1

Neutral Evaluator Jobs (NOW HIRING)

next page

Showing results 1-20

Neutral Evaluator information

See salary details

$29.5K

$65.5K

$106.5K

How much do neutral evaluator jobs pay per year?

As of Jul 27, 2026, the average yearly pay for neutral evaluator in the United States is $65,471.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $44,500.00 and $79,500.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What are some typical challenges Neutral Evaluators face when facilitating dispute resolution?

Neutral Evaluators often encounter the challenge of maintaining impartiality while navigating complex, emotionally charged disputes. Balancing the interests of all parties and effectively managing communication to prevent escalation require strong interpersonal and analytical skills. Additionally, Neutral Evaluators must stay objective when assessing evidence and legal arguments, ensuring their evaluations are both fair and clear. Successful professionals in this role continuously develop their conflict resolution techniques and stay updated on relevant legal standards.

What is the difference between Neutral Evaluator vs Forensic Psychologist?

AspectNeutral EvaluatorForensic Psychologist
CredentialsTypically requires a psychology degree and relevant licensingRequires advanced psychology degrees, licensing, and specialized forensic training
Work EnvironmentLegal settings, courts, or mediation environmentsCourts, law enforcement agencies, or correctional facilities
Industry UsageUsed in legal disputes, mediations, and evaluationsInvolved in criminal cases, assessments, and expert testimony
Search & Comparison IntentUnderstanding roles in legal evaluations and mediationsFocus on criminal justice, assessments, and expert witness roles

While both roles involve psychological assessments within legal contexts, a Neutral Evaluator primarily provides impartial opinions in disputes or mediations, whereas a Forensic Psychologist conducts detailed evaluations for criminal or civil cases, often serving as expert witnesses. The key differences lie in their specific training, work environment, and the nature of their evaluations.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a Neutral Evaluator, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Neutral Evaluator, you need a strong background in legal analysis, dispute resolution, and subject matter expertise relevant to the cases you evaluate, often supported by a law degree or specialized certification. Familiarity with case management systems, legal research databases, and ADR (Alternative Dispute Resolution) platforms is typically required. Exceptional impartiality, active listening, and clear written and verbal communication are essential soft skills for building trust and accurately assessing disputes. These skills ensure fair, unbiased evaluations and facilitate efficient, effective resolution processes.

What are Neutral Evaluators?

Neutral Evaluators are impartial third-party professionals who assess disputes or claims, usually in legal or workplace contexts, to provide an unbiased opinion about the facts and merits of a case. Their role is not to make binding decisions, but to offer an objective evaluation that can help parties better understand the strengths and weaknesses of their positions. This process can facilitate settlement discussions, reduce litigation costs, and promote fair outcomes. Neutral Evaluators are often attorneys, judges, or experts in relevant fields, chosen for their expertise and neutrality.
More about Neutral Evaluator jobs
What job categories do people searching Neutral Evaluator jobs look for? The top searched job categories for Neutral Evaluator jobs are:
Infographic showing various Neutral Evaluator job openings in the United States as of July 2026, with employment types broken down into 72% Full Time, 22% Part Time, 1% Temporary, and 5% Contract. Highlights an 87% Physical, 4% Hybrid, and 9% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $65,471 per year, or $31.5 per hour.
INSURANCE ANALYST II - 43004742

INSURANCE ANALYST II - 43004742

MyFlorida

Tallahassee, FL • On-site

$51K/yr

Other

Posted 13 days ago


State Of Florida rating

6.6

Company rating: 6.6 out of 10

Based on 186 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

46th of 50 rated states


Job description

Requisition No: 879337 

Agency: Financial Services

Working Title: INSURANCE ANALYST II - 43004742

 Pay Plan: Career Service

Position Number: 43004742 

Salary:  $51,000.00 

Posting Closing Date: 07/21/2026 

Total Compensation Estimator Tool

****INTERNAL AGENCY EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY***** 

CLASS TITLE: INSURANCE ANALYST II

DIVISION: CONSUMER SERVICES

BUREAU: CONSUMER ASSISTANCE

CITY: TALLAHASSEE

COUNTY: LEON

SPECIAL NOTES:

This is an internal agency employment opportunity for current employees, including OPS, of the Department of Financial Services, the Office of Financial Regulation, and the Office of Insurance Regulation.

A high school diploma or equivalent is required.

 

Preferences:

  • A bachelor's degree from an accredited college or university preferably with major course work in insurance or risk management. 
  • One (1) year working as an insurance representative, insurance agent or an insurance adjuster for an insurance agency or insurance company. A post-secondary degree in Risk Management may be substituted for experience on a year-by-year basis.
  • Experience with mediations or neutral evaluations.

 

Minimum Qualifications for this position include the following REQUIRED ENTRY LEVEL KNOWLEDGE, SKILLS AND ABILITIES:

  • Skill in use of personal computers
  • Skill in use of Microsoft Word, Outlook and Excel
  • Ability to communicate effectively orally and in writing
  • Ability to review and retain legislation, rule chapters and Florida Statutes and apply the knowledge effectively
  • Ability to review and resolve insurance complaints from consumers and other parties
  • Ability to work well with others
  • Ability to plan, organize and coordinate work assignments

It is the agency's goal to fill multiple positions with this advertisement.

The Florida Department of Financial Services requires all employees who hold an insurance license or who have ownership in an insurance agency to place their license in a hold/abeyance status.

This position requires a security background check, including fingerprint as a condition of employment.

This position will start at the non-negotiable salary of $51,000.00 annually.

 

Employees of the Department of Financial Services are paid on a monthly pay cycle.

 

Responses to qualifying questions must be clearly supported by the state application and any omission, falsification, or misrepresentation in the answering of the qualifying questions will be cause for immediate elimination from the selection process.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DUTIES:

This position handles Alternative Dispute Resolution Program requests including commercial residential mediation, automobile mediation, continuing care retirement community (CCRC) mediation, residential mediation, and sinkhole neutral evaluation. Applies research and problem-solving techniques in order to accomplish the objectives of the Alternative Dispute Resolution Programs.

Answers questions received via incoming calls and email regarding the Alternative Dispute Resolution programs.

Provides guidance to consumers regarding the mediation or neutral evaluation process by analyzing and reasoning with information and data to make decisions and solve problems. These processes involve making decisions about the relative importance of information and choosing the best solution.

Assigns mediators and neutral evaluators for scheduling of conferences.

Oversees compliance of Rules and Statutes by the mediators and evaluators.

Ensures timely payment of administrative fees associated with the mediation program.

Ensures timely follow-up on mediation survey responses provided by consumers and/or insurance companies.

Prepares and sends written correspondence to the public and/or insurance company representatives or officials, and discusses files with attorneys, assignees, consumers, and insurance companies for the Alternative Dispute Resolution Programs. Provides insurance information and advice to the public, insurance agents, companies, adjusters and other parties as necessary.

Participates in the Alternative Dispute Resolution Program team meetings in order to provide information, review updates, and discuss implementation of new legislation.

Serves as a staff member for Automatic Call Distribution on the Alternative Dispute Resolution helpline.

Assist walk-in consumers with requests related to the Alternative Dispute Resolution programs.

Updates and maintains records in computer databases, provides reports, and performs special research assignments related to the Alternative Dispute Resolution and other Department programs

Performs other duties and responsibilities as assigned by Supervisor.

The incumbent in this position is a member of the DFS disaster response team and in that capacity may be required, on short notice, to perform duties in support of disaster relief efforts.

Candidates requiring a reasonable accommodation, as defined by the Americans with Disabilities Act, must notify the agency hiring authority and/or People First Service Center (1-866-663-4735). Notification to the hiring authority must be made in advance to allow sufficient time to provide the accommodation.

The State of Florida supports a Drug-Free workplace. All employees are subject to reasonable suspicion drug testing in accordance with Section 112.0455, F.S., Drug-Free Workplace Act.

VETERANS' PREFERENCE.  Pursuant to Chapter 295, Florida Statutes, candidates eligible for Veterans' Preference will receive preference in employment for Career Service vacancies and are encouraged to apply.  Certain service members may be eligible to receive waivers for postsecondary educational requirements.  Candidates claiming Veterans' Preference must attach supporting documentation with each submission that includes character of service (for example, DD Form 214 Member Copy #4) along with any other documentation as required by Rule 55A-7, Florida Administrative Code.  Veterans' Preference documentation requirements are available by clicking here.  All documentation is due by the close of the vacancy announcement. 


What State Of Florida employees say

Pay

Benefits

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom