1

Fraud Investigation Supervisor Jobs (NOW HIRING)

$70K - $124K/yr

... investigation and/or for support in the evidence of the fraud and damages * Researches and responds to complex customer communications, concerns, conflicts or issues Supervisory Responsibilities

$70K - $124K/yr

... claims for investigation and/or for support in the evidence of the fraud and damages * Researches and responds to complex customer communications, concerns, conflicts or issues Supervisory ...

SIU Field Investigator

Chicago, IL · On-site

$70K - $124K/yr

... investigation and/or for support in the evidence of the fraud and damages * Researches and responds to complex customer communications, concerns, conflicts or issues Supervisory Responsibilities

SIU Field Investigator

Chicago, IL · On-site

$70K - $124K/yr

... investigation and/or for support in the evidence of the fraud and damages * Researches and responds to complex customer communications, concerns, conflicts or issues Supervisory Responsibilities

Serve as level 2 escalation for regular-high severity fraud cases, acting as l fraud investigator ... supervisors * Serve as designated SME for specific fraud processes and events * Help the Lead and ...

Showing results 41-60

Fraud Investigation Supervisor information

See salary details

$15

$30

$53

How much do fraud investigation supervisor jobs pay per hour?

As of Sep 11, 2026, the average hourly pay for fraud investigation supervisor in the United States is $30.83, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $22.12 and $35.34 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What does a fraud investigation supervisor do?

A Fraud Investigation Supervisor oversees a team of investigators responsible for identifying, analyzing, and resolving cases of suspected fraud within an organization. They coordinate investigations, ensure compliance with legal and regulatory standards, and develop strategies to prevent future fraudulent activities. This role also involves training staff, preparing reports, and collaborating with law enforcement or legal teams when necessary. Their leadership helps maintain the integrity of the organization's financial and operational processes.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a fraud investigation supervisor?

To thrive as a Fraud Investigation Supervisor, you need a solid background in fraud detection, investigative techniques, and knowledge of regulatory compliance, often supported by a bachelor’s degree in criminal justice or a related field. Familiarity with case management systems, data analysis tools, and certifications such as Certified Fraud Examiner (CFE) are typically required. Strong leadership, critical thinking, and effective communication skills help you manage teams and coordinate with stakeholders. These competencies ensure effective fraud prevention, thorough investigations, and protection of organizational assets.

What are some common challenges a fraud investigation supervisor faces when managing a team of investigators?

A Fraud Investigation Supervisor often encounters challenges balancing caseloads among team members and ensuring thorough, consistent investigations under tight deadlines. They must also stay updated on evolving fraud tactics and regulatory changes, providing ongoing training and support to their team. Additionally, fostering effective collaboration with other departments, such as compliance and legal, is essential for successful case resolution. Strong communication and adaptability are key to overcoming these obstacles while maintaining high investigation standards.

What is the difference between Fraud Investigation Supervisor vs Fraud Analyst?

AspectFraud Investigation SupervisorFraud Analyst
Required CredentialsBachelor's degree, fraud investigation certifications (e.g., CFE)Bachelor's degree, often certifications like CFE or ACFE
Work EnvironmentSupervisory role overseeing investigations, team managementAnalyzing data, conducting investigations, reporting findings
Employer & Industry UsageFinancial institutions, insurance companies, retailFinancial services, banking, insurance, retail
Common Search & ComparisonOften compared for leadership and oversight rolesCompared for analytical and investigative roles

The Fraud Investigation Supervisor and Fraud Analyst roles share similar credentials and industry usage, but differ mainly in responsibility level. The supervisor oversees investigation teams and manages cases, while the analyst focuses on conducting investigations and analyzing fraud patterns. Both roles are essential in fraud prevention and detection within financial and retail sectors.

What cities are hiring for Fraud Investigation Supervisor jobs?

Cities with the most Fraud Investigation Supervisor job openings:

What states have the most Fraud Investigation Supervisor jobs?

States with the most job openings for Fraud Investigation Supervisor jobs include:

What are popular job titles related to Fraud Investigation Supervisor jobs?

For Fraud Investigation Supervisor jobs, the most frequently searched job titles are:

SIU Field Investigator

On-site

Allstate Insurance Company
Insurance Services • 10K+ employees

$70K - $124K/yr

Other

Posted 9 days ago


Allstate Insurance rating

7.4

Company rating: 7.4 out of 10

Based on 571 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz


Job description

National General is a part of The Allstate Corporation, which means we have the same innovative drive that keeps us a step ahead of our customers’ evolving needs. We offer home, auto and accident and health insurance, as well as other specialty niche insurance products, through a large network of independent insurance agents, as well as directly to consumers.

Job Description

This job is responsible for investigating and analyzing complex, multi-discipline coverage and claims that have been referred to the special investigation unit (SIU) for potential fraud. This role typically handles a combination of complex attorney represented and unrepresented claims and moderate to complex losses, in which suspicious activity has been identified. The individual performs a thorough investigation including; (1) conducting background searches, scene investigations, and clinic inspections; (2) taking recorded statements; (3) reviewing and analyzing medical notes, bills, and property damage; and (4) conducting witness interviews and social media searches. The individual conducts surveillance on property and/or creates scene reconstructions on some investigations and reviews whether fraud can be substantiated and supports a lawsuit. The individual provides work guidance and direction to less senior employees and provides mentoring and coaching to the team.

We are seeking an experienced SIU Investigator to join our growing team! This role is responsible for conducting complex fraud investigations across multiple lines of business, including Auto, Homeowners, and Specialty Lines. This is a field-based position supporting a territory within approximately a three-hour radius of Chicago, IL. Prior investigative experience is required, with a strong preference for candidates who have a Special Investigations Unit (SIU) background and a proven track record of identifying, investigating, and resolving suspicious claims.

Key Responsibilities
  • Enters SIU claim data information into multiple SIU systems
  • Reviews investigations with fraud outcomes to validate whether denial is appropriate
  • Updates files with investigation outcome, and when no fraud or insufficient evidence is found, returns file to MCO for further handling and settlement
  • Conducts complex online data application searches, research, and evaluation
  • Conducts complex site inspections, including body shops, medical clinics, loss locations etc.
  • Conducts thorough investigations of complex that are potentially fraudulent to determine if payment is warranted, including scene investigations and surveillance as needed
  • Validates that the information provided and obtained through investigation is true and accurate and follows up on all possible leads
  • Summarizes documents and enters into claim system notes, documenting a claim file with notes, evaluations and decision-making process
  • Utilizes analytic tools or SIU field intelligence to identify complex claims for investigation and/or for support in the evidence of the fraud and damages
  • Researches and responds to complex customer communications, concerns, conflicts or issues
Supervisory Responsibilities
  • This job does not have supervisory duties.

As a requirement of employment, individuals who currently hold an active insurance license must terminate all existing appointments prior to onboarding and must not hold any outside appointments at any point during employment. Applicants seeking an adjuster role who also hold a resident producer license must formally surrender that license when instructed to by the licensing team. By proceeding with the application process, applicants acknowledge and accept these licensing requirements and agree to comply.

Skills

Analytical Thinking, Claims Processing, Critical Thinking, Evidence Gathering, Fraud Investigation, Fraud Investigations, Information Collection, Insurance Claims Investigations, Insurance Investigation, Investigative Research, Investigative Skills, Researching, Special Investigations, Time Management

Compensation

Base compensation offered for this role is:

  • Special Investigative Unit Consultant II: $62,100 - $105,300
  • Special Investigative Unit Sr Consultant I: $68,500- $117,700
  • Special Investigative Unit Sr Consultant II: $70,100 - $124,500

Annually and is based on experience and qualifications. Total compensation for this role is comprised of several factors, including the base compensation outlined above, plus incentive pay (i.e. commission, bonus, etc.) if applicable for the role.

Joining our team isn’t just a job — it’s an opportunity. One that takes your skills and pushes them to the next level. One that encourages you to challenge the status quo. One where you can shape the future of protection while supporting causes that mean the most to you. Joining our team means being part of something bigger – a winning team making a meaningful impact.

Effective July 1, 2014, under Indiana House Enrolled Act (HEA) 1242, it is against public policy of the State of Indiana and a discriminatory practice for an employer to discriminate against a prospective employee on the basis of status as a veteran by refusing to employ an applicant on the basis that they are a veteran of the armed forces of the United States, a member of the Indiana National Guard or a member of a reserve component.

National General Holdings Corp., a member of the Allstate family of companies, is headquartered in New York City. National General traces its roots to 1939, has a financial strength rating of A– (excellent) from A.M. Best, and provides personal and commercial automobile, homeowners, umbrella, recreational vehicle, motorcycle, supplemental health, and other niche insurance products. We are a specialty personal lines insurance holding company. Through our subsidiaries, we provide a variety of insurance products, including personal and commercial automobile, homeowners, umbrella, recreational vehicle, supplemental health, lender-placed and other niche insurance products.

Companies & Partners

Direct General Auto & Life, Personal Express Insurance, Century-National Insurance, ABC Insurance Agencies, NatGen Preferred, NatGen Premier, Seattle Specialty, National General Lender Services, ARS, RAC Insurance Partners, Mountain Valley Indemnity, New Jersey Skylands, Adirondack Insurance Exchange, VelaPoint, Quotit, HealthCompare, AHCP, NHIC, Healthcare Solutions Team, North Star Marketing, Euro Accident.

Benefits
  • National General Holdings Corp. is an Equal Opportunity (EO) employer – Veterans/Disabled and other protected categories.
  • All qualified applicants will receive consideration for employment regardless of any characteristic protected by law.
  • Candidates must possess authorization to work in the United States, as it is not our practice to sponsor individuals for work visas.
  • In the event you need assistance or accommodation in completing your online application, please contact NGIC main office by phone at (336) 435-2000.
  • Allstate provides a comprehensive technology setup, including a laptop, monitors, headset, keyboard, and mouse.
  • Employees eligible to work from home also receive a monthly connectivity reimbursement to help offset internet costs.
  • When working from home, you must have a dedicated, private workspace free from distractions, along with appropriate desk and seating.
  • Reliable internet is required, with minimum speeds of 50 MB download and 5 MB upload.

It is the Company’s policy to employ the best qualified individuals available for all jobs. Therefore, any discriminatory action taken on account of an employee’s ancestry, age, color, disability, genetic information, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual and reproductive health decision, marital status, medical condition, military or veteran status, national origin, race (include traits historically associated with race, including, but not limited to, hair texture and protective hairstyles), religion (including religious dress), sex, or sexual orientation that adversely affects an employee's terms or conditions of employment is prohibited. This policy applies to all aspects of the employment relationship, including, but not limited to, hiring, training, salary administration, promotion, job assignment, benefits, discipline, and separation of employment.

#J-18808-Ljbffr

What Allstate Insurance employees say

Pay

Benefits

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom


Allstate Insurance logo

About Allstate Insurance

Sourced by ZipRecruiter

We're a purpose-driven company powered by purpose-driven people. We're reinventing protection and transforming the company for our customers, communities and each other. You could play a role in our transformation. Join a 90-year-old, Fortune 100 insurance company as we challenge the status quo, champion inclusion and strengthen our communities. If being a part of that future gives you goosebumps, you've come to the right place. Reinventing the future of protection means rethinking how we work together. From marketing to claims, our employees have flexibility in how, when and where they work — whether at home, the office or both. We're creating an inclusive, diverse and equitable workplace. We encourage collaboration, support taking chances and foster a strong sense of community. Let's build a new kind of Allstate together.

Industry

Insurance services, real estate, finance and insurance and insurance agencies and brokerages

Company size

10,000+ Employees

Headquarters location

Northbrook, IL, US