ZipRecruiter

Log In

1

Insurance Customer Service Call Center Supervisor Jobs

DXC Technology

Insurance Call Center Representative

$31K - $54K/yr

Insurance Customer Service Representative We are seeking a customer-focused Insurance Customer ... D.). * 2+ years of experience in customer service, call center, or a high-volume client-facing ...

Lightserve

Customer Service/Call Center Representative

Stow, OH · Hybrid

$14.25 - $18.25/hr

Operations SUPERVISOR: Managed Services Division Manager SUMMARY: The Customer Service/Call Center ... Company paid long-term disability and life insurance. * Paid time off plus 10 company paid holidays.

Adecco

Customer Service Call Center

Matthews, NC · Remote

$21/hr

Previous call center, customer service, or contact center experience preferred * Strong verbal and ... life insurance, short-term disability, additional voluntary benefits, EAP program, commuter ...

McCall Staffing Services

Be Seen First

Customer Service - Call Center - OnSite

San Francisco, CA · On-site

$23 - $25/hr

... in insurance, financial services, healthcare, or another regulated industry is a plus, since ... customer service, administrative, call center, or operations support experience preferred ...

MCI Careers

Call Center Supervisor

Savannah, GA · On-site

$40K/yr

We deliver Customer Experience (CX), Business Process Outsourcing (BPO), and Anything-as-a-Service ... call center environment. The Customer Service Supervisor I position is responsible for ensuring ...

next page

Showing results 1-20

All JobsBusiness JobsCustomer Service JobsCustomer Service Manager JobsInsurance Customer Service Call Center Supervisor Jobs

Insurance Customer Service Call Center Supervisor information

See salary details

$24.5K

$58K

$101K

How much do insurance customer service call center supervisor jobs pay per year?

As of Sep 9, 2026, the average yearly pay for insurance customer service call center supervisor in the United States is $57,998.00, according to ZipRecruiter salary data. Most workers in this role earn between $41,000.00 and $70,000.00 per year, depending on experience, location, and employer.

What are popular job titles related to Insurance Customer Service Call Center Supervisor jobs?

For Insurance Customer Service Call Center Supervisor jobs, the most frequently searched job titles are:

Infographic showing various Insurance Customer Service Call Center Supervisor job openings in the United States as of August 2026, with employment types broken down into 1% As Needed, 79% Full Time, 18% Part Time, and 2% Contract. Highlights an 92% Physical, 1% Hybrid, and 7% Remote job distribution, with an average salary of $57,998 per year, or $27.9 per hour.

Supervisor, Customer Service Call Center

Zionsville, IN • On-site

Group1001
201 - 500 employees
Learn more about Group1001external

Full-time

Medical, Dental, Vision, Life, Retirement

Posted 9 days ago

Group1001 rating

9.5

Company rating: 9.5 out of 10

Based on 8 frontline employees who took The Breakroom Quiz

7th of 315 rated insurance

Job description

Group 1001 is a consumer-centric, technology-driven family of insurance companies on a mission to deliver outstanding value and operational performance by combining financial strength and stability with deep insurance expertise and a can-do culture. Group1001's culture emphasizes the importance of collaboration, communication, core business focus, risk management, and striving for outcomes. This goal extends to how we hire and onboard our most valuable assets - our employees.
Why This Role Matters:
The Contact Center Supervisor oversees Customer Service Coordinators within the Contact Center Team(s). This includes directing staff to achieve department goals and objectives within established service delivery expectations; representing the needs of the work units for product implementation and system enhancements; training and mentoring representatives to assure cohesive unit; and ensuring department and Company policies and procedures are applied correctly.
How You'll Contribute:
  • Supervises staff including setting expectations, coaching, and counseling staff, evaluating performance, conducting performance reviews, delivering side-by-side observations and coaching, maintaining attendance records, ensuring department and company practices and procedures are followed, ensuring adequate coverage, and assisting with the hiring process. Ensures staff provides highest level of service to customers within service delivery standards for accuracy, timeliness, and productivity.
  • Provide coaching and mentoring to Customer Service Coordinators to create and foster engagement, as well as a high-performance culture
  • Work in partnership with other leaders (Team Lead, Supervisor, Manager, Sr. Manager, Associate Director, Director, Vice President) to provide consistent messaging and support to the team(s)
  • Assists with monitoring service levels and communicates issues to Contact Center leadership and Workforce Management
  • Addresses escalated calls/issues and takes appropriate action to calm upset customers and resolve customer issues/complaints in relation to our process
  • Observes the work environment to ensure we maintain a positive and engaged atmosphere
  • Monitors phone call quality, attends and participates in meetings focused on quality and efficiency
  • Serves as an active presence in chats (when required) - adds content, answers questions, validates and provides additional resources
  • Identifies training opportunities and conducts quick hit sessions (when required)
  • Utilizes system resources to ensure regular coaching and feedback is provided and documented
  • Assists with other duties as assigned

What We're Looking For:
  • Minimum of 3 years supervising employees in a life insurance-industry related field, with life and annuity business preferred.
  • Minimum of 4 years of related experience with customer service/call center, agency administration, life insurance/annuity processing
  • Knowledge of Annuity Products, (Fixed, Fixed Index, and Variable), preferred
  • Demonstrated ability to communicate effectively and concisely on complex matters to all levels of management, both written and verbal
  • Strong research, analytical, problem solving, organizational, and math skills
  • Ability to engage, retain and develop talent to improve team capabilities
  • Detail-oriented and capable of managing multiple initiatives at one time
  • Proven ability to supervise teams of staff in a fast-paced and deadline driven environment without losing sight of customer service requirements
  • Exceptional time management skills, including ability to multi-task and work with shifting priorities, meeting tight deadlines and timetables
  • Professional designations or demonstrated work toward achieving designations such as LOMA's Fellow/Associate Life Management Institute, (FLMI/ALMI), Associate in Annuity Products and Administration (AAPA), Associate in Customer Service (ACS), Associate Insurance Regulatory Compliance (AIRC), and/or Associate Insurance Agency Administration (AIAA)
  • Associates or bachelor's degree preferred

Benefits Highlights:
Employees who meet benefit eligibility guidelines and work 30 hours or more weekly, have the ability to enroll in Group 1001's benefits package. Employees (and their families) are eligible to participate in the Company's comprehensive health, dental, and vision insurance plan options. Employees are also eligible for Basic and Supplemental Life Insurance, Short and Long-Term Disability. All employees (regardless of hours worked) have immediate access to the Company's Employee Assistance Program and wellness programs-no enrollment is required. Employees may also participate in the Company's 401K plan, with matching contributions by the Company.
Group 1001, and its affiliated companies, is strongly committed to providing a supportive work environment where employee differences are valued. Diversity is an essential ingredient in making Group 1001 a welcoming place to work and is fundamental in building a high-performance team. Diversity embodies all the differences that make us unique individuals. All employees share the responsibility for maintaining a workplace culture of dignity, respect, understanding and appreciation of individual and group differences.
#LI-ST1

What Group1001 employees say

Pay

Benefits

Hours and flexibility

Workplace

Get the full story on Breakroom

Apply