ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Insurance Paralegal Jobs in Indiana (NOW HIRING)

Gutwein Law

Litigation Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

We're growing and looking for a Litigation Paralegal who wants more than a job. Someone who thrives ... Insurance plan, including health insurance, vision insurance, and group life insurance * Firm-wide ...

Gutwein Law

Litigation Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

We're growing and looking for a Litigation Paralegal who wants more than a job. Someone who thrives ... Insurance plan, including health insurance, vision insurance, and group life insurance * Firm-wide ...

Gutwein Law

Litigation Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN

We're growing and looking for a Litigation Paralegal who wants more than a job. Someone who thrives ... Insurance plan, including health insurance, vision insurance, and group life insurance * Firm-wide ...

Securitas

Contracts Specialist and Paralegal

Carmel, IN · On-site

$46K - $54K/yr

Medical, dental, vision, and life insurance * 10 accrued vacation days, 4 personal holidays, 6 sick ... Associate's Degree, paralegal certificate, or equivalent experience considered * 1-3 years of ...

FBT Gibbons LLP

Litigation Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

This position will primarily work with attorneys in the Product, Tort and Insurance Litigation ... A certificate from an ABA approved paralegal training program specializing in the area for which ...

Securitas

Contracts Specialist and Paralegal

Carmel, IN · On-site

$46K - $54K/yr

Medical, dental, vision, and life insurance * 10 accrued vacation days, 4 personal holidays, 6 sick ... Associate's Degree, paralegal certificate, or equivalent experience considered * 1-3 years of ...

FBT Gibbons LLP

IP Patent Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

We are currently seeking an IP Patent Paralegal to join our collaborative Intellectual Property ... insurance, short- and long-term disability, paid parental leave, employee wellbeing and EAP ...

Esswd

Investment Management Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · Hybrid

$45 - $55/hr

... insurance; and a 401(k) plan. Application Deadline on or before: June 1, 2026. What is required: * Bachelor's degree required; paralegal certificate preferred; applicable work experience may be ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsInsurance Paralegal JobsInsurance Paralegal Jobs in Indiana

Insurance Paralegal information

See Indiana salary details

$31.4K

$56.8K

$84.7K

How much do insurance paralegal jobs pay per year?

As of Jul 15, 2026, the average yearly pay for insurance paralegal in Indiana is $56,838.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $45,700.00 and $65,200.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

Can a paralegal make $100,000?

Insurance paralegals can potentially earn $100,000 or more, especially with significant experience, specialized knowledge, or working in high-paying regions or firms. Advancement often requires additional certifications, such as the Certified Paralegal credential, and proficiency with legal research tools like LexisNexis or Westlaw.

What does an Insurance Paralegal do?

An Insurance Paralegal assists attorneys in legal matters related to insurance claims, policies, and disputes. They conduct legal research, draft documents, review contracts, and help prepare cases for litigation. They may also communicate with clients, gather evidence, and coordinate with insurance companies. Their role ensures that legal processes run smoothly and efficiently.

Do paralegals work for insurance companies?

Insurance paralegals work for insurance companies, law firms, or legal departments, assisting with claims, policy analysis, and legal documentation. They often use legal research tools and require knowledge of insurance law and regulations. Their role involves supporting attorneys or legal teams in handling insurance-related legal matters.

What kinds of tasks might I handle on a daily basis as an Insurance Paralegal?

As an Insurance Paralegal, your daily tasks may include reviewing and analyzing insurance policies, preparing legal documents and correspondence, assisting with discovery, and managing case files. You might also communicate with clients, insurance adjusters, and opposing counsel to help gather information relevant to claims or litigation. In addition, you’ll often help attorneys prepare for hearings, depositions, and trials by organizing exhibits and evidence. This role requires excellent organizational skills and the ability to work independently as well as part of a legal team.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive in the Insurance Paralegal position, and why are they important?

To thrive as an Insurance Paralegal, you need a solid understanding of insurance law, legal research, document management, and claims processing, typically supported by a paralegal certificate or relevant experience. Familiarity with litigation management software, case management systems, and e-filing platforms is commonly required. Strong attention to detail, effective communication, and the ability to multitask make candidates stand out in this role. These competencies are essential for ensuring accuracy, efficiency, and successful support of attorneys handling insurance-related cases.

Will AI replace paralegals?

AI technology can automate routine tasks such as document review, data entry, and legal research, which are part of an insurance paralegal's responsibilities. However, paralegals also perform complex analysis, client communication, and case management that require human judgment and interpersonal skills, making complete replacement unlikely in the near future.

What field of paralegal makes the most money?

Insurance paralegals, especially those working in complex areas like insurance defense or litigation, tend to earn higher salaries compared to other paralegal specialties. Specialized skills, certifications, and experience in insurance law can lead to increased earning potential within this field.
What are popular job titles related to Insurance Paralegal jobs in Indiana? For Insurance Paralegal jobs in Indiana, the most frequently searched job titles are:
What job categories do people searching Insurance Paralegal jobs in Indiana look for? The top searched job categories for Insurance Paralegal jobs in Indiana are:
What cities in Indiana are hiring for Insurance Paralegal jobs? Cities in Indiana with the most Insurance Paralegal job openings:
Insurance Paralegal jobs near you
Infographic showing various Insurance Paralegal job openings in Indiana as of July 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 72% Full Time, 23% Part Time, and 4% Contract. Highlights an 91% Physical, 1% Hybrid, and 8% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $56,838 per year, or $27.3 per hour.
Litigation Paralegal

Litigation Paralegal

Gutwein Law

Indianapolis, IN • On-site

Full-time

Medical, Vision, Life, Retirement, PTO

Posted 28 days ago

Job description

We're Gutwein Law. We help businesses get deals done, solve problems, and grow. We're a team of smart people doing great work for great clients. We act as trusted advisors, working directly with business owners, executives, entrepreneurs, and investors to help them navigate opportunities, challenges, and growth.
We're growing and looking for a Litigation Paralegal who wants more than a job. Someone who thrives in a fast-paced environment, takes pride in staying organized, and enjoys playing a critical role in helping clients solve complex disputes. If you're looking for a place where your work matters, your ideas are valued, and your growth is encouraged, keep reading.
What You'll Do
You'll work closely with our litigation team to help clients navigate disputes, claims, and business challenges with confidence. Your work will include:
  • Supporting attorneys through all phases of litigation, from case intake through trial and resolution
  • Drafting, reviewing, and filing pleadings, motions, discovery requests, and other legal documents
  • Managing case files, deadlines, calendars, and court filings
  • Coordinating document collection, organization, and production
  • Assisting with trial preparation, hearings, depositions, and mediation
  • Communicating with clients, courts, opposing counsel, and third-party vendors
  • Conducting factual research and helping maintain accurate case records
  • Collaborating with attorneys and team members to deliver exceptional client service

What We're Looking For
You may be a great fit if you:
  • Have prior litigation paralegal experience
  • Possess strong organizational and project management skills
  • Are detail-oriented and take pride in producing high-quality work
  • Communicate clearly and professionally, both in writing and in person
  • Can manage multiple priorities and deadlines without sacrificing accuracy
  • Take ownership of your work and proactively solve problems
  • Enjoy working as part of a collaborative team
  • Are driven to learn, grow, and make an impact
  • Value integrity, professionalism, and doing things the right way

What You'll Find Here
We believe talented people do their best work when they're supported, challenged, and given opportunities to grow. That's why we invest heavily in our team through:
  • Salary and discretionary bonuses
  • 401K with employer contribution
  • Insurance plan, including health insurance, vision insurance, and group life insurance
  • Firm-wide training sessions
  • Modern, centrally located office space with paid parking
  • Health club membership reimbursement
  • Mobile phone plan reimbursement
  • Paid time off (PTO)
  • Remote working and flex time policies
  • Swag, parties, and other cultural initiatives

Ready for What's Next?
If you're looking for a place where your work matters, your ideas are valued, and your growth is encouraged, we'd love to meet you.

Apply