $110K/yr

Senior Underwriter Salary Range: $90,000-$110,000 / Year, DOE + Bonus This is an opportunity to ... The ideal candidate is an experienced specialty insurance underwriter who combines strong technical ...

New

Tmhcc

Senior Underwriter, Accident & Health

Carmel, IN · On-site

$98K - $116K/yr

As a global leader in specialty travel medical and trip protection insurance, we are passionate ... The Senior Accident & Health Underwriter is responsible for reviewing and analyzing underwriting ...

Allied Solutions LLC

Senior Production Underwriter

Carmel, IN · On-site

$98K - $116K/yr

The Senior Production Underwriter is directly responsible for establishing and leading company growth and profitability objectives for the Risk Management Operations (RMO) Lender Placed Insurance ...

Allied Solutions LLC

Senior Production Underwriter

Carmel, IN · On-site

$98K - $116K/yr

The Senior Production Underwriter is directly responsible for establishing and leading company ... Utilizes advanced insurance product & services industry knowledge, experience and skill set to ...

Brotherhood Mutual

Senior Underwriter

Fort Wayne, IN · On-site

$97K - $114K/yr

Senior Underwriter FLSA Status: Exempt Job Family: Underwriting Department: UW - Data & Quality ... Must have a thorough understanding of Property and Casualty insurance rating systems, underwriting ...

Brotherhood Mutual

Senior Underwriter

Fort Wayne, IN · On-site

$97K - $114K/yr

Senior Underwriter FLSA Status: Exempt Job Family: Underwriting Department: UW - Data & Quality ... Must have a thorough understanding of Property and Casualty insurance rating systems, underwriting ...

Elevance Health

Group Underwriter, Senior

Indianapolis, IN · Hybrid

$94K - $111K/yr

The Group Underwriter, Senior is responsible for determining acceptability of insurance risks and appropriate premium rates for small, complex renewal and prospect employer groups in accordance with ...

Elevance Health

Group Underwriter, Senior

Indianapolis, IN · Hybrid

$94K - $111K/yr

The Group Underwriter, Senior is responsible for determining acceptability of insurance risks and appropriate premium rates for small, complex renewal and prospect employer groups in accordance with ...

Elevance Health

Group Underwriter Senior

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$76K - $126K/yr

The Group Underwriter Senior will be responsible for determining acceptability of insurance risks and appropriate premium rates for large, complex renewal and prospect employer groups in accordance ...

Elevance Health

Group Underwriter, Senior

Indianapolis, IN · Hybrid

$94K - $111K/yr

The Group Underwriter, Senior is responsible for determining acceptability of insurance risks and appropriate premium rates for small, complex renewal and prospect employer groups in accordance with ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsInsurance Underwriter JobsSenior Insurance Underwriter JobsSenior Insurance Underwriter Jobs in Indiana

Senior Insurance Underwriter information

See Indiana salary details

$35.2K

$101.4K

$127K

How much do senior insurance underwriter jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 12, 2026, the average yearly pay for senior insurance underwriter in Indiana is $101,438.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $93,700.00 and $110,900.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is a senior insurance underwriter?

A Senior Insurance Underwriter is a professional responsible for evaluating and analyzing the risks involved in insuring people or assets, and determining appropriate policy terms and premiums. They review applications, assess financial documents, and use specialized software to decide whether to provide insurance coverage and at what cost. Senior underwriters typically handle more complex or high-value cases, mentor junior staff, and help develop underwriting guidelines. Their role is crucial in ensuring the insurance company maintains profitability while offering fair coverage to clients.

What are some common challenges faced by senior insurance underwriters when assessing complex or high-value risks?

Senior Insurance Underwriters often encounter challenges when evaluating complex or high-value risks, such as incomplete client information, rapidly changing market conditions, and evolving regulatory requirements. They must exercise strong analytical skills and sound judgment to balance risk exposure with the company's profitability goals. Additionally, collaborating with sales teams, actuaries, and legal departments is essential to develop tailored solutions, which can add further complexity to the decision-making process. Staying current with industry trends and risk assessment tools helps underwriters navigate these challenges effectively.

What is the difference between Senior Insurance Underwriter vs Insurance Underwriter?

AspectSenior Insurance UnderwriterInsurance Underwriter
CredentialsTypically requires 3+ years experience, relevant certifications (e.g., CPCU)Entry to mid-level experience, often pursuing certifications
Work EnvironmentMore autonomous, decision-making authority, leadership rolesSupervised, focused on assessing and processing applications
Employer & Industry UsageUsed in insurance companies, brokerage firms, and reinsuranceCommon in same settings, often as entry-level or mid-level roles

The main difference between a Senior Insurance Underwriter and an Insurance Underwriter lies in experience, decision-making authority, and responsibilities. Senior Underwriters typically have more experience, greater autonomy, and may oversee complex cases or mentor junior staff, whereas Insurance Underwriters focus on evaluating applications under supervision. Both roles are essential in the insurance industry, with the senior position representing a higher level of expertise and leadership.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a senior insurance underwriter, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Senior Insurance Underwriter, you need deep expertise in risk assessment, policy analysis, and industry regulations, usually supported by a bachelor's degree in finance or a related field and several years of underwriting experience. Familiarity with underwriting software, statistical analysis tools, and certifications such as CPCU (Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter) are common requirements. Excellent decision-making, negotiation, and communication skills set top performers apart in this role. These capabilities ensure accurate risk evaluation, profitable policy issuance, and strong client and broker relationships in a competitive insurance market.

How much do senior insurance underwriters make in the US?

Senior insurance underwriters in the US typically earn between $70,000 and $120,000 annually, with the median salary around $90,000. Compensation varies based on experience, location, and the complexity of the policies they evaluate, and often includes benefits such as bonuses and professional development opportunities.
What are the most commonly searched types of Insurance Underwriter jobs in Indiana? The most popular types of Insurance Underwriter jobs in Indiana are:
What are popular job titles related to Senior Insurance Underwriter jobs in Indiana? For Senior Insurance Underwriter jobs in Indiana, the most frequently searched job titles are:
What job categories do people searching Senior Insurance Underwriter jobs in Indiana look for? The top searched job categories for Senior Insurance Underwriter jobs in Indiana are:
What cities in Indiana are hiring for Senior Insurance Underwriter jobs? Cities in Indiana with the most Senior Insurance Underwriter job openings:
Senior Insurance Underwriter jobs near you
Infographic showing various Senior Insurance Underwriter job openings in Indiana as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 73% Full Time, 21% Part Time, and 5% Contract. Highlights an 96% Physical, 1% Hybrid, and 3% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $101,438 per year, or $48.8 per hour.

Senior Underwriter

Boutique Recruiting

Fort Wayne, IN • On-site, Remote

$90K - $110K/yr

Full-time

Medical, Retirement, PTO

Posted yesterday

New

Job description

Position Title: Senior Underwriter
Salary Range: $90,000-$110,000 / Year, DOE + Bonus
This is an opportunity to step into a high-impact underwriting role with an established, independently owned specialty insurance organization serving a unique national market. The Senior Underwriter will lead complex risk evaluation, manage key accounts, oversee renewals and referrals, and work directly with insureds and carrier partners while helping strengthen underwriting processes across the business. The ideal candidate is an experienced specialty insurance underwriter who combines strong technical judgment with polished communication, exceptional attention to detail and the confidence to own relationships with sophisticated commercial clients.
Responsibilities
  • Evaluate specialty insurance applications, submissions and complex risks to determine appropriate underwriting strategy and coverage
  • Manage renewals, referrals and accounts requiring carrier review or approval while maintaining accuracy and responsiveness throughout the process
  • Build and maintain strong relationships with insureds, carrier partners and key commercial accounts
  • Partner with the junior underwriting team on application preparation, account servicing and day-to-day underwriting activities
  • Coordinate certificates, endorsements, underwriting documentation and supporting information for active accounts
  • Balance underwriting responsibilities with a high level of customer service, particularly during the January through May peak renewal season
  • Contribute to process improvements, annual planning and underwriting strategy as the organization continues to grow

Requirements
  • 5+ years of specialty insurance underwriting experience, ideally involving niche, complex or hard-to-place risks
  • Strong risk analysis, underwriting judgment and attention to detail
  • Proven ability to communicate directly and professionally with insureds, commercial clients and executive-level stakeholders
  • Experience managing customer and carrier relationships with a service-driven approach
  • Ability to work independently, stay organized and manage competing priorities in a fully remote environment
  • Strong proficiency with Microsoft Office, Excel, Microsoft Teams, and other cloud-based business tools

Benefits
  • 100% remote work environment with flexibility and strong work-life balance
  • Health insurance with approximately 70% of employee premiums covered by the company and family coverage available
  • 4 weeks of PTO plus major and floating holidays
  • SIMPLE IRA retirement plan with a 3% company match
  • Company-provided laptop and equipment

This is a rare opportunity to become a senior underwriting voice within a stable, highly specialized organization where your expertise will directly influence clients, carrier relationships and future growth. If you're ready to take ownership of complex specialty risks and build your career beyond the confines of a traditional corporate insurance environment, apply today!
#LI-KR1 #LI-LO1
Boutique Recruiting logo

About Boutique Recruiting

Sourced by ZipRecruiter

We are a team with shared goals; mindfully placing candidates in the workforce to successfully fulfill their career ambitions while encouraging a sense of purpose and value. We have created a new kind of placement firm — one that values connection, personalization, commitment, impact, boldness and achievement. At Boutique Recruiting, our clients, candidates and employees are at the heart of our success.

Industry

Recruiting and staffing services

Company size

51 - 200 Employees

Headquarters location

San Diego, CA, US

Year founded

2014

Social media

FacebookTwitter

View All Boutique Recruiting Jobs

Apply