Auto Claims Manager Jobs in Ohio (NOW HIRING)

Keller Executive Search is partnering with a family-owned leader in the waste and recycling industry to recruit a Risk and Claims Manager based full-time on-site in Cincinnati, OH. Our client is one of the largest firms of its kind, delivering essential waste and recycling services to millions of residents, businesses, and communities, and it is growing quickly. This is a high-impact leadership seat within the Loss Control department, offering the chance to shape how a large, fast-expanding operation manages risk and resolves claims.

Waste, recycling, and fleet operations carry some of the most complex and high-exposure risk profiles in the country, where commercial auto claims combine high frequency with significant severity. That makes disciplined, data-driven claims leadership a genuine driver of the bottom line. In this role you will lead a small, experienced team of claims professionals, own the timely and sound resolution of complex commercial auto, property-damage, and bodily-injury claims within settlement authority, and turn claims data into risk-reduction strategy that lowers the company's total cost of risk.

This is a replacement hire with a built-in advantage: you will overlap with the current, long-tenured manager for hands-on knowledge transfer, so you can ramp with confidence rather than start cold. Beyond the desk, you will partner with safety, operations, HR, IT, and legal to design and measure loss-control programs, and present actionable trend analysis directly to senior leadership. As the company continues to grow, so will the claims function and the leadership structure around it, creating real room for advancement. If you combine mature claims judgment, practical team leadership, and an analytical loss-control mindset, this is a rare opportunity to make a lasting difference.

• Lead the overall planning, development, direction, and administration of claims handling across the team
• Manage a team of claims professionals to ensure files progress appropriately and resolve in a timely manner
• Provide technical guidance and direction on complex claim-file management
• Review complex and high-exposure claims, advise on resolution strategy, and exercise settlement authority within approved limits
• Present recommendations on matters exceeding assigned authority to the Assistant General Counsel for Claims and Litigation
• Analyze company and industry-wide claims trends, frequency, and severity to develop and present risk-reduction recommendations to leadership
• Use databases and dashboards to evaluate claims-handling trends and surface opportunities for improvement
• Support business continuity and catastrophe response planning for large-scale loss events, coordinating with TPAs and consulting experts
• Develop and recommend loss-control policies and procedures for implementation
• Partner with corporate and regional safety, operations, and HR teams to design, implement, and measure loss-control programs, safety policies, training, and corrective actions
• Monitor safety databases for data-collection and workflow improvements and work with IT to resolve performance issues
• Set consistent claims-handling and reserving standards and support the development of team members

• Location: Cincinnati, OH
• Full-time, permanent, on-site at the corporate headquarters
• Occasional travel to other locations, approximately once per month
• Ability to work flexible hours, including nights, weekends, or holidays as needed during large-loss events
• Applicants must be legally eligible to work in the United States
• To apply, submit your application through this posting; Keller Executive Search manages this search on behalf of our client

Requirements

• ~10 years in commercial auto property-damage and bodily-injury claims, owning complex, high-exposure files
• Minimum 5 years managing and developing a claim team with accountability
• Strong critical thinking and trend analysis, translating claims data into actionable risk-reduction recommendations
• Substantial knowledge of insurance principles: loss reduction and control, claims management, adjusting, reserving, and subrogation
• Proficiency in Power BI or equivalent BI/data-analysis tools, able to analyze claims data independently
• Bachelor's degree in Business Administration, Risk Management and Insurance, Finance, or related field
• Excellent written and verbal communication, with fluent, professional English
• Willing to work full-time on-site in Cincinnati, OH (relocation support available)
• Legally eligible to work in the United States

• Direct property-damage and auto claims experience for a carrier, TPA, or self-insured organization
• Industry exposure in waste, recycling, transportation, fleet, logistics, or field operations
• Catastrophe/large-loss response and TPA/consulting-expert coordination experience
• Cross-functional partnership with safety, operations, HR, IT, and legal on loss-control programs
• Advanced Excel, SQL, RMIS, Tableau, or Qlik claims analytics experience
• Approachable, consistent, communicative leadership style suited to a close-knit, in-person team

You are a hands-on claims leader who blends mature technical judgment with genuine people-management skill. You are comfortable owning complex commercial auto, PD, and BI files, setting settlement and reserving standards, and coaching a small team, while also analyzing trends and presenting loss-reduction strategy to leadership. Approachable, consistent, and analytical, you thrive in a collaborative, safety-oriented culture and are ready to commit to a full-time on-site role.

Benefits

• Base salary of approximately $104,000 to $172,000, depending on experience, plus bonus potential up to 25%
• Health, dental, and vision insurance
• Matching 401(k) and life insurance
• Three weeks paid vacation plus paid holidays
• Relocation assistance available
• Structured onboarding with knowledge transfer from the current manager
• Career growth as the company and claims function expand

Keller is a recruitment agency that provides services to clients ranging from startups and non profits to multinational corporations. Keller emphasizes ethical search processes, attentive candidate care, and leadership placements that support long-term client outcomes.

To learn more about the firm and about our candidate services - please visit our website

Equal Employment Opportunity: Keller Executive Search and our clients are Equal Opportunity Employers. Qualified applicants receive consideration for employment without regard to race, skin color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, national origin, age, protected veteran status, disability, genetic information, or any other legally protected status. We are committed to fostering a diverse, inclusive workplace and comply with all federal, state, and local nondiscrimination laws across all employment terms, including recruiting, hiring, promotion, compensation, and termination.

Harassment Prohibition: Workplace harassment based on any protected characteristic listed above is expressly prohibited.

Reasonable Accommodations: We provide reasonable accommodations to individuals with disabilities and pregnant individuals through an interactive, good-faith process.

Compensation Transparency: Compensation information for client roles is included in the job post or, where not provided, shared during the interview process consistent with applicable law. Salary ranges may vary by role, location, skills, and experience. In Colorado, Nevada, New York City, California, and Washington, compensation details are provided as required by local law. We do not request salary history in Rhode Island or New Jersey (unless voluntarily disclosed), and we provide wage range information in Connecticut upon request or before discussing pay. We conduct periodic pay equity analyses in line with applicable laws.

Privacy: California residents may review our Privacy Policy at www.kellerexecutivesearch.com for details on personal information collected for recruiting and employment purposes.

E-Verify: Keller Executive Search and/or our clients may participate in E-Verify; details will be provided during the application process where applicable.