ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

First Party Property Attorney Jobs (NOW HIRING)

Robert Half

Attorney/Lawyer

San Ramon, CA · Remote

$75.21 - $87.09/hr

This is an immediate need for an attorney who can independently analyze coverage issues, conduct ... Evaluate first-party property insurance claims and related coverage questions. * Draft detailed ...

New

Clausen Miller P.C.

Associate Attorney

Florham Park, NJ · On-site

$105K - $115K/yr

Clausen Miller PC seeks an Associate Attorney with 1-5 years of New York AND New Jersey litigation experience in first-party property and liability coverage . The associate attorney would work ...

Clausen Miller P.C.

Associate Attorney

Jersey City, NJ · On-site

$105K - $115K/yr

Clausen Miller PC seeks an Associate Attorney with 1-5 years of New York AND New Jersey litigation experience in first-party property and liability coverage . The associate attorney would work ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsFirst Party Property Attorney Jobs

First Party Property Attorney information

See salary details

$62.5K

$199.3K

$289K

How much do first party property attorney jobs pay per year?

As of Jul 11, 2026, the average yearly pay for first party property attorney in the United States is $199,306.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $156,500.00 and $256,000.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is the difference between First Party Property Attorney vs Insurance Defense Attorney?

AspectFirst Party Property AttorneyInsurance Defense Attorney
CredentialsJurisdiction-specific law degree, bar admissionJurisdiction-specific law degree, bar admission
Work EnvironmentLaw firms, insurance companies, or as in-house counselLaw firms, insurance companies, or as in-house counsel
Industry UsageHandles claims related to policyholders' damagesDefends insurance companies against claims
Common Search IntentSeeking legal help for property damage claimsSeeking legal help to defend insurance companies

First Party Property Attorneys focus on representing policyholders in property damage claims, while Insurance Defense Attorneys defend insurance companies against such claims. Both roles require similar credentials and often work within the insurance industry, but their client focus and responsibilities differ significantly.

What are some typical challenges faced by First Party Property Attorneys when handling insurance claims?

First Party Property Attorneys often encounter challenges such as interpreting complex insurance policy language, managing tight filing deadlines, and negotiating with insurance adjusters who may dispute the extent of damages or coverage. They must also gather and present strong evidence to support their client’s claims, which may involve coordinating with experts like appraisers or contractors. Additionally, balancing a high caseload while maintaining detailed communication with clients and insurance representatives can be demanding, requiring strong organizational and negotiation skills.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as a First Party Property Attorney, and why are they important?

To thrive as a First Party Property Attorney, you need a Juris Doctor (JD) degree, state bar admission, and strong expertise in insurance law and property claims. Familiarity with legal research tools (like Westlaw or LexisNexis), case management software, and e-filing systems is typically required. Exceptional negotiation, analytical thinking, and client communication skills help attorneys excel in managing complex claims and litigation. These skills ensure effective representation of clients, successful dispute resolution, and compliance with legal and regulatory standards.

What is a First Party Property Attorney?

A First Party Property Attorney is a lawyer who represents policyholders or insurance companies in disputes over property insurance claims. These attorneys handle cases where the policyholder is seeking compensation from their own insurance provider for damages to their property, such as from fire, storms, theft, or other covered events. Their work includes reviewing insurance policies, negotiating settlements, and litigating claims if necessary to ensure clients receive the benefits they are entitled to under their insurance policy.
More about First Party Property Attorney jobs
What cities are hiring for First Party Property Attorney jobs? Cities with the most First Party Property Attorney job openings:
What states have the most First Party Property Attorney jobs? States with the most job openings for First Party Property Attorney jobs include:
What job categories do people searching First Party Property Attorney jobs look for? The top searched job categories for First Party Property Attorney jobs are:
First Party Property Attorney jobs near you
Infographic showing various First Party Property Attorney job openings in the United States as of July 2026, with employment types broken down into 100% Full Time. Highlights an 67% In-person, and 33% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $199,306 per year, or $95.8 per hour.
Staff Attorney Trial Specialist

Staff Attorney Trial Specialist

Security First Insurance Company (Security First Managers)

Orlando, FL

Full-time

Medical, Dental, Vision, Retirement, PTO

Re-posted 2 days ago

Job description

Position will be headquartered in Orlando but also involves some travel to our Ormond Beach office.

Staff Attorney – Trial Specialist

Help Shape the Future of First-Party Property Litigation

Are you the attorney other trial lawyers call when the stakes are highest?

Security First is looking for an experienced, strategic trial attorney to elevate our litigation team through mentorship, courtroom excellence, and innovative trial strategy. This isn't a high-volume litigation position—it's an opportunity to influence outcomes, develop attorneys, and help build one of the strongest in-house litigation teams in Florida.

If you enjoy trying complex cases, coaching other attorneys, and helping shape litigation strategy from start to finish, apply today!

What You'll Do

As our Staff Attorney Trial Specialist, you'll serve as the organization's litigation strategist and trial mentor. You'll work alongside talented Staff Counsel Attorneys to strengthen trial preparation, refine courtroom strategy, and help deliver exceptional outcomes for our policyholders and the company.

In this role, you will:

  • Lead trial strategy discussions for complex First Party Property litigation.
  • Coach and mentor Staff Counsel Attorneys in trial advocacy, witness preparation, evidentiary issues, and courtroom presentation.
  • Serve as second chair during trials across Florida, while occasionally acting as lead trial counsel.
  • Evaluate trial readiness and identify opportunities to strengthen cases before they reach the courtroom.
  • Partner with Claims professionals and Litigation Specialists to develop winning litigation strategies.
  • Assist with mediation strategy and settlement evaluations.
  • Create and deliver engaging trial training programs and best practices.
  • Share your knowledge to help develop the next generation of exceptional trial attorneys.

What You Bring

We're looking for someone who combines courtroom confidence with a passion for coaching others.

Qualifications include:

  • Juris Doctor from an accredited law school
  • Active member of The Florida Bar
  • Minimum 12 years of trial experience
  • Extensive experience handling First Party Property litigation
  • Strong courtroom presence and exceptional communication skills
  • A collaborative leadership style and passion for mentoring attorneys
  • Strategic thinking and the ability to simplify complex legal issues
  • Ability to travel throughout Florida as needed for trials

Why You'll Love Working Here

We're serious about our work—but we also believe work should be enjoyable.

Our offices were designed with our team members in mind and includes:

  • State-of-the-art fitness center
  • Complimentary chef-prepared lunches monthly
  • Beautiful walking trail around our offices
  • Team Member appreciation events throughout the year
  • Hybrid work environment that supports collaboration and flexibility
  • Food truck events featuring local favorites
  • Professional development, mentoring, and continuing education
  • Competitive benefits package including medical, dental, vision, paid time off, 401(k), and more

At Security First, you'll find a collaborative culture where people genuinely enjoy working together and where your expertise is valued.

The Kind of Person Who Thrives Here

You are someone who:

  • Enjoys leading through influence rather than direct supervision and takes pride in helping others succeed.
  • Loves being in the courtroom.
  • Enjoys mentoring and developing attorneys.
  • Thinks strategically—not just tactically.
  • Builds strong relationships across departments.
  • Leads with integrity, professionalism, and humility.
  • Believes great teams produce great results.

Apply