1

Arbitration Analyst Jobs (NOW HIRING)

Manager, Arbitration

Matteson, IL · On-site

$74K - $111K/yr

The Arbitration Manager will oversee the day-to-day operations of an Arbitration team, providing ... Strong analytical and problem-solving skills with a focus on operational efficiency. Preferred ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

Arbitration Analyst information

See salary details

$31K

$73.3K

$130K

How much do arbitration analyst jobs pay per year?

As of Jun 9, 2026, the average yearly pay for arbitration analyst in the United States is $73,261.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $52,500.00 and $87,000.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is an Arbitration Analyst?

An Arbitration Analyst is a professional who manages and analyzes disputes, often in the financial or insurance sectors, that are resolved through arbitration rather than litigation. They review case documentation, evaluate evidence, and make recommendations or decisions based on regulatory guidelines and company policies. Arbitration Analysts may also communicate with involved parties, prepare reports, and ensure compliance with arbitration procedures. Their role helps organizations resolve conflicts efficiently and fairly without going to court.

What is the difference between Arbitration Analyst vs Litigation Specialist?

AspectArbitration AnalystLitigation Specialist
Required CredentialsBachelor's degree, certifications in dispute resolution or arbitrationBachelor's degree, legal certifications or paralegal credentials
Work EnvironmentFinancial institutions, corporate dispute departments, arbitration centersLaw firms, corporate legal departments, courts
Employer & Industry UsageUsed mainly in finance, international trade, and arbitration institutionsCommon in legal firms, corporate legal teams, and courts
Search & Comparison IntentPeople comparing roles in dispute resolution or arbitration processesIndividuals exploring legal or court-related careers

While both roles involve dispute resolution, Arbitration Analysts focus on analyzing arbitration cases, often within financial or corporate settings, whereas Litigation Specialists handle legal proceedings in courts. The roles share similar credentials but differ in work environment and industry focus.

How does an Arbitration Analyst typically interact with legal teams and other stakeholders during dispute resolution processes?

As an Arbitration Analyst, you will frequently collaborate with legal teams, claims specialists, and external parties to gather and analyze relevant documentation for dispute cases. Your role often involves synthesizing complex contractual or financial data, preparing detailed reports, and presenting findings to support arbitration proceedings. Strong communication skills are essential, as you may be called upon to clarify your analyses or provide expert input during negotiations. This collaborative environment not only sharpens your analytical abilities but also provides valuable exposure to cross-functional teamwork and the broader dispute resolution process.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an Arbitration Analyst, and why are they important?

To thrive as an Arbitration Analyst, you need strong analytical skills, attention to detail, and a background in finance, business, or law, often supported by a relevant degree. Familiarity with case management systems, arbitration platforms, and proficiency in data analysis tools like Excel are typically required. Excellent communication, problem-solving abilities, and negotiation skills help you effectively manage disputes and collaborate with stakeholders. These skills ensure accurate resolution of cases, efficiency in processing claims, and maintaining compliance with regulatory standards.
More about Arbitration Analyst jobs
What job categories do people searching Arbitration Analyst jobs look for? The top searched job categories for Arbitration Analyst jobs are:
Infographic showing various Arbitration Analyst job openings in the United States as of May 2026, with employment types broken down into 33% Full Time, and 67% Contract. Highlights an 80% Physical, 8% Hybrid, and 12% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $73,261 per year, or $35.2 per hour.
OON Mandate Arbitration Analyst

Full-time

Medical, Dental, Vision, Retirement, PTO

Posted 21 days ago


Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey rating

8.0

Company rating: 8.0 out of 10

Based on 22 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

145th of 260 rated insurance


Job description

Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey empowers our members to achieve their best health. For over 90 years, we have been New Jersey's health solutions leader driving innovations that improve health care quality, affordability, and member experience. Our members are our neighbors, our friends, and our families. It is this understanding that drives us to better serve and care for the 3.5 million people who place their trust in us. We pride ourselves on our best-in-class employees and strive to maintain an innovative and inclusive environment that allows them to thrive. When our employees bring their best and succeed, the Company succeeds.

About the Role

The Out of Network (OON) Mandate Arbitration Analyst will be responsible for researching, investigating and coordinating of document collections as well as preparing a summary of information related to Executive/Regulatory complaints, litigation, legal requests and other inquiries received related to the No Surprises Act (NSA). The OON Mandate Analyst will need to work with a variety of internal departments to prepare fulsome analysis for the assigned Paralegal (including outside counsel) and Executive/Regulatory team members.

What You'll Do

Job Responsibilities:

  • Prepare factual investigation files and research summary including root cause summary analysis as outlined on Litigation Document, Subpoena Request, Administrative Law Case Request, Commission Appeals/2nd Level Administrative appeals and NSA files (and/or other outside agency research request).
  • Analysis of data including but not limited to claim charts, medical authorizations, call records, provider requests, appeals, complaints, correspondence and other documents related to the requested case.
  • Summarize a justification for the legal, Exec/Reg, or other department regarding Horizon's claim handling, including but not limited to member benefits, contracts, payment methodology, mandate policies and procedures.
  • Provide reports as needed for the case. May include requests for informatics reports.
  • Search and review all phone calls (listening to each to determine how the call was handled) related to the case and summarize findings.
  • Request and provide copies of relevant documents, including but not limited to: Summary Plan Documents and Contracts, NSA negotiation and/or arbitration documents.
  • Review contracts for appropriate application of benefits/mandates.
  • Assess cause of complaint/appeal/legal case and determines the root cause of errors. Shares root cause with the appropriate Service Teams for re-education.
  • Recommends actions to the legal department on LDR cases based on case file review, i.e., overturn a denial due to an authorization that was on file, or claim payment that was not made correctly.
  • Other duties as assigned or needed by the Legal Department, by the Commission, Department of Banking and Insurance and/or another agency.
  • Attendance at Deposition Hearings, Administrative Law Hearings, Commission Meetings and other outside Committee meetings requiring subject matter expertise by the preparer of the files.

What You Bring

Education/Experience:

  • High School Diploma/GED required
  • Requires seven years of business experience which must include 4+ years of correspondence and/or telephone customer service experience screening, investigating and examining inquiries.
  • In lieu of seven years of experience, Bachelor's and 4+ years of correspondence and/or telephone customer service experience screening, investigating and examining inquiries is acceptable.
  • Healthcare industry experience required.
  • Experience in complex claims processing necessary.
  • Prior OON Mandate, Complaint/appeals handling experience preferred.
  • Ability to navigate various claims and service operations systems to obtain the necessary case information.

Knowledge:

  • Knowledge of OON State and Federal Mandates required
  • Knowledge of HBCBSNJ complaints and appeals process preferred
  • Knowledge of insurance claim and membership systems required
  • Knowledge of medical terminology, COB, Medicare procedures required
  • Knowledge of NCompass and Nasco required
  • Knowledge of Claims Policy guidelines required
  • Must be proficient in the use of personal computers and supporting software in a Windows based environment, including MS Office products, (Word, Excel, PowerPoint and Outlook).

Skills and Abilities:

  • Requires the ability to understand and use language correctly
  • Requires the ability to read, understand and interpret written materials.
  • Requires the ability to analyze information and to understand and apply rules and procedures
  • Strong verbal and written communication including the ability to clearly communicate technical information to all levels of internal management and external stakeholder
  • Must be able to detail member/provider-specific issues through the development of individual correspondence for each case explaining all issues in a comprehensive, understandable fashion
  • Excellent interpersonal skills (i.e. active listening)
  • Strong research, investigative, analytical and problem solving skills
  • Requires the ability to handle confidential, proprietary, and privileged information with total discretion.
  • Ability to multitask
  • Time management skills

Travel:

  • Some travel may be required.

Why Horizon?

At Horizon, you'll do meaningful work that directly improves lives-while being supported by a missiondriven organization that values expertise, collaboration, and growth. We believe that when our people thrive, our communities do too. If you are passionate about making an impact, we'd love to hear from you!

Salary Range:

$70,500 - $94,395

This compensation range is specific to the job level and takes into account the wide range of factors that are considered in making compensation decisions, including but not limited to: education, experience, licensure, certifications, geographic location, and internal equity. This range has been created in good faith based on information known to Horizon at the time of posting. Compensation decisions are dependent on the circumstances of each case. Horizon also provides a comprehensive compensation and benefits package which includes:

  • Comprehensive health benefits (Medical/Dental/Vision)

  • Retirement Plans

  • Generous PTO

  • Incentive Plans

  • Wellness Programs

  • Paid Volunteer Time Off

  • Tuition Reimbursement

Disclaimer:

Horizon BCBSNJ employees must live in New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Connecticut or Delaware. This job summary has been designed to indicate the general nature and level of work performed by colleagues within this classification. It is not designed to contain or be interpreted as a comprehensive inventory of all duties, responsibilities, and qualifications required of colleagues assigned to this job.

Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey is an Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action employer. All qualified applicants will receive consideration for employment without regard to race, color, religion, sex, national origin, sexual orientation, gender identity, protected veteran status or status as an individual with a disability and any other protected class as required by federal, state or local law. Horizon will consider reasonable accommodation requests as part of the recruiting and hiring process.


What Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey employees say

Pay

Benefits

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom