ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Evening Personal Lines Insurance Jobs (NOW HIRING)

KSP Insurance

Personal Lines Insurance Producer

Wyandotte, MI · On-site

$40K - $55K/yr

... Prior personal lines insurance sales experience · Experience with auto and homeowners insurance · Strong communication, sales, organization, andfollow-up skills · Comfortable using carrier ...

Southwest Insurance Services, LLC

Be Seen First

Personal Lines Insurance Agent

Lafayette, LA · On-site

$40K - $65K/yr

Southwest Insurance Services has been providing commercial and personal lines insurance for nearly 25 years and we have a spot available for an experienced personal lines agent with a Louisiana ...

New

Huff Insurance

Personal Lines Insurance Agent

Pasadena, MD · On-site

$44K - $60K/yr

Job Stability in a growing industry The Personal Lines Producer at Huff insurance is responsible for maintaining and maximizing profitable relationships with personal lines clients and for growing ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All Jobsevening JobsFinance and Insurance JobsInsurance JobsInsurance Customer Service Specialist JobsEvening Personal Lines Insurance Jobs

Evening Personal Lines Insurance information

See salary details

$26K

$53.3K

$93K

How much do evening personal lines insurance jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 30, 2026, the average yearly pay for evening personal lines insurance in the United States is $53,312.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $43,500.00 and $60,000.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What is the difference between Evening Personal Lines Insurance vs Personal Lines Insurance Agent?

AspectEvening Personal Lines InsurancePersonal Lines Insurance Agent
Work HoursPrimarily evening or night shiftsStandard daytime hours, with some evening appointments
CertificationsRequires licensing and insurance certificationsRequires licensing and insurance certifications
Work EnvironmentCall centers, remote or office settings during evening hoursOffice or client-facing environments during regular hours
Job FocusHandling customer inquiries, policy adjustments, claims support during eveningsSelling policies, advising clients, managing accounts during daytime

Both roles require similar certifications and industry knowledge, but Evening Personal Lines Insurance professionals focus on evening shifts and customer support during non-standard hours, while Personal Lines Insurance Agents typically work during regular business hours on sales and client management.

What cities are hiring for Evening Personal Lines Insurance jobs?

Cities with the most Evening Personal Lines Insurance job openings:

What are the most commonly searched types of Personal Lines Insurance jobs?

The most popular types of Personal Lines Insurance jobs are:

What states have the most Evening Personal Lines Insurance jobs?

States with the most job openings for Evening Personal Lines Insurance jobs include:

Evening Personal Lines Insurance jobs near you

Personal Lines Insurance Agent

Lenz-Balder Insurance

Ludington, MI • On-site

$40K - $60K/yr

Full-time

Dental, Vision, Life, Retirement, PTO

Posted 26 days ago

Job description

The primary function of the Personal Lines Account Executive is to attract new clients to the Agency through prospecting, networking, and other lead-generating methods. This position is responsible for quoting, presenting, and selling Personal Lines insurance policies. This position is accountable for meeting the minimum quarterly New Business production requirements.

ESSENTIAL FUNCTIONS:

  • Identify, pursue and capitalize on sources of Personal Lines New Business.
  • Meet quarterly New Business production requirements.
  • Document activity in Agency Management System as required by management for appropriate tracking of activity and production.
  • Maintain knowledge of underwriting, coverages and rating procedures for all types of Personal Lines policies offered by all carriers with which the Agency is appointed.
  • Participate in seminars and other industry training in order to maintain knowledge and develop skills.

KNOWLEDGE, SKILLS AND ABILITIES:

  • Must be a proactive self-starter, imaginative and creative with good verbal and written communication skills.
  • Must show demonstrated success with building an insurance customer base from scratch.
  • Multi-tasking abilities with focus on accuracy and detailed documentation.
  • Must be willing to follow established agency and departmental processes/procedures.
  • Must be comfortable and experienced at networking and building centers of influence.

EDUCATION & EXPERIENCE:

  • Two or more years outbound personal lines insurance sales experience required.
  • College degree preferred.
  • Must have current licenses (Property/Casualty) as required by the State Department of Insurance.
  • Must be proficient in Microsoft Office Products

WHY WORK FOR LENZ-BALDER?

  • LBI offers careers, not "jobs"
  • Competitive salary, paid time off benefits and paid holidays
  • The culture of a small company with the benefits of a large company
  • Company paid licensing and continuing education
  • 401K retirement with company match
  • Medical, Dental, Vision, Short-Term/Long-Term Disability and Life benefits
  • Discount on all of your personal insurance

See why a career with Lenz-Balder Insurance is like no other! Visit us at www.lenzbalderins.com for more information about us!

Company Description

Lenz-Balder Insurance is a locally owned company with strong family values and a pride in hard work. We aim to treat people fairly and support those who want to work hard for our clients and coworkers. Our hiring process is robust because we want people who work hard, take pride in where they work, and experience positive growth.