ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Insurance Paralegal Jobs in Indiana (NOW HIRING)

Ogletree Deakins

Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

... Life Insurance including Dental & Vision coverage, Health Savings Account /Flexible Spending ... Paralegal" in the subject line. Please note, applications submitted via e-mail will not be ...

White Lodging Careers

Paralegal

Merrillville, IN · On-site

We are seeking a Full Time Paralegal to support our in-house legal team at White Lodging ... Day 1 Medical, Dental, and Vision insurance * Vacation/Paid Time Off (PTO) with rollover

Old National Bank

Paralegal

Evansville, IN · On-site

$121K/yr

... insurance. 401K, continuing education opportunities and an employee assistance program are also ... Responsibilities The Paralegal will be responsible for legal team support for multiple areas of ...

Contact Government Services, LLC

Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$55K - $60K/yr

Paralegal Employment Type: Full Time, Mid-Level Department: Legal CGS is seeking a Paralegal to ... Therefore, we offer a comprehensive benefits package: - Health, Dental, and Vision - Life Insurance ...

Contact Government Services, LLC

Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$55K - $60K/yr

Paralegal Employment Type: Full Time, Mid-Level Department: Legal CGS is seeking a Paralegal to ... Therefore, we offer a comprehensive benefits package: - Health, Dental, and Vision - Life Insurance ...

Fort Wayne Metals

Paralegal- Onsite

Fort Wayne, IN · On-site

Paralegal certification, preferred. * Minimum 3-5 years of relevant experience. Job ... In addition to offering medical, dental, vision, life, and disability insurance options to suit ...

Crisp Recruit

Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN

Draft settlement demand/submission brochures for insurance adjusters and work with the attorney ... Experience: 3-5 years of paralegal experience preferred, ideally in personal injury, with the ...

FBT Gibbons LLP

Litigation Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

Litigation Paralegal FBT Gibbons LLP is a national law firm focused on serving companies operating ... This position will primarily work with attorneys in the Product, Tort and Insurance Litigation ...

FBT Gibbons LLP

Litigation Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

Litigation Paralegal FBT Gibbons LLP is a national law firm focused on serving companies operating ... This position will primarily work with attorneys in the Product, Tort and Insurance Litigation ...

Gutwein Law

Litigation Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

We're growing and looking for a Litigation Paralegal who wants more than a job. Someone who thrives ... Insurance plan, including health insurance, vision insurance, and group life insurance * Firm-wide ...

Gutwein Law

Litigation Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN

We're growing and looking for a Litigation Paralegal who wants more than a job. Someone who thrives ... Insurance plan, including health insurance, vision insurance, and group life insurance * Firm-wide ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsInsurance Paralegal JobsInsurance Paralegal Jobs in Indiana

Insurance Paralegal information

See Indiana salary details

$31.4K

$56.8K

$84.7K

How much do insurance paralegal jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 28, 2026, the average yearly pay for insurance paralegal in Indiana is $56,838.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $45,700.00 and $65,200.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What does an insurance paralegal do?

An Insurance Paralegal assists attorneys in legal matters related to insurance claims, policies, and disputes. They conduct legal research, draft documents, review contracts, and help prepare cases for litigation. They may also communicate with clients, gather evidence, and coordinate with insurance companies. Their role ensures that legal processes run smoothly and efficiently.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an insurance paralegal?

To thrive as an Insurance Paralegal, you need a solid understanding of insurance law, legal research, document management, and claims processing, typically supported by a paralegal certificate or relevant experience. Familiarity with litigation management software, case management systems, and e-filing platforms is commonly required. Strong attention to detail, effective communication, and the ability to multitask make candidates stand out in this role. These competencies are essential for ensuring accuracy, efficiency, and successful support of attorneys handling insurance-related cases.

Do insurance paralegals work for insurance companies?

Insurance paralegals typically work for law firms, insurance companies, or corporate legal departments, assisting with claims, policy analysis, and legal documentation. They often need knowledge of insurance laws, strong organizational skills, and familiarity with legal software. Their work environment can vary between in-house legal teams and external legal service providers.

How much does an insurance paralegal make?

Insurance paralegals typically earn a median annual salary of around $55,000 to $70,000, depending on experience, location, and employer size. They often require knowledge of legal procedures, insurance policies, and may use legal research tools like Westlaw or LexisNexis. Salaries can vary based on certifications and the complexity of cases handled.

What cities in Indiana are hiring for Insurance Paralegal jobs?

Cities in Indiana with the most Insurance Paralegal job openings:

Insurance Paralegal jobs near you
Infographic showing various Insurance Paralegal job openings in Indiana as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 94% Full Time, and 6% Part Time. Highlights an 81% In-person, and 19% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $56,838 per year, or $27.3 per hour.

Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN • On-site

Norton Estate Planning & Elder Law Firm, LLC
See more jobs at Norton Estate Planning & Elder Law Firm, LLCexternal

Full-time

Re-posted 8 days ago

Job description

Description
We are seeking a skilled and compassionate Senior Paralegal to support our Attorneys with the administration of Guardianship and Probate matters from appointment through closing. In this role, you'll independently manage key aspects of cases, including preparing documents for a variety of transactions, communicating with clients and various business and legal entities, managing Guardianship and Probate administration from start to finish, and providing excellent customer service.
Successful candidates will have the ability to individually manage the cases from start to finish, including drafting and organizing court and financial documents, conducting asset collection and valuation, facilitating meetings, and communicating effectively with clients, banks, insurance companies, and other stakeholders. Strong organizational skills and the ability to manage multiple competing tasks and deadlines are essential.
The ideal candidate is highly organized, detail-oriented, and comfortable managing deadlines, client communications, and financial documentation while maintaining accuracy and confidentiality.
Applicants must be comfortable preparing, proofreading, and filing legal documents and correspondence to ensure accuracy and timely communication. Preferred qualifications include a high school diploma, a paralegal degree or certificate, and 2-5 years of experience as a paralegal in the estate planning field. Strong written and verbal communication skills, attention to detail, and the ability to understand and maintain confidential information are key to success in this role. Research skills and the ability to interpret financial documents are preferred.
Responsibilities
$48
Qualifications
• Minimum of 2 years of Guardianship and Probate legal experience preferred OR 2+ years of experience in estate planning (paralegal or legal assistant)
• Bachelor's degree or paralegal certificate preferred; relevant experience may be considered in lieu of a degree
• Strong organizational and time-management skills
• Exceptional client service and interpersonal skills
• Excellent written and verbal communication abilities
• High level of attention to detail and accuracy
• Ability to manage multiple deadlines and work independently
• Proficiency in Microsoft Office; experience with legal case management software is a plus
• Familiarity with Probate and Guardianship procedures within the Indiana court system is strongly preferred

Apply