ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Night Shift Manager Jobs in Indiana (NOW HIRING)

Steak 'n Shake

NIght Shift Manager

Fort Wayne, IN · On-site

$16/hr

Night Shift Manager - Steak 'n Shake - Paying up to $16 per hour! At Steak 'n Shake, we don't just compete on pay - we lead the market. We are a Maximum Wage Employer , paying the highest hourly ...

Subway - 13088-0

Night Shift Manager

Edinburgh, IN · On-site

$13 - $15/hr

As part of the Subway ® Team, you as a Shift Manager will focus on six main things: * Providing an excellent guest experience * Ensuring that great food is prepared & served * Keeping our ...

Dunkin

Night Shift Manager

Chesterton, IN · On-site

$12 - $16.25/hr

They assist in the development of Crew and Shift Leaders and fulfill accountabilities assigned by the Restaurant Manager. Competencies: Great Focus: Understands and exceeds guest expectations, needs ...

Dunkin'

Night Shift Manager

Chesterton, IN · On-site

$15 - $20/hr

They assist in the development of Crew and Shift Leaders and fulfill accountabilities assigned by the Restaurant Manager. Competencies: Great Focus: * Understands and exceeds guest expectations ...

Dunkin

Night Shift Manager

Valparaiso, IN · On-site

$10.75 - $14.50/hr

They assist in the development of Crew and Shift Leaders and fulfill accountabilities assigned by the Restaurant Manager. Competencies: Great Focus: Understands and exceeds guest expectations, needs ...

Dunkin'

Night Shift Manager

Valparaiso, IN · On-site

$15 - $20/hr

They assist in the development of Crew and Shift Leaders and fulfill accountabilities assigned by the Restaurant Manager. Competencies: Great Focus: * Understands and exceeds guest expectations ...

Dunkin'

Night Shift Manager

Valparaiso, IN · On-site

$15 - $20/hr

They assist in the development of Crew and Shift Leaders and fulfill accountabilities assigned by the Restaurant Manager. Competencies: Great Focus: * Understands and exceeds guest expectations ...

Dunkin

Night Shift Manager

Valparaiso, IN · On-site

$10.75 - $14.50/hr

They assist in the development of Crew and Shift Leaders and fulfill accountabilities assigned by the Restaurant Manager. Competencies: Great Focus: Understands and exceeds guest expectations, needs ...

NewDay

Night Shift Residential Shift

Bloomfield, IN · On-site

$28K - $35K/yr

Overview: Night shift personal are entrusted to spearhead our efforts in bringing hope, healing ... Record all incidents and communicate them to the management. * Maintain a professional and high ...

Palmer-Donavin

Night Shift Operations Supervisor

Bluffton, IN · On-site

$11.50 - $15.50/hr

This role oversees nightly workflow, assigns tasks, and manages the performance and development of the night shift team. The supervisor works closely with operations leadership and other departments ...

Checkers & Rally's

Shift Manager Late Night

Evansville, IN

$12.25 - $16.25/hr

The Shift Manager will support the restaurant and General Manager to ensure we are 1st Choice for our Guests and Employees. HOW YOU MAKE A DIFFERENCE EVERYDAY * Building sales and profits by ...

Checkers & Rally's

Shift Manager Late Night

Seymour, IN

$11 - $14.75/hr

The Shift Manager will support the restaurant and General Manager to ensure we are 1st Choice for our Guests and Employees. HOW YOU MAKE A DIFFERENCE EVERYDAY * Building sales and profits by ...

Checkers & Rally's

Shift Manager Late Night

Madison, IN

$11.75 - $15.50/hr

The Shift Manager will support the restaurant and General Manager to ensure we are 1st Choice for our Guests and Employees. HOW YOU MAKE A DIFFERENCE EVERYDAY * Building sales and profits by ...

Steak 'n Shake

Shift Manager

Fort Wayne, IN · On-site

$12.25 - $15.75/hr

Night Shift Manager - Steak 'n Shake - Paying up to $16 perhour! At Steak 'n Shake, we don't just compete on pay - welead the market. We are a Maximum Wage Employer ,paying the highest hourly rates ...

Chick-fil-A

Front of House Manager (PM)

Carmel, IN

$21 - $24/hr

Full-Time Manager (Night Shift) $21.00-$24.00/hour | Full-Time | Sundays Off, Every Week Ready to lead a team that runs like clockwork and takes real pride in what they do? We're looking for a Night ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsShift JobsNight Shift Manager JobsNight Shift Manager Jobs in Indiana

Night Shift Manager information

See Indiana salary details

$7

$14

$25

How much do night shift manager jobs pay per hour?

As of Aug 26, 2026, the average hourly pay for night shift manager in Indiana is $14.48, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $11.68 and $15.58 per hour, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is a night shift manager?

Night Shift Managers are supervisors responsible for overseeing operations, staff, and safety during the nighttime hours in various industries such as hospitality, manufacturing, healthcare, or retail. Their duties typically include managing employees, handling emergencies, ensuring tasks are completed efficiently, and maintaining security. They often act as the main point of contact for any issues that arise during the night shift and are expected to enforce company policies and procedures. A successful Night Shift Manager must have strong leadership and problem-solving skills, as well as the ability to work independently.

What are some common challenges faced by a night shift manager, and how can they be addressed?

Night Shift Managers often encounter challenges such as managing a smaller team, handling unexpected issues with limited support, and ensuring staff engagement during late hours. To address these, strong communication and proactive planning are key, as is fostering a supportive team culture to maintain morale. Additionally, regular check-ins with day-shift counterparts help ensure smooth handovers and continuity in operations.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a night shift manager, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Night Shift Manager, you generally need strong leadership abilities, experience in operations or logistics management, and a relevant educational background such as a degree in business or management. Familiarity with scheduling software, incident reporting systems, and safety compliance tools is essential for overseeing night operations. Excellent communication, problem-solving, and conflict resolution skills help you manage diverse teams and handle unexpected challenges. These competencies are crucial for maintaining productivity, safety, and effective team performance during off-hours.

What is the difference between Night Shift Manager vs Night Supervisor?

AspectNight Shift ManagerNight Supervisor
ResponsibilitiesOversees entire night operations, manages staff, handles escalationsSupervises shift staff, ensures tasks are completed, reports issues
CredentialsTypically requires management experience, sometimes certificationsOften requires supervisory experience, sometimes certifications
Work EnvironmentIncludes administrative tasks, decision-making, team leadershipFocuses on direct supervision, operational oversight
Industry UsageCommon in retail, manufacturing, logisticsCommon in retail, hospitality, warehouses

While both roles involve overseeing night operations, the Night Shift Manager has broader responsibilities, including strategic decision-making and staff management, whereas the Night Supervisor focuses on supervising shift activities and ensuring operational tasks are completed efficiently.

What does a night shift manager do?

A night shift manager oversees operations during overnight hours, ensuring staff performance, safety, and productivity. They handle scheduling, resolve issues, and maintain compliance with company policies, often using management tools and reporting to higher management.

What's the best night shift manager job?

The best night shift manager jobs are typically in industries like manufacturing, healthcare, or logistics, where 24-hour operations are essential. These roles often require strong leadership, organizational skills, and experience with scheduling and safety protocols, with some positions offering higher pay or additional shift differentials for overnight work.

What are the most commonly searched types of Night Shift jobs in Indiana?

The most popular types of Night Shift jobs in Indiana are:

What are popular job titles related to Night Shift Manager jobs in Indiana?

For Night Shift Manager jobs in Indiana, the most frequently searched job titles are:

What job categories do people searching Night Shift Manager jobs in Indiana look for?

The top searched job categories for Night Shift Manager jobs in Indiana are:

What cities in Indiana are hiring for Night Shift Manager jobs?

Cities in Indiana with the most Night Shift Manager job openings:

Night Shift Manager jobs near you
Infographic showing various Night Shift Manager job openings in Indiana as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 85% Full Time, 13% Part Time, and 2% Contract. Highlights an 83% Physical, 2% Hybrid, and 15% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $30,112 per year, or $14.5 per hour.

NIght Shift Manager

Fort Wayne, IN

Steak 'n Shake Meijer Dr. Ft. Wayne
See more jobs at Steak 'n Shake Meijer Dr. Ft. Wayneexternal

$16/hr

Full-time

Re-posted 15 days ago

Job description

Night Shift Manager – Steak ’n Shake - Paying up to $16 per hour!

At Steak ’n Shake, we don’t just compete on pay — we lead the market.  We are a Maximum Wage Employer, paying the highest hourly rates within 25 miles of our restaurants - plus unique bonus pay options! 

On top of paying up to $16 per hour we offer unique perks like:  

    Perks

    • Flexible Scheduling
    • Meal Discounts
    • Paid Training
    • Next Day Pay – receive up to 50% of your prior day’s earned wages

    * Benefits are subject to service 

    What You Will Do:

    • Lead daily restaurant operations with energy, confidence, and accountability
    • Ensure strong openings and closings by setting up the team for success
    • Set the tone for the shift—motivate and coach team members for success
    • Deliver fast, friendly, and accurate service that exceeds guest expectations
    • Ensure all brand standards are met - cleanliness, food safety, and quality
    • Handle opening and closing duties, including key-holder responsibilities
    • Count drawers, manage deposits, and finalize end-of-day reports
    • Communicate clearly and respectfully with guests and team members
    • Support training and onboarding of new team members
    • Foster a positive, team-oriented environment built on trust and respect
    • Step into any station as needed to keep operations running smoothly

    What We’re Looking For

    • Proven reliability and professionalism
    • Positive, servant-leadership attitude
    • Strong people skills with a passion for mentoring others
    • Commitment to exceptional guest service
    • Ability to thrive in a fast-paced environment
    • Effective communicator—both verbal and written
    • Detail-oriented, organized, and adaptable
    • Ability to manage team member performance with fairness and empathy
    • Flexible availability including nights, weekends, and holidays
    • Reliable transportation
    • Prior experience in a supervisory, shift lead, or restaurant management role preferred
    • US work authorization
    • High School Diploma or equivalent

    Ready to lead with purpose, serve with pride, and grow with us? Apply today and help us carry on Steak ’n Shake’s legacy of premium burgers, hand-crafted shakes, and legendary hospitality.


    We use eVerify to confirm U.S. Employment eligibility.