1

Nonprofit Cybersecurity Jobs in Indiana (NOW HIRING)

Our cybersecurity offerings are designed around a defense-in-depth strategy to provide a multi ... and nonprofit sectors. We focus on partnership to understand and achieve your goals, address ...

IT Technical Lead

Carmel, IN · On-site

$48K - $58K/yr

Experience in nonprofit, broadcast, camp, or education environments a plus. * Experience ... Working knowledge of industry and cybersecurity best practices through ongoing learning.

Nonprofit Cybersecurity information

What is nonprofit cybersecurity?

Nonprofit cybersecurity refers to the practices and technologies that nonprofit organizations use to protect their digital information, systems, and networks from cyber threats. Nonprofits often handle sensitive donor, client, and financial data, making them targets for cyberattacks. Effective cybersecurity helps prevent data breaches, protects organizational reputation, and ensures compliance with legal and ethical standards. Due to limited resources, nonprofits may adopt cost-effective security measures and seek partnerships or guidance to strengthen their defenses.

What are some common cybersecurity challenges faced by nonprofit organizations, and how does this role help address them?

Nonprofit organizations often operate with limited budgets and staff, which can make implementing robust cybersecurity measures challenging. Common issues include outdated technology, lack of dedicated IT personnel, and heightened risk of phishing or data breaches due to handling sensitive donor information. In a nonprofit cybersecurity role, you’ll focus on identifying vulnerabilities, training staff on security best practices, and implementing cost-effective safeguards tailored to nonprofit needs. Your work directly helps protect the organization’s reputation and the privacy of its donors, ensuring mission-critical operations continue smoothly.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive in nonprofit cybersecurity, and why are they important?

To thrive in Nonprofit Cybersecurity, you need a solid understanding of information security principles, risk management, and compliance, often backed by a degree in cybersecurity or a related field. Familiarity with security tools like firewalls, intrusion detection systems, and certifications such as CompTIA Security+ or CISSP are typically required. Strong communication, problem-solving, and a collaborative mindset help translate technical risks to non-technical stakeholders and foster a security-focused culture. These skills ensure that limited resources are effectively used to protect sensitive data and maintain trust with donors, clients, and the community.

What is the difference between Nonprofit Cybersecurity vs Nonprofit IT Specialist?

AspectNonprofit CybersecurityNonprofit IT Specialist
CertificationsCybersecurity certifications (e.g., CISSP, CompTIA Security+)IT certifications (e.g., CompTIA A+, Network+)
Work EnvironmentFocus on security measures, threat mitigation, and risk managementBroader IT support, hardware/software management, network setup
Employer & Industry UsageNonprofit organizations with a focus on data securityNonprofits needing general IT support and infrastructure
Search & Comparison IntentUnderstanding cybersecurity roles in nonprofitsGeneral IT support roles in nonprofits

Nonprofit Cybersecurity specialists focus on protecting organizational data and systems from cyber threats, requiring security-specific certifications. Nonprofit IT Specialists handle broader technology support, including hardware, software, and network management. While both roles serve nonprofit organizations, cybersecurity roles emphasize security protocols and threat mitigation, whereas IT specialists provide general technology support.

What are popular job titles related to Nonprofit Cybersecurity jobs in Indiana?

For Nonprofit Cybersecurity jobs in Indiana, the most frequently searched job titles are:

What cities in Indiana are hiring for Nonprofit Cybersecurity jobs?

Cities in Indiana with the most Nonprofit Cybersecurity job openings:

Infographic showing various Nonprofit Cybersecurity job openings in Indiana as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 100% Full Time. Highlights an 100% In-person job distribution.

Full-time

Posted 29 days ago


Job description

Description

Heritage Federal Credit Union, a Readers' Choice Best Credit Union gold award recipient, is growing thanks to the focus on helping our members and community. At Heritage, we foster a dynamic and collaborative environment where your contributions truly make a difference. As we continue to expand, we are searching for a Cybersecurity Analyst to join our amazing team!


The Cybersecurity Analyst, under the direction of the SVP Enterprise Risk Management & Information Security Officer (SVPERMISO), assists in all aspects of, and in various assignments supporting the information security, incident response, user access review, business continuity, and vendor management programs to ensure compliance with federal and state regulations specifically for information security and cybersecurity. This is a role that involves independently conducting complex investigations; analyzing, collecting, monitoring, reporting cybersecurity metrics, alerts, logs, reports, surveillance controls in alignment with regulatory and credit union expectations. Additional responsibilities include assisting in risk assessments, delivery and development of awareness training, and development and enforcement of security policies, compliance measures, and IT security data flow diagrams.


What you'll do:

  • Independently investigate alerts and security incidents, perform root cause analysis, and recommend corrective actions to SVPERMISO.
  • Support containment and recovery activities during security incidents.
  • Tune SIEM and endpoint detection tools to improve effectiveness and reduce false positives.
  • Support risk assessments, controls testing, and regulatory exams; Maintain logs and documentation for audits and NCUA exams.
  • Assist in security audits and risk assessments to identify weaknesses and recommend fixes; review vulnerability reports and prioritize remediation in collaboration with IT and business stakeholders.
  • Monitor threat intelligence and assess relevance to the credit union's environment; Research new threats, vulnerabilities, and mitigation techniques to stay proactive.
  • Assist in the production of incident reports, management metrics, and executive summaries for management and regulators.
  • Participate in tabletop exercises and incident response testing.
  • Monitor security tools (i.e. SIEM, IDS/IPS, EDR) and perform initial alert triage following documented procedures.
  • Escalate potential incidents and suspicious activity with clear documentation and timelines to SVPERMISO.
  • Assist with incident response activities, including evidence gathering and post-incident reporting.
  • Assist in the development and implementation of security awareness and required compliance training. 
  • Review user access rights and permissions based on least privilege.
  • Support the credit union in adherence to financial regulations and internal policies related to information security and cybersecurity.
  • Participate in disaster recovery and business continuity planning.
  • Maintain awareness of how security systems affect the credit union's security posture, exposure, and production environment.
  • Maintain security related data flow diagrams for the credit union.


Qualifications/Experience Required:

  • Associate degree in cybersecurity or similar area with two years of relevant work experience in related field or at least four years of direct relevant experience
  • Relevant work experience should come from at least two of the following domains: Security and Risk Management, Security Architecture and Engineering, Communication and Network Security, Identity and Access Management, Security Assessment and Testing, or Security Operations
  • Intermediate experience with SIEM, endpoint security, and log analysis.
  • Foundational knowledge of networking, operating systems, and security concepts.
  • Intermediate knowledge of FFIEC, GLBA, and NIST CSF requirements.
  • Strong documentation and communication skills
  • Exposure to cloud security monitoring and applications/software
  • Prior experience working in a regulated financial services environment
  • Strong analytical, problem solving, and critical thinking skills
  • Attention to detail
  • Ability to maintain confidentiality

About Heritage Federal Credit Union
 

Heritage Federal Credit Union is a full-service financial institution with over $1 billion in assets and serves more than 65,000+ members in Gibson, Posey, Warrick, Vanderburgh, Daviess, Knox, Spencer, Pike, Perry, Crawford, Clark, Floyd, or Harrison Counties in Indiana; or Henderson, Daviess, Hopkins, Hancock, Ohio, McLean, Webster, Union, or Crittenden Counties in Kentucky; or Lawrence, Wabash, White, Gallatin or Hardin Counties in Illinois. As a nonprofit, credit unions provide low-cost financial services to their members and are mission driven. Founded in 1965, Heritage Federal is committed to improving daily lives of those we live and work with, providing members the best financial products and services, and giving back to the local communities through donations, sponsorships, and volunteerism. More information regarding Heritage Federal Credit Union can be located at heritagefederal.org.


EOE