ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Underwriter Manager Jobs in Wisconsin (NOW HIRING)

United Fire Group

Underwriting Manager

Madison, WI

$140K - $185K/yr

UFG is looking for an Underwriting Manager to join the team in the Great Lakes Region! In this role you will be responsible for leading a team of multi-line, multi-industry production underwriters to ...

Berkley

Underwriter

Appleton, WI · On-site

Their Trellis Management Liability Portfolio- of coverages include directors and officers ... Company URL: Responsibilities The Underwriter will manage all related underwriting tasks for ...

Berkley

Underwriter

Appleton, WI · On-site

Their Trellis Management Liability Portfolio of coverages include directors and officers ... Company URL: Responsibilities The Underwriter will manage all related underwriting tasks for ...

Berkley

Underwriter

Appleton, WI · On-site

Their Trellis Management Liability Portfolio of coverages include directors and officers ... The Underwriter will manage all related underwriting tasks for renewal accounts required in ...

LHH US

Underwriter

Fond Du Lac, WI

$60K - $75K/yr

We are hiring for an Underwriter in Fond du Lac, WI. This role is open due to a future retirement ... Pay Details: $60,000.00 to $75,000.00 per year Search managed by: Pat Dermody Equal Opportunity ...

LHH US

Underwriter

Fond Du Lac, WI · On-site

$60K - $75K/yr

We are hiring for an Underwriter in Fond du Lac, WI. This role is open due to a future retirement ... Pay Details: $60,000.00 to $75,000.00 per year Search managed by: Pat Dermody Equal Opportunity ...

Berkley

Sales Underwriter

Appleton, WI · On-site

This role applies underwriting, sales, and distribution management skills to manage an overall book of business and achieve profitability goals. Apply intermediate-level underwriting analysis ...

PNC Bank

Underwriting Associate - Commercial

Portage, WI · On-site +1

$37K/yr

Managing Risk - Assessing and effectively managing all of the risks associated with their business ... Underwriting, Managing Multiple Priorities, Office Support Tools, Operational Functions Work ...

Marsh & McLennan Companies, Inc.

Victor Insurance Managers Inc., a subsidiary of Marsh, is the world's oldest and largest underwriting manager of specialty insurance, professional liability, and risk management programs. Victor is ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsUnderwriter JobsUnderwriter Manager JobsUnderwriter Manager Jobs in Wisconsin

Underwriter Manager information

See Wisconsin salary details

$48.4K

$104K

$160K

How much do underwriter manager jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 23, 2026, the average yearly pay for underwriter manager in Wisconsin is $104,046.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $77,700.00 and $122,100.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What does an underwriter manager do?

An Underwriter Manager oversees a team of underwriters who evaluate and assess the risk of insuring clients or approving loans. They are responsible for ensuring that underwriting guidelines and compliance standards are met, reviewing complex cases, and making final decisions on high-value or high-risk applications. Additionally, they train and mentor staff, implement process improvements, and collaborate with other departments to optimize risk management strategies. Their role is vital in maintaining profitability and minimizing losses for the organization.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an underwriter manager?

To thrive as an Underwriter Manager, you need a strong background in risk assessment, underwriting policies, and financial analysis, typically supported by a bachelor's degree in finance, business, or a related field. Expertise with underwriting software, risk management platforms, and familiarity with industry certifications such as CPCU or ARM are commonly expected. Leadership, decision-making, and effective communication skills set top performers apart by enabling them to guide teams and negotiate with stakeholders. These skills ensure sound risk evaluation, regulatory compliance, and efficient team management, which are critical for organizational profitability and growth.

What are some common challenges faced by underwriter managers when overseeing a team of underwriters?

Underwriter Managers often face challenges such as balancing workload distribution among team members, ensuring consistent application of underwriting guidelines, and keeping up with regulatory changes. They must also mentor junior underwriters, handle escalated cases, and foster collaboration between underwriting, sales, and compliance departments. Effective communication and adaptability are key, as Underwriter Managers need to support team development while meeting organizational targets and maintaining risk standards.

What is the difference between Underwriter Manager vs Underwriter?

AspectUnderwriter ManagerUnderwriter
ResponsibilitiesOversees underwriting teams, develops policies, manages risk assessment strategiesPerforms individual risk assessments, approves or rejects insurance applications
CredentialsTypically requires a relevant insurance or finance certification, experience in underwritingRequires similar certifications, often with less managerial experience
Work EnvironmentManagement meetings, team supervision, strategic planningAnalyzing applications, assessing risks, making underwriting decisions
Industry UsageCommon in insurance companies, financial institutionsWidespread across insurance, reinsurance, and financial sectors

The main difference between an Underwriter Manager and an Underwriter is that the manager oversees the underwriting team and strategic processes, while the underwriter focuses on individual risk assessment and decision-making. Both roles require similar credentials, but the manager has additional leadership responsibilities.

How much does an underwriting manager earn?

An underwriting manager typically earns between $80,000 and $150,000 annually, depending on experience, location, and the size of the organization. They often oversee underwriting teams, review risk assessments, and require strong analytical and leadership skills.

Is an underwriting manager a good job?

An underwriting manager oversees the evaluation and approval of insurance applications, managing a team of underwriters and ensuring risk assessment accuracy. The role typically offers strong job stability, competitive salaries, and opportunities for advancement, especially with relevant certifications and experience in the insurance industry.

What are the most commonly searched types of Underwriter jobs in Wisconsin?

The most popular types of Underwriter jobs in Wisconsin are:

What cities in Wisconsin are hiring for Underwriter Manager jobs?

Cities in Wisconsin with the most Underwriter Manager job openings:

Underwriter Manager jobs near you
Infographic showing various Underwriter Manager job openings in Wisconsin as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 88% Full Time, 11% Part Time, and 1% Contract. Highlights an 81% Physical, 2% Hybrid, and 17% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $104,046 per year, or $50 per hour.

Mortgage Underwriter

Nicolet National Bank

Green Bay, WI • On-site

Full-time

Medical, Dental, Vision, Life, Retirement, PTO

Re-posted 7 days ago

Nicolet National Bank rating

8.1

Company rating: 8.1 out of 10

Based on 12 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

65th of 171 rated banks

Job description

At Nicolet National Bank, our culture is based on the principles of community banking, putting the needs of our customers at the forefront of our decision-making. Our Core Values drive everything we do, and we are committed to serving our customers with excellence. We believe that every job in our organization is critical to our success, and we are dedicated to creating a work environment where our employees feel valued, respected, and supported. With locations in Wisconsin, Michigan, Minnesota, Iowa, and Florida we are proud to service our local communities and make a positive impact on the lives of our customers. At Nicolet National Bank, we believe that our people are our most valuable asset, and we are committed to investing in their growth and development.
The Mortgage Underwriter is responsible for the preparation, processing, and underwriting of mortgage loan files and for evaluating secondary market applications. Mortgage Underwriters are also responsible for working collaboratively with mortgage lenders and processing staff to ensure that the financial needs of Nicolet’s customers are met with loan products offered by Nicolet.
As a Mortgage Underwriter, you will:
  • Independently screen loan applications to determine loan eligibility of customers by compiling and analyzing personal financial data of the customer, the proposed loan structure or product, and other relevant data that, in the Mortgage Underwriter’s discretion, the Mortgage Underwriting finds may materially impact the customer’s ability to pay the proposed loan to Nicolet.
  • Approve or reject loan applications based on the Mortgage Underwriter’s findings and, when appropriate, propose an alternative loan structure or product.
  • Prepare written confirmation of findings including, but not limited to, system coding, denial notice preparation, HMDA coding, and uploads into Director record-keeping system.
  • Exercise discretion and independent judgment to assess loan quality of proposed loans by to confirm that the loan file, as approved, is underwritten to reasonably comply with specific GSE guidelines and investor overlays to decrease potential for loan repurchase. This includes interpreting relevant guidelines that may be issued by federal or state agencies or investors and conducting research to make underwriting decision. Attention to detail is critical.
  • Establish underwriting conditions needed to clear loans to close and communicate those conditions to lenders and processors.
  • Work as liaison between investors and lenders on loan products that Nicolet is not able to approve.
  • Clear all file pends from investors and third-party audit companies.
  • Assist the Underwriting Manager with training of new and existing employees on accurate data input for accurate findings and applications to reduce potential for negative impact to borrower(s) and Nicolet.
  • Answer phone inquiries from lenders, staff, and customers to resolve issues and ensure customer satisfaction.
  • Interpret guideline changes for different loan products and varying over-lays of investors and communicate concise information to frontline as needed.
  • Evaluate, analyze, and recommend products and/or process changes that would increase efficiency, ensure competitiveness, and reduce costs or redundancies.
  • Attend webinars, review ALLREGS, and attend investor seminars as volume allows to keep underwriting and investor guidelines’ knowledge current.
  • Work with Underwriting Manager to coordinate productive, informative retail meetings, assisting frontline with meeting Nicolet’s goals and customer expectations.
  • Use bullets from ESSENTIAL DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITES ensuring proper tense is used – This section should always end with the following bullet points (if a manager uses categories to break out their job descriptions, please classify the below as “General:”)
  • Uphold Nicolet’s philosophy and policies by maintaining appropriate controls to ensure full compliance with applicable laws and regulations, thereby fulfilling legal responsibilities and enhancing the quality of services provided by Nicolet.
  • Understand and communicate the value of diversity within the workplace and to work successfully with others without regard to age, gender, race, sexual orientation, ethnicity, culture, religion, disability status, socioeconomic status or other non-job-related classification, including a commitment to Nicolet’s policies on equal employment opportunities and non-discrimination with a willingness to pursue efforts of inclusion and respect toward different perspectives.
  • Performs all other duties as assigned.
Qualifications:
  • High School Diploma or equivalent. Associate Degree in Administration or Finance-Related field of study.
  • 1-3 years required mortgage processing or underwriting experience required.
  • 3+ years mortgage processing or underwriting experience preferred.
  • Proficiency with computer, phone system, and general office equipment.
  • Ability to learn and become proficient with Microsoft Office suite and other mortgage specific software applications.
  • Highly developed attention to detail and organizational skills.
  • Ability to prioritize and work rapidly and accurately in fast-paced environment.
  • Ability to maintain strict confidentiality.
  • Knowledge of mortgage processing, underwriting and secondary market functions.
Benefits:
  • Medical, Dental, Vision, amp; Life Insurance
  • 401(k) with a company match
  • PTO amp; 11 1/2 Paid Holidays
The above statements are intended to describe the general nature and level of work being performed. They are not intended to be construed as an exhaustive list of all responsibilities and skills required for the position.
Equal Opportunity Employer/Veterans/Disabled

What Nicolet National Bank employees say

Pay

Benefits

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom

Apply