ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Insurance Subrogation Jobs in New York (NOW HIRING)

Madison Approach

Paralegal

Islandia, NY

$65K - $75K/yr

Support attorneys handling a high-volume caseload of no-fault auto insurance and subrogation matters * Draft and prepare legal correspondence, pleadings, and arbitration submissions * Coordinate with ...

Madison Approach

Paralegal

Armonk, NY · On-site

$65K - $78K/yr

Insurance Litigation Paralegal What You'll Do * Support attorneys handling a high-volume caseload of no-fault auto insurance and subrogation matters * Draft and prepare legal correspondence ...

Malapero Prisco & Klauber

Be Seen First

Insurance Defense Attorney

Hoboken, NJ · On-site

$85K - $200K/yr

... subrogation defense services for insurance carriers, third-party administrators, municipalities, and self-insured entities.

Malapero Prisco & Klauber

Be Seen First

Insurance Defense Attorney

Hoboken, NJ · On-site

$85K - $200K/yr

... subrogation defense services for insurance carriers, third-party administrators, municipalities, and self-insured entities.

Jobot

Insurance Coverage Attorney

Uniondale, NY · On-site

$150K - $190K/yr

Insurance Coverage Attorney for a full service law firm This Jobot Job is hosted by: Sherwin ... Handle subrogation matters and interplay between primary and excess coverage layers * Stay current ...

Malapero Prisco & Klauber

Be Seen First

Insurance Defense Litigation Attorney

Manhattan, NY · On-site

$85K - $200K/yr

... subrogation defense services for insurance carriers, third-party administrators, municipalities, and self-insured entities.

Markowitz & Barkoff, P.C.

Be Seen First

Litigation Attorney Position

Jericho, NY · On-site

$85K - $125K/yr

C. is a Long Island civil litigation firm with an active practice in subrogation and insurance defense. We are seeking a motivated Associate Attorney to manage a litigation caseload from intake ...

Veterinary Pet Insurance

Sr Trial Attorney

Elmsford, NY · Hybrid

Our Senior Trial Attorneys are seasoned litigation attorneys with significant civil litigation experience in property and casualty insurance defense or subrogation. As a Senior Trial Attorney, you'll ...

Malapero Prisco & Klauber

Be Seen First

Insurance Defense Litigation Attorney

Manhattan, NY · On-site

$85K - $200K/yr

... subrogation defense services for insurance carriers, third-party administrators, municipalities, and self-insured entities.

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsInsurance Subrogation JobsInsurance Subrogation Jobs in New York

Insurance Subrogation information

See New York salary details

$21.3K

$81.7K

$120.9K

How much do insurance subrogation jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 22, 2026, the average yearly pay for insurance subrogation in New York is $81,702.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $52,500.00 and $109,400.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is insurance subrogation?

Insurance subrogation is the process by which an insurance company seeks reimbursement from the at-fault party or their insurer after paying out a claim to its own policyholder. This typically occurs when an insurer has compensated its policyholder for damages or losses, and then pursues recovery from the responsible third party. Subrogation helps keep insurance costs down by ensuring that the party responsible for the loss ultimately pays for it. The policyholder may be required to cooperate with the insurer during the subrogation process, but usually does not need to take direct action themselves.

How does an insurance subrogation specialist typically collaborate with other departments or external parties during the recovery process?

Insurance Subrogation Specialists frequently work closely with adjusters, claims examiners, legal teams, and sometimes external parties such as attorneys and representatives from other insurance companies. Their primary responsibility involves gathering documentation, analyzing claims, and negotiating settlements, which requires strong communication and coordination skills. Effective collaboration ensures the accurate exchange of information and expedites the recovery process, ultimately maximizing recoveries for their organization. Building strong professional relationships is key to overcoming common challenges such as delayed responses or disputed claims.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an insurance subrogation specialist, and why are they important?

To excel as an Insurance Subrogation Specialist, you need a solid understanding of insurance policies, claims processing, and legal procedures, often supported by experience in insurance, claims, or related certifications. Familiarity with claims management software, case management systems, and basic legal research tools is commonly required. Strong negotiation, analytical thinking, and attention to detail are essential soft skills for resolving claims efficiently and professionally. These abilities are critical for maximizing recoveries, minimizing losses, and ensuring compliance with legal and policy requirements.

What is the difference between Insurance Subrogation vs Insurance Claims Adjuster?

AspectInsurance SubrogationInsurance Claims Adjuster
Primary RoleRecover funds from third parties after a claimAssess and settle insurance claims with policyholders
CredentialsKnowledge of insurance laws, negotiation skillsLicensing, claims handling certifications
Work EnvironmentLegal and insurance settings, often involving negotiationsInsurance companies, field and office work
Industry UsageInsurance, legal, recoveryInsurance, customer service

Insurance Subrogation focuses on recovering costs from third parties after a claim, while Insurance Claims Adjusters evaluate and settle claims directly with policyholders. Both roles require insurance knowledge and certifications but serve different functions within the insurance industry.

How to become an insurance subrogation adjuster?

To become an insurance subrogation adjuster, typically one needs a high school diploma or equivalent, along with experience in insurance claims or related fields. Many employers prefer candidates with a state license or certification in claims adjusting, and strong analytical, negotiation, and communication skills are essential for success in this role.

What are popular job titles related to Insurance Subrogation jobs in New York?

For Insurance Subrogation jobs in New York, the most frequently searched job titles are:

What job categories do people searching Insurance Subrogation jobs in New York look for?

The top searched job categories for Insurance Subrogation jobs in New York are:

Insurance Subrogation jobs near you
Infographic showing various Insurance Subrogation job openings in New York as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 73% Full Time, 21% Part Time, and 5% Contract. Highlights an 90% Physical, 1% Hybrid, and 9% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $81,702 per year, or $39.3 per hour.

Paralegal

Madison Approach

Islandia, NY

$65K - $75K/yr

Full-time

Re-posted 23 days ago

Job description

Insurance Litigation Paralegal
Islandia, NY (Suffolk County) · On-Site · Direct Hire
POSITION DETAILS
Location
Islandia, NY · On-Site
Schedule
Mon–Fri, 9:00 AM–5:00 PM
Compensation
$65,000–$75,000 DOE
Start
Immediate
BENEFITS
  • Discretionary year-end bonus
  • Profit-sharing contributions
  • Health insurance — employer contribution toward single-rate premium
ABOUT THE OPPORTUNITY
A well-established New York litigation firm with a strong track record in insurance law is seeking an experienced Insurance Litigation Paralegal for its Long Island office. This is a stable, long-term opportunity with a collegial, low-stress office culture in a convenient suburban setting — no city commute required. The firm values its people and has a strong record of employee retention.
WHAT YOU'LL DO
  • Support attorneys handling a high-volume caseload of no-fault auto insurance and subrogation matters
  • Draft and prepare legal correspondence, pleadings, and arbitration submissions
  • Coordinate with insurance carriers, opposing counsel, and arbitration forums
  • Monitor case files and proactively identify next steps and upcoming deadlines
  • Prepare materials for arbitration hearings and assist with e-filing
  • Handle client communications professionally via phone and email
  • Maintain well-organized, current case files
WHAT WE'RE LOOKING FOR
  • Minimum 1 year of paralegal experience in no-fault auto insurance, subrogation, or insurance defense litigation in New York
  • A true paralegal skillset: able to draft legal documents and apply substantive knowledge of insurance law — not limited to administrative support
  • Solid understanding of New York insurance litigation procedures and terminology
  • Proficient in Microsoft Office; experience with legal case management software a plus
  • Excellent written and verbal communication skills
  • Highly organized with strong attention to detail
  • Ability to work independently across multiple active matters
PREFERRED
  • Experience in AAA or Arbitration Forums, Inc. arbitration
  • Workers' Compensation subrogation background
  • Paralegal certificate or college degree