1

Litigation Claims Manager Jobs in Ohio (NOW HIRING)

As a Liability Claims Manager, you will lead a team of casualty claim adjusters handling first and ... Manage litigated inventory in partnership with defense counsel, including litigation plans, budgets ...

As a Liability Claims Manager, you will lead a team of casualty claim adjusters handling first and ... Manage litigated inventory in partnership with defense counsel, including litigation plans, budgets ...

Casualty Claims Manager

Wooster, OH · On-site

$94 - $145/hr

Description The Casualty Claims Manager coaches and develops a team of 5-8 internal and external ... Participate in monthly reviews of litigation and complex files with in-house counsel, VP Claim, AVP ...

Present recommendations to the Assistant General Counsel - Claims & Litigation for matters ... This position will manage 1-5 employees * This position will not oversee and direct other managers ...

The Auto Damage Claims Manager drives workflow, coaching, and technical excellence to ensure fair ... Coach and develop adjuster performance on alternative dispute resolution, litigation strategy and ...

The Auto Damage Claims Manager drives workflow, coaching, and technical excellence to ensure fair ... Coach and develop adjuster performance on alternative dispute resolution, litigation strategy and ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

Litigation Claims Manager information

What skills and qualifications are needed to be a litigation claims manager?

To thrive as a Litigation Claims Manager, you need a solid understanding of insurance claims processes, legal principles, and dispute resolution, typically supported by a bachelor’s degree in law, business, or a related field. Familiarity with claims management systems, legal research tools, and certifications such as CPCU or AIC are often required. Strong negotiation, analytical thinking, and effective communication are standout soft skills in this role. These skills and qualities are crucial for efficiently managing complex litigation cases, minimizing risk, and ensuring favorable outcomes for the organization.

What is the difference between Litigation Claims Manager vs Claims Adjuster?

AspectLitigation Claims ManagerClaims Adjuster
CredentialsBachelor's degree, legal or insurance certifications often preferredHigh school diploma or equivalent, insurance licensing may be required
Work EnvironmentLegal firms, insurance companies, corporate legal departmentsInsurance companies, third-party claims organizations
ResponsibilitiesOversees litigation processes, manages legal claims, coordinates with attorneysInvestigates claims, assesses damages, determines claim validity

The Litigation Claims Manager focuses on managing legal claims and overseeing litigation processes within insurance or legal settings, often requiring legal knowledge and managerial skills. In contrast, Claims Adjusters handle the initial investigation and assessment of claims, typically with a focus on damage evaluation and settlement. Both roles are integral to the claims process but differ in scope and responsibilities.

What does a litigation claims manager do?

A Litigation Claims Manager oversees the process of handling claims that have escalated to litigation, typically within an insurance or legal environment. Their responsibilities include evaluating the merits of claims, coordinating with legal counsel, managing settlements, and ensuring compliance with laws and company policies. They work to minimize financial exposure while ensuring fair treatment of all parties involved. Additionally, they may supervise a team of claims adjusters or specialists and report on the status and outcomes of litigated claims to senior management.

How does a litigation claims manager collaborate with legal teams and other departments?

A Litigation Claims Manager works closely with internal legal teams, external counsel, and various departments such as risk management, finance, and operations. Collaboration involves sharing case updates, strategizing defense or settlement approaches, and ensuring all documentation and communications are aligned. Effective communication and teamwork are crucial, as the manager often serves as a liaison between stakeholders to facilitate timely and informed decisions. This cross-functional collaboration helps ensure claims are handled efficiently and in the best interest of the organization.

What cities in Ohio are hiring for Litigation Claims Manager jobs?

Cities in Ohio with the most Litigation Claims Manager job openings:

Infographic showing various Litigation Claims Manager job openings in Ohio as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 85% Full Time, 10% Part Time, and 4% Contract. Highlights an 93% Physical, 3% Hybrid, and 4% Remote job distribution.

Casualty Claims Manager

Western Reserve Group

Wooster, OH • Hybrid

Full-time

Posted 12 days ago


Job description

The Casualty Claims Manager coaches and develops a team of 5-8 internal and external Claims Adjusters, Senior Claims Adjusters, and Claims Specialists responsible for the management, investigation, and resolution of claims, ensuring a high-quality work product, while continuously developing talent by assisting with the selection of top talent. The Casualty Claims Manager promotes a culture of claims customer service excellence where all are committed to providing differentiated customer experience.

The Casualty Claims Manager will also ensure that staff properly manage an appropriate caseload of files in accordance with company standards and IC 27-4-1/ORC 3901-1-54. This position would be a hybrid position required to work from the office 3 days per week and remotely 2 days per week.

Salary Grade (15)  93,695 - 119,460 - 145,226

ESSENTIAL DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES include the following. Other duties may be assigned.

  • Leads and develops a team of Claims Adjusters, Senior Claims Adjusters, and Claims Specialists, ensuring the quality, accuracy, and timely resolution of claims that include high exposure/complex cases and litigation.
  • Proactively assists in selecting top talent, delivering continuous coaching, and rewarding and recognizing employees to reinforce behavior that ensure service excellence.
  • Assesses volume and nature of claims to be assigned and provides direction on losses to claim representatives as appropriate.
  • Direct involvement on select claims (significant exposure or complexity).
  • Review reserve amounts on high-cost claims and claims over the authority of the Claims Adjusters, Sr. Claim Adjusters and Claim Specialists.
  • Ensure effective communication with Underwriting, Agents, Insureds and Counsel.
  • Ensure compliance with all statutory and unfair claims practices act.
  • Monitors the work of team members to ensure reserves are adequately set and customer expectations are surpassed.
  • Conducts monthly audits of the claims process to include coverage analysis, investigation, valuation, scope, estimate, reserving, timeliness and the accurate disposition of claims. Provides feedback to the team for continuous improvement.
  • Analyzes any problematic trends and takes steps to avoid recurrence, appropriately escalating issues if needed.
  • Participate in monthly reviews of litigation and complex files with in-house counsel, VP Claim, AVP Claims and assigned Claims Adjusters/Specialists.
  • Promotes a culture committed to identifying process inefficiencies to continuously improve how work is performed.
  • Present complex cases to roundtable committee.
  • Attend and participate in mediations, pre-trials and trials.
  • Resolves customer complaints.
  • Promotes and advocates business unit goals and objectives, ensuring alignment with broader claims functional goals.
  • Organizes and conducts training of new employees.
  • Conduct performance evaluations and salary reviews of staff.
  • Maintains a regular diary system and reviews system reports to identify claims to review for quality and regulatory compliance.
  • Actively participates in or leads continuous improvement projects 
  • Stays current on industry trends and changes in insurance laws and regulations impacting claims handling.
  • Acts as a back-up for other unit Managers and adjusters while they are unavailable.
  • Performs various administrative activities, such as reviewing, preparing, and running reports, preparing follow-up letters to insureds regarding coverage, and attending agency meetings and functions.
  • Reviews claims on a regular basis checking for coverage, adequate reserves, accuracy and acts as a resource for answering claims questions. Provides additional services as required.
  • Works with SIU on fraudulent claims, and coordinates with Legal Department on litigated files
  • Resolves coverage or unusual questions within designated authority. Conducts related research as necessary.
  • Continuously seek out and evaluate potential services or vendors that may increase efficiency, accuracy, or quality, or reduce expenses while maintaining quality customer service.
  • Makes recommendations to and participates with leadership in developing and evaluating claims procedures.
  • Provide recommendations and technical assistance on business system development, implementation and testing. Other special projects as needed.
  • Develops, analyzes, and reports metrics useful in measuring performance as well as effectiveness of the team operations
  • Travel as needed relevant to position.

SUPERVISORY RESPONSIBILITIES

Will supervise 5 – 8 direct reports

QUALIFICATIONS

Qualified candidates would have a minimum of 5 years experience in Casualty or General Liability claims.  To perform this job successfully, an individual must be able to perform each essential duty satisfactorily. The requirements listed below are representative of the knowledge, skill, and/or ability required. Reasonable accommodations may be made to enable individuals with disabilities to perform the essential functions.

EDUCATION and/or EXPERIENCE

College Degree or Equivalent Experience.

5+ Years of Casualty or General Liability Claims experience gained through increasingly responsible position within the claims field.

Extensive experience in appropriate reserving procedures, effective negotiation skills in Personal, Commercial, General Liability, and Property coverage and settlement practices.

Excellent Written and Verbal Communication Skills.

Extensive experience in directing Independent Vendors and Coverage Counsel.

Superior Interpersonal Skills.

Efficient time management skills.

LANGUAGE SKILLS

Excellent verbal and written communication skills.  The individual must be able to effectively and clearly communicate with agents, insured’s, departmental and company personnel via telephone, fax, e-mail, one-on-one dialogue and small group presentations in a highly professional manner.

REASONING ABILITY

The position requires the individual to apply common sense, understanding, reasoning and sound educated judgement coupled with sound Claims training and experience to properly evaluate and analyze claims for recommended action within assigned authority levels.

CERTIFICATES, LICENSES, REGISTRATIONS

AIC or CPCU designations highly preferred

PHYSICAL DEMANDS

The physical demands described here are representative of those that must be met by an employee to successfully perform the essential functions of this job. Reasonable accommodations may be made to enable individuals with disabilities to perform the essential functions.

Employees are required to sit at a work station to perform various PC functions.  Additionally, the employee is required to devote substantial time to telephone communication.

While performing the duties of this job, the employee is regularly required to sit and talk or hear.  The employee frequently is required to use hands to finger, handle, or feel.  The employee is occasionally required to stand, walk, and reach with hands and arms.

Employees may be required to travel from time to time.  This may require extended periods of time sitting in a vehicle.

WORK ENVIRONMENT

The work environment characteristics described here are representative of those an employee encounters while performing the essential functions of this job. Reasonable accommodations may be made to enable individuals with disabilities to perform the essential functions.

The Casualty Manager is responsible for supervising claims staff to see that all WRG policies and philosophies are adhered to.  The Property Manager will be assigned a specific work area.  The work area will be located adjacent to other similar work areas.  The work area has the necessary equipment to perform the position duties including personal computer, telephone, file space, and needed work table space.

The environment is reasonably quiet with needed interaction between other team members, immediate supervisor, and other company staff.  Moderate noise level from telephone calls is expected.