ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Insurance Paralegal Jobs in Indiana (NOW HIRING)

Indiana Legal Services

Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$37K/yr

Job Announcement Paralegal Agency Description : Indiana Legal Services, Inc. (ILS) is a statewide ... ILS offers an excellent fringe benefits package including health insurance (medical, dental, vision ...

Old National Bank

Paralegal

Evansville, IN · On-site

$121K/yr

... insurance. 401K, continuing education opportunities and an employee assistance program are also ... Responsibilities The Paralegal will be responsible for legal team support for multiple areas of ...

Coinamatic Canada

Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

Coordinate the intake, tracking, and management of insurance claims across all lines of coverage (e ... Paralegal certificate from an ABA-approved program, or equivalent combination of education and ...

Benchmark Human Services

Paralegal

Fort Wayne, IN

$25 - $31/hr

Life Insurance * Flexible Schedule * Advancement opportunities. * Employee discounts with various ... Possess a 2- or 4-year paralegal degree from an accredited institution or equivalent education ...

Benchmark Human Services

Paralegal

Fort Wayne, IN

$25 - $31/hr

Life Insurance * Flexible Schedule * Advancement opportunities. * Employee discounts with various ... Possess a 2- or 4-year paralegal degree from an accredited institution or equivalent education ...

Benchmark Human Services

Paralegal

Fort Wayne, IN · On-site

$25 - $31/hr

Life Insurance * Flexible Schedule * Advancement opportunities. * Employee discounts with various ... Possess a 2- or 4-year paralegal degree from an accredited institution or equivalent education ...

Crisp Recruit

Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN

Draft settlement demand/submission brochures for insurance adjusters and work with the attorney ... Experience: 3-5 years of paralegal experience preferred, ideally in personal injury, with the ...

Isaacs and Isaacs

Litigation Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · On-site +1

$24 - $31.25/hr

Verify and communicate with insurance carriers regarding coverage and claims * Track and manage ... Minimum 5+ years of personal injury litigation paralegal experience (required) * Experience ...

Isaacs & Isaacs PSC

Litigation Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$24 - $31.25/hr

Verify and communicate with insurance carriers regarding coverage and claims * Track and manage ... Minimum 5+ years of personal injury litigation paralegal experience (required) * Experience ...

Old National Bank

Paralegal

Evansville, IN · On-site

$121K/yr

... insurance. 401K, continuing education opportunities and an employee assistance program are also ... The Paralegal will be responsible for legal team support for multiple areas of bank work. The role ...

Isaacs & Isaacs PSC

Litigation Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

$24 - $31.25/hr

Verify and communicate with insurance carriers regarding coverage and claims * Track and manage ... Minimum 5+ years of personal injury litigation paralegal experience (required) * Experience ...

Gutwein Law

Litigation Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

We're growing and looking for a Litigation Paralegal who wants more than a job. Someone who thrives ... Insurance plan, including health insurance, vision insurance, and group life insurance * Firm-wide ...

Botkin & Hall, LLP

Be Seen First

Paralegal / Receptionist

South Bend, IN · On-site

$32K - $42K/yr

We have an immediate opening for a full-time paralegal for general practice law firm. This is a ... The position includes, employer contribution to health insurance, and retirement plan.

Gutwein Law

Litigation Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN

We're growing and looking for a Litigation Paralegal who wants more than a job. Someone who thrives ... Insurance plan, including health insurance, vision insurance, and group life insurance * Firm-wide ...

Gutwein Law

Litigation Paralegal

Indianapolis, IN · On-site

We're growing and looking for a Litigation Paralegal who wants more than a job. Someone who thrives ... Insurance plan, including health insurance, vision insurance, and group life insurance * Firm-wide ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsInsurance Paralegal JobsInsurance Paralegal Jobs in Indiana

Insurance Paralegal information

See Indiana salary details

$31.4K

$56.8K

$84.7K

How much do insurance paralegal jobs pay per year?

As of Aug 7, 2026, the average yearly pay for insurance paralegal in Indiana is $56,838.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $45,700.00 and $65,200.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What does an insurance paralegal do?

An Insurance Paralegal assists attorneys in legal matters related to insurance claims, policies, and disputes. They conduct legal research, draft documents, review contracts, and help prepare cases for litigation. They may also communicate with clients, gather evidence, and coordinate with insurance companies. Their role ensures that legal processes run smoothly and efficiently.

What are the key skills and qualifications needed to thrive as an insurance paralegal?

To thrive as an Insurance Paralegal, you need a solid understanding of insurance law, legal research, document management, and claims processing, typically supported by a paralegal certificate or relevant experience. Familiarity with litigation management software, case management systems, and e-filing platforms is commonly required. Strong attention to detail, effective communication, and the ability to multitask make candidates stand out in this role. These competencies are essential for ensuring accuracy, efficiency, and successful support of attorneys handling insurance-related cases.

What cities in Indiana are hiring for Insurance Paralegal jobs? Cities in Indiana with the most Insurance Paralegal job openings:
Insurance Paralegal jobs near you
Infographic showing various Insurance Paralegal job openings in Indiana as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 93% Full Time, and 7% Part Time. Highlights an 80% In-person, and 20% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $56,838 per year, or $27.3 per hour.

Paralegal

Indiana Legal Services

Indianapolis, IN • On-site

$37K/yr

Full-time

Medical, Dental, Vision, Life, Retirement, PTO

Re-posted 7 days ago

Job description

Indiana Legal Services, Inc.
Job Announcement
Paralegal
Agency Description: Indiana Legal Services, Inc. (ILS) is a statewide, not-for-profit organization that provides free legal services to eligible clients in civil cases through eight regional offices. ILS is funded by the Legal Services Corporation, Indiana Civil Legal Aid Fund, United Ways, Area Agencies on Aging, and approximately 60 other funding sources.
Our Commitment: ILS is committed to being an equal opportunity employer. We recruit, employ, train, compensate, and promote without regard to race, color, religion, gender, gender identity or expression, sexual orientation, national origin, genetics, disability, age, veteran status, or any category protected by law. We encourage all qualified applicants to apply.
Location: This position is located in the Indianapolis Regional Office.
Position: A Full-time Paralegal
Start Date: As soon as reasonably possible.
Job Summary: The Paralegal will work as part of the Central Indiana Medical-Legal Partnership Project. The primary role of the Paralegal is to interview potential clients for legal services. Intake interviews are conducted by telephone and at on-site outreach locations. The Paralegal will also provide paralegal support to the MLP project attorneys. The Paralegal will assist MLP project attorneys in a variety of civil cases, including family law, public benefits, landlord-tenant, and consumer law cases by drafting pleadings, correspondence, other paralegal tasks, and other clerical tasks.
Responsibilities:
  • Draft pleadings and correspondence under the supervision of an attorney.
  • Conduct potential client intake in-house and off-site.
  • Conduct legal research.
  • Assist attorneys as requested with case handling, client contact and general support, including clerical and administrative tasks.
  • Serve as primary case handler on specific cases, where appropriate, working under supervision of an attorney
  • Participate in and support the team's Case Acceptance Meetings and processes.
  • Conduct outreach and assist with community education and clinics.
  • Assist with developing and maintaining community partnerships and collaborations.
  • Assist with grant and other reporting and compliance requirements.

Qualifications:
  • Dedicated to the mission of Indiana Legal Services and the medical-legal partnership.
  • Interested in helping low-income individuals and families with their legal needs.
  • Excellent written and oral communication skills.
  • Spanish language fluency preferred.
  • Experience drafting legal correspondence and legal pleadings preferred.
  • Proficient in Microsoft Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Teams, and Outlook and able to quickly learn new software.
  • Excellent typing skills are required.
  • Sensitivity to applicants and clients from many different backgrounds and experiences, including clients with health conditions.
  • Ability to maintain client confidentiality.
  • Have excellent case, task, and time management skills.
  • College degree, paralegal certification, and/or experience working in a law office is preferred.
  • Experience with intake or outreach preferred but not required.
  • Have reliable transportation.

Compensation: Starting salary is $37,123.50 with a range up to a maximum of $49,506.50 depending on experience. ILS offers an excellent fringe benefits package including health insurance (medical, dental, vision, Rx), disability insurance, life insurance, a 401(k) plan, a flex benefit plan and generous vacation and sick leave.
TO APPLY: Please apply online by submitting a resume and a list of 3 references with email addresses and telephone numbers by email to human.resources@ilsi.net.

Apply