1

Underwriter Manager Jobs in Indiana (NOW HIRING)

Senior Underwriter

Fort Wayne, IN · On-site

$97K - $114K/yr

Provide ongoing training to underwriters/assistant underwriters and assist the Regional Underwriting Manager as needed. Provide assistance to agents in resolving issues with existing policies and/or ...

Senior Underwriter

Fort Wayne, IN · On-site

$97K - $114K/yr

Provide ongoing training to underwriters/assistant underwriters and assist the Regional Underwriting Manager as needed. Provide assistance to agents in resolving issues with existing policies and/or ...

Underwriting Manager FLSA Status: Exempt Job Family: Underwriting Department: Underwriting Location: Corporate Office (Fort Wayne, IN) JOB SUMMARY Responsible for managing, training, and developing ...

New

Senior Underwriter

Fort Wayne, IN · On-site +1

$90K - $110K/yr

The Senior Underwriter will lead complex risk evaluation, manage key accounts, oversee renewals and referrals, and work directly with insureds and carrier partners while helping strengthen ...

New

Appropriately document all files so that other underwriters, department and company management, and ... external auditors can identify and understand action taken with respect to policy issuance, renewal ...

Appropriately document all files so that other underwriters, department and company management, and ... external auditors can identify and understand action taken with respect to policy issuance, renewal ...

This position works closely with the Executive Director, Director of Underwriting, and the Loan Committee to structure, underwrite, and manage complex and high-value credit relationships.

next page

Showing results 1-20

Underwriter Manager information

See Indiana salary details

$45.7K

$98.1K

$150.8K

How much do underwriter manager jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 13, 2026, the average yearly pay for underwriter manager in Indiana is $98,089.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $73,300.00 and $115,100.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

How much does an underwriter manager earn?

An underwriter manager typically earns between $80,000 and $130,000 annually, depending on experience, location, and the size of the organization. They often oversee underwriting teams, review complex policies, and require strong analytical and leadership skills.

What does an underwriter manager do?

An Underwriter Manager oversees a team of underwriters who evaluate and assess the risk of insuring clients or approving loans. They are responsible for ensuring that underwriting guidelines and compliance standards are met, reviewing complex cases, and making final decisions on high-value or high-risk applications. Additionally, they train and mentor staff, implement process improvements, and collaborate with other departments to optimize risk management strategies. Their role is vital in maintaining profitability and minimizing losses for the organization.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an underwriter manager?

To thrive as an Underwriter Manager, you need a strong background in risk assessment, underwriting policies, and financial analysis, typically supported by a bachelor's degree in finance, business, or a related field. Expertise with underwriting software, risk management platforms, and familiarity with industry certifications such as CPCU or ARM are commonly expected. Leadership, decision-making, and effective communication skills set top performers apart by enabling them to guide teams and negotiate with stakeholders. These skills ensure sound risk evaluation, regulatory compliance, and efficient team management, which are critical for organizational profitability and growth.

What is the difference between Underwriter Manager vs Underwriter?

AspectUnderwriter ManagerUnderwriter
ResponsibilitiesOversees underwriting teams, develops policies, manages risk assessment strategiesPerforms individual risk assessments, approves or rejects insurance applications
CredentialsTypically requires a relevant insurance or finance certification, experience in underwritingRequires similar certifications, often with less managerial experience
Work EnvironmentManagement meetings, team supervision, strategic planningAnalyzing applications, assessing risks, making underwriting decisions
Industry UsageCommon in insurance companies, financial institutionsWidespread across insurance, reinsurance, and financial sectors

The main difference between an Underwriter Manager and an Underwriter is that the manager oversees the underwriting team and strategic processes, while the underwriter focuses on individual risk assessment and decision-making. Both roles require similar credentials, but the manager has additional leadership responsibilities.

Is an underwriting manager a good job?

An underwriting manager oversees the evaluation and approval of insurance applications, managing teams and ensuring risk assessment accuracy. The role typically offers a competitive salary, opportunities for advancement, and requires strong analytical, leadership, and communication skills. Job satisfaction depends on individual interests in risk management and leadership responsibilities.

What are some common challenges faced by underwriter managers when overseeing a team of underwriters?

Underwriter Managers often face challenges such as balancing workload distribution among team members, ensuring consistent application of underwriting guidelines, and keeping up with regulatory changes. They must also mentor junior underwriters, handle escalated cases, and foster collaboration between underwriting, sales, and compliance departments. Effective communication and adaptability are key, as Underwriter Managers need to support team development while meeting organizational targets and maintaining risk standards.
What are the most commonly searched types of Underwriter jobs in Indiana? The most popular types of Underwriter jobs in Indiana are:
What cities in Indiana are hiring for Underwriter Manager jobs? Cities in Indiana with the most Underwriter Manager job openings:
Infographic showing various Underwriter Manager job openings in Indiana as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 84% Full Time, 13% Part Time, and 2% Contract. Highlights an 94% Physical, 2% Hybrid, and 4% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $98,089 per year, or $47.2 per hour.

$97K - $114K/yr

Full-time

Posted 19 days ago


Brotherhood Mutual rating

7.3

Company rating: 7.3 out of 10

Based on 6 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

236th of 306 rated insurance


Job description

Job Title: Senior Underwriter

FLSA Status: Exempt

Job Family: Underwriting

Department: UW - Data & Quality

Location: Corporate Office (Fort Wayne, IN)


JOB SUMMARY
Responsible within assigned authority to evaluate, classify and price new and renewal church and related ministry business consistent with company established standards for growth and profitability, including accounts that are of large size and/or high complexity. Provide ongoing training to underwriters/assistant underwriters and assist the Regional Underwriting Manager as needed. Provide assistance to agents in resolving issues with existing policies and/or answer questions with respect to coverage existence or
availability.


POSITION ESSENTIAL FUNCTIONS AND RESPONSIBILITIES
To perform this job successfully, an individual must be able to perform each essential duty satisfactorily. Reasonable accommodations may be made to enable individuals with disabilities to perform the essential functions.

  • Evaluate, classify and price new and renewal church/related ministry accounts that include those of large size and/or high complexity.
  • Appropriately document all files so that other underwriters, department and company management, and external auditors can identify and understand action taken with respect to exposures, thought process, policy issuance, and pricing strategy.
  • Participate and/or lead teams, as assigned by the Regional Underwriting Manager, to research or solve departmentally identified issues, problems, or special projects.
  • Provide training to underwriters and assistant underwriters or others in the underwriting department.
  • Participate in agency visits and meet with prospects or current insureds.
  • Provide input to departmental and company personnel relative to agency performance affecting growth and profitability.
  • Work with Legal in developing manuscript and new coverage forms to address current and prospective policyholder needs.
  • Arrange reinsurance as needed in accordance with the company’s retention, catastrophe, concentration, and treaty/facultative arrangements.
  • Report any marketplace, customer trends, or state specific underwriting requirements that may positively or negatively impact the company and/or its target niche, and contribute to development of corresponding underwriting guidelines.
  • Negotiate underwriting issues with agents within established guidelines. Effectively and professionally communicate underwriting positions with agents in a positive manner.
  • Effectively prioritize, process, and manage workflows within the region to meet or exceed established service standards for agents and policyholders.
  • Assist regional managers with reviewing underwriter referrals, developing state strategies, and developing agency relationships and strategies.
  • Contribute to the development/maintenance of the Underwriting Resource Center.
  • Complete other projects as assigned.


KNOWLEDGE, SKILLS, AND ABILITIES
The requirements listed below are representative of the knowledge, skills, and/or abilities required to perform each essential duty satisfactorily. Reasonable accommodations may be made to enable individuals with
disabilities to perform the essential functions.

  • Must have demonstrated proficiency in basic math and professional writing competency.
  • Must have demonstrated proficiency in using computers and business software applications.
  • Must have a thorough understanding of Property and Casualty insurance rating systems, underwriting principles, practices, reinsurance concepts, and policy coverage forms.
  • Must be able to analyze various sources of information and make sound decisions relative to policy pricing and coverage that will lead to profitable business being acquired by the company.
  • Must be able to make independent decisions.
  • Must have strong analytical, negotiation, and organizational skills.
  • Must be able to effectively and professionally communicate complex concepts both orally and in writing.
  • Must be able to develop creative solutions to problems and be comfortable working in a dynamic environment.
  • Must possess strong interpersonal skills and present a positive and professional image of the company.
  • Must be able to develop and train underwriters, assistant underwriters, and other underwriting staff.
  • Effectively interface with external contacts, Brotherhood employees, managers, and department staff members.


EDUCATION AND/OR EXPERIENCE
List Degree Requirement, Years' Experience, and Certifications

  • Must have a Bachelor’s degree.
  • Must have CPCU, CIC, or other relevant insurance coursework.
  • Must have four to six years commercial underwriting experience.
  • Six or more years of Property/Casualty commercial underwriting or insurance-related experience is desired.
  • Knowledge of building construction and/or valuation is desired.
  • Experience in training of underwriters or other underwriting staff is desired.


Terms and Conditions

This description is intended to describe the general content of and requirements for the performance of this position. It is not to be construed as an exhaustive statement of duties, responsibilities, or requirements.
Because the company’s niche is the church and related ministries market, and because effective service requires a thorough understanding of this market, persons in this position must be familiar with church operations and must conduct themselves in a manner that will neither alienate nor offend persons within this target niche.

Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company reserves the right to modify, interpret, or apply this position description in any way the company desires. This job description in no way implies that these are the only duties, including essential duties, to be performed by the employee occupying this position. This position description is not an employment contract, implied or otherwise. The
employment relationship remains “at-will”.


What Brotherhood Mutual employees say

Pay

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom