ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Subrogation Manager Jobs in Elizabeth, IN (NOW HIRING)

Cna

Claims Consultant, Life Sciences

Louisville, KY

Manages an inventory of highly complex commercial claims with large exposures that require a high ... Realizes and addresses subrogation/salvage opportunities or potential fraud occurrences by ...

All JobsSubrogation JobsSubrogation Manager JobsSubrogation Manager Jobs in Elizabeth, IN

Subrogation Manager information

See Elizabeth, IN salary details

$25.1K

$74.5K

$125.4K

How much do subrogation manager jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 16, 2026, the average yearly pay for subrogation manager in Elizabeth, IN is $74,483.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $45,600.00 and $106,200.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive in the subrogation manager position, and why are they important?

A Subrogation Manager needs a strong understanding of insurance claims, legal principles related to subrogation, and experience in claims management, often supported by a bachelor's degree in business, insurance, or a related field. Familiarity with claims management software, document management systems, and industry certifications such as CPCU (Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter) are highly beneficial. Exceptional negotiation, analytical thinking, and leadership skills distinguish top performers in this role. These competencies are critical for effectively recovering funds, managing teams, and ensuring compliance with legal and industry standards.

What does a subrogation manager do?

A Subrogation Manager oversees the recovery of funds from third parties who are responsible for a loss covered by an insurance company. They manage a team of subrogation specialists, review claims, coordinate investigations, and ensure legal compliance. Their role involves negotiating settlements, collaborating with attorneys, and optimizing recovery processes to minimize financial losses for the company. Strong analytical, negotiation, and leadership skills are essential for success in this role.

What are the typical challenges faced by subrogation managers in their daily work?

Subrogation Managers often face the challenge of coordinating complex recovery processes, which can involve multiple parties, strict regulatory requirements, and tight deadlines. They need to analyze detailed claims data, negotiate settlements with third parties or their insurers, and monitor ongoing litigation or arbitration cases. In addition to overseeing their team, they must keep pace with changing industry regulations and ensure that all actions align with company policies. Success in this role requires balancing strong technical knowledge with effective communication and problem-solving skills, especially when handling difficult negotiations or resolving disputes.

What cities near Elizabeth, IN are hiring for Subrogation Manager jobs?

Cities near Elizabeth, IN with the most Subrogation Manager job openings:

Subrogation Manager jobs near you

Paralegal Legal Assistant

Barnett Porter & Dunn

Louisville, KY • On-site

$17.50 - $30/hr

Full-time

PTO

Re-posted 13 days ago

Job description

About the Firm

We are a fast-paced law firm focused on insurance defense and subrogation matters, representing insurers, businesses, and individuals in a wide range of civil litigation cases. Our team is committed to delivering efficient, high-quality legal services while maintaining a collaborative and supportive work environment.


About the Role

We are seeking an experienced Paralegal/Legal Assistant with a background in civil litigation, preferably in insurance defense and/or subrogation. This role is essential in supporting attorneys through all stages of litigation—from case intake through trial—while ensuring deadlines are met and files are maintained with precision.

Key Responsibilities

·         Draft, format, and file pleadings, motions, and discovery documents

·         Handle high-volume case management for insurance defense and subrogation files

·         E-file in state and federal courts and track filing deadlines

·         Maintain and organize electronic and physical case files

·         Assist with discovery, including drafting interrogatories, requests for production, and responses

·         Coordinate depositions, inspections, mediations, and hearings

·         Prepare trial materials, exhibits, and binders

·         Communicate professionally with clients, insurance adjusters, experts, and opposing counsel

·         Review medical records, bills, and claim-related documents

·         Assist with subrogation recovery tracking and lien documentation


Qualifications

·         2+ years of experience as a Legal Assistant in civil litigation

·         Prior experience in insurance defense and/or subrogation strongly preferred

·         Familiarity with litigation procedures, deadlines, and court rules

·         Experience with e-filing in state and federal courts

·         Proficiency in Microsoft Office (Word, Outlook, Excel)

·         Strong attention to detail and ability to manage multiple deadlines

·         Excellent written and verbal communication skills


Preferred Skills

·         Experience working with insurance carriers and adjusters

·         Knowledge of medical terminology and billing records

·         Familiarity with case management and billing software (e.g., Clio, Time Matters, or similar)

·         Trial preparation experience

·         Paralegal certificate is a plus