ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Preferred Mutual Jobs (NOW HIRING)

Dexian

Finance/Accounting Intern

Castle Shannon, PA · On-site

$30 - $33/hr

Mutual Fund experience preferred * Prior Financial services experience preferred Dexian stands at the forefront of Talent + Technology solutions with a presence spanning more than 70 locations ...

New

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsPreferred Mutual Jobs

Preferred Mutual information

See salary details

$11K

$78.3K

$118K

How much do preferred mutual jobs pay per year?

As of Jul 18, 2026, the average yearly pay for preferred mutual in the United States is $78,333.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $50,000.00 and $96,500.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive at Preferred Mutual, and why are they important?

To thrive at Preferred Mutual, strong analytical skills, a solid understanding of insurance principles, and relevant educational qualifications such as a degree in business, finance, or a related field are essential. Familiarity with insurance management systems, claims processing software, and regulatory compliance tools is typically required. Exceptional communication, attention to detail, and problem-solving abilities are important soft skills that set candidates apart. These competencies ensure efficient service delivery, accurate claims management, and positive client relationships in the insurance industry.

What is the difference between Preferred Mutual vs Claims Adjuster?

AspectPreferred MutualClaims Adjuster
CredentialsLicenses, insurance certificationsLicenses, insurance certifications
Work EnvironmentOffice, remote, fieldOffice, remote, field
Industry UsageInsurance provider, mutual companyInsurance company, claims processing

Preferred Mutual is an insurance company that offers various policies, while a Claims Adjuster is a professional who investigates and settles insurance claims for companies like Preferred Mutual. Both roles require similar certifications and work environments, but their focus differs: Preferred Mutual is a provider, whereas Claims Adjuster is a role within insurance claims processing.

What is Preferred Mutual?

Preferred Mutual is a regional property and casualty insurance company that provides insurance products such as auto, home, business, and umbrella policies. Founded in 1896 and headquartered in New Berlin, New York, Preferred Mutual serves customers primarily in the Northeastern United States. The company works through a network of independent agents to deliver personalized insurance solutions. Preferred Mutual is known for its strong customer service and commitment to local communities.

What are some common challenges faced by insurance professionals at Preferred Mutual, and how can new hires prepare to address them?

Insurance professionals at Preferred Mutual often encounter challenges such as adapting to evolving regulations, mastering new technology platforms, and balancing customer service with risk assessment. New hires can prepare by familiarizing themselves with industry compliance standards, becoming proficient in common insurance software, and developing strong communication skills. The company typically provides comprehensive training and encourages collaboration, allowing team members to learn from experienced colleagues and tackle complex cases together.
More about Preferred Mutual jobs
What cities are hiring for Preferred Mutual jobs? Cities with the most Preferred Mutual job openings:
What are the most commonly searched types of Preferred Mutual jobs? The most popular types of Preferred Mutual jobs are:
What states have the most Preferred Mutual jobs? States with the most job openings for Preferred Mutual jobs include:
What job categories do people searching Preferred Mutual jobs look for? The top searched job categories for Preferred Mutual jobs are:
Preferred Mutual jobs near you
Infographic showing various Preferred Mutual job openings in the United States as of July 2026, with employment types broken down into 3% As Needed, 82% Full Time, 12% Part Time, and 3% Contract. Highlights an 90% Physical, 3% Hybrid, and 7% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $78,333 per year, or $37.7 per hour.
Claims Care Representative-Hybrid in New Berlin, NY

Claims Care Representative-Hybrid in New Berlin, NY

Preferred Mutual Insurance Company

New Berlin, NY

$20 - $22/hr

Other

Medical, Dental, Vision, Life, Retirement, PTO

Re-posted 24 days ago

Job description

Please note this position is a hybrid position requiring 3-6 months of on site training in our New Berlin, NY office and working on site several times a month once training is completed.

Pay: $20.00 to $22.00 per hour

Rotating schedule of 7:30am-4pm and 8:30am-5pm. No nights or weekends!

At Preferred, we understand the importance of holistic health. To meet the diverse needs of our employees, we offer a comprehensive set of benefits:

Financial

  • Short-term disability, long-term disability, and life insurance coverage are provided at no cost
  • Optional benefits include enhanced life insurance and critical illness plans
  • 401k plan with an employer contribution that you will receive regardless of your own contribution to the plan
  • A cash-balance pension plan
  • Student Loan Repayment Assistance
  • A short-term incentive plan for all employees

Social

  • Generous paid time off, offering of 25 days at hire (prorated based on start date for the first year)
  • 7 days of paid sick leave
  • 10 paid company holidays
  • Personalized paid time off after 3 years!

Emotional

  • Access to 26 sessions with a BetterHelp therapist each year for you and up to 5 dependents, as well as access to all of BetterHelps group and digital resources
  • Access to Family First, a team of care experts who can provide you and your loved ones 1:1 assistance with a variety of caregiving solutions, from elder care to legal and financial challenges, insurance and Medicare navigation, and more!

Physical

  • Medical, dental, and vision coverage options begin on the first day of employment
  • Health Savings Accounts (with a generous employer contribution!)

YOUR PURPOSE AND FUNCTION IN OUR COMPANY:

The Claim Care Representative I will work to provide an exceptional experience to our valued internal and external customers by processing transactions and delivering services for high-touch and high-volume transactions and interactions of lower to medium complexity within claims, supporting each unit in the department.

The Claims Care Representative I will:

  • Develop proficiency in routine claims support functions, including First Notice of Loss (FNOL) intake, Safelite glass claim coordination, rental management, and handling inbound claims calls, with the ability to work independently within 36 months.
  • Follow established SOP's and provide continuous improvement feedback to SOP's.
  • Meet individual goals within defined KPI's and SLA's.
  • Escalate issues and non-routine transactions to supervisor as appropriate;

KEY CAPABILITIES FOR SUCCESS:

  • A positive, customer-first attitude.
  • Attention to detail.
  • Team focus, able to work collaboratively as a member of a team.
  • Excellent listening skills.
  • Able to communicate in English clearly and effectively, both verbally and in writing.
  • Maintain a consistent quality and quantity of work at established standards.
  • Maintain confidentiality.
  • Ability to learn various technology platforms and navigate them simultaneously.

QUALIFICATIONS:

  • High School Diploma or equivalent, required.
  • Related work experience preferred
  • Experience with various technology platforms utilized by Preferred Mutual including but not limited to Microsoft Windows, Microsoft Office Suite, etc.) desired.

ABOUT US:

As a mutual company, we are independent by nature, so we think about insurance solutions a little differently. Through listening, problem solving, examining your challenges and collaborating on the right solutions for you, Preferred Mutual independent agents provide flexible solutions and adapt to your evolving needs. We do the same for our employees. We are process and domain experts, focused on the solutions that deliver results for our clients and our company. We offer a great work environment, professional development, challenging careers, and competitive compensation. With Preferred, there are no surprises. You can count on us to deliver on our promises and be there when you need us, as your insurance provider and your employer. Preferred Mutual is an Equal Opportunity Employer. Employment decisions are made without regard to race, color, religion, national or ethnic origin, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, age, disability, protected veteran status or other characteristics protected by law.

DISCLAIMER:

This role (job) description indicates in general terms, the type and level of work performed as well as the typical responsibilities of employees in this classification. The duties described are not to be interpreted as being all-inclusive to any specific employee. Management reserves the rights to add, modify, change or rescind the work assignments of different positions and to make reasonable accommodations so that qualified employees can perform the essential functions of the job. Nothing in this position description changes the at-will employment relationship existing between Preferred Mutual Insurance Company and its employees.

The base pay range for this position is $20.00 to $22.00 paid on an hourly basis. The rate offered to any candidate will be reflective of the candidates experience and any relevant education, certification, or qualifications related to their ability to perform the responsibilities of this position as permitted by law.

Apply