ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Substitute Teacher Jobs in Rutherford, NJ (NOW HIRING)

Metuchen School District

Substitute Teacher

Metuchen, NJ · On-site

$280/day

Substitute/Substitute Teacher Date Posted: 10/15/2025 Location: All schools, all grade levels as needed Date Available: 10/15/2025Daily substitute teachers needed! Please include Cover Letter with ...

Wyckoff Public Schools

Substitute Teacher

Wyckoff, NJ · On-site

Substitute/Substitute Teacher Date Posted: 1/8/2022 Location: Board of Education Office Description: Substitute Teacher Job Summary: Provide instruction to assigned students in keeping with the ...

Bogota School District

Substitute Teacher

Bogota, NJ · On-site

Substitute Teacher An ESS substitute teacher assists with classroom instruction in the absence of a regular teacher. This person follows and teaches lesson plans, aids students in understanding ...

Bayonne School District

Substitute Teacher

Bayonne, NJ · On-site

Substitute Teacher An ESS substitute teacher assists with classroom instruction in the absence of a regular teacher. This person follows and teaches lesson plans, aids students in understanding ...

Lodi Public Schools

Substitute Teacher

Lodi, NJ · On-site

Substitute Teacher An ESS substitute teacher assists with classroom instruction in the absence of a regular teacher. This person follows and teaches lesson plans, aids students in understanding ...

Linden Public Schools

Substitute Teacher

Linden, NJ · On-site

Substitute Teacher An ESS substitute teacher assists with classroom instruction in the absence of a regular teacher. This person follows and teaches lesson plans, aids students in understanding ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsSubstitute Teacher JobsSubstitute Teacher Jobs in Rutherford, NJ

Substitute Teacher information

See Rutherford, NJ salary details

$19.4K

$43.1K

$70.3K

How much do substitute teacher jobs pay per year?

As of Jun 14, 2026, the average yearly pay for substitute teacher in Rutherford, NJ is $43,065.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $31,600.00 and $51,000.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What are some common challenges substitute teachers face, and how can they effectively manage them?

Substitute teachers often encounter challenges such as unfamiliar classroom environments, varying lesson plans, and managing students they have not met before. To handle these situations effectively, substitutes should arrive early to review lesson materials, establish clear expectations with students at the start of the day, and be flexible in adapting to different teaching styles and classroom routines. Building quick rapport and maintaining clear communication with both students and staff can help ensure a successful and productive day.

What do you need to be a substitute teacher?

To become a substitute teacher, applicants typically need a high school diploma or equivalent, a criminal background check, and often a substitute teaching license or certification issued by the state's education department. Some districts may require additional training or coursework in education or classroom management.

Who pays the most for substitute teachers?

Pay rates for substitute teachers vary by region, school district, and level of education or certification. Generally, districts in urban or high-cost areas tend to offer higher pay, and substitutes with specialized skills or certifications may earn more. Some states or districts also provide additional stipends for long-term or high-need assignments.

What is required to be a substitute teacher?

To become a substitute teacher, applicants in Ohio must hold at least a high school diploma or equivalent and complete a substitute teacher training program approved by the Ohio Department of Education. They also need to pass a background check and may be required to obtain a substitute teaching license or permit, depending on district requirements.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a Substitute Teacher, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Substitute Teacher, you generally need a bachelor's degree (often in education or a related field), a substitute teaching permit or certification, and a solid understanding of classroom management. Familiarity with digital classroom tools, student information systems, and educational platforms like Google Classroom is often required. Flexibility, strong communication, and the ability to quickly build rapport with students are standout soft skills in this role. These abilities are crucial for maintaining a productive learning environment and ensuring continuity of instruction when the regular teacher is absent.

What is needed to be a substitute teacher in CA?

To become a substitute teacher in California, applicants must hold at least a high school diploma or equivalent, complete a substitute teacher training program, and pass a background check. Some districts may require additional certification or fingerprinting, and having good communication skills and classroom management abilities is important for success in the role.

What is the difference between Substitute Teacher vs Classroom Teacher?

AspectSubstitute TeacherClassroom Teacher
CredentialsHigh school diploma or equivalent; some states require substitute teaching certificationBachelor's degree; state certification/license required
Work EnvironmentTemporary, short-term assignments in various classroomsFull-time, ongoing teaching in a specific classroom
Employer & IndustrySchool districts, substitute staffing agenciesSchool districts, private schools

Substitute teachers fill in for classroom teachers on a temporary basis, often with minimal preparation, while classroom teachers have a permanent role with ongoing responsibilities and curriculum planning. Both roles require similar basic credentials, but substitute teachers typically work on short-term assignments, whereas classroom teachers have a continuous presence in their classrooms.

What Does a Substitute Teacher Do?

A substitute teacher is a trained, certified, and background-checked education professional who teaches in place of another teacher who is unable to work on a particular day or for a duration of time. Substitutes are often needed in cases of illness, medical leave, or family emergencies. Substitute teachers follow the lesson plan and use supplies, education materials, and teacher-created materials left by the regular teacher. Substitute teachers are tasked with maintaining order and student productivity with as little disruption as possible.

What does a substitute teacher do?

A substitute teacher temporarily takes over classroom instruction when the regular teacher is absent. They follow lesson plans left by the regular teacher, manage classroom behavior, and ensure students remain engaged with their assignments. Substitute teachers may work in different grade levels and subject areas, adapting quickly to new classroom environments. Their main goal is to maintain continuity in students' education during the teacher's absence.
More about Substitute Teacher jobs
What are the most commonly searched types of Substitute Teacher jobs in Rutherford, NJ? The most popular types of Substitute Teacher jobs in Rutherford, NJ are:
What job categories do people searching Substitute Teacher jobs in Rutherford, NJ look for? The top searched job categories for Substitute Teacher jobs in Rutherford, NJ are:
What cities near Rutherford, NJ are hiring for Substitute Teacher jobs? Cities near Rutherford, NJ with the most Substitute Teacher job openings:
Substitute Teacher jobs near you

Substitute Teacher

Metuchen School District

Metuchen, NJ • On-site

$280/day

Full-time

Posted yesterday

Job description

Position Type:
Substitute/Substitute Teacher
Date Posted:
10/15/2025
Location:
All schools, all grade levels as needed
Date Available:
10/15/2025Daily substitute teachers needed! Please include Cover Letter with your application - just let us know what you are currently doing and why you want to sub, thanks!
25-26 School Year Pay Rates
$115/day - Substitute with 30+ college credits
$120/day - Substitute with bachelor's degree (no teacher cert)
$125/day - NJ Teacher Certification
$105/day - Paraprofessional Substitute
$16/hour - Secretary Substitute
$16/hour - Custodian Substitute
$210/day - Nurse Substitute
$280/day - 1:1 Nurse Substitute
Benefits not included with this position
Upon submission of your application, please email Carolyn Taylor, Personnel Coordinator, at ctaylor@metboe.k12.nj.us to alert her of a new candidate thank you!

Apply