1

Litigation Manager Jobs in Montclair, NJ (NOW HIRING)

Manage a docket of active litigation and arbitration matters involving Whatnot sellers and buyers end-to-end: driving litigation and resolution strategy, coordinating with outside counsel, reviewing ...

Showing results 41-60

Litigation Manager information

See Montclair, NJ salary details

$49.9K

$101.9K

$165.1K

How much do litigation manager jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 21, 2026, the average yearly pay for litigation manager in Montclair, NJ is $101,929.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $68,800.00 and $124,800.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What does a litigation manager do?

A Litigation Manager is responsible for overseeing and coordinating all aspects of legal disputes and lawsuits for an organization or law firm. Their duties typically include managing legal teams, developing case strategies, supervising litigation processes, and ensuring compliance with relevant laws and regulations. They also work closely with attorneys, clients, and other stakeholders to prepare for court proceedings, negotiate settlements, and monitor case progress. Effective Litigation Managers possess strong organizational, communication, and analytical skills to handle complex legal matters efficiently.

What does a litigation manager do?

A litigation manager works on civil lawsuits for a company. They may help defend the company against civil suits, or bring cases against others on behalf of the company. They are typically, but not always, a lawyer themselves with legal experience in civil litigation. Responsibilities may include managing a team of in-house attorneys, paralegals, or legal assistants. Alternatively or additionally, the litigation manager might oversee outside legal representation. They are also consulted before business decisions to help protect the company from potential lawsuits. Job duties include managing caseloads and coordinating technological support. In large legal firms, litigation managers head the litigation department and are responsible for assigning cases and supervising work. This career typically exists in large companies or law firms. The typical education qualification is a bachelor’s degree in a related field. Many litigation managers are practicing or retired attorneys. Skills in information technology, document management systems, and trial representation are essential. Additionally, this job requires strong communication skills to interact with attorneys and staff.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a litigation manager, and why are they important?

To thrive as a Litigation Manager, you need a solid background in law, strong analytical abilities, and experience managing legal cases, generally supported by a law degree and relevant licensure. Familiarity with case management software, e-discovery tools, and legal research databases is crucial for effectively handling complex litigation processes. Exceptional organizational skills, leadership, and clear communication are important soft skills for coordinating legal teams and liaising with clients. These skills ensure efficient case management, successful outcomes, and strong client relationships in high-pressure legal environments.

What are some common challenges faced by a litigation manager, and how can they be effectively addressed?

Litigation Managers often face challenges such as managing multiple complex cases simultaneously, ensuring clear communication among diverse legal teams, and keeping up with changing legal regulations. Effective organization, strong leadership, and the use of case management software can help streamline workflows and keep cases on track. Additionally, fostering open communication with attorneys, paralegals, and clients is crucial for navigating unexpected developments and achieving successful outcomes.

What is the difference between Litigation Manager vs Litigation Paralegal?

AspectLitigation ManagerLitigation Paralegal
CredentialsBachelor's degree, legal or management certification often preferredAssociate's degree or paralegal certification
Work EnvironmentOversees legal teams, manages case strategies, interacts with attorneysSupports attorneys by preparing documents, conducting research, managing case files
Employer & Industry UsageLaw firms, corporate legal departments, litigation support companiesLaw firms, legal departments, litigation support firms

The main difference between a Litigation Manager and a Litigation Paralegal lies in their responsibilities and seniority. Litigation Managers oversee case strategies and manage legal teams, requiring management skills and experience. Litigation Paralegals assist attorneys with case preparation and document management, focusing on support tasks. Both roles are essential in litigation but differ in scope and level of responsibility.

What are the most commonly searched types of Litigation jobs in Montclair, NJ?

The most popular types of Litigation jobs in Montclair, NJ are:

What job categories do people searching Litigation Manager jobs in Montclair, NJ look for?

The top searched job categories for Litigation Manager jobs in Montclair, NJ are:

What cities near Montclair, NJ are hiring for Litigation Manager jobs?

Cities near Montclair, NJ with the most Litigation Manager job openings:

Infographic showing various Litigation Manager job openings in Montclair, NJ as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 90% Full Time, 5% Part Time, and 5% Contract. Highlights an 72% In-person, 14% Hybrid, and 14% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $101,929 per year, or $49 per hour.

Senior Liability Litigation Specialist

Travelers

Morristown, NJ

$94K - $155K/yr

Full-time

Medical, Life, Retirement, PTO

Re-posted 15 days ago


Travelers Insurance rating

8.9

Company rating: 8.9 out of 10

Based on 176 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

46th of 311 rated insurance


Job description

Who Are We?

Taking care of our customers, our communities and each other. That’s the Travelers Promise. By honoring this commitment, we have maintained our reputation as one of the best property casualty insurers in the industry for over 170 years. Join us to discover a culture that is rooted in innovation and thrives on collaboration. Imagine loving what you do and where you do it.

Compensation Overview

The annual base salary range provided for this position is a nationwide market range and represents a broad range of salaries for this role across the country. The actual salary for this position will be determined by a number of factors, including the scope, complexity and location of the role; the skills, education, training, credentials and experience of the candidate; and other conditions of employment. As part of our comprehensive compensation and benefits program, employees are also eligible for performance-based cash incentive awards.

Salary Range

$94,400.00 - $155,800.00

Target Openings

3

What Is the Opportunity?

Under general supervision, this position is responsible for investigating, evaluating, reserving, negotiating and resolving assigned Specialty Liability Bodily Injury and Property Damage claims. Provides quality claim handling throughout the claim life cycle (customer contacts, coverage, investigation, evaluation, reserving, litigation management, negotiation and resolution) including maintaining full compliance with internal and external quality standards and state specific regulations. Provides consulting and training resources, and serves as a contact and technical resource to the field and our business partners. This job does not manage staff.
This role is eligible for a sign on bonus.

What Will You Do?

  • Directly handles assigned severity claims.
  • Provides quality customer service and ensures quality and timely coverage analysis and communication with insured based on application of policy information to facts or allegations of each case.
  • Consults with Manager on use of Claim Coverage Counsel as needed.
  • Directly investigates each claim through prompt and strategically-appropriate contact with appropriate parties such as policyholders, accounts, claimants, law enforcement agencies, witnesses, agents, medical providers and technical experts to determine the extent of liability, damages, and contribution potential. Interview witnesses and stakeholders; take necessary statements, as strategically appropriate.
  • Actively engages in the identification, selection and direction of appropriate internal and/or external resources for specific activities required to effectively evaluate claims, such as Subrogation, Risk Control, nurse consultants, and fire or fraud investigators, and other experts.
  • Verifies the nature and extent of injury or property damage by obtaining and reviewing appropriate records and damage documentation.
  • Maintains claim files and documents claim file activities in accordance with established procedures.
  • Utilizes evaluation documentation tools in accordance with department guidelines.
  • Proactively creates Claim File Analysis (CFA) for adherence to quality standards.
  • Utilizes diary management system to ensure that all claims are handled timely.
  • At required time intervals, evaluate liability & damages exposure.
  • Establishes and maintains proper indemnity and expense reserves.
  • Recommends appropriate cases for discussion at roundtable.
  • Attends and/or present at roundtables/ authority discussions for collaboration of technical expertise resulting in improved payout on indemnity and expense.
  • Actively and enthusiastically shares experience and knowledge of creative resolution techniques to improve the claim results of others.
  • Applies the Company's claim quality management protocols and Best Practices to all claims; documents the rationale for any departure from applicable protocols with or without assistance.
  • Develops and employ creative resolution strategies.
  • Responsible for prompt and proper disposition of all claims within delegated authority.
  • Negotiates disposition of claims with insureds and claimants or their legal representatives.
  • Recognizes and implements alternate means of resolution.
  • Manages litigated claims. Develops litigation plan with staff or panel counsel, including discovery and legal expenses, to assure effective resolution and to satisfy customers.
  • Applies litigation management through the selection of counsel, evaluation and direction of claim and litigation strategy,
  • Tracks and controls legal expenses to assure cost-effective resolution.
  • Effectively and efficiently manage both allocated and unallocated loss adjustment expenses.
  • Perform other duties as assigned.

What Will Our Ideal Candidate Have?

  • Bachelor's Degree.
  • Advanced level knowledge in coverage, contract interpretation, liability and damages analysis and has a thorough understanding of the litigation process, relevant case and statutory law and expert litigation management skills.
  • Extensive claim and/or legal experience and technical expertise to evaluate severe and complex claims.
  • Able to make independent decisions on most assigned cases without involvement of supervisor.
  • Thorough understanding of business line products, policy language, exclusions, ISO forms, and effective claims handling practices.
  • Analytical Thinking - Advanced.
  • Judgment/Decision Making - Advanced.
  • Communication - Advanced.
  • Negotiation - Advanced.
  • Insurance Contract.
  • Knowledge - Advanced.
  • Principles of Investigation - Advanced.
  • Value Determination - Advanced.
  • Settlement Techniques - Advanced.
  • Legal Knowledge - Advanced.
  • Medical Knowledge - Intermediate.

What is a Must Have?

  • High School Degree or GED.
  • 3 years of liability claim handling experience and/or comparable litigation claim experience.
  • In order to perform the essential job functions of this job, acquisition and maintenance of Insurance License(s) may be required to comply with state and Travelers requirements.
  • Generally, license(s) are required to be obtained within three months of starting the job.

What Is in It for You?

  • Health Insurance: Employees and their eligible family members – including spouses, domestic partners, and children – are eligible for coverage from the first day of employment.
  • Retirement: Travelers matches your 401(k) contributions dollar-for-dollar up to your first 5% of eligible pay, subject to an annual maximum. If you have student loan debt, you can enroll in the Paying it Forward Savings Program. When you make a payment toward your student loan, Travelers will make an annual contribution into your 401(k) account. You are also eligible for a Pension Plan that is 100% funded by Travelers.
  • Paid Time Off: Start your career at Travelers with a minimum of 20 days Paid Time Off annually, plus nine paid company Holidays.
  • Wellness Program: The Travelers wellness program is comprised of tools, discounts and resources that empower you to achieve your wellness goals and caregiving needs. In addition, our mental health program provides access to free professional counseling services, health coaching and other resources to support your daily life needs.
  • Volunteer Encouragement: We have a deep commitment to the communities we serve and encourage our employees to get involved. Travelers has a Matching Gift and Volunteer Rewards program that enables you to give back to the charity of your choice.

Employment Practices

Travelers is an equal opportunity employer. We value the unique abilities and talents each individual brings to our organization and recognize that we benefit in numerous ways from our differences. 

In accordance with local law, candidates seeking employment in Colorado are not required to disclose dates of attendance at or graduation from educational institutions.

If you are a candidate and have specific questions regarding the physical requirements of this role, please send us an email so we may assist you.

Travelers reserves the right to fill this position at a level above or below the level included in this posting.

To learn more about our comprehensive benefit programs please visit http://careers.travelers.com/life-at-travelers/benefits/.


What Travelers Insurance employees say

Pay

Benefits

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom


Travelers logo

About Travelers

Sourced by ZipRecruiter

We are an insurance company that cares. Travelers takes on the risk and provides the coverage you need to protect the things that are important to you — your home, your car, your valuables and your business — so you don’t have to worry. We have been around for more than 165 years and have earned a reputation as one of the best property casualty insurers in the industry because we take care of our customers. Our expertise and focus on innovation have made us a leader in personal, business and specialty insurance and the only property casualty company in the Dow Jones Industrial Average. Every day, our approximately 30,000 employees and 13,500 independent agents and brokers in the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom and Ireland help provide peace of mind to our customers.

Industry

Insurance services

Company size

10,000+ Employees

Headquarters location

New York, NY, US

Year founded

1853