1

Fraud Investigation Supervisor Jobs (NOW HIRING)

Fraud Investigator

Flint, MI · On-site

$35.60 - $39.47/hr

Interviews complainants, witnesses, employees, contractors, supervisors, and other involved parties ... Ability to successfully complete a comprehensive background investigation. Ability to obtain and ...

Fraud Investigator I

Anchorage, AK · On-site

$63K - $99K/yr

Fraud Operations Officer Functions Supervised: None Primary Functions: Carry out detailed investigations concerning potential losses and/or suspected criminal activity. Interview potential victims ...

Fraud Investigator

Tampa, FL · Hybrid

$65K - $80K/yr

Reporting to the Senior Fraud Prevention Manager (Vice President) of Fraud Operations. The ... This is a non-supervisory position, distinguished from the higher-level investigators by the ...

Fraud Investigator I

Anchorage, AK · On-site

$69K - $112K/yr

Fraud Operations Officer Functions Supervised: None Primary Functions: Carry out detailed investigations concerning potential losses and/or suspected criminal activity. Interview potential victims ...

$45K - $47K/yr

Prepares a Report of Investigation (ROI) and submits to supervisor for review, approval, and ... fraud complaint occurred, and if it did, is it non-intentional or intentional. The employee makes ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

Fraud Investigation Supervisor information

See salary details

$15

$30

$53

How much do fraud investigation supervisor jobs pay per hour?

As of Sep 10, 2026, the average hourly pay for fraud investigation supervisor in the United States is $30.83, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $22.12 and $35.34 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What does a fraud investigation supervisor do?

A Fraud Investigation Supervisor oversees a team of investigators responsible for identifying, analyzing, and resolving cases of suspected fraud within an organization. They coordinate investigations, ensure compliance with legal and regulatory standards, and develop strategies to prevent future fraudulent activities. This role also involves training staff, preparing reports, and collaborating with law enforcement or legal teams when necessary. Their leadership helps maintain the integrity of the organization's financial and operational processes.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a fraud investigation supervisor?

To thrive as a Fraud Investigation Supervisor, you need a solid background in fraud detection, investigative techniques, and knowledge of regulatory compliance, often supported by a bachelor’s degree in criminal justice or a related field. Familiarity with case management systems, data analysis tools, and certifications such as Certified Fraud Examiner (CFE) are typically required. Strong leadership, critical thinking, and effective communication skills help you manage teams and coordinate with stakeholders. These competencies ensure effective fraud prevention, thorough investigations, and protection of organizational assets.

What are some common challenges a fraud investigation supervisor faces when managing a team of investigators?

A Fraud Investigation Supervisor often encounters challenges balancing caseloads among team members and ensuring thorough, consistent investigations under tight deadlines. They must also stay updated on evolving fraud tactics and regulatory changes, providing ongoing training and support to their team. Additionally, fostering effective collaboration with other departments, such as compliance and legal, is essential for successful case resolution. Strong communication and adaptability are key to overcoming these obstacles while maintaining high investigation standards.

What is the difference between Fraud Investigation Supervisor vs Fraud Analyst?

AspectFraud Investigation SupervisorFraud Analyst
Required CredentialsBachelor's degree, fraud investigation certifications (e.g., CFE)Bachelor's degree, often certifications like CFE or ACFE
Work EnvironmentSupervisory role overseeing investigations, team managementAnalyzing data, conducting investigations, reporting findings
Employer & Industry UsageFinancial institutions, insurance companies, retailFinancial services, banking, insurance, retail
Common Search & ComparisonOften compared for leadership and oversight rolesCompared for analytical and investigative roles

The Fraud Investigation Supervisor and Fraud Analyst roles share similar credentials and industry usage, but differ mainly in responsibility level. The supervisor oversees investigation teams and manages cases, while the analyst focuses on conducting investigations and analyzing fraud patterns. Both roles are essential in fraud prevention and detection within financial and retail sectors.

What cities are hiring for Fraud Investigation Supervisor jobs?

Cities with the most Fraud Investigation Supervisor job openings:

What states have the most Fraud Investigation Supervisor jobs?

States with the most job openings for Fraud Investigation Supervisor jobs include:

What are popular job titles related to Fraud Investigation Supervisor jobs?

For Fraud Investigation Supervisor jobs, the most frequently searched job titles are:

Fraud Investigations Supervisor - Oak Ridge, NJ

Jefferson Township, NJ • On-site

Provident Bank
Commercial Banking • 201 - 500 employees

Other

Medical, Dental, Vision, Life, Retirement, PTO

Posted 12 days ago


Key responsibilities

  • Oversee and manage employee workload for case investigations of potentially fraudulent activity and support regulatory filings such as SARs.

  • Assist and support internal and external parties in fraud detection, mitigation, and compliance efforts.

  • Develop and maintain training programs to help employees and customers identify red flags and fraud schemes.


Job description

Select how often (in days) to receive an alert:

Fraud Investigations Supervisor - Oak Ridge, NJ

How would you like to join one of the most highly regarded financial institutions in New Jersey with deep roots in the community? Provident is a successful and highly regarded multi-billion-dollar bank that continues to grow with branches in New Jersey, Eastern Pennsylvania and New York. Our longevity is a testament to our commitment to placing our employees, customers, and the communities we serve at the center of all we do. At Provident Bank, we are committed to enhancing our customer and employees’ experience.

POSITION SUMMARY:

Reporting to the Fraud Manager, the Fraud Investigations Supervisor is responsible for overseeing the Fraud Investigations team and supporting investigations related to allegations of financial fraud, including check fraud, kiting, wire transfer fraud, check scams, new account fraud, identity theft, employee defalcation, financial misconduct, and loan fraud perpetrated within or against the Bank.

This role helps ensure investigations and related Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) filings are completed timely, escalated when warranted, and maintained with appropriate records and audit trails to support internal and external audits and regulatory examinations. The Fraud Investigations Supervisor maintains oversight of case portfolios, supports management reporting, provides guidance on fraud-related issues, and helps ensure individual and team performance and quality control standards are met.

KEY RESPONSIBILITIES:

  • Oversee and manage employee workload for case investigations of potentially fraudulent activity reported through various channels, including review of investigator analysis of transaction history, online logins, checks, wire activity, Zelle, and related information to support prompt and thorough investigations and regulatory filings such as SARs.
  • Assist and support internal areas of the Bank when fraud is detected in products, services, or transactions, and coordinate with external sources such as law enforcement and other financial institutions to mitigate losses and comply with subpoena and 314(b) requests.
  • Develop and maintain training programs for employees and customers to identify red flags, fraud schemes, and methods to mitigate losses and harm to the financial institution and customers.
  • Assist the Fraud Manager and BSA/Fraud Officer in developing and producing reports for Executive Management and the Board of Directors related to fraud issues, department resources, employee workload, fraud trends, system upgrade needs, significant cases, and SARs.
  • Evaluate, document, and discuss performance with employees to ensure goals are met and to foster professional development.
  • Carry out supervisory responsibilities in accordance with organizational policies, including interviewing, hiring, training and managing employees, planning and assigning work, appraising performance, rewarding and disciplining employees, and addressing employee complaints and concerns.

MINIMUM QUALIFICATIONS:

  • Four-year bachelor’s degree required, or commensurate banking experience of no less than 5 years.
  • 5+ years of banking experience combined with management and Fraud Mitigation/BSA responsibilities.
  • Excellent and proven knowledge of applicable banking laws and regulations related to fraud investigations.
  • Strong communication skills and the ability to maintain effective working relationships with executives, managers, legal staff, employees, regulators, and examiners.
  • Knowledge of general banking policies and procedures, with the ability to identify and define problems related to internal controls, policies, and procedures; collect data; establish facts; draw valid conclusions; and make appropriate recommendations for corrective action.
  • Ability to remain composed and make appropriate decisions under stressful conditions while managing a range of responsibilities and defined timetables.
  • Ability to train and supervise personnel, shift attention quickly and accurately from one matter to another, prioritize multiple projects, and complete work on time.

PREFERRED QUALIFICATIONS

  • Knowledge of fraud typologies and trends, regulatory communications, system functionality, and fraud-related reporting practices preferred.

Why Join Provident Bank?

At Provident Bank, you’ll play an important role in protecting the Bank, its customers, and the communities we serve by supporting timely, thorough, and well-documented fraud investigations. This role offers the opportunity to partner across internal Bank teams, law enforcement, other financial institutions, and regulatory stakeholders while helping strengthen fraud awareness, training, reporting, audit readiness, and loss mitigation efforts.

OTHER DUTIES:

Please note this job description is not designed to cover or contain a comprehensive listing of activities, duties or responsibilities that are required of the employee for this job. Duties, responsibilities, and activities may change at any time with or without notice. Job descriptions and duties may be modified when deemed appropriate by management.

WORKING CONDITIONS:

  • Prolonged sitting.
  • Work is performed in a normal office environment.
  • Noise levels are usually moderate.
  • May require travel between Provident offices or branches.

HAZARDS:

The hazards are mainly those present in a normal office setting and those present in commuting by car. Occasionally, this role may be exposed to conditions present in public forums and meeting places.

Provident Bank recognizes and supports the importance of creating a socially and culturally diverse employee base. We understand, value, and appreciate the unique perspectives that a diverse workforce can contribute to our organization. We put the employee and the customer at the center of strategy because culture is a critical differentiator for why people choose to work here.

We are an equal opportunity employer, and all qualified applicants will receive consideration for employment without regard to age 40 and over, color, disability, gender identity, genetic information, military or veteran status, national origin, race, religion, sex, sexual orientation or any other applicable status protected by state or local law.

$87,000 - $124,500 annually

This role is eligible to participate in an incentive plan, based upon company, business, and/or individual goal achievement and performance.

Team members accrue paid time-off (PTO), receive Holiday (PTO) and are eligible to participate in the bank’s Health and Wellness benefits including Medical, Dental and Vision Plans, Flexible and Health Savings Accounts, and a 401(k) Retirement Plan. In addition, the company provides Disability Insurance, an Employee Assistance Program, and Basic Life Insurance. Company sponsored Tuition Disbursement and Loan Repayment programs are also available. Voluntary benefits include Supplemental Life Insurance, Accident, Critical Illness, Hospital Indemnity and Legal plans.

About Provident Bank

For more than 180years, Provident Bank has served individuals, families, and businesses in our local communities with personal and business banking services.

Volunteering is a Way of Life

Our brand promise - “Commitment you can count on” - supports the investments we make in the community and donations made by our employees. It’s a promise also reflected in the volunteerism of our employees, who lend time and talent and countless hours to assist hundreds of organizations and thousands of people and animals each year.

Why do we love it?

  • We get to volunteer in areas that are meaningful to the bank and impactful in the community.
  • Through generous contributions, we have raised over $912,000 in 2022. No item or donation is too small; we find a home for it all.
#J-18808-Ljbffr